#HBC | Joker
Space Marine
- Joined
- Feb 2, 2012
- Messages
- 3,864
- Location
- St. Clair Shores, Michigan
- NNID
- HBCJoker
- 3DS FC
- 1864-9780-3232
Ryker
Ryker hasn't done or said a whole lot, but I guess neither have I. What I've seen looks townie to me. His posts feel like he's looking for scum.
Null/Town
No Lynch
At first I was suspicious as hell of this slot. Soup seemed to be tunneling BSP for no reason, and it smelled fishy to me. Once that was over, the things they did started making more sense. I think he was just jumpstarting the game, and has since been reading players and hunting scum in a way that makes me like seeing them post.
Town
frozenflame
Not really sure what to think here. It feels like he's skating by. I don't see much activity from him in general. He's not asking questions, he's not putting pressure on anyone. He's just telling other people that their reasoning is weak. I don't like this. Convince me you are town, sir.
Null/scum
Vinyl
I know I'm not alone here. Vinyl is impossible to read
I'm inclined to call his actions town, because I don't think he'd be sticking his neck out so much if he was scum. That's my best guess.
Null/Town
BSL
I like seeing BSL post. When I see him post, I see a townie. He's asking questions that make sense to me.
Town
194
Too soon to tell. Replacing into a terrible slot that is terribly inactive does not provide a good read.
Hell if I know
Orboknown
Orbo's general inactivity isn't that unusual. When he posts, he gets in there and posts quite a bit, so I'm inclined to blame it on him being busy/unable to post the rest of the time. What I do see when he posts is stuff that I generally like. He's looking for the bad guys, it feels like.
Town lean
Kary
Kary usually asks questions that I like a lot. I'm not seeing as much of it, but I think he's just busy? I dunno. What I do see seems like what I expect from him. I've only played one game with Kary where he ICed (IC Kary is pretty different from regular Kary) but I caught a glimpse of regular Kary when I read D1 of Newbie 19, where Kary was a regular player, and a townie. So far, this game's play looks like that game.
Town
Badwolf
BW is just a terrible town player. I explained this in my last post. I think if he was scum, he'd be making an effort to mislynch townies. Not sit back with his thumb up his butt being an *** to everyone. I don't think he likes being a townie. Not a super reliable read, but I'm gonna stick with it for now as I don't think he'd be a good play for today, even if it did turn out he was scum.
Town lean
Riddle
I want to call him a townie, I really do. I think he probably is a townie. His line of questioning and reasoning always feels... off? Like, he's trying to find scum, but he's looking at stuff I wouldn't look at. Maybe that's a good thing, though. I'd rather keep him around as a townie than call him scum for weak *** reasoning, like "icky feelings", and lose him.
Null/Town
BSP
I honestly think BSP and I think a lot alike. His early interaction with No Lynch felt like the way I'd probably react to that kind of meaningless pressure. Maybe it's because we have about the same amount of mafia experience. I don't wanna trick myself into confirming him as town, but I'm not seeing scum from him either. What I'd like to see is him acting outside of being pushed. That would give me a much better read.
Town lean
KevinM
This man wants to lynch scum sooooo bad. At least that's what he'd like us to believe. I, myself, am inclined to believe it. I don't know how he usually plays, but I feel like a scum player would not be making this much effort to seize control of the town. I didn't really like his reasoning for the Tery wagon though. Like, at all. I'd feel more comfortable if I knew where his head was at.
Town lean
Anomadaris_Rake
Rake is town guys. srsly. srsly guys. Town. I had an inkling that Hando was town, but once Rake stepped in it kinda became clear.
Town
Wish I had some stronger scumreads. Until I put this down in writing, I honestly had no idea ff was my strongest scumread X_x
In the interest of getting something out of him
Vote: Frozenflame
Ryker hasn't done or said a whole lot, but I guess neither have I. What I've seen looks townie to me. His posts feel like he's looking for scum.
Null/Town
No Lynch
At first I was suspicious as hell of this slot. Soup seemed to be tunneling BSP for no reason, and it smelled fishy to me. Once that was over, the things they did started making more sense. I think he was just jumpstarting the game, and has since been reading players and hunting scum in a way that makes me like seeing them post.
Town
frozenflame
Not really sure what to think here. It feels like he's skating by. I don't see much activity from him in general. He's not asking questions, he's not putting pressure on anyone. He's just telling other people that their reasoning is weak. I don't like this. Convince me you are town, sir.
Null/scum
Vinyl
I know I'm not alone here. Vinyl is impossible to read
I'm inclined to call his actions town, because I don't think he'd be sticking his neck out so much if he was scum. That's my best guess.Null/Town
BSL
I like seeing BSL post. When I see him post, I see a townie. He's asking questions that make sense to me.
Town
194
Too soon to tell. Replacing into a terrible slot that is terribly inactive does not provide a good read.
Hell if I know
Orboknown
Orbo's general inactivity isn't that unusual. When he posts, he gets in there and posts quite a bit, so I'm inclined to blame it on him being busy/unable to post the rest of the time. What I do see when he posts is stuff that I generally like. He's looking for the bad guys, it feels like.
Town lean
Kary
Kary usually asks questions that I like a lot. I'm not seeing as much of it, but I think he's just busy? I dunno. What I do see seems like what I expect from him. I've only played one game with Kary where he ICed (IC Kary is pretty different from regular Kary) but I caught a glimpse of regular Kary when I read D1 of Newbie 19, where Kary was a regular player, and a townie. So far, this game's play looks like that game.
Town
Badwolf
BW is just a terrible town player. I explained this in my last post. I think if he was scum, he'd be making an effort to mislynch townies. Not sit back with his thumb up his butt being an *** to everyone. I don't think he likes being a townie. Not a super reliable read, but I'm gonna stick with it for now as I don't think he'd be a good play for today, even if it did turn out he was scum.
Town lean
Riddle
I want to call him a townie, I really do. I think he probably is a townie. His line of questioning and reasoning always feels... off? Like, he's trying to find scum, but he's looking at stuff I wouldn't look at. Maybe that's a good thing, though. I'd rather keep him around as a townie than call him scum for weak *** reasoning, like "icky feelings", and lose him.
Null/Town
BSP
I honestly think BSP and I think a lot alike. His early interaction with No Lynch felt like the way I'd probably react to that kind of meaningless pressure. Maybe it's because we have about the same amount of mafia experience. I don't wanna trick myself into confirming him as town, but I'm not seeing scum from him either. What I'd like to see is him acting outside of being pushed. That would give me a much better read.
Town lean
KevinM
This man wants to lynch scum sooooo bad. At least that's what he'd like us to believe. I, myself, am inclined to believe it. I don't know how he usually plays, but I feel like a scum player would not be making this much effort to seize control of the town. I didn't really like his reasoning for the Tery wagon though. Like, at all. I'd feel more comfortable if I knew where his head was at.
Town lean
Anomadaris_Rake
Rake is town guys. srsly. srsly guys. Town. I had an inkling that Hando was town, but once Rake stepped in it kinda became clear.
Town
Wish I had some stronger scumreads. Until I put this down in writing, I honestly had no idea ff was my strongest scumread X_x
In the interest of getting something out of him
Vote: Frozenflame
