magnebula said:
Just to disagree with some of your points... Fox and Falco are fighter pilots? To me that is grounds for a fighting game. The way I look at it... Zelda is Sheik, so she obviously has combat experience. Falcon is a bounty hunter, but maybe Ill give you that one. Doc is one I cant argue, he is simply a doctor.
(sarcastically) But hell, if you want Meowth, why not Psyduck?!? He was a pretty big part of the original series and had some pretty powerful mnd capabilities! So why not?!?!
Because he has no appeal. Same with Meowth. I just dont get the interest from them like I should be getting. I say Raichu because he is the evolved form of Pikachu. Just like Pichu doesnt really have a huge impact on the game, Pichu is simply another form of Pikachu. Jigglypuff and Pikachu were the 2 favorite Pokemon between japan and the USA, which is why they were guaranteed their spots (asaide from other possibly obvious reasons). I get what I should be getting from Pichu, same with every other character in Melee. But Meowth... just imagine playing as him, making him jump and toss coins and scratch his opponenets... for me, and Id imagine for many more, it is not a great idea, or even a good one at that.
I mentioned Meowth to a few of my friends, and though for generally different reasons, they all thought it was a horrid idea. Meowth doesnt really have that special kind of potential to be a Smasher, just as Pacman, Megaman, or any other unrealistic choice of characters (Megaman X, Ryu, Ken, Zero...) doesnt. I dont even feel Snake has that special feel to him... but I will accept him only due to the fact that I do feel that he could possibly have the potential to be a smasher, given that the devs design him correctly
Id take Pacman, and a few others over Meowth simply because I dont feel he is right for this game on any given level in any regard. But I feel Pacman is right there with Meowth. They are not Smash material.
As of right now, the only characters I would hands down accept, label as true smash material would be Geno, Dark Samus, and MAYBE... a Sonic & Tails Duo. Geno especially. He has the potential, fan base, and impact. Meowth has little to none of all 3 of those. I mean, any character can be given the potnetial with the right moveset, but it would not fit his character. His fan base is minimal, though evidently existant. And he would not have a huge impact on the game. With Meowth, you mine as well add Psyduck, Bulbasaur, Charmander, Togepi. he just doesnt fit in.
blah blah blah.
all of this is opinion.
who YOU label "smash material" is not someone nintendo may or may not agree with.
meowth's fanbase minimal?
haha.
where are you getting this stuff from?
your local town of kids who dislike pokemon as a whole?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Meowth
read up my uneducated friend.
meowth is an extremely well-liked character.
also, if you have ever been in the pokemon center in NY when it was opened they had various pikachu, meowth, and jigglypuff backpacks/toys/etc.
whereas the lesser known cast had their individual half-inch toys, and that's that.
also, meowth has made an appearance in almost EVERY SINGLE POKEMON EPISODE.
and has been in all the movies.
do you know how many pokemon episodes there are to date?
#454 was just recently aired in japan.
magnebula said:
Because he has no appeal. Same with Meowth. I just dont get the interest from them like I should be getting. I say Raichu because he is the evolved form of Pikachu. Just like Pichu doesnt really have a huge impact on the game, Pichu is simply another form of Pikachu. I get what I should be getting from Pichu, same with every other character in Melee. But Meowth... just imagine playing as him, making him jump and toss coins and scratch his opponenets... for me, and Id imagine for many more, it is not a great idea, or even a good one at that.
this argument of yours simply put is a total contradiction.
i won't go into meowth's appeal because obviously your whole argument is based upon YOUR opinion, not facts.
but pichu
simply being another form of pikachu?
wtf is raichu to you then?
also, we are not talking about the game.
but since you insist, since when did any non-legendary pokemon besides the starters have a huge impact in the game?
ESPECIALLY raichu, since you love him so much.
and i do not understand this:
magnebula said:
Jigglypuff and Pikachu were the 2 favorite Pokemon between japan and the USA, which is why they were guaranteed their spots (asaide from other possibly obvious reasons).
what other obvious reasons?
BESIDES the fact they basically represent pokemon by themselves?
meowth is a character people should know only second to pikachu, jigglypuff after.
magnebula said:
His fan base is minimal, though evidently existant. And he would not have a huge impact on the game. With Meowth, you mine as well add Psyduck, Bulbasaur, Charmander, Togepi. he just doesnt fit in.
what i don't understand if your constant shuffling back and forth between the anime series, and the game.
you include psyduck and togepi, and yet, they are main characters in the ANIME.
not in the game.
no one individual pokemon's fanbase has been created solely on the games.
psyduck, bulbasaur, charmander, and togepi have no freaking history in the anime.
no backstory, nothing.
they just repeat their names and battle for the sake of their affection and loyalty to their respective trainer.
MEOWTH ACTUALLY HAS A HISTORY.
they have episodes of the anime based solely on him.
i needn't argue with you anymore.
you are clearly misinformed with your argument, and it's boring me.