Sword/Delvro: Why are you two not voting Tandora if you believe her to be scummy?
Actually I was busy building a case aginst her, that's why!
---
Tanny's play was always in the the back of my mind toDay, but Delvo's recent "Tanny is playing advice dog" part of post has inspired me to go and look back at her posts to see if there is truth in those statments. (hint: it's true!)
Note that I'm only bringing up quotes that bother me, if I went through all of her posts this would take forever.
Wait...I thought Jesters had to self-hammer.
Rockin, I agree with your post overall. However, your estimation of Cello is completely wrong. There are some people he likes to tunnel. It varies from person to person. First there was FF, then there was J, and now you. (I'm sure there were people inbetween, but those are the ones I thought of)
I'm glad to see you're more comfortable with your own sexuality to be okay with the thought of Cello man crushing on you. But the simple fact is you'll never be more than frenemies.
@Cello, between Rockin and KY, I'd go for KY. I'd like to see more from Rockin, but I think his posts so far fit what I have seen of his town play. Haven't played with KY in a while so seeing his reaction to pressure would be good.
VOTE KIRBYOSHI
This post right here is what starts to bother me about her play. This post starts off her tendacy to give advice rather then actually try to be usful. I'm also
really not liking the KY vote. Her reason seems really week and it gives off vibes that she was just trying to find a reason to jump on a bandwagon.
After it was pointed out, I realized my mistake. Partly blame it on never having played with a jester on forum.
I can see the point Vocal is making. However, anyone can pretty much take three posts and make a point on them. I don't feel they necessarily prove KY's alignment. I think however, it does point positively towards Vocal for pulling them up.
Not cool, man.
I get that Cello is hard headed. But do you think mocking him is going to make him agree with you or make you not look like a jerk? Make your points, disagree with him, or ignore him, but statements like the one above just lead to personal arguing that is all too often T-v-T which I would like to avoid.
I love how my joke about Kuz learning Ate from you makes you do a visual Ate.
It's RVS ( or was) and I just never know how to get into that stage. Sitting back, commenting here and there. You know?
I've also made the mistake of being active in four games and I'm letting the oldest one have priority for activity. I WILL NOT BE A LURKER! I'm just saying until the game gets into more full swing, I just not gonna say much. It makes me look scum every game. =/
Also, I've seen lately that town tends to drag its feet on lynch wagons. We get down to the zero hour, scramble to get a lynch and a townie dies. Suck. So I wanted to participate on the KY wagon for some reads. Heck, the Kuz wagon got some good reactions, so I'm feeling pretty good about this game.
And I"m really glad we're moving away from the DBZ flavor and it being "D3". Although those reactions are good to look at, I don't think our whole discussions needed to be about them.
As far as X1 goes, yeah I see him as being scummy. But he's always on my scumdar and I've found that makes me tunnel unnecessarily. Ironically, it makes me less likely to lead a lynch on him because of that personal WIFOM.
Third to last paragraph: Not important, people already know this stuff. It's really just filler.
Second to last paragraph: Spoken way after the fact. Also pointless filler.
Last paragraph: wishy-washy
everything else about this post is fine, I guess.
That's not what I heard from the grapevine. >.>
As far as scummy players, it's still a little early from me. I probably say this every game, but I don't really get invested until D2.
Would definitely like to hear more from Bed now that you're posting.
I like the idea of pressuring inactives to get reactions and to get them involved in the game. However, that only works if they are actually lurking. Unless we know for a fact that Bed has been looking at the thread at any point, pressuring him has no effect. It would be a waste of time.
Inactivity past the point of posting once every 72 hours should fall to the responsibility of the mod. Players should definitely remind/request for prods, but ultimately, it is the mod who determines if a player needs to be replaced or modkilled.
REQUEST PROD FOR SIR BED
These two posts all are super duper fluffy. There is no intent to catch scum in them. There all meant just to show us that she exists still. This is definitly advice dog here.
God, this and every single damn game I've ever played complains about how quiet I am on D1. Let's be honest, although there's some content going on the last couple of pages, what I have mostly seen is Kuz telling Teryble how to run their stupid hydra.
There's been more discussion about how a hydra has been managed than anything else.
Also, kinda is discouraging to get involved when we have people saying the following:
No johns
Also stalling much?
It comes off as fluff defense. "Your argument is invalid because you cannot you posted in green instead of white." I mean realistically TD is attempting to do town a favor by showing who's thinking what when and how instead of the usual hydra ambiguity. And Kuz focuses on that?
Add it to his previous strike for supporting a guilty claim and I just don't like his play. Trying to decide if my fear of him being jester is valid or not before I move my vote.
I cannot fathom why she would seriously be cocerned at all with there beig a jester. It seems so . . . pointless to me.
Also more stalling.
I gave up on multiquotig after this post so I could start to construct this one, so . . . yeah.
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=11998499&postcount=419
This post is constructed to just make a point, but it does not actually go anywhere. Bad
vhttp://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12003353&postcount=442
REALLY bad. This post goes nowhere, at all. I mean I can understand aswering a question, but it's really just a whole lot of nothing important.
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12021756&postcount=622
Again, she states another person she's suspicious of but does nothing to go after them. Also, she has a town read on two players but does nothing to try to stear off the wagon, cause there's "not enough time." What? Dude, 30 hours is plenty of time! This seems like you're trying to clear all links between you and townies. Do not like.
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12056844&postcount=901
Mostly just more advice dog here.
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12060109&postcount=946
Cello sums this up nicly in his 249:
Cello said:
Her 978 is also not helpful.
http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12066446&postcount=1038
This still makes no sense, at all. Seriously, lynching someone cause you think they might be jester who has to hammer themselves to win is terribad.
---
Other points of interest:
-Practically the only time Tanny gives actual opinions of stuff is when she's asked for it.
-Her lurkingish playstyle could be interpertated as scum having a hard time finding what to say. I know that personally, when I'm scum, I have a hard time getting into the converstion just because I'm super careful about slipping up.
-To her defense, she did attack X1 in her 392. However, she did not follow up on any suspicion she had for X1 (or anyone she said was scummy, for that matter). This makes it feel more likely to be a bus.
-Also to her defense, there was a handful of her posts which seemed legit enough for me. Still not enough though to get her out of the hot water she's in now.
-Guys look at my 615 and then X1's 616. Ha, that's pretty bad looking for Tanny right there. Now look at X1's 630. He metions her somewhat and attacks her. Nothing super hardcore though. He takes a fairly safe stance on her. Also it's important to note that she never responds to X1's attack, even though she previously thought he was acting "OOC." pretty suspicious stuff if you ask me.
Really, having seems scummy one way or another, but at this point she simply seems the scummiest.
vote tanny
Other people to consider lynching toDay include (in order):
Rockin
Mainly just because I actually find him in the most iffy gray area i this game that I am not comfortable having any player in. Generally connot remember what he has done for us this game.
Bed playerslot
For the same reason as above, but at the very least he posted good things when he did post (at least I think so).
KY
For X1's direct defense of him late yesterDay and for his iffish claim.
Ran
Lots of pointless stuff being posted by him. Want to see him play toDay out more before I make a stronger judgment of him though.
DH/Kuz
For the reasons that everyone else finds these two scummy, cept that I simply don't find them nearly as scummy.
I think Tanny is definitly the way to go toDay.
J I saw you made a post before this but I did not read it so sorry if I ninja anything.