I Honestly hadn't noticed the character reductions (I haven't really played w/ peach or sonic >_>)
But all in all, it's a pretty amazing story for one w/o dialogue.. The annoying part was Giga Diddy Kong (you had to kill that beast with a military of items). And yes, it's kind of typical that the beginning started off w/ Kirby saving Princess Peach (or Zelda), but that's typical since the creators were HAL. Laboratory. I hated those stupid Cloud stages. They should have made the levels more character-oriented. The one w/ Pokemon Trainer was very insipid. Why would a pokemon trainer be at some deserted zoo if he's looking for a Charizard/Ivysaur. The character placements and what they do seems very shallow.
The main problem was each character's story and their background. For instance, there was basically no sign of Tabuu until the end. He also had no explanation and nor did Master Hand (Why and how he was tied up). Even though trophies are there to describe for example, Tabuu, they don't give enough information... Also, for each cutscene, I almost always asked
"How did they get here? Why are they here? This makes no sense"
For example, they could have added more custscenes to infer the fact that the character just returned from a scene which was in their respective game ie:
Pokemon Trainer just exiting a pokemon center and finds a swarm of Primids.
There were also several contradictions with characters.
For any character, how did they end up in this trophy world?
Why was the Master Sword in the stump? When exactly is this happening?
Why was Samus in her Zero Suit? HOW did she lose her Power Suit? How did it end up there?
Why was Lucas scared? If it happened either before or after the events of Mother 3, it still makes no sense. This is before Mother 3: If he was scared, it later shows in the SSE that he's grown to be strong and brave. But then Mother 3 occurs and he's scared all over again. If it happened AFTER the events of Mother 3, that doesn't explain why he was frightened in the beginning of his appearance.
For Ness and Lucas, they both have PK Moves they shouldn't have (PK Starstorm, PK Freeze, PK Fire)
I Know I may seem picky to point out those errors, but I just want to know how everything fits together. Also, many are complaining that the 3 hidden characters weren't involved. I Don't see why they weren't included. Wolf could have an easy part in the story. At the beginning of Fox's appearance, his ship crashed. Now why is that? hmm, probably because a certain Wolf blasted his Arwing-donkey to this planet. For Jigglypuff.. Well, Pikachu was found in a generator, Lucario was found majestically standing on a mountain top, P.T Was found in a deserted Zoo. Let's say Jigglypuff was found being knocked around during the Arwing-Halberd fight. As for Toon Link, he's the only one who has a valid reason to be excluded from the story. What would Link do if he saw Toon Link? Sure, he'd think "HEY! THAT GREEN FREAK WITH THE BOMBS CLONED ME INTO SOME DEMENTED 3 COLOUR VERSION OF MYSELF" and then they'd fight. But what would happen after? They'd probably make up some how, but they'd both be scared from each other, seeing as, well I don't know. One of them is the grandpa of the other! Also, where would T.L have come from? His main adventures are on the Great Sea.
Other than that, Wolf and Jiggly easily had a place, and so did Sonic instead of randomly coming out of no where and defeating the hardest part about Tabuu. _SIGH_ Sorry it's a lot to read.