I'd need BC on the panel, I have never actually played Buzz, and last time I played Chex was a year and a half ago. So him and Buzz could cover East Idaho. But I definitely know the most about West Idaho, so I'm self-nominating, lol. Then at least one more from W. Idaho.
I'd say it's between Qraq and Knuttz, if we were to pick one. They both have played quite a few of us, and are both pretty active. However, Qraq is a better player (sorry Knuttz, we know it's true ;D), and better players are often better judges. But Knuttz has more experience playing all of us, and it will probably stay that way, since Qraq is up in Mountain Home a lot of the time. Really we could just put both..
One problem I have with Buzz is that he doesn't have much experience against any of us from West Idaho, and it will probably only be downhill from here. I'm saying this not in a "I don't want him on" way, but in a sympathetic way; it'd be hard for him to judge and expecting him to would be sucky of us.
And finally, I think we have enough to do a top 10. Qraq, me, Felix, Aaron, BC, Knuttz, Josh, Julius, Buzz, Sephiroth M, gotta mention my boy The Chancellor, and the list goes on.
(It'd be easiest to just ignore East Idaho since it's hard to treat them fairly, considering the lack of playtime against them... just put Buzz on an honorable mentions list, lol.)