Lost Mafia - Who won? - The viewing audience of course

[Evil Eye]

 

[Evil Eye]

so kevbro you gonna give us something to work with or what

 

[Chaco]

Unlike Jerkus he at least as content to evaluate.

Unvote: Vote Jerkus

Actually Circus does have some content to evaluate, and what little there was I didn't like. What are you your thoughts on his push on Auspher?

I support Circus Pressure. Unvote; Vote: Circus

 

[Evil Eye]

In a word: Meh.

What are you feeling about his content?

 

[KevinM]

so kevbro you gonna give us something to work with or what

I'm working on it.. game is currently hard to read.

 

[Chaco]

Stated them previously. Lemme find the quote.

 

[Chaco]

I doubt a scummate would allow him to suicide like that, and if you don't believe the product he's selling then you feel, like me, he's bent on surviving. No? What causes this thought process? Primarily struggling new town trying to avoid a mislynch in the only way they know how, flailing. However, FoS: Gorf and Circus for attacking similar traits. This is just light suspicioun, and really nothing to it other than I dislike the one sidedness to your case. Also, it is uncommon for noob scum to request a lynch and fire off retorts like lynch me, it just doesn't happen. Noob town, yes. Scum, no.

EXACTLY this post, except with the additional suspicioun raised to Gorf and especially Circus. I feel his ability to differentiate the two would definitely shine through, seems like a widely accepted easy, viable lynch target.

These two posts mainly sum it up well.

 

[hidajiremi]

Ladies and gentlemen of Flight 815, I realize there has been some turbulence, but undoubtedly we'll all soon be rescued.

With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch!

Vote Count:
RR: (1) Auspher
Dooms: (2) KevinM, Soupamario
Glyph: (1) Kataefi
Mentosman: (2) Acrostic, Glyph
Acrostic: (3) Mentos, Ryker, Rajam
Auspher: (1) Circus
Gheb: (1) Dooms
Kataefi: (2) Gheb, Gorf
Circus: (2) Chaco, Evil Eye


Not voting: (2) frozenflame751, Red Ryu

Prods for inactivity:
Acrostic - 2
Glyph - 1
KevinM - 1
Circus- 1
Soupamario - 1
Kataefi - 1

Deadline December 23rd, 11:59 PM.



Thanks for flying with Oceanic.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Vote: mentosman8

His responses look really scummy to me and I dislike his need to want to hide information from town. His scum picks are alos super safe, it doesn't seem like picking Ryu, Auspher, Acro, and Soup was something her reached, more so something he is conforming to look town.

He should give reasons for each scum pick.

~

Acro should be tested with his role of course. I like EE more for taking his gambit off on Mentos, I like Ryker after his responses to how Mentos and Glyph interacted.

But I require clarification on why the two are scum, or for Glyph why he thinks it was staged.

Gorf, scum picks please.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

I'm still thinking Ausupher for reasons stated. I'd be def. looking into you v Ausupher upon an Ausupher scum flip cuz I remember the interaction just looking so fixed and swingy and weird and BLECK! The case on Circus looks fabulous, but I really wanna look more into Kat... I looked back at his posts and they were really just leaving me with an empty feeling, you get me dawg?

I'll tell you that I DON'T agree with your mentos suspicion :s

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

I don't know anything about Lost but Acro's roleclaim seems believable and supposedly it works out with his nameclaim as well [and I know there's a role named "Priest" that lacks the ability to cast the hammer vote]. I don't think we should lynch him with a credible and confirmable fullclaim and if he was sick that'd explain why he couldn't be active. I'll make up my mind on him later.

Unvote Vote Kataefi

How 'bout that?

Unvote Vote Ausupher

Unvote Vote Ruy

Unvote Vote... maybeCircus

How's about that?

I don't see a Kat case, and, admittingly, he's one of those people that I forget are even in the game.

._.

Unvote Vote Kataefi

I'll take you on it mang.

Kat's definitely been milking those computer johns. There were a few times I actually saw him in the thread "Replying to Thread" for literally hours and then he'd disappear for another day without making said post. Really didn't like that.

But eh. It can wait; I'm gonna finish my finals and then I'm gonna reread Kat. Unlike Jerkus he at least as content to evaluate.

Unvote: Vote Jerkus

What the hell?

Acro needs to be put to L-1.

Are you guys blind?

 

[Dooms]

Vote: Acrostic

I agree with Ryker on this.

Not seeing why the Kataefi pressure is needed at all.

Don't remember anything from Circus. Need to re-read him.

 

[Chaco]

Gorf, how does the case on Jerkus look fabulous when I called you out on the same thing?

Bout to be agreeing with Ryker.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Not seeing why the Kataefi pressure is needed at all.

Kat pressure is entirely warranted. Still want Circus first.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Ryker do you want Acro's ability proven first before this day moves on?

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

I mean like, I haven't forgotten about that, but I'd rather assure that that's not hindering scumhunting. And besides, can't that be proven on somebody else as equally as it can be proven on him? If the person at L-1 is lynched he's obv lying scum, if not then he's obv not O.o

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Gorf, how does the case on Jerkus look fabulous when I called you out on the same thing?

Cuz I've been doing stuff?

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

I'm still thinking Ausupher for reasons stated. I'd be def. looking into you v Ausupher upon an Ausupher scum flip cuz I remember the interaction just looking so fixed and swingy and weird and BLECK! The case on Circus looks fabulous, but I really wanna look more into Kat... I looked back at his posts and they were really just leaving me with an empty feeling, you get me dawg?

I'll tell you that I DON'T agree with your mentos suspicion :s

Why do you still think he isn't noobtown over noobscum? Look at his reponses to people when he said, "we would lose" if we lynched him. That screams more like noobtown frustrated with minor pressure.

Circus wagon is something I could dig, but I want more elaboration on why.

Kat is warranted if the johns stick.

Mentos, I heavily disagree with thinking Glyph was scummier than Mentos in that exchange. There wasn't a lot of commitment and some flip flopping with the back and worth with Glyph, along with his reluctance again to provide information to town for rather bad reasons.

 

[Chaco]

Cuz I've been doing stuff?

So, because you've been doing stuff what's scummy on Circus isn't scummy on you? So you're an exception to the scumdar, cool, good to know.

Unvote: Vote: Gorf

 

[Chaco]

Glyph vs Mentos is either TvT, or TvS, I don't see being staged as an option. And in the event that it is TvS, I'd lean more towards Glyph being scum than Mentos. When I questioned Mentos individually the responses he gave me were as direct as they come and there was no meandering or anything, where as watching Glyph from an overview I've seen little direct contribution and more so just random pop ins and outs with no true use. Only thing he's done is shown a like to EE by backing him up, I'd pretty much call that null and in the event one is scum I highly doubt the other is. The connection is one sided for sure, and I feel it's just from them being buds outside of game that Glyph went in and backed up an action he thought EE went through with. That's why I'm considering the actual action null, however, the way he handled Mentos was entirely poor.

 

[Chaco]

Why do you still think he isn't noobtown over noobscum? Look at his reponses to people when he said, "we would lose" if we lynched him. That screams more like noobtown frustrated with minor pressure.

I agree with this.

Circus wagon is something I could dig, but I want more elaboration on why.

-Lurking
-Opportunistic Votes on Auspher with inability to take the more in-depth read and settling on the surface to push a widely supported thought to a lynch.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

I didn't even mention Glyph's name O.o... Ausupher is just rubbing off badly to me from earlier in the Day, and I don't wanna let that feel go mang. If I see his play improve then things may be different but for now I'm not letting go. As far as Circus goes, I'd expect a lot more from em coming back from the abyss than that lackluster post he had stating his stances on players that did all have suspicion on em at one time or another, which all happened to be inexperienced players who probz wouldn't have enough to back themselves. Circus is just, overall, being sloppy as hell.

So, because you've been doing stuff what's scummy on Circus isn't scummy on you? So you're an exception to the scumdar, cool, good to know.

Unvote: Vote: Gorf

I sent out a memo... You didn't get it?

I don't see the resemblence of play between me and Circus. Iirc your FoS on us was because we were both going after the same player(s). The difference between us two going after said player(s) (I put parenthesis around the s because the only common scummy I seem to remember between us is Ausupher) is that I actually have reason for my suspicion, and have voiced said reason in thread. Shiz, that one post where I put a buncha pics has WAY more content than I can remember Circus having all game. PLUS, unlike Circus, my scum picks aren't necessarily convenient.

If I'm missing something in the common ground that me and Circus share, please inform me.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Ok, I reread that, I can see why that vote would make it worth a vote. Lurking I'm not sure if I can call him out on that since the inactivity seems to be with all games he is playing.

Read list:

Town
9. Red_Ryu
14. Gheb_01
6. Auspher
12. Evil Eye
13. Ryker

Null
10. Acrostic (Town if role is proven)
15. Chaco
1. Joey
2. DtJ Glyphmoney
3. frozenflame751
4. Gordito
5. Rajam
7. KevinM
16. Soupamario

Scum
17. Mentos
11. Kataefi
8. Circus

 

[Chaco]

I didn't even mention Glyph's name O.o... Ausupher is just rubbing off badly to me from earlier in the Day, and I don't wanna let that feel go mang. If I see his play improve then things may be different but for now I'm not letting go. As far as Circus goes, I'd expect a lot more from em coming back from the abyss than that lackluster post he had stating his stances on players that did all have suspicion on em at one time or another, which all happened to be inexperienced players who probz wouldn't have enough to back themselves. Circus is just, overall, being sloppy as hell.



I sent out a memo... You didn't get it?

I don't see the resemblence of play between me and Circus. Iirc your FoS on us was because we were both going after the same player(s). The difference between us two going after said player(s) (I put parenthesis around the s because the only common scummy I seem to remember between us is Ausupher) is that I actually have reason for my suspicion, and have voiced said reason in thread. Shiz, that one post where I put a buncha pics has WAY more content than I can remember Circus having all game. PLUS, unlike Circus, my scum picks aren't necessarily convenient.

If I'm missing something in the common ground that me and Circus share, please inform me.

Nope, this is what I wanted. I like having people directly respond to me so I can gauge them. Back to Jerkus.

Unvote; Vote: Circus

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

I'm curious about that Ryker read.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Nope, this is what I wanted. I like having people directly respond to me so I can gauge them. Back to Jerkus.

Unvote; Vote: Circus

Damn I fell for your trap ._.

 

[#HBC | Ryker]

Ryker do you want Acro's ability proven first before this day moves on?

No. I want you to help me test it WHILE the day moves on. Jerkus knows even with a light skim of the thread that he's the de facto lynch unless he's scum with Acro and knows he won't be able to prove his ability. Kat knows he needs to do something as there's about 3 people who are currently after Jerkus who would be willing to vote him. Everything I care about can move forward just fine without either not testing Acro's ability or scrambling to do it at the last minute and ****ing up.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

unvote
Vote: Acrostic

I can play ball.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Hmm. Yea true.

Unvote Vote Circus

Unvote Vote Kat

Unvote Vote Acrostic

L-3.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Damn it.

EBWOP Unvote Vote Ausupher

Unvote Vote Circus

Unvote Vote Kat

Unvote Vote Acro

 

[~ Gheb ~]

So Joey, you don't see how pressuring Kataefi is warranted ... but you also think lynching somebody who claimed a confirmable role is a good idea?!? What point is there in pressuring somebody we can find about telling the truth anyway? Quit being such a gogdamn tool to Ryker's command - you're making yourself a hinderance to town, not a help.

 

[Dooms]

So Joey, you don't see how pressuring Kataefi is warranted ... but you also think lynching somebody who claimed a confirmable role is a good idea?!? What point is there in pressuring somebody we can find about telling the truth anyway? Quit being such a gogdamn tool to Ryker's command - you're making yourself a hinderance to town, not a help.

Are you really THAT ********?

We're testing the role on Acrostic himself, which is why I'm voting him.

-_-.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

No, we're not doing that.

 

[Dooms]

No, we're not doing that.

Why no t?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Because we can test it without lynching him.

 

[Dooms]

Because we can test it without lynching him.

If he's lying, he hammers himself.

If he's telling the truth, the hammer doesn't go through and we unvote instantly.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Unvote Vote Acrostic

I'm a 'lil dum

 

[Dooms]

Request Votecount

 

[Dooms]

Just counted. If the vote count above is right, then we only need one more vote on Acro before he votes himself.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Sounds good, if someone accidentally hammers and he flips priest, they are scum and we kill them tomorrow.

Also 3 days til deadline it seems.