I agree actually, a big chunk of the fan base are stupid, but hen again this is true of most fan bases. Anyways, I'm not sure I'd like voice acting since it'll give Link personality and he's not supposed to have one, like Gordon Freeman. Link is supposed to be a hollow vessel where we project ourselves, not a character we are reading about. So I would be ok with voice acting for everyone but Link.
That's perfectly fine, Link doesn't really matter, but to only have awkward little snippets of sound coming from the characters while they talk (OH GOD HYRULE WARRIORS WHY?) is really disjointed and takes away from the experience. Rock on Ele-
I don't want Link voiced. I tend to be picky and probably wouldn't like how he sounds.
Ok that's fine, maybe Link shouldn't talk since he's us essentially but I feel the rest of the game are fine being voiced to add to the personality the games already have and-
They've tried it and it failed (in the cartoon series and the CDI games). Link should remain mute. There are some conventions which don't need to be broken and this is one of them.
Aw dangit, that's exactly what I mean though, people refer to other bad voice acting (one handled by a cartoon company literally named "Dic" entertainment, and the other not handled by anyone with brains and not officially recognized by nintendo) and use that as some sort of excuse that nintendo "shouldn't" even try, and that's why Other M rekindled my hate for people who use bad dubs as an excuse not to add voices. "DUH HUH other m turned samus into a carboard montotone pussbag, so there's no conceivable way any actor on the planet no matter how acclaimed or talented could ever make any other game sound good, and video games characters should just be mute so I can project my fantasies onto them DUH HUH" is all I hear in that argument. Anyone who seriously thinks voice over in LoZ would completely destroy the series does not give LoZ any credit at all.
That being said I'm certainly not insinuating that you feel that way Elessar nor Rizen, I just started seeing the trend reoccur and jumped on it.
I should elucidate that I'm not at odds with the games the way they are now, they could rerelease the original LoZ with a few alterations every year and I'd still play it. I just worry a fear of experimentation is going to lead to yearly rehash Zelda in a matter of time, and that would drive the less mindless fans (unlike me) away.
A true talent evolves as it proceeds, taking great strides to preserve it's legacy whilst refining it's delivery and evaluating it's place in the present age, and LoZ's place in this world is inside the console being played as much as possible.
I just feel like certain (extremely vocal and toxic) elements of the fanbase (the same as any else really) are what keeps the series from really strutting the excellence we know it contains, and will not be satisfied until ALttp/OoT/MM and WW are printed on Diamonds and are used as currency, and god save the poor dreamer who dares alter a single lock of Link's hair. Let's not play any blame games here,(you know who you are, calling people out) Let's fight like Gentlemen!