Mini Mafia Game Thread | Newbies are welcome! | Town wins Gheb's game | Zen next to host!

[Orboknown]

Gorf trg won his first game as scum and was regarded as obvtown the whole game. Change your opinion?
Kary tunnels moreso as town than as scum but it should be a nulltell for him

 

[Jdietz43]

You mentioned me and you did it in the wrong context. Do you earnestly expect me to not take note of it or point it out?

Your name was in the sentence, that was all. The question was for TRG and him alone, why did you feel the need to step in? He's a big boy, he can answer his own questions when I'm wrong about my assumptions.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

What are your town/scum reads looking like at this point in time man if you say you're not necessarily scum reading me?

Orbo and Dietz are vague scum reads for me atm.

 

[Orboknown]

Explain to me why you feel it's telling over a null. Surprising means just what it sounds like, it's not the answer I was expecting.

Because its not something i feel like trg would just blurt out as scum,in death note as the sole scum he was very calculated with how he presented himself and what thoughts he put out there

 

[The Real Gamer]

You could have fooled me acting so buddy with him already then.

I thought we were making it obvious that we were clearly goofing around... Especially the "we're scumbuddies" part.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Your name was in the sentence, that was all. The question was for TRG and him alone, why did you feel the need to step in? He's a big boy, he can answer his own questions when I'm wrong about my assumptions.

And that disallows me from pointing out something I might have issues with?

 

[Jdietz43]

I thought we were making it obvious that we were clearly goofing around... Especially the "we're scumbuddies" part.

You were, it's just there's sometimes an element of truth in every joke. I'm taking the possibility very seriously.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Because its not something i feel like trg would just blurt out as scum,in death note as the sole scum he was very calculated with how he presented himself and what thoughts he put out there

[quote="Gheb_01, post: 16089670, member: 120558"In Death Note you didn't actually have a setup to keep in mind because it was just Kira vs Detectives. And Vinyl hasn't actually posted the final setup for this game either. It's very much possible that you genuinely believed Kary could have been BP regardless of your alignment. Say what you will, Gorf's conclusion that your reaction was pro-town is simply untenable.[/quote]


Not liking Orb's play one bit.

 

[Jdietz43]

And that disallows me from pointing out something I might have issues with?

No, but it makes me mad suspicious when you feel the need to defend a player you have no town way of knowing the alignment of when this game has just started.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Oh man ninja's galore! Someone better get these guys some walrus so they can chillax!

By the by, Kary's not allowed to answer the question in my last post second paragraph.

Mr. The Real Gamer, I feel like Gheb's just trying to be what the FCC has become for television. He's try'na censor me man! Like, shut me down man! I say nay, power to the people !

Actually yea screw it this is the most solid thing I've got so far so I'll go ahead for it!

Vote: Kary

I also don't dig the fact that you're so eager to call people "on the sidelines" and whatnot. This game started up less than 24 hours ago, not everybody's just chillin around hoarding the site man. It's like you're overexerting yourself to scum hunt, ya know? The vibe's just not rubbin well.

 

[Orboknown]

Im not sure if Gorf missed my question to him

 

[Orboknown]

What arent you liking about my.play gheb?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

No, but it makes me mad suspicious when you feel the need to defend a player you have no town way of knowing the alignment of when this game has just started.

Because falsely lumping me with TRG's town reads totally isn't suspicious, right? Of course I'm going to point that out and step in.

You're not an idiot - you can tell the difference between pointing out something that is directly related to me and me "defending" somebody else. I'm not concerned about how you're interacting with TRG, I'm concerned with what you're saying about me.

 

[The Real Gamer]

Currently trying to figure out if scum would be more likely to try to clear me as town as a means of looking town or trying to discredit Gorf's clear since I would then pose a threat to the mafia for seeming obvtown... Can't make any reads based off of meta since I haven't played with most of you.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

What arent you liking about my.play gheb?

Constantly repeating **** like "I don't see X doing Y as scum" isn't fine with me. You do it all the time and it's just the most worthless fluff. You don't back up anything, you don't leave room to debate your points and you don't actually take a stance. You're not actually taking part in the game despite not posting too little. That bothers me.

Also, bringing up arguments that have already been debunked looks bad.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Currently trying to figure out if scum would be more likely to try to clear me as town as a means of looking town or trying to discredit Gorf's clear since I would then pose a threat to the mafia for seeming obvtown... Can't make any reads based off of meta since I haven't played with most of you.

You won't figure that out. Drop it and move on.

 

[Jdietz43]

Because falsely lumping me with TRG's town reads totally isn't suspicious, right? Of course I'm going to point that out and step in.

You're not an idiot - you can tell the difference between pointing out something that is directly related to me and me "defending" somebody else. I'm not concerned about how you're interacting with TRG, I'm concerned with what you're saying about me.

Ah, I get it.

Alright then, I wanted to check the intent on pointing it out yourself. Town read assumption was an honest mistake based on how he was acting.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Orbo I'll take your word for reading Kary's tunneling to an extent but I calls em as I sees em, ya know? And no, I don't care that TRG won as scum by being called obvtown throughout. I'm sure you guys saw his play as obvtown man, but like, it wasn't his play that cleared him for me. It's just the slip man! Scum would just not do that, especially new scum!

Orbo and Dietz are vague scum reads for me atm.

I can buy what you're saying about Dietz, but like, why Orbo? I actually kinda like the slot and the fact that he's seemed willing to put his head out and let himself make a paper trail, ya feel me?

Actually having caught up to my last post (I'm gonna be SO MAD if I have to do this for the next hour or so by the way man) I'm feeling worse and worse about Dietz. If you're town chill out and take a step back for a second man. Your line of thought's making no sense!

 

[~ Gheb ~]

I actually kinda like the slot and the fact that he's seemed willing to put his head out and let himself make a paper trail, ya feel me?

No, I don't feel you.

#1134 explains why.

 

[Orboknown]

Constantly repeating **** like "I don't see X doing Y as scum" isn't fine with me. You do it all the time and it's just the most worthless fluff. You don't back up anything, you don't leave room to debate your points and you don't actually take a stance. You're not actually taking part in the game despite not posting too little. That bothers me.

Also, bringing up arguments that have already been debunked looks bad.

If i do it all the time its null then isnt it?
I'm repearing myself to different people because I'm saying the same thing because i believe it. I typically post things as simply as i can make them and thats just how i play.
I think dietz is town,i'm unsure on kary atm. I think trg and gorf might be town. Im null on you and swords

 

[Jdietz43]

I can't say I feel you either Gorf, I'm waiting for Orbotells.

Talk to us about Kary, I'm not really getting your angle.

 

[Orboknown]

Dietz is town because his thought process he is laying out feels real similar to how he lays things out to me when we hydra

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Constantly repeating **** like "I don't see X doing Y as scum" isn't fine with me. You do it all the time and it's just the most worthless fluff. You don't back up anything, you don't leave room to debate your points and you don't actually take a stance. You're not actually taking part in the game despite not posting too little. That bothers me.

Also, bringing up arguments that have already been debunked looks bad.

Just a note Gheb, I hate it too. But the fact is that, and don't take offense by this Orbo, but the guy's obviously not that good at the game. I don't like that he's just chillin on meta and what if's, but that's something that I'd find scummy from somebody like you moreso than somebody by Orbo, ya know? If he keeps it up I'll start liking him less and less, but for about 24 hours worth of time it just doesn't seem like something telling yet

Btw glad to see that it was just you getting a feel for my vibe rather than just blatantly hating on my vibe. You can chill as one of my town reads now

 

[~ Gheb ~]

If i do it all the time its null then isnt it?

No.

 

[The Real Gamer]

People can try to discredit Gorf and Orbo's reasoning all they want but that doesn't change the fact that they're dead on the money about me being town. Orbo in particular seems to have me read like a book.

You won't figure that out. Drop it and move on.

Don't have anything else to really base my reads off of atm so I might as well stick to it.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

I hope the above clears up the Orbo vibe I'm trying to get across for you GBizzle.

But Orbo you're not helping my case with your 1139 -.- just a note NEVER COMMENT ON YOUR OWN PLAY THAT'S THE BEST WAY TO GET PEOPLE TO HATE ON YOU MAN!

 

[Orboknown]

No.

Do you just have different definitions of the words we use?

 

[Jdietz43]

Just a note Gheb, I hate it too. But the fact is that, and don't take offense by this Orbo, but the guy's obviously not that good at the game. I don't like that he's just chillin on meta and what if's, but that's something that I'd find scummy from somebody like you moreso than somebody by Orbo, ya know? If he keeps it up I'll start liking him less and less, but for about 24 hours worth of time it just doesn't seem like something telling yet

Btw glad to see that it was just you getting a feel for my vibe rather than just blatantly hating on my vibe. You can chill as one of my town reads now

I don't really like the fact that you're using "Orbo is bad" as an excuse to not read him Gorf. That seems like a pretty shallow way to dismiss a slot. Especially that backdoor you give yourself on the opinion at the end of that paragraph.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

People can try to discredit Gorf and Orbo's reasoning all they want but that doesn't change the fact that they're dead on the money about me being town.

And what does them being right tell you?

Do you just have different definitions of the words we use?

No, I don't. I just don't think that scummy or anti-town behavior becomes null by repeating it over and over. Just because you do it all the time and other people let it slide, doesn't mean I will do it. And if it's the 500th time you play like that I will still hold you accountable for it if I deem your posts scummy or anti-town or suspicious.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

I don't really like the fact that you're using "Orbo is bad" as an excuse to not read him Gorf. That seems like a pretty shallow way to dismiss a slot. Especially that backdoor you give yourself on the opinion at the end of that paragraph.

That's Gorf for you, though.

[Plus I don't agree with him anyway].

 

[Jdietz43]

If he keeps it up I'll start liking him less and less, but for about 24 hours worth of time it just doesn't seem like something telling yet

If you don't like it now, why give it a pass "until later"?

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

And that's what I mean by chillax man!

I'm not making up an excuse to not read him. I thought I made it clear that I disagree with Gheb's vague scum read on the guy. If I disagree on a scum read, that means that the opposite is what I feel. I feel like Orbo is a null town read at the moment, and I've been clear as to why I think so. Here are some words of wisdom for you Dietz my man: don't feel the need to be aggressive all the time man! It'll only hurt you in the end when you start to keep your head hanging over dumb things man! So to wrap up, no, I'm not not reading Orbo. I'm just saying that reading im isn't as cut and dry as it should be because he's not quite good at the game.

You're clinging onto dumb things. You ought to toast some walrus man

 

[The Real Gamer]

And what does them being right tell you?

Orbo in particular is giving me strong townie vibes since his meta reads on me are dead on, but at the same time he wants to be cautious of me because of what happened in Death Note. In other words he doesn't seem to be labeling me as town just for the sake of looking town. Of course this is a read only I can have since nobody else can confirm if what Orbo is saying is actually true or not but I can.

Gorf is a more of a null read. Unlike Orbo Gorf seems intent on clearing me as obvtown which I'm slightly leery of. He could easily be scum just trying to buddy up with me.

 

[Jdietz43]

And that's what I mean by chillax man!

I'm not making up an excuse to not read him. I thought I made it clear that I disagree with Gheb's vague scum read on the guy. If I disagree on a scum read, that means that the opposite is what I feel. I feel like Orbo is a null town read at the moment, and I've been clear as to why I think so. Here are some words of wisdom for you Dietz my man: don't feel the need to be aggressive all the time man! It'll only hurt you in the end when you start to keep your head hanging over dumb things man! So to wrap up, no, I'm not not reading Orbo. I'm just saying that reading im isn't as cut and dry as it should be because he's not quite good at the game.

You're clinging onto dumb things. You ought to toast some walrus man

Aight, aight, it coo'

I just cant know if I don't ask sometimes

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Orbo in particular is giving me strong townie vibes since his meta reads on me are dead on [...]

Is being right a town-tell now?

 

[The Real Gamer]

Is being right a town-tell now?

It's the fact that his reads are accurate PLUS the fact that he still wants to be cautious of me that's telling. His reads on me seem genuine as opposed to a slimy attempt to seem town and buddy with a townie.

 

[The Real Gamer]

Really need to see more from Kary and Swords.

 

[Orboknown]

I dont like that gheb just slashed out the rest of that post where trg explained how he read my intent

 

[~ Gheb ~]

It's the fact that his reads are accurate PLUS the fact that he still wants to be cautious of me that's telling. His reads on me seem genuine as opposed to a slimy attempt to seem town and buddy with a townie.

That's not what I asked.

I dont like that gheb just slashed out the rest of that post where trg explained how he read my intent

What's the problem with it? Do I need to quote the whole thing just to ask him a question?

 

[The Real Gamer]

That's not what I asked.

Yes in this particular case yes Orbo being right is a town tell. Gorf is a no and I've already explained why.