Bedoop
Poyon
Are you implying that I already haven't made that image my TF2 sprayHey, SmashRiver64! Check out my conversations page on my profile page. You'll find out about my icon.
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Are you implying that I already haven't made that image my TF2 sprayHey, SmashRiver64! Check out my conversations page on my profile page. You'll find out about my icon.
Maybe.Are you implying that I already haven't made that image my TF2 spray
This is the response of an adult, good work. Money is always a factor, this isn't a game of picking crayons out of a box. People's hard earned money is at stake, ignoring this concept is foolish. Am I mocking Sakurai? No, I too am a artist and criticism is a bit hard to deal with sometimes, however the person paying for your product in reality could care less about the creator's (your) feelings. Which is sad, but it's a reality one has to go through, especially when money is on the table.I'm a consumer buying his products.
Brilliant idea.Let's not start a debate please.
^ThisSakurai is due a ton of respect, especially for his self-destructive work ethic.
I do agree with your sentiment; however, I honestly, under this hypothetical scenario, want to read his justification before I decide to not appreciate his creative vision. Perhaps he has an extremely good reason? Doubtful, but I am not going to have a knee-jerk reaction.Sakurai is due a ton of respect, especially for his self-destructive work ethic. However, there's a very simple principle of cause and effect in some situations where he probably feels "sad." You take Ridley and make him a boss despite his support, and give a glorified "too big" as justification for your "vision"? Fans ain't gonna be happy. You add random tripping to "level the playing field" between players of different skill levels? People ain't gonna be happy.
It's tough, because you have legitimate complaints lumped in with genuinely stupid or uninformed ones, like "clones took my character's spot," which makes people completely shut down all criticism toward the guy in general. In general, credit must be given where credit is due, and the same goes for criticism. You can't be balanced while having one without the other.
And let me tell you, if tomorrow's Famitsu scans come out with a justification from him on no K. Rool, he had better be prepared for a lot of fans in here to not appreciate that "vision."
Nicely put. It also didn't help that they did try to keep everyone in the dark for the Ridley fiasco as well. When assists like Takamaru or Prince Sablé (both of which I'd honestly never heard of before) were announced, Nintendo or Sakurai immediately and clearly pointed out that they were indeed assist characters. I remember wondering how anyone could have assumed Prince Sablé was a full character, but Sakurai still reposted to clarify. Ridley got a shadow and a few passing mentions - sure some people saw how 'obvious' it was that Ridley was a boss, but there was confusion and it was not clarified.Sakurai is due a ton of respect, especially for his self-destructive work ethic. However, there's a very simple principle of cause and effect in some situations where he probably feels "sad." You take Ridley and make him a boss despite his support, and give a glorified "too big" as justification for your "vision"? Fans ain't gonna be happy.
I can never keep track of the Famitsu schedule. Are we getting more news tomorrow?Sakurai is due a ton of respect, especially for his self-destructive work ethic. However, there's a very simple principle of cause and effect in some situations where he probably feels "sad." You take Ridley and make him a boss despite his support, and give a glorified "too big" as justification for your "vision"? Fans ain't gonna be happy. You add random tripping to "level the playing field" between players of different skill levels? People ain't gonna be happy.
It's tough, because you have legitimate complaints lumped in with genuinely stupid or uninformed ones, like "clones took my character's spot," which makes people completely shut down all criticism toward the guy in general. In general, credit must be given where credit is due, and the same goes for criticism. You can't be balanced while having one without the other.
And let me tell you, if tomorrow's Famitsu scans come out with a justification from him on no K. Rool, he had better be prepared for a lot of fans in here to not appreciate that "vision."
I would personally accept that as a reason to be honest. If I was the creative director of Smash, I would have NO clue how to properly represent King K. Rool and make all of his fans happy. Conversely, that is obviously the allure of King K. Rool and therefore not an entirely good reason.... You know what would be an extremely ironic reason for K. Rool to not be in Smash? Too much moveset potential. Sakurai had too many options to work with, and decided that he wouldn't be able to represent him properly with how many things he would have to leave out. I don't think that will be the case... But it's Sakurai.
Nicely done!https://soundcloud.com/celerinajackrabbit/crocodile-cocophany Well I finished that remix.
Thank ya. The only problem I can see with it is the ending. It just ends up being too loud... but that's what happens sometimes when it sounds decent in the program, but the render is super loud. - w-Nicely done!
I was just speaking in regard to myself. I am not personally going to have a knee-jerk reaction based on what he says and if he supports his claim, I have no reason to disdain his reasoning. The notion is, as usual, subjective. I have no problem with other people criticizing his reasons and I have no doubt that they interpret "knee-jerk" differently from I. Basically, I am just being open about it. I have not thought of all of the possibilities.Famitsu releases on Friday, but typically has its scans come out two days before on Wednesday.
I don't know what sort of "really well-reasoned reason" Sakurai could give for leaving out K. Rool. Not interesting? Irrelevant? Too big? I preferred other characters despite claiming to be aiming for fanservice? Criticizing stuff of that caliber isn't kneejerk by any stretch of the imagination; that label applies to the team if they legitimately used those reasons to dismiss the character. The only remotely possible thing I could think of would be "we want to be able to do him justice with the resources of a full team" or something, and even then, they made a character as complex as Ryu with a smaller team.
Let's not forget the reasoning of Ridley's flying being a problem, even though a good 10% of the cast can "fly" (Including a Pokemon that is a flying type...) or levitate and they have no problem being "portrayed accurately" .You take Ridley and make him a boss despite his support, and give a glorified "too big" as justification for your "vision"? Fans ain't gonna be happy.
And let me tell you, if tomorrow's Famitsu scans come out with a justification from him on no K. Rool, he had better be prepared for a lot of fans in here to not appreciate that "vision."
Sounds great! I also checked out some of your other work.https://soundcloud.com/celerinajackrabbit/crocodile-cocophany Well I finished that remix.
See, here's the thing, when someone dangles a dollar in front of you only for them to snatch it away and punch you in the nuts, you get pretty unkind and don't feel like thanking them for it.Regardless, whether or not we get K. Rool this time, we must at least send a thank you for giving him the attention when all is said and done.
Oh gosh that old stuff? Really? Well, alright, I guess.Sounds great! I also checked out some of your other work.
I really enjoyed Metal Harbor, the Paper Mario title screen/file select theme, Corneria, and K.K. Condor.
Good stuff.
This is a fairly easy question to answer... What you have in the super heavyweight class is Ganondorf, Bowser, King Dedede, Charizard and Donkey Kong. Whether you think these descriptions are accurate or not... Ganondorf is sheer power, Bowser has good defensive moves that help him become a good floor general and defensive specialist, Dedede has a penchant for being in the air, Charizard has speed and Donkey Kong is kind of all-around, but is the king of off-stage KOs, specifically meteor smashes.K. Rool needs a proper way to distinguish himself from the rest of the cast.
So what are some Concept ideas?
Ferocious Speedster?
Tricky Heavyweight?
Yea. The reasoning behind Ridley's exclusion was plain stupid. K Rool & Ridley are my top votes. And according to a somewhat reliable source, I learned that K Rool is the number 1 most requested charcter, and Ridley is tied for 3rd (with paper mario).Sakurai is due a ton of respect, especially for his self-destructive work ethic. However, there's a very simple principle of cause and effect in some situations where he probably feels "sad." You take Ridley and make him a boss despite his support, and give a glorified "too big" as justification for your "vision"? Fans ain't gonna be happy. You add random tripping to "level the playing field" between players of different skill levels? People ain't gonna be happy.
It's tough, because you have legitimate complaints lumped in with genuinely stupid or uninformed ones, like "clones took my character's spot," which makes people completely shut down all criticism toward the guy in general. In general, credit must be given where credit is due, and the same goes for criticism. You can't be balanced while having one without the other.
And let me tell you, if tomorrow's Famitsu scans come out with a justification from him on no K. Rool, he had better be prepared for a lot of fans in here to not appreciate that "vision."
If by those you mean Kid Icarus and KirbyI'm annoyed by the way Sakurai made/loved franchises take center stage for 4.
It does add somethingI also want to destroy Equipment. I don't like it in the slightest and it adds nothing.
I think the Miis are fine.I'd also delete Mii Fighters from existence. Because **** them. Waste of resources on 3 movesets for a Mii when that could have been 3 more iconic Nintendo characters.
I assume he means Fire Emblem and Kid Icarus. Personally, it's a sore spot for me that longtime franchises like Star Fox, Metroid and Donkey Kong had to settle for a Melee stage a third time around for the 3DS version instead new stages.If by those you mean Kid Icarus and Kirby
Kid Icarus I definitely agree with
But Kirby
Heeeeelll no
Kirby has been down in the dumps with Smash 4
No new characters at all
Only 1 new stage per game (Excluding Halberd and Dream Land 64)
Not really any Smash Run enemies to begin with (Not even a Gordo, man)
Kirbs definitely isn't in the spotlight.
Star Fox, Metroid, and Donkey Kong are starting to feel like the ******* children of Smash for some people. The reason I bring up those three in particular because they're still among the more popular IPs alongside Mario, Pokemon, and Zelda, yet don't really receive much in the way of new stuff.I assume he means Fire Emblem and Kid Icarus. Personally, it's a sore spot for me that longtime franchises like Star Fox, Metroid and Donkey Kong had to settle for a Melee stage a third time around for the 3DS version instead new stages.
Seriously. can't stand getting labeled as a "melee-purist" whenever i criticize the flaws in this game(of which there are several but i won't go on here) or the way he handles things as a director, creator, and professional in general.Yes, sakurai has done many great things in the past and his dedication is truly admirable but that doesn't mean everything the man does or touches is instant gold that should be praised or worship or that he infact does not have his share of flaws or stubbornly bull-headed views on things. Not every captain can keep steering a good ship well forever and i honestly think sakurai's a tad out of touch these days but, that's just my view.The thing that bugs me the most is that people act like Sakurai's word is on par that of God, and when people criticize his decisions or tendencies in any way, they get excommunicated or are declared heretics for daring to question His Eminence.
I am very annoyed with the Smash 4 roster. There's a lot of good in it, but there's a lot of stupid too. I'm annoyed by the way Sakurai made/loved franchises take center stage for 4. I'm annoyed by the fact that he keeps trying to fix things that aren't broken, and leaves broken things that need to be fixed. I'm VERY annoyed by his double talk, saying one thing one minute and completely contradicting himself the next.
I honestly think that he's not the man to keep helming this series. But when I say that, I get accused of being a Ridley loving (Guilty as charged) fanboy who can't be pleased and I should just shut up and take what Papa Sakurai gives me.
I bought this game with my money. TWICE (Stupid 3DS millstone around the Wii U's potential....) I have the right to point out it's flaws, especially repeat offenders. And when these repeat offenders are directly tied to the director's personal bias....
I can respect Sakurai for what he's done in the past, but I can't put him on an immutable pedestal. Especially when he acts like a fourteen year-old Deviantart user when his work is criticized. (Seriously, he's starting to sound like Andrew Dobson with all the "Why won't people unquestionably love my work!?")
I had a dude tell me to go back to play Melee because I was initially upset that the K. Rool costume might have deconfirmed him.Seriously. can't stand getting labeled as a "melee-purist" whenever i criticize the flaws in this game(of which there are several but i won't go on here) or the way he handles things as a director, creator, and professional in general.Yes, sakurai has done many great things in the past and his dedication is truly admirable but that doesn't mean everything the man does or touches is instant gold that should be praised or worship or that he infact does not have his share of flaws or stubbornly bull-headed views on things. Not every captain can keep steering a good ship well forever and i honestly think sakurai's a tad out of touch these days but, that's just my view.
Isn't that the most overused retort in all of Smash history, even when it doesn't make any sort of sense?I had a dude tell me to go back to play Melee because I was initially upset that the K. Rool costume might have deconfirmed him.
It doesn't even make sense. I can't play as K. Rool in Melee, either.
That's one thing I've always disliked about Sakurai.With all due respect to Sakurai, because there's plenty due, he is a grown man in his 40s with over two decades of experience making video games. He is one of the most respected and critically acclaimed developers in the industry, easy.
He shouldn't be so sensitive about what a few people on the internet say about his games. He is providing a service we are paying for; unreasonable or otherwise, consumers will criticize you. Suck it up.
Well... I can think of one guy.You NEVER hear other game developers talk about how much a series is "killing them".