Zalak
Smash Lord
I would also like Rosalina to post the reads.
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
I agree with what I quoted here, and I also want Gheb to explain moreMy reads thus far,
Zalak is town. By far it's clear he has the intent to try and figure out the cast while being as vocal as possible..FE left me in a null area before he replaced out...........
I want to put Kursed as a town lean...only very very slightly though. I don' have much of a basis here I would call "legitimate" It's a feel mostly........
I would lynch Ninja if I had to lynch someone right now.
Agreeing with someone is okay, but people rarely have exactly the same opinion as everyone else. The only reason someone would be agreeing with everyone is to assimilate within the group, avoid enemies and essentially avoid being lynched. However, a town would not do that as they know they can't win while being friends with everyone. Mafia, on the other hand, can.I suppose it's mostly because you called yourself the most suspicious player, Kursed. Also, you're calling me scum for.. agreeing with people. Am I never supposed to agree with anyone? I suppose you've been more helpful recently, but you seemed to be voting randomly a lot earlier on. To me, you seem really hungry for a lynch.
This is quite similar to my opinion of you.Well, he's yet to give a truly unique read on anyone. So far, all of his reads seem to just be him agreeing with someone.... not that there is anything wrong with agreeing with people, but he hasn't brought much to the table himself.
@My reads thus far,
Zalak is town. By far it's clear he has the intent to try and figure out the cast while being as vocal as possible.
I want to put Maven in the town category, been pretty happy with his content. Outside of the me "sheeping" people one. :/ Still watching this play out.
If Gheb doesn't explain his read on me I am willing to lynch him, FE left me in a null area before he replaced out. But he isn't a priority.
I don't recall Rosalina's if much at all.
I want to put Kursed as a town lean...only very very slightly though. I don' have much of a basis here I would call "legitimate" It's a feel mostly.
I would lynch Ninja if I had to lynch someone right now.
In retrospect, you are right. I judged based off of Kursed's reactions, and assumed you were blindly agreeing with everyone. As for my reads, the entire reason I am hiding them is so that the mafia don't know who I think is town, and therefore don't know who would be a good idea to lynch. Some may be town, some may be null. As the people I'm reading town are not in a situation to be lynched right now, I don't believe revealing them would aid us very much. But I will expand on my mafia reads:Wait, whom do you read as town right now, Rosalina? Everyone except for Hunter and me? And what do you mean they're not being investigated? If you think about it, we're all kind of being investigated right now. You have to spill some of the beans, Rosalina. Perhaps not all of them, but you've been too vague recently. Give us some beans.
Also, you and Kursed keep calling me out for agreeing with everyone, but most instances you've mentioned were just me making compensations before starting to argue against someone. There was the time Kursed called me out for agreeing with Hunter when he said that Kursed was acting scummy, but I was the first one to call Kursed out, so in reality, Hunter was the one agreeing with me.The only time I completely agreed with someone was when Maven made me realize I was making your job too easy by defending you before you had a chance to defend yourself, Rosalina. I agreed with him only because he was right. I made a rookie mistake, though I have not completely let Maven off of the hook because of that. I still think he was being strangely aggressive.
I'm open to hearing everyone's opinions because I do not want to make the mistake of lynching a townie on the first day. Right now, I'm very suspicious of you, Rosalina, but I suppose I am biased, as you are currently trying to get me lynched.I'd love to hear the others' thoughts on the matter.
It's hard to order my suspicions right now, but I think Hunter is still the most suspicious in my eyes.If either Kursed or Rosalina are maf though, I think it's likely they're working together.
Why do you think I would be working with Kursed if I were mafia? Other than the fact I agreed with the notion you were being excessively agreeable.Wait, whom do you read as town right now, Rosalina? Everyone except for Hunter and me? And what do you mean they're not being investigated? If you think about it, we're all kind of being investigated right now. You have to spill some of the beans, Rosalina. Perhaps not all of them, but you've been too vague recently. Give us some beans.
Also, you and Kursed keep calling me out for agreeing with everyone, but most instances you've mentioned were just me making compensations before starting to argue against someone. There was the time Kursed called me out for agreeing with Hunter when he said that Kursed was acting scummy, but I was the first one to call Kursed out, so in reality, Hunter was the one agreeing with me.The only time I completely agreed with someone was when Maven made me realize I was making your job too easy by defending you before you had a chance to defend yourself, Rosalina. I agreed with him only because he was right. I made a rookie mistake, though I have not completely let Maven off of the hook because of that. I still think he was being strangely aggressive.
I'm open to hearing everyone's opinions because I do not want to make the mistake of lynching a townie on the first day. Right now, I'm very suspicious of you, Rosalina, but I suppose I am biased, as you are currently trying to get me lynched.I'd love to hear the others' thoughts on the matter.
It's hard to order my suspicions right now, but I think Hunter is still the most suspicious in my eyes.If either Kursed or Rosalina are maf though, I think it's likely they're working together.
I have been deliberately vague, to avoid hinting at who I regard as town. But I still don't see how town reads help. Consider I say person X, who up till now has been playing perfectly fine, without the spotlight being placed on him, is town. What would you say? Would you question it? Would you argue it? After all, he's been playing fine, and you yourself probably had a similar read on him. It wouldn't generate much content, would probably be soon forgotten, and would only tell the mafia who to lynch if everyone came to the consensus that person Y is town. It doesn't help us at all. For instance, consider everyone's reveal of reads thus far. Can you actually remember who said who was town? On the other hand, I can remember conflicts between certain players, who thought who may have been mafia. Admittedly, I still need to sometimes reread for a refresher, but they stayed in my mind much more securely than any town reads they gave.Wait, whom do you read as town right now, Rosalina? Everyone except for Hunter and me? And what do you mean they're not being investigated? If you think about it, we're all kind of being investigated right now. You have to spill some of the beans, Rosalina. Perhaps not all of them, but you've been too vague recently. Give us some beans.
Also, you and Kursed keep calling me out for agreeing with everyone, but most instances you've mentioned were just me making compensations before starting to argue against someone. There was the time Kursed called me out for agreeing with Hunter when he said that Kursed was acting scummy, but I was the first one to call Kursed out, so in reality, Hunter was the one agreeing with me.The only time I completely agreed with someone was when Maven made me realize I was making your job too easy by defending you before you had a chance to defend yourself, Rosalina. I agreed with him only because he was right. I made a rookie mistake, though I have not completely let Maven off of the hook because of that. I still think he was being strangely aggressive.
I'm open to hearing everyone's opinions because I do not want to make the mistake of lynching a townie on the first day. Right now, I'm very suspicious of you, Rosalina, but I suppose I am biased, as you are currently trying to get me lynched.I'd love to hear the others' thoughts on the matter.
It's hard to order my suspicions right now, but I think Hunter is still the most suspicious in my eyes.If either Kursed or Rosalina are maf though, I think it's likely they're working together.
Since D1's about to end, I may as well comment on Ryu then.My reads thus far,
Zalak is town. By far it's clear he has the intent to try and figure out the cast while being as vocal as possible.
I want to put Maven in the town category, been pretty happy with his content. Outside of the me "sheeping" people one. :/ Still watching this play out.
If Gheb doesn't explain his read on me I am willing to lynch him, FE left me in a null area before he replaced out. But he isn't a priority.
I don't recall Rosalina's if much at all.
I want to put Kursed as a town lean...only very very slightly though. I don' have much of a basis here I would call "legitimate" It's a feel mostly.
I would lynch Ninja if I had to lynch someone right now.
Granted we all want to see Rosalina's reads, you do seem to be most concerned about themWait, whom do you read as town right now, Rosalina? Everyone except for Hunter and me? And what do you mean they're not being investigated? If you think about it, we're all kind of being investigated right now. You have to spill some of the beans, Rosalina. Perhaps not all of them, but you've been too vague recently. Give us some beans.
Also, you and Kursed keep calling me out for agreeing with everyone, but most instances you've mentioned were just me making compensations before starting to argue against someone. There was the time Kursed called me out for agreeing with Hunter when he said that Kursed was acting scummy, but I was the first one to call Kursed out, so in reality, Hunter was the one agreeing with me.The only time I completely agreed with someone was when Maven made me realize I was making your job too easy by defending you before you had a chance to defend yourself, Rosalina. I agreed with him only because he was right. I made a rookie mistake, though I have not completely let Maven off of the hook because of that. I still think he was being strangely aggressive.
I'm open to hearing everyone's opinions because I do not want to make the mistake of lynching a townie on the first day. Right now, I'm very suspicious of you, Rosalina, but I suppose I am biased, as you are currently trying to get me lynched.I'd love to hear the others' thoughts on the matter.
It's hard to order my suspicions right now, but I think Hunter is still the most suspicious in my eyes.If either Kursed or Rosalina are maf though, I think it's likely they're working together.
Yeah because I totally didn't try to kick start the game or anything to get content moving.I'm not in the game long enough to really have a solidly informed on all players yet so I'm just doing the good ol' PoE thing:
- I'm OK with Maven's content so far and can see where he's coming from with his reads on Ryu and Rosa atm.
- Zalak has posted a lot of content and not hesitated to make his stances clear. We're not gonna lynch him toDay.
- Kursed behavior looks a bit suspicious but his posts aren't scummy. I can see why somebody would think that player X generally agreeing with just about everything is scummy. I'd consider him null for now.
- Rosie seems to avoid tanking clear stances and has an extremely consensual approach to the game. Forever null but I will not oppose a lynch either.
- HNRP generally seems to be the punching bag toDay and I'm not sure if it's justified or not. He just seems to lack confidence yet but if he were scum I'd expect his parner to show up and defend him or deflect the attention somewhere else. Probably not a terrible lynch though I'm not actively gonna push it.
That leaves Ryu's slot and I cant think of anything pro-town he's done yet. None of the reads he posted are substantial or backed up solidly and it's the only time he's shared any content. That's pretty shallow and weak. So yeah, I'd prefer to lynch Ryu toDay but could compromise on HNRP and Rosie if it comes down to it. Will only vote Kursed if it's necessary to prevent a no lynch.
![]()
Reading up? For the most part, just your content hasn't left me with a solid impression right now.Since D1's about to end, I may as well comment on Ryu then.
His early game was decent, imo, with questioning and attempts to read. However, his content dropped quite a bit midgame, and I disagree with a couple of his current reads. However, I cannot consider someone mafia merely due to disagreement.
Red Ryu: Slight town read.
@#HBC | Red Ryu How can you not remember me? Virtually the entire last two pages was Maven trying to lynch me. Have you been reading up?
That is pretty much the only reason. Also.. intuition.. I guess. Mostly a gut feeling.Why do you think I would be working with Kursed if I were mafia? Other than the fact I agreed with the notion you were being excessively agreeable.
Rosalina has been trying WAY too hard to justify holding onto secret reads. Like.. right hereI post when I can
Granted we all want to see Rosalina's reads, you do seem to be most concerned about them
Why is that?
@I have been deliberately vague, to avoid hinting at who I regard as town. But I still don't see how town reads help. Consider I say person X, who up till now has been playing perfectly fine, without the spotlight being placed on him, is town. What would you say? Would you question it? Would you argue it? After all, he's been playing fine, and you yourself probably had a similar read on him. It wouldn't generate much content, would probably be soon forgotten, and would only tell the mafia who to lynch if everyone came to the consensus that person Y is town. It doesn't help us at all. For instance, consider everyone's reveal of reads thus far. Can you actually remember who said who was town? On the other hand, I can remember conflicts between certain players, who thought who may have been mafia. Admittedly, I still need to sometimes reread for a refresher, but they stayed in my mind much more securely than any town reads they gave.
Primarily for the reasons stated above. While no-one or very few people posted they thought you were town, concealing my read of you would allow me to prevent attention being drawn to you. However, after everyone revealed their thoughts on you, my reason became moot. Questioning Zalak was primarily an attempt to generate content and attempt to get a better read of him. Additionally, his reasoning actually brought to mind several reasons I shouldn't conceal my reads, some of which I'd forgotten. Thus, I decided to reveal my reads after my reasons to conceal them became moot.why did you want to hide that
Sorry meant to quote you in the above post to get your responsePrimarily for the reasons stated above. While no-one or very few people posted they thought you were town, concealing my read of you would allow me to prevent attention being drawn to you. However, after everyone revealed their thoughts on you, my reason became moot. Questioning Zalak was primarily an attempt to generate content and attempt to get a better read of him. Additionally, his reasoning actually brought to mind several reasons I shouldn't conceal my reads, some of which I'd forgotten. Thus, I decided to reveal my reads after my reasons to conceal them became moot.
Can you tell me what I have done to become suspicous?- Kursed behavior looks a bit suspicious but his posts aren't scummy. I can see why somebody would think that player X generally agreeing with just about everything is scummy. I'd consider him null for now.
![]()
Because it is so true! As if whenever you begin an argument/quote you begin withAlso, you and Kursed keep calling me out for agreeing with everyone,
I'm just making compensations so they'll listen to me more carefully.Because it is so true! As if whenever you begin an argument/quote you begin with
"I see your side and agree with you, but..."
Pretty much. However, I said I had reads since I would be asked about the rest of my reads, or I'll have to lie, which is never a good idea.Ok, I think I get you. My push on you, while you believe it to be wrong, made you think I was town because you understand where I'm coming from, but you didn't want to post it because you didn't want to attract mafia attention to me, but you wanted people to know you had reads so you mentioned it anyways, though not the details. This correct?
Two things,I post when I can
Granted we all want to see Rosalina's reads, you do seem to be most concerned about them
Why is that?
Fishing for pro-town credit on grounds of "getting town out of RVS" is scummy, my friend. Not to mention that you didn't kickstart" ****. You just asked Zalak a couple of shallow questions.Yeah because I totally didn't try to kick start the game or anything to get content moving.
Gheb plz.
Uhhhhhhh, I have no idea what you're trying to tell me ...Gheb how can you call Ninja just a punching bag, he's been prodded for solid stances best being his post #216 and activity but to no avail on a solid direction with him.
Do you think lack of confidence makes sense here for his activity when he has posted? Can you give me examples then.
No, it's quite irrelevant now.Can you tell me what I have done to become suspicous?
We'll play a bit later XDTwo things,
1) lets wifi again. Dorfpatrol is ready for action again.
2) can you discuss me with your reads and why you think such in the best detail, if not I am 100% for lynching you first right now. I don't feel as though you are invested in finding scum which is a scum tell to me.
If you are, be as honest as possible in your next post and go into every thought you have on the cast at large.
The first 'read' is just a blatant copy of what Zalak had said.We'll play a bit later XD
Okay
If Rosalina is mafia, then Kursed is his partner.
Zalak is probably town
As for Gheb and you Red, I'm not too sure
My first two reads (Rosalina and Kursed) seem the most likely due to concealed reads (which is pretty suspicious regardless if they are town reads or not) Kursed has been pushing Zalak for agreeing with people, and I know this isn't a great basis for scum, but based on his posts it doesn't take much to peg him as such.
My Zalak and Maven reads aren't as sure
Zalak has been giving really strong town vibes since the start, but having the same opinion as most can mean you are trying to stay on good terms with everyone which could point to mafia. Or you really feel that way :L
Maven, I honestly don't have a definitive read as well, but I don't want to peg you as null just yet
I'll make my vote in the next post
I just want to push this out before my phone dies