• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Mafia Royal Sleepover - The Party has been Crashed! Mafia Wins!

~ Gheb ~

Life is just a party
Joined
Jun 27, 2008
Messages
16,916
Location
Europe
GHeb, if it was such a scumtell, then why would scum not do it?
Wow, are you serious?

Gheb, why were you using AtE against OS?
He's annoying me to no end ever since he joined dGames and I wish he weren't playiing mafia at all.

Shown already.
Where?

SO maybe I have. HOwever, does that mean that I m contributing nothing, just riding my claim?

obv contradiction is obv.
A fake contribution is not a contribution. Attacking exclusively your attackers is a fake contribution. Your claim is the only thing that kept you alive yesterDay and you haven't contributed anything ever since or before that.

No contradiction at all.

Quite a statement, especially considering me and OS are attacking you for almost completely different reasons.


Okay gheb.

WHy did you bring that up the moment I started to attack you? Thats borderline exclusive.
I've made that accusation before you even started to attack me JFYI. In fact, I'm pretty sure that's what led to this discussion to begin with.

Gheb, I was V/LA the exact time you accused me, not "some time during this game".
But the accusation that you are useless is not time specific. You were useless yesterDay just as much as you were toDay. It's not like I pointed it out just toDay but long before on D1 - when you were *not* V/LA.

GHeb, this no way an omgus. The fact that you are an experienced player accusing me of this does not give off a good vibe.
Accusing you of being useless and attacking only your attackers doesn't give you a good vibe? Sorry then, you apparently can't handle the truth - so far you haven't even shown me how I was wrong but just counter attacked me. Why don't you even try to show me how I was wrong? Your answer is pretty much a more elaborate "no u".

:059:
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
I've had a few games now, enough to understand what's generally going on in a game.

Though I'll be honest I haven't started reading the thread, I'll hit it hard after I get home tonight.
 

Overswarm

is laughing at you
Joined
May 4, 2005
Messages
21,181
All your reasoning seems pretty scummy Gheb.



Wow, are you serious?
Never heard of Yomi? that's weird. I remember you talking about what DH is mentioning before. It's not a unique concept. KKing actually brought it up in Community mafia at the end when commenting on players, saying I acted "so scummy that I couldn't be scum" at one point. Yomi.

He's annoying me to no end ever since he joined dGames and I wish he weren't playiing mafia at all.



A fake contribution is not a contribution. Attacking exclusively your attackers is a fake contribution. Your claim is the only thing that kept you alive yesterDay and you haven't contributed anything ever since or before that.
How is this relevant to his alignment? If his claim kept him alive yesterday and he hasn't been a target toDay, I highly doubt he's done anything scummy to circumvent his status. Why aren't you suggesting a way in which DH could be confirmed, given how he's already claimed?

It seems like you're not really interested in progress, but more self-preservation. Your posts don't have a future to them; they're just straight-up responses with no depth. Shallow.

I've made that accusation before you even started to attack me JFYI. In fact, I'm pretty sure that's what led to this discussion to begin with.
You should post it.

But the accusation that you are useless is not time specific. You were useless yesterDay just as much as you were toDay. It's not like I pointed it out just toDay but long before on D1 - when you were *not* V/LA.
*moves goal posts*

Are you implying that those deemed useless should be lynched at this point? I'm not sure what your argument is. Are you for or against a DH lynch?

Accusing you of being useless and attacking only your attackers doesn't give you a good vibe? Sorry then, you apparently can't handle the truth - so far you haven't even shown me how I was wrong but just counter attacked me. Why don't you even try to show me how I was wrong? Your answer is pretty much a more elaborate "no u".

:058:
Is that all you have on him? "You're useless and also you attacked me after I said that"?



Oh, and you should vote for Gheb. He's the play for toDay. :B

:009:
 

~ Gheb ~

Life is just a party
Joined
Jun 27, 2008
Messages
16,916
Location
Europe
My reasons are scummy? What "reasons"? I'm not trying to justify a DH lynch because I don't consider him scum. Why do you misconstrue my argument? I'm not even trying to make him look like scum so don't say stuff like "is that all you have on him".

I'm saying:
"DH is useless, therefore he's useless".

You try to make it look like:
"DH is useless, therefore he's scum".

Your accusation is vague and fluffy. You say "my post don't have any future" ... as if you know what the future brings. You're just pulling reasons out of your *** now.

:059:
 

Overswarm

is laughing at you
Joined
May 4, 2005
Messages
21,181
My reasons are scummy? What "reasons"? I'm not trying to justify a DH lynch because I don't consider him scum. Why do you misconstrue my argument? I'm not even trying to make him look like scum so don't say stuff like "is that all you have on him".

I'm saying:
"DH is useless, therefore he's useless".

You try to make it look like:
"DH is useless, therefore he's scum".

Your accusation is vague and fluffy. You say "my post don't have any future" ... as if you know what the future brings. You're just pulling reasons out of your *** now.

:058:
Oh, my bad. I assumed repeated attacks on a player's character and play in such an aggressive manner implied you thought there was something anti-town about his play. So why, exactly, are you attacking Dark Horse?

Oh, that's right. Your favorite logical fallacy: Ad Hominem!

Attacking the attacker does little to change any of his arguments.

You also didn't vote for Gheb.
 

~ Gheb ~

Life is just a party
Joined
Jun 27, 2008
Messages
16,916
Location
Europe
Correct.

Not sure how to "prove" somebody being useless, though. I can't refer to things he didn't do [if he actually did stuff my accusation would hold little merit] but if it helps you his lack of input hinders the town's progress in my opinion [yes, Swiss is playing anti-town too imo]. Even though he started to post more now he still focuses on people who attack him, which already was unhelpful yesterDay. I don't think his scum lists ever exceeded more than one player and it's always been the one player who attacks him the most. That's something I'd say has no future.

:059:
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
Gheb I haven't read anything but this page and some of the last (40ppp), but what? So he's anti-town, but its no big deal to you?

OS I am starting to see why you are saying he is the play for today.
 

Overswarm

is laughing at you
Joined
May 4, 2005
Messages
21,181
Correct.

Not sure how to "prove" somebody being useless, though. I can't refer to things he didn't do [if he actually did stuff my accusation would hold little merit] but if it helps you his lack of input hinders the town's progress in my opinion [yes, Swiss is playing anti-town too imo]. Even though he started to post more now he still focuses on people who attack him, which already was unhelpful yesterDay. I don't think his scum lists ever exceeded more than one player and it's always been the one player who attacks him the most. That's something I'd say has no future.

:058:
Are you implying OMGUS is not content?

Are you implying OMGUS is inherently scummy?
 

#HBC | J

Prince of DGamesia
Joined
Feb 14, 2010
Messages
7,591
Location
Colorado
*catching up*

Just wanted to say though.

Yay Glyph replaced in! =D Maybe he'll make this game more enjoyable.

Glyph will we actually get to play this game to the full this time?
 

#HBC | J

Prince of DGamesia
Joined
Feb 14, 2010
Messages
7,591
Location
Colorado
J, answer this.

WHAT KIND OF LOGIC DOES ATE HAVE AND WHAT REASON DOES A TOWNIE HAVE TO USE IT?
.....really? If I need to explain this then please learn some facts. You do realize the polarizing effect of this opinion right?

Are we playing the same game here? I've been pretty much the only one who tried to go against the wagon happiness of this pathetic excuse for a town. When exactly have I been wagoning anybody at all this game? I have not wagoned Chibo yesterDay ... I was the first to vote him to begin with. Nor did I wagon you because I've voiced my issues long before people realized that you're scum. I also tried to avoid the kuz wagon so get your facts straight. Atm you're a bandwagoner for turning on me out of nowhere now that people decide to be stupid and actually vote for me. Just die already, nothing you say makes sense.
You do realize I was talking about just your bandwagoning on me correct? You are still dripping with put-downs to a "pathetic excuse for a town." You are wagoning with me and you even admitted in this post THAT YOU HAVE ADDED NOTHING NEW. You have said yourself that you just restated the facts. Which are in its own worthless pieces of garbage and saying it isn't it a lie. Where did I talk about you wagoning Chibo, and why did you feel the need to point out, "Nuh-uh! I was the first to vote him!!!!" Bolded sentence is a lie because no you have not. Really big yellow part. But now who is the one speaking ****?

[Collapse=J's "Bandwagoning" Gheb]
J's still stupid.

We should lynch Gheb toDay.
Care to explain why? The only one who looks really stupid is the ones just saying "Lynch Gheb just cuz!" or "No lynch J just cuz!".

I actually am debating on not lynching Gheb just to spite you because your lack of justified reasoning and your overall attitude.
Sounds like something pro-town. Also seems like you've been okay with lynching Gheb prior. Why's that? What do you gain from not lynching Gheb other than self-satisfaction?

Gheb is the play for toDay.
Yes, Gheb is a scum pick of mine and I wouldn't mind seeing him dieing but your reasoning is just god awful and holds nothing substancial. It may seem childish but sometimes people's egos need to be popped.

You ignored my question.

And you fail at this challenge to the extreme.
Sounds like town reasoning again. Go against your scum pick to show a townie a lesson. Good self control. Definitely not stupid.

Your reasoning seems similar to Ghebs. You should try the "outrage / calm" disparity in the future, it draws less correlation between the two. Good whether you're town or scum after Gheb's flip, since I don't think anyone here would be willing to save you after his flip.
I have no proof you are town, I'm just following what I have seen from your play which is a cookie cutter of your All-Stars play in which what you tried to do was exactly what you were trying to do to Tandora to Gheb. So "showing a townie" and you have not justified Gheb's lynch yet to me and that is the true stupidity of the matter.

What are you talking about in the second paragraph because what it seems is a bunch of dribble.
request prod on swiss while viewing thread
noted


I did respond to your previous post. I said "J is still stupid" and then said "Gheb is the play for toDay".

Why aren't you voting Gheb, J? He's your scumpick, right? Why protect him?
That's not a response, that's just being curt.

Protecting him? Hell no. I want Nabe as I've said and that's why I'm not voting him.
I don't see anyone else going after Nabe.

You should go after Gheb instead.
Why? You've yet to give good, and I mean good reasoning as to why I am scum.
No, I've stated why I want Nabe first and you are still ignoring justfying WHY I should change my vote.

Honestly it's like talking to a wall.
Ignore J drama.

J, vote Gheb. It's your only way to survive today. You want to survive right? You're town, right?

Vote gheb.
Why should people ignore the "drama" as you call it enshrouding me?

For the hundredth time, not until you justify your poorly constructed case and answer all the questions in response to my 1218. Yes, I want to survive to help town but at the point it's feeling hopeless. And yes I'm town.
You could live toDay. Trust in me. Vote Gheb.

Do it J. Everyone will laugh if you don't. You don't want them to laugh. You want them to think you're swift and strong and smart. Vote Gheb. It's what a leader would do. You don't want to play reactionary, do you? You should take a stand and vote Gheb. Kill scum on Day 1. Be a part of it rather than a force trying to actively stop it. You'll help town that way. Everyone will love you if you do. We will all laugh and laugh after the game at how close we were to lynching you and how useful you were for the rest of the game. All thanks to J. Vote for Gheb J.

Gheb is the play for toDay.
Do you have any respect or dignity while playing this game? I mean seriously what is that post besides a mockery of me in which you continue to ignore me and then you have the gall to make a post like that? You have the a sickening play style that needs a severe re-look.

Get over yourself and deflate that ego of yours or quit talking to me in this game.
[/Collapse]

You honestly have not read anything at all as to what I have been saying for the quite some time now and saying that I voted you and have been bandwagoning you is just so full of crap it's astounding.


Gheb]Facts said:
Gheb]Facts said:
contradiction like fake posting restriction or harmless things but conflicting stances that show that he's playing for his own good more than for the town.
You still haven't pointed out these "oh so many contradictions" and I have pointed out and explained things. It is YOU who has refused to listen to what I say and I am starting to think you have ignored me and just set on a tunnel mind that I must be scum along with Zen after you joined the wagon on me. Conflicting stances? Are you still babbling on about that weak thing of Zen/Chibo that I have literally spelled out for you at this point. HOW AM I PLAYING FOR MY OWN GOOD?

Gheb said:
FoS Mentosman

Why are you avoiding to give your reads? Reading your posts you have a null read on most people and if you don't you always have an excuse to vote him still. Lynching a townie to get OS out of his tunnel? Rather than trying to convince him that he's wrong to begin with?

Take a hard stance on somebody who's scum and vote for him, mentos. I think you're just taking the backseat in this game and cruising more ... this is a challenge to prove me wrong. I don't see why we would have to ask specifically for stuff as you mentioned before just to get your stances. Part of the reason why J was suspect yesterDay.

:059:
Agree with the FoS nonetheless.

There is no depth here. I can re-word so maybe you understand. "It's similar to saying you're scum because I say you are." It's self-fulfilling. I used it that way first because it was in that big post you made so I figured you would understand what I meant.
No I didn't understand but w/e.

So, not much to respond to, but I never attacked you for asking for questions J, so can't call hypocrisy there. Second of all, you misrepped some of my reads there, so let me correct you.

Gheb=leaning town on him, as evidenced by "I don't see Ghebscum," not null. The only reason I'm willing to hammer there is because it'll get OS out of the tunnel for a bit, and I'm not 100% confident in my read.

J=null, because I can't really read you all that well this game, so I'm fine with you dying despite not having scumread on you.

Swiss= leaning scum, questioning mostly because his play is different than ANY play I've seen from him before and while he's playing scummy by being so barebones in his posts, it doesn't fit established play of any kind from him. Not null though, just a questioned scum read that I want to develop more before I push it.

Zen=The null is unnecessary. Just leaning scum :D
First part, talking as a whole to town not just you.

Gheb, you are willing to lynch him to get OS off your back? What? Also you just state null-leaning town but don't take a stance on him.

J, So because you cannot read someone well you are willing to kill them.....just cuz? And you even say you do not have a scum-read on me but two people you have a scum-read on you aren't pushing! I mean what is this crap?

Swiss, So the only reason you feel Swiss is null-leaning scum like you've said is because of meta?

Zen, why?[/COLOR]
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
On page 14 out of 33

Surprised DH isn't dead.
 

Swiss

Smash Lord
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
1,082
Location
Don't get mad - get Swiss
Glyph, all will become clear. You replaced X1 amirite?

The last few big posts have consisted entirely of "no u".

Blaaaaaaaaaaah bandwagon Unvote Vote Gheb. OS you owe me cakes and hugs. I dislike getting trolled into following someone else.

So Glyph why is X1 town? Do you feel the recent posts by OS and Gheb are sufficiently damning of Gheb to vote him, or is it the older posts? You seemed to indicate it was the newer stuff. So quip quote me some reasoning.

Gheb I've swip swapped onto you, what will you do to ensure you do not become the lynch toDay?
 

~ Gheb ~

Life is just a party
Joined
Jun 27, 2008
Messages
16,916
Location
Europe
Gheb I haven't read anything but this page and some of the last (40ppp), but what? So he's anti-town, but its no big deal to you?

OS I am starting to see why you are saying he is the play for today.
When did I say it's not a big deal to me? Do you think I call him out just for fun?

How does this make me the play anyway? This is exactly what I feared would happen - you're fairly new to this game and confuse scum hunting with "looking for a blame puppet as long as I stay alive in the process is fine".

Take your own stances.

Are you implying OMGUS is not content?
OMGUS is not content

Are you implying OMGUS is inherently scummy?
No.

You do realize I was talking about just your bandwagoning on me correct?
But. I. Did. Not. ****ing. Bandwagon. You. God. ****ing. Damned.

Are you terrible at reading?

You are wagoning with me and you even admitted in this post THAT YOU HAVE ADDED NOTHING NEW.
I don't need anything new if the old is more than enough to clearly show how you're scummy. Also, I'm adding new things all the time in my responses - you just choose to ignore it.

Am I supposed to ignore evidence just because it's old? No, because it's still evidence. The same applies to your case.

You have said yourself that you just restated the facts. Which are in its own worthless pieces of garbage and saying it isn't it a lie.
Way to be a hypocrite. Calling me out for condescending remarks but then make baseless claims about a case being bad, WHEN YOU STILL HAVE NOT GIVEN A ADEQUATE RESPONSE TO WHAT I ACCUSED YOU OF DAY 1.

And again, you do nothing to show my points wrong. You just say "they are wrong deal with it". If they are "facts" as you call them then they are ****ing facts. If they are ignored I restate them, especially since they are strong enough to show how you're scum.

Where did I talk about you wagoning Chibo, and why did you feel the need to point out, "Nuh-uh! I was the first to vote him!!!!"
You're playing stupid now. You know very well why I mentioned Chibo in this because it was your accusation that I'm a bandwagoner and I'm pointing out that I'm *not* jumping wagons but others have done plenty. Just because I wagon you doesn't mean I'm more of a bandwagoner than others are. Why do you have no issues with X1 jumping you?

It's because you're hunting selectively. You know that this is your chance to stay alive so you attack the next most popular target.

Bolded sentence is a lie because no you have not.
And yet again, you fail to show anything. "No you have not". OMG WHAT AN AMAZING ARGUMENT. I'm baffled by your debating skills

inb4condescendingyaddayaddapseudohunting

Why don't you try and point out where you have said I am scum since D1 and your "omg holy" suspicions of me?
Because I have done so at least twice toDay already and I'm not going to play this nonsense any longer. You accuse me of not reading but then you don't even see that I've summarized my points long ago. You are not reading, you don't even see when somebody points out your scummy behavior. You couldn't skim harder if you tried.

You even said "What took you so long to answer it finally if it was that simple of an answer." You just refuse to admit I have already explained why.
Where?

What are you even talking about? I have not buddied Zen/Chibo and you haven't yet to point out exactly where I have. You just say that I have.
Pointed it out twice toDay. L2read and skim less. Do your homework.

Yet you don't get on people such as Swiss/Gova/Mentos/Chibo/Dark Horse but no I have no substance.
I've made my points on all these players except Swiss. You're getting really embarrassing now. If you don't know my stances towards Gova, Mentos, Chibo and DH by now I suggest you replace out or just get lynched.

That is just...I don't know what to call this. It's just wrong. You have not shown in clear detail how my stances are contradictory and the "obvious" anti-town implications." You haven't backed it up with quotes "multiple times" and it is NOT true.
Once again, I'm pointing out that I've gone into detail here, backed up with quotes, which I once again point out, you did not read carefully.

So by using one tiny word like "if" it's a hypothetical. So what is your read on X1 or moreso X1's slot.
Null to scum. Replacement with new player blurs read.

Really? All I see that you find anti-town about it is your section yet you call the entire post anti-town without even mentioning the other parts of it. Your attack on my post is based on self-defense and if you truly found it anti-town/scummy you would have destroyed it's entirety and not just the section that addressed you.
No, I always point out in every game ever how such long posts are anti-town. I wish you wouldn't make them because it forces me to read that stuff and it's just flat-out not worth it. Plus I have to respond to it with longass posts myself. Keep your arguments shorter if you actually have something against me. Oh wait, you can't because you need farfetch'd arguments that are hard to respoond to because the substance behind it is non-existent.

Agree with the FoS nonetheless.
Shut up.

Gheb I've swip swapped onto you, what will you do to ensure you do not become the lynch toDay?
It's a confession of failure of this town that it even got that far.

OS - is awful at scumhunting. Stubbornly sticks to principles proven wrong [lynch all liars, AtE / AtR as scumtells etc]. Why do people listen to him? Is it a surprise that the smartest players in this game [mentos, Gova] disagree? These people are among the better players in this game for a reason.

DH - is known to be inexperienced at scum hunting and highly inclined to vote for the people "against him" rather than whom he believes to be scum. Often confuses the two, which led to critique in other games. Can't be trusted to make an educated decision.

Zen - is still not helpful for the town. He claims to not care about being good/bad at this game as long as town wins but he doesn't help the town winning at all. Jumps randomly back and forth from wagon to wagon without explanation; chooses to abandon his own inherent case against J [his most legit one at that] to go with the flow. Has received major flak D1 for playing poorly and continues to do so.

Nabe - extremely unconvincing case against Gova. Switched to my wagon just now despite insisting on being town earlier. Contradictory and opportunistic - probably scum.

None of the people are particularly trustworthy in terms of scum hunting [proven] or helping town win games [proven]. Overswarm and DH in particular have highly questionable pasts in dGames based on poor play and major contributions to their side's losses. Overswarm's scum hunting process is still the same from Mafia Barhouse Sleepover, where he received heavy critiques from players way beyond his level and he fails to admit being wrong. Stuck to this playstyle, which almost led town to failure in bioware [you should know what I mean].

If these people convince you to lynch me then you're not playing up to the level you've reached recently. J is a tool who's doing just about anything right now to not be lynched [once again showing that his own preservation matters more to him than the town's success]. Most of the people here have yet to show ability to take their own stances and not let them be swayed by trivial things such as big, empty words [J] or insanely long posts filled with [proven] lies / half-truths [Overswarm]. This town is being played pretty badly atm.

:059:
 

~ Gheb ~

Life is just a party
Joined
Jun 27, 2008
Messages
16,916
Location
Europe
Currently thinking of a J, Nabe, Mentos/ Swiss scumteam. J is the scumbag who's on the forefront drawing attention of the town [shame he's currently getting away from it], Nabe is playing opportunistic by giving me townie credit [to look credible upon townGheb flip] but also voting me to give agreement to the town ... trying to please all sides to look golden in every case. Mentos / Swiss are the sleepers, cruising through this game and let their scumbuddies do the work.

:059:
 

Overswarm

is laughing at you
Joined
May 4, 2005
Messages
21,181
Are you high, Gheb?

I was a solo Serial Killer in Barhouse Mafia. I was NKilled by scum on N1. You were scum. I apparently caused enough distress for you to NKill me.

Here's the final vote from D1, prior to before your faction killed me.

With 14 people, it takes 8 to lynch
Chibo (8) - Tom, KevinM, Junglefever, Nix, Ronike, Mentos, Virg, Summoner

Steel (2) - Overswarm, Riddle

Virg (1) - Steel

Riddle (1) - Chibo

Junglefever (1) - Gheb

Those not voting : Frozenflame
If I recall, you were scum in that game. People should read up.
 

~ Gheb ~

Life is just a party
Joined
Jun 27, 2008
Messages
16,916
Location
Europe
I was scum that game. We killed you for all the wrong connections you had with people like frozen and because you were very active. It had nothing to do with the "distress" you caused but that's besides the point.

You still hunt scum by the same principles and these principles have been proven at least unreliable. Not that it matters, even if I thought of your points against me as legit, I'd still find DH's, Zen's and Nabe's motives highly questionable and opportunistic. At least one of them has to be scum ... probably Nabe.

:059:
 

Overswarm

is laughing at you
Joined
May 4, 2005
Messages
21,181
I was scum that game. We killed you for all the wrong connections you had with people like frozen and because you were very active. It had nothing to do with the "distress" you caused but that's besides the point.

You still hunt scum by the same principles and these principles have been proven at least unreliable. Not that it matters, even if I thought of your points against me as legit, I'd still find DH's, Zen's and Nabe's motives highly questionable and opportunistic. At least one of them has to be scum ... probably Nabe.

:059:
Considering my plan in that game was to create connections between town members and ride that through the game, as Rockin can confirm and mentioned in passing in that game's thread, I think I did alright. My issue wasn't my implementation, it was drawing too much scum attention to myself.

Did I mention you're the play toDay? I'm also going to ignore your WIFOM last-minute scum picks; it is strongly suggested others do the same, as it is kind of obvious that you're dropping leads. This could imply that Nabe is scum simply because you're pointing him out so much that it's "too obvious", or it could be that you picked three town members to attempt to get town to lynch ONE of them toMorrow. Regardless, it will be ignored.

You are the play for toDay, Gheb.
 

Rockin

Juggies <3
BRoomer
Joined
Oct 16, 2006
Messages
3,546
Location
Bronx, New York
Mafia Royal Sleepover

J (1) - Gheb

Gheb (5) OS, Dark Horse, Zen, Nabe, Swiss

Nabe (1) - J

Zen (1) - Chibo

Not Voting - Mentos, Gova, Glyph

Deadline is Feb 25th 2011 on 11:59 PM. It takes 6/11 votes for a lynch
 

Overswarm

is laughing at you
Joined
May 4, 2005
Messages
21,181
Feb. 25th?

Chibo, mentos, gova, glyph, and gheb remain not voting for gheb. One of them will have to hammer. Volunteers?

Gheb, claim in your next post.
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
Okay finally caught up.

Gheb relax a bit, this is a princess themed mafia on a website dedicated to Super Smash Bros. As for your reply to me, you have very very clearly stated that you found DH's play to be anti-town. I'd be so bold as to say that means his play is a detriment to the town's win condition, at least according to you. But you don't find that scummy? Does that make him counter-productive town in your eyes?

OS, why the refusal to build actual evidence against Gheb for so long? (please don't make me go back and quote all the posts where you said nothing but "Gheb is the play for today"). I'm not a fan of the tactics you used to try to pressure people into voting either.

Swiss, I did indeed replace X1, and to be perfectly honest the vast majority of his posts I've seen in this game weren't very good. However, I did find myself generally agreeing with his reads when he choose to vocalize them.

I'm not voting Gheb until we get a claim of course, and even then the only big thing I've taken issue with from him is what I've asked him to clarify on in this post.
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
Yes, I would be willing to hammer.

OS I would like an answer to my question though too.
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
OS if you've already decided he was the play for today then what was the point of having him claim.
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
Swiss what good does it do us to know who he targeted unless we happen to have a tracker or something.

All I can see that doing is letting the arsonist know if he needs to change up his gameplan or not.
 

Overswarm

is laughing at you
Joined
May 4, 2005
Messages
21,181
Hammer, Glyph. There's nothing more to see here.

He's either an arsonist or a mafia member safe claiming firefighter to make it appear as if there is an arsonist in the game.


Gheb dies toDay.
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
Right, but pretend you're the arsonist. Why would you go through the trouble of priming someone twice? You wouldn't. If we get his target from him, all we're doing is giving the arsonist assurance that his targets will die when he ignites them.

If I'm missing something let me know, but I really don't think its a good idea to get that information from him. What would we gain from that?

And yeah, I'd say his claim makes sense right now. Enough that I'd prefer to not lynch him.
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
Hammer, Glyph. There's nothing more to see here.

He's either an arsonist or a mafia member safe claiming firefighter to make it appear as if there is an arsonist in the game.


Gheb dies toDay.
And if he's telling the truth? Then what?
 
Top Bottom