Mafia Tournament Sleepover! Game Over! SK wins the game! (ITS LEGIT THIS TIME! LOL)

[Morrigan]

What are your thoughts on the current issues? Who's suspicious to you? What do you think about the people on my wagon? What do you think of Nix? Do you agree with people that he's not suspicious? Do you think that XACE-K's parroting is suspicious or not? There are people who aren't posting a lot - do you think it's scum trying to stay under the radar?

Cacti's and Nix's rush is the most suspicious to me.
They've been wanting to end D1 fast enough for the game to "actually begin" since the very beginning without contributing something that's worth it. Cacti's been making a big buzz over your (supposedly scummy) reaction and he's still doing it. Honestly I didn't find anything suspicious about you; either you're good at pretending, or you're really wanting the bandwagoners to stop the dumb moves and to get on the actual game.

Nix's No Lynch vote is outright scummy. I mean why would someone vote for a No lynch on D1 almost 2 weeks before deadline? There's still room for more discussion. No Lynching right now would be like granting a wish to scum.

I don't know what made people stop suspecting on Nix and drop their votes on him.

And regarding the wagoners...I really don't know.

 

[Morrigan]

Also, Ronike, wth?

 

[mentosman8]

Dekuu, part of the reason I'm cutting Nix slack(don't know about the others) is he said he's played a lot of Epic Mafia. It's pretty much the usual there to nl long before the deadline D1, and rely on PRs instead of scumtells, in which case night is where the action happens.

 

[Morrigan]

So basically he's "safe" because he played EM...where it's common to NL D1, so? This isn't EM. He could b using that as an excuse.

 

[Rockin]

With 18 players, it takes 10 votes to lynch

Gheb (4) - KevinM, Marshy, KK, FF

Mentos (1) - Junglefever

Nix (1) - Chibo

Cacti (2) - Mcfox, Macman

No lynch (1) - Nix

Dekuu (1) - Menounderwater

KK (1) - Iggy

Frozen Flame (1) Omis

Macman (1) Ronike

Those who haven't voted : Dekuu, Mentos, Cacti, Xace, Gheb

Deadline for Day 1 is on Nov 14, 2009

 

[mentosman8]

It's not that he's safe, it's that I know his mentality. People who play a lot of EM and not much else inherently get it into their heads that night actions are the big point of the game. If you play ANY day start game on EM, it's almost an instant no-lynch if it's not a forced lynch setup. Understanding where people have played before helps you see their thought process.

 

[Morrigan]

Yeah, I understand. But I believe my point still stands nonetheless. It is a possibility we should take into consideration.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

It does stand, but he seemed genuine enough. Plus I doubt there was anyway he would have known that marshy was going to ask him where he has played previously.

 

[#HBC | marshy]

stuff

why aren't you voting gheb? we're not quick lynching him we're policy lynching him. also deadline's a day before my birthday and ill be letdown if that's not a gift

 

[DtJ Jungle]

also deadline's a day before my birthday and ill be letdown if that's not a gift

This is one of the most convincing arguments I've seen on this forum.

 

[Ronike]

Sorry Marshy, but no can do yet. Once I get a picture of Meno's new and improved mafia board of cluster****, I'll consider re-voting.

 

[McFox]

Don't see any particular reason to unvote Cacti, so my vote's staying where it is.

meow

 

[KevinM]

Bro's don't tell other bro's to wait bro, I'm feeling a definite lack of commitment here.

 

[Nix2100]

You know, I've tried re-reading these posts...and all I'm seeing is some annoying "Bro Alliance" and a argument over whether or not to lynch Gheb.....so I'm thinking this will continue on until the week of the deadline then? -_-

FoS: Meno because anyone who tries to hard to make a "chart" and show pics, is obviously hiding something in my opinion.

 

[Cacti]

...what do you mean? What does that have anything to do with hiding something? Pseudo-Scumhunting are we?

 

[Nix2100]

I see no reason to post something like that, it has no real purpose other then to either show off, or to make it seem like you are town.

 

[Cacti]

I'm asking how does making a chart relate to hiding something, and how it warrants a FoS.

What I'm saying is what you're doing may be to make you seem like town.

 

[KevinM]

You guys keep blaming the "Bro alliance" for your inability to scum hunt, why would I hold your hands if you guys can't even crawl yet.

^_^b

 

[Morrigan]

I'm asking how does making a chart relate to hiding something, and how it warrants a FoS.

What I'm saying is what you're doing may be to make you seem like town.

Just look at the previous posts (2 pages if you have default posts per page settings).
When he posted that chart it sparked some unnecessary 'l o l lets arrange our votes to make his chart chaotic' and such comments. If Meno's goal was to derail the focus of attention away from him I think he quite made it...until Nix posted.

 

[deepseadiva]

You obviously can but that's beside the point. It's not about what you're doing - it's about what you're not doing: Contributing! What are your thoughts on the current issues? Who's suspicious to you? What do you think about the people on my wagon? What do you think of Nix? Do you agree with people that he's not suspicious? Do you think that XACE-K's parroting is suspicious or not? There are people who aren't posting a lot - do you think it's scum trying to stay under the radar?

Overall, I don't have much thoughts. It's Day 1 and there's 18 people.

There's not much I'm noticing that's suspicious that can't also be equally explained as " for the lulz."

Oh, and also, FOS: Nix, Gheb, Kevin, frozen, marshy, kk, ronike, dekuu, meno, and macman

Die.

I see no reason to post something like that, it has no real purpose other then to either show off, or to make it seem like you are town.

This is correct. Again, I don't have much to post, so I thought I'd show I'm at least thinking about the game.

 

[XACE-K]

I see no reason to post something like that, it has no real purpose other then to either show off, or to make it seem like you are town.

It can help with the thought process?

If Meno's goal was to derail the focus of attention away from him I think he quite made it...until Nix posted.

But he really didn't have much attention on him at the time. People did discuss Meno not posting much but it was being overshadowed by other stuff. (Bro alliance, my parroting, and what not)

 

[karthik_king]

btw I think everyone noticed McFox's post restriction. So he must be a cat... So therefore cats are evil so he must be mafia but Rockin might like cats....

 

[McFox]

Unvote

Vote: karthik

FoS: Cacti

meow

 

[KevinM]

I'd actually be ok with a Karthik lynch here. Like 100 percent ok with it.

unvote
Vote Karthik

 

[DtJ Jungle]

I'm okay with a karthik lynch as well.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

unvote vote: Karthik

until he posts something of even meager substance.

 

[Morrigan]

His post was plain dumb rather thn scummy (or are you guys voting him for being dumb lol)

Unless it's an inside joke I'm not aware of (how I hate inside jokes in mafia...).

 

[KevinM]

Nope but your wishy washy posts aren't helping.

:D

 

[Morrigan]

Wishy washy?

I've stated my point a few posts ago and nothing much happened after it besides Menounderwater's chart discussion and the bro crap. I'm not blaming the Bro thing for my inability to scum hunt, I just don't get the whole point of them.

 

[CT Chia]

Unvote

Vote: Dekuu

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Dekuu it's okay to say you hate bros.

I hate them too.

 

[Ronike]

Dude, Meno, those were all totally legit FOS's and I expect them to be put on your chart. No hissy fits now.

 

[Morrigan]

Dekuu it's okay to say you hate bros.

I hate them too.

Never said I hated them.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Vote Chibo

Explain your vote on Dekuu. You didn't contibute anything so far. Parroting and unexplained votes don't make you look town. Convinve me otherwise.

 

[Rockin]

With 18 players, it takes 10 votes to lynch

Gheb (3) - Marshy, KK, FF

Cacti (1) - Macman

No lynch (1) - Nix

Dekuu (2) - Menounderwater, Chibo

KK (4) - Iggy, Mxfox, KevinM, Junglefever

Frozen Flame (1) Omis

Macman (1) Ronike

Chibo (1) - Gheb

Those who haven't voted : Dekuu, Mentos, Cacti, Xace

Deadline for Day 1 is on Nov 14, 2009

 

[Cacti]

Vote: KK

This works, and KK's been seemingly actively lurking the most out of all of the people here after a quick check, and his recent post makes it seems like he's trying to contribute to town.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

His posts make it seem like he's contributing to town? His posts contribute to nothing no matter how you look at them.

 

[Ronike]

Unvote Vote: Cacti

He plays like that always. The only reason he didn't in TS is because I gave hima role that forced him to be active.

So not only do you jump on KK for doing the same old same old while he has a pressure wagon on him, and because you say his posts are attempts to seem contributing? No.

 

[Cacti]

Well how would I know that how he plays is by actively lurking? Even if he does, that's not very good for town and he hasn't really posted anything significant.

 

[#HBC | Mac]

So you are voting Cacti for not knowing KK's meta?