• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Glyph Muscles Proudly Presents: Mario Party 2 Mafia: Game OVER!

#HBC | Laundry

Grand Sage of Swag
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Messages
3,954
Location
Under a bridge
3DS FC
3926-6895-8719
For the love of goodness, I said the exact same thing about Marshy and you call me scummy for it? Please tell me this is not the case. =/

Still reading the post storm.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA.

No, you didn't. Try harder.
 

#HBC | Laundry

Grand Sage of Swag
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Messages
3,954
Location
Under a bridge
3DS FC
3926-6895-8719
Ryker, what do you make of WL's basic cookie-cutter views of yours and insistent buddying of your slot? I feel like he is just trying to get on your good side with his over-the-top way of pushing your scum-reads as well and is trying to reach for reasons to make himself seem original on the wagons that have been presented to himself.
Have you ever thought that, despite his ******* D1 shot, he's the only play who I even remotely trust right now?

Like, my ****ing gog, how ******** are people in this game.

What makes you of a July-WL connection to do the way WL is trying to subtly diffuse the July wagon? He is the only one to speak up thus far of the July case not having merit and actually the first to call it reaching because none of Swords/Ran/and even July herself called the case reaching.
What? What? Way to just subtly spin what I'm doing into a scummy light, yo.

The July case means jack **** to me when it's caused by someone I view as scum. The only way I see July as town is if you and marshy flip scum. Hell, it's possible that July's town just if you flip scum. If you flip town, I'd go back and look at July. But I'm so far ****ing convinced that you're scum that I'm damn well not acting like it. Try again, *******.

This is actually where I can see the point to where WL is scummier than July because she at least responds to posts and actually tries to see the others PoV in the argument while still giving her defense. WL just tries to find a way to discredit the argument and inflate it into a show of "OMG U SO SCUUUUUUUUUUMMY" without actually providing much reasoning behind his suspicions. His posts come across as extremely fake, especially when talking about his J/Marshy/July posts. I do not get his JulyTown read where he is okay with her not being in the lynch pool. I also find his suspicion of Swords unprecendented and I don't get why he finds him as scum. He says because of Swords weird hop onto WL when he was actually like the main proponent to WL's wagon and his suspicion of Swords seems invested in a bit of OMGUS.
>extremely fake



I've explained my July town read twice now. If your ****ing failure at reading comprehension and basic logic prevents you from understanding that, it is no fault of mine.

scumJ+scumMarshy=townJuly

Try again.

Also I said I found it weird because it came from left field. I'm fine with Swords. He can live for now. But that's a slot I'd analyze down the road if you and marshy flip scum.

Or you and KevMo. I don't ****in' know.
 

#HBC | Laundry

Grand Sage of Swag
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Messages
3,954
Location
Under a bridge
3DS FC
3926-6895-8719
@laundry 544: you dont like ran? what dont you like about him?
I dislike Ran's approach to this game and I feel like he's off on some of the things he's done but as a whole I don't find him scummy. I just dislike what he's doing.

@ washedlaundry 559: "Your opening posts were the only thing in the game that did not involve LDR/EE/Mentos. It's odd and, like I said, against the grain of the game (LDR's shot and Mentos' reaction to it, then analysis of Mentos' reaction). Rather than embroil yourself in it, you simply just elected to **** off into your own world.

Yep, that's not shady in the slightest, no ****ing way."

**** the grain of the game. this town has ****ed up in so many ways already so not rolling with the general poor direction of the town is...well if thats scummy then i gladly accept my entrance into bizarro world. as for "****ing off into my own world" yeah more like "exploring other avenues while ee/mentos/ryker circlejerk" see how easy it is for me to frame that ****
Alright, lemme explain why it caught my eye:

With Ryker being town and Mentos flipping town, I had a hunch that scum was going to sit back and subtly push the game in a way where they wouldn't have to do much of the work because town was too busy killing itself. townRyker shot townEE and lynched townMentos, probtownRan and maybetownSword were immediately pushing on townLaundry over bull****, indyJerkus actually was taking more of a background approach and was even pegged as much. Seeing you and Macman come in and completely ignore everything going on was somewhat of a red flag.

Your response made me realize that I'm wrong about it and that it was dumb of me to explore you when I should've been barking up indyJerkus for sitting there and doing jack **** and even claiming as much.

GEE I WONDER WHO ELSE DID THE EXACT SAME GOGDAMN THING

btw just wanna say the hate on the july wagon is dumb. when quickwagons form early in the game its often all/mostly protown players who are taking action to kill who they believe to be scum while the scum just let the game stall
Fine, feel free to. As shady as it is, I can understand it from you after Math Blasters.

But I don't think for a second that J would take that course of action as town.
 

#HBC | Laundry

Grand Sage of Swag
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Messages
3,954
Location
Under a bridge
3DS FC
3926-6895-8719
gonna split up the next few posts for the sake of digestion

iight so to start off understand that i am 13 hours ahead of you all (est) so obviously im often sleeping while yall are active in this game and vice versa. on top of that i have 11 hour work days and spend a lot of free time with coworkers and trying to maintain my relationships with friends/family back home. i understand im under pressure right now but try to see things from my angle in that when yall are hyper posting like you were at the beginning of this day phase i may not be around so this information is just to dispel future "lol marshys lurking" garbage (which i dont even do as scum but whatever). also since i usually post from my phone while yall are active (as evidenced by my earlier posts) its hard to respond to everything til i can get to a computer. i can get to a computer every day tho so just understand while i WILL be active i might kind of look like frozenflame in that yall might be waiting on a post/response from me but i dont have the proper timezone/internet access to be complete in my responses. anyways

lets analyze rykers thought process that me or kevin would likely be top candidates for killing macman. i actually can understand this from rykertown and am going to be frank in stating that macmans death (why would anyone ****ing kill him) made me look at kevin. before the day ended you can see that i quoted macmans statement of "kevins probably scum" and switched my vig choice from macman to laundry because that comment made me deeply second guess my hate on macman. macmans got a good kevinscuMdar and im often wary of kevins buddying (he does this regardless of alignment) me cuz im usually content to let him stay around til later in the game. he likes to bus his buddies anyway

why i have little (im not cocky enough to say NO motive) to kill macman and why kevin would

im assuming ryker believes that macmans killer was either me or kevin due to our past history in playing games with each other. but yeah when ive been scum against macman as town i usually dont kill him til way later in the game and/or just buddy mad hardbody. here:

m3ds harry potter: i admit this isnt the best example cuz macman was fairly new and a weaker player at the time. i killed him n4 and we didnt interact with each other all game. he suspected me here and there but they were never very strong at all and were just mentioned in passing. he was not a threat

mafia tournament sleepover: **** i actually killed him n1 here what a terrible example! nah not really because the kills blatantly differ (if you look from the perspective that im scum in this game which im not but hey since im apparently being considered as a play right now ill go indepth as to why i wouldnt kill macman) in that he was actively scumhunting (voting and fosing my scumbros all daily) and bashing the terrible d1 lynch there. he was a THREAT. here...he was lurking and content to let the mentos wagon go while not reading the thread

wonderland mafia: this is around the time that macman improved leaps and bounds in mafia...**** i killed him n1 here too. well that was cuz of the same reasons as above and he basically confirmed himself town by spearheading (again not doing that in this game) the lynch against my scumbuddy riddle. so yeah i killed his *** n1 but there is an obvious reason as opposed to this game

tv-allstars: i buddied him all game and kept him around til endgame. very different strategy than what scummarshy would be doing here

scum wars: i buddied him all game and kept him around til endgame. very different strategy than what scummarshy would be doing here

down n dirty: i didnt interact with him much all game and kept him around til endgame. very different strategy than what scummarshy would be doing here

so yeah. usually i buddy him and then just kill him at least in the newer games weve played together. he posed no threat to me OR my potential scumbuddies in this game (he never voiced suspicions against me and just listed some people hedve been content with lynching) which were the only reasons i killed him in those earlier games. he was also obvtown in those earlier games and while i admit i was the main person pressuring him this game i think its pretty clear that no one in this game thought he was obvtown

now lets look at what happens when kevin is scum and macman is town

monster mafia: kevin keeps macman around til mylo but macman deduces that he is the final scum. so macman catches him there

scum wars mafia: kevin is some ****tyass role (lol sorry tom) that basically enables my kill choices. kevin didnt have sole control over mafia kills so this game is null but am putting it here for the sake of completion

batma(n)fia 2: macman harbors suspicions against kevin from pretty early on in the game and pushes his lynch. so macman catches him again

unintended consequences mafia: macman catches kevinscuM again and helps lynch him d3

one piece mafia: most of yall cant see this but basically macman was scum and kevin was an sk. macman gets lynched before he could do anything

good times

anyway i think its obvious which of us wouldve killed macman
I don't particularly even like delving into the WIFOM but I understand it and am okay with it. It's possible that you're telling the truth. It's possible you're doing this because it could incriminate KevMo and get that M/L. I like that it's limited the option to you two though.

But considering the basis of my suspicions on you is trusting Ryker in that you would shoot Macman and your hardcore buddybuddy with scumJ, I'm starting to like your slot more after this post and the other one I just quoted.

J's still scum regardless. Better flesh that out more than "HE'S SUCH A ****ING *******."
 

#HBC | Laundry

Grand Sage of Swag
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Messages
3,954
Location
Under a bridge
3DS FC
3926-6895-8719
Alright, time to break down J suspicions. I'm not gonna do a ****ton of quotes but I'll reference **** for people asking me where I got it.

Let's start with the most obvious thing he's done today: willingly and knowingly putting July at L-1 within hours of the start of the day with 4 people yet to post and July had not claimed yet. I can expect such behavior from marshy, but from my experience with J, that is so far against everything he says and does. The guy usually bludgeons people whenever they try to quickhammer without information. Call it meta, yes, but it's the reaction to being called out for such scummy behavior that really stands out to me. Ryker called J out for the such scummy behavior and J's immediate response is to compare what he had done to what Ryker had done and call him a hypocrite for it when there's no damn comparison to be made in the first place.

That reeks. Not only is the logic ****, he's further using his scummy play to try to attack our obvtown Dayvig. He completely stands by it rather than knowing that he's getting called out for it and backing down, he stands by it. **** that noise.

But then there's also D1, where he came in and despite poking at Mentos, he flat-out ****ing says that he's not gonna do a lot until something catches his eye. THAT'S MOTHER****IN' SHADY. As I've already stated, with Ryker's shot and then attack on Mentos, town was already eating itself. Then Ran dropped a load of bull**** on me and made it worse. At that point, for some ****ing reason, he goes after July instead but his case is so ****ing dumb because he completely contradicts himself in it. Earlier in the game he actually praised me for retracting a town-lean on him saying that he hadn't warranted it. The second he did that, he became a scum-lean. J fluffed like mad for the entire early game. And yet, for July to call him scummy she's obvscum, right? BULL****.

Obviously this is coming down to the question of dumb or scum. I've seen J make some completely ******* statements and cases before but his entire game is riddled with them. I really cannot believe that J's this dumb. He's proved to me countless times that he's not this ****ing dumb. His piddly *** logic, terrible reaches, blatant contradictions, and scummy play all suggest that he's scum here.

Die J.
 

KevinM

TB12 TB12 TB12
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 30, 2007
Messages
13,625
Location
Sickboi in the 401
Holy suspicions batman..

Marshy kinda obv town at this point

WL kinda reeks

J kinda reeks

wouldn't be surprised for that to be T v S or S v S distancing since the best distance usually happens when a lot of other threats are being thrown around so they're not being analyzed strongly.

Marshy, I didn't kill Macman bro, I don't understand why you're playing the whole me OR you game without giving any other logical thought to other people that would want him dead.

Ryker is null but still leaning town for me just because given the size of the game a one dayshot survivor doesn't seem like a role that could be balanced easily.

July is null not quite sure her strong reads but I liked the fact that she finally put a hard post down on the game.

Umm I don't have much else to say...

Ok with WL going or Raziek going for trying to cost hard into the end of the game.

Not sure where people have their heads at on that still
 

Raziek

Charging Limit All Day
Joined
Oct 14, 2008
Messages
9,626
Location
Halifax, Nova Scotia
NNID
Raziek
3DS FC
3866-8131-5247
@ raziek 253: why did you specifically ask kevin this question here?
Kevin had just posted, and was still viewing thread.

Straight up, I have so little interest in this game because Ryker's just shooting people willy-nilly and making me hate even trying to deal with his motivations. Someone else catch scum, I'll vote where needed.
 

ranmaru

Smash Legend
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
13,297
Switch FC
SW-0654 7794 0698
Question Raz, who's vote will you follow then? (and why)
 

Raziek

Charging Limit All Day
Joined
Oct 14, 2008
Messages
9,626
Location
Halifax, Nova Scotia
NNID
Raziek
3DS FC
3866-8131-5247
I want to say Ryker, but his shots have been pretty ****. I'm still mad about the EE shot, that was absolutely pants-on-head ********.

Probably WL or Marshy.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
I'd be REAL careful with that Marshy town read. It's gonna be dangerous to have if he flips scum which seems to be possible.
 

ranmaru

Smash Legend
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
13,297
Switch FC
SW-0654 7794 0698
Oh gross, I just realized that KevMo/J/Marshy could be a thing.
Yeah, I'm not going to think of scum teams much without scum flipping.

Also, if J/Marshy flipped town, I'd lynch July right after wards, not Raz. That's if we lynched one of those two. I'm re-reading to decide who'll go ToDay.

But tell me, why are you voting KevinM tho? What did you see?
 

ranmaru

Smash Legend
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
13,297
Switch FC
SW-0654 7794 0698
Ryker, what do you make of WL's basic cookie-cutter views of yours and insistent buddying of your slot? I feel like he is just trying to get on your good side with his over-the-top way of pushing your scum-reads as well and is trying to reach for reasons to make himself seem original on the wagons that have been presented to himself.

What makes you of a July-WL connection to do the way WL is trying to subtly diffuse the July wagon? He is the only one to speak up thus far of the July case not having merit and actually the first to call it reaching because none of Swords/Ran/and even July herself called the case reaching.

This is actually where I can see the point to where WL is scummier than July because she at least responds to posts and actually tries to see the others PoV in the argument while still giving her defense. WL just tries to find a way to discredit the argument and inflate it into a show of "OMG U SO SCUUUUUUUUUUMMY" without actually providing much reasoning behind his suspicions. His posts come across as extremely fake, especially when talking about his J/Marshy/July posts. I do not get his JulyTown read where he is okay with her not being in the lynch pool. I also find his suspicion of Swords unprecendented and I don't get why he finds him as scum. He says because of Swords weird hop onto WL when he was actually like the main proponent to WL's wagon and his suspicion of Swords seems invested in a bit of OMGUS.
J, are you serious? Get back on July. WL isn't a play ToDay man.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
Yeah, I'm not going to think of scum teams much without scum flipping.

Also, if J/Marshy flipped town, I'd lynch July right after wards, not Raz. That's if we lynched one of those two. I'm re-reading to decide who'll go ToDay.

But tell me, why are you voting KevinM tho? What did you see?
His last post didn't even address what I'm talking about which is more than important to him. I don't know if he's covered it elsewhere. As of now, he can go before Marshy.



I'm not asking you to lynch Raz if J and Marshy and/or Kevin flips town. But, to be completely honest, I will film me eating my hat if that happens.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
Raz, sit down and play the game. If you're not ****ing scum, work with me and read this damn day phase.

If you are, keep going, you're in line to die.
 

ranmaru

Smash Legend
Joined
Feb 10, 2008
Messages
13,297
Switch FC
SW-0654 7794 0698
Mmm, I'm not convinced. I'm not interested in Kevin until this J/Marshy/July situation is situated.

I know you aren't asking me, I'm telling you I don't want to lynch Raz before July.

I have only skimmed Marshy's post btw, I'll read it further later. I'm going to play minecraft.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
gonna split up the next few posts for the sake of digestion

iight so to start off understand that i am 13 hours ahead of you all (est) so obviously im often sleeping while yall are active in this game and vice versa. on top of that i have 11 hour work days and spend a lot of free time with coworkers and trying to maintain my relationships with friends/family back home. i understand im under pressure right now but try to see things from my angle in that when yall are hyper posting like you were at the beginning of this day phase i may not be around so this information is just to dispel future "lol marshys lurking" garbage (which i dont even do as scum but whatever). also since i usually post from my phone while yall are active (as evidenced by my earlier posts) its hard to respond to everything til i can get to a computer. i can get to a computer every day tho so just understand while i WILL be active i might kind of look like frozenflame in that yall might be waiting on a post/response from me but i dont have the proper timezone/internet access to be complete in my responses. anyways

lets analyze rykers thought process that me or kevin would likely be top candidates for killing macman. i actually can understand this from rykertown and am going to be frank in stating that macmans death (why would anyone ****ing kill him) made me look at kevin. before the day ended you can see that i quoted macmans statement of "kevins probably scum" and switched my vig choice from macman to laundry because that comment made me deeply second guess my hate on macman. macmans got a good kevinscuMdar and im often wary of kevins buddying (he does this regardless of alignment) me cuz im usually content to let him stay around til later in the game. he likes to bus his buddies anyway

why i have little (im not cocky enough to say NO motive) to kill macman and why kevin would

im assuming ryker believes that macmans killer was either me or kevin due to our past history in playing games with each other. but yeah when ive been scum against macman as town i usually dont kill him til way later in the game and/or just buddy mad hardbody. here:

m3ds harry potter: i admit this isnt the best example cuz macman was fairly new and a weaker player at the time. i killed him n4 and we didnt interact with each other all game. he suspected me here and there but they were never very strong at all and were just mentioned in passing. he was not a threat

mafia tournament sleepover: **** i actually killed him n1 here what a terrible example! nah not really because the kills blatantly differ (if you look from the perspective that im scum in this game which im not but hey since im apparently being considered as a play right now ill go indepth as to why i wouldnt kill macman) in that he was actively scumhunting (voting and fosing my scumbros all daily) and bashing the terrible d1 lynch there. he was a THREAT. here...he was lurking and content to let the mentos wagon go while not reading the thread

wonderland mafia: this is around the time that macman improved leaps and bounds in mafia...**** i killed him n1 here too. well that was cuz of the same reasons as above and he basically confirmed himself town by spearheading (again not doing that in this game) the lynch against my scumbuddy riddle. so yeah i killed his *** n1 but there is an obvious reason as opposed to this game

tv-allstars: i buddied him all game and kept him around til endgame. very different strategy than what scummarshy would be doing here

scum wars: i buddied him all game and kept him around til endgame. very different strategy than what scummarshy would be doing here

down n dirty: i didnt interact with him much all game and kept him around til endgame. very different strategy than what scummarshy would be doing here

so yeah. usually i buddy him and then just kill him at least in the newer games weve played together. he posed no threat to me OR my potential scumbuddies in this game (he never voiced suspicions against me and just listed some people hedve been content with lynching) which were the only reasons i killed him in those earlier games. he was also obvtown in those earlier games and while i admit i was the main person pressuring him this game i think its pretty clear that no one in this game thought he was obvtown

now lets look at what happens when kevin is scum and macman is town

monster mafia: kevin keeps macman around til mylo but macman deduces that he is the final scum. so macman catches him there

scum wars mafia: kevin is some ****tyass role (lol sorry tom) that basically enables my kill choices. kevin didnt have sole control over mafia kills so this game is null but am putting it here for the sake of completion

batma(n)fia 2: macman harbors suspicions against kevin from pretty early on in the game and pushes his lynch. so macman catches him again

unintended consequences mafia: macman catches kevinscuM again and helps lynch him d3

one piece mafia: most of yall cant see this but basically macman was scum and kevin was an sk. macman gets lynched before he could do anything

good times

anyway i think its obvious which of us wouldve killed macman
There is a really key difference in this game and those.

In this game, the rest of player list that's good is:

Me, who you've all been shouting at as ******** and was certainly not very threatening going into toDay.
WL, who isn't even considered as good by as many people. You were pushing his lynch. He was looking for a replacement.
KevMo, the fact that KevMo is alive over Macman has really got me thinking here. Marshy/J/KevMo looking fine.
Macman, who you, Kevin, and possibly myself consider good. Everyone else is going almost solely off of meta that says he's inactive and lurks and off of the current game where he was entirely non-threatening.


The rest of the player list is:

J, who is almost certainly scum.
Ranmaru, who was gunning for a July lynch and not hurting you at all.
July, who was being tossed around as a lynch candidate.
Sword, who wasn't threatening you at all.
Raz, who hasn't BEEN HERE at all.





Sure, you may generally keep Macman around and KevMo may generally kill Macman, but it doesn't really matter because, from both of your PoVs, the only logical kill choice was Macman.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
Mmm, I'm not convinced. I'm not interested in Kevin until this J/Marshy/July situation is situated.

I know you aren't asking me, I'm telling you I don't want to lynch Raz before July.

I have only skimmed Marshy's post btw, I'll read it further later. I'm going to play minecraft.
Ran, get interested in Kevin. My PoE leaves him and Marshy to be confirmed as at least one scum if not both, which also makes sense given that they chose less threatening Macman over the other one of the two.

Ran, PLEASE take off the blinders in regards to July. Please? She could be scum, but don't throw it away on the possibility. Marshy, Kevin, and J are all bigger targets. Look at how Raz and July play in this day phase and beyond and then weigh it against July. If you still think you're right, then, by all means, but do the work before you pull the trigger. If the game goes that long, I'm probably not going to be there. Hell, I'm probably not going to be around until tomorrow unless I get the doc.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
heres a question for ranmaru/ryker (dont care to read your posts anymore scumlaundry): why the **** do you guys think kevin is protown? lets please take a look at his posts. im skipping his first few posts which were just confirmation and a declaration of vla
I was wrong, tbh. I thought he was town and the first post you made on the subject was enlightening.

I'm fairly certain that I wanted him to be town because he backed the Mentos lynch and did it well, which was a welcome breath of fresh air.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
ryker 577: i put july at -1 cuz i dont care if she dies and dont feel like waiting half a week for kevin to post

"Do you really think that anyone currently alive other than you and Kevin would kill Macman with the threat level he presented?"

i could see you doing it but youre not a play today. i dont dispute that me or kevin being the killer is rational. laundrys been my favorite choice since d1 and i hate the fact that his ****ing wagon failed for a protown player. still wanna kill im
I mentioned myself previously for the benefit of other players, but I didn't actually think you'd give me that much credit. Yeah, I could've done it, but I didn't and I will GLADLY throw myself into the circle of you, me, and Kevin and say there's at least one scum there.

As for July, I feel you on that. I'm pretty sure you'd do that as either alignment, but no one else will see it that way, which suits me just fine. However, I do NOT want this day phase ending in anything other than a lynch of you or Kevin.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
and now everyones following ryker despite a 1-shot vig being completely null in terms of alignment with a poor d1 shot and pushing a mislynch and now pushing me when im not scum

i agree that hes not a play...today. but i mean ****
10 points from Gryffindor.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
Ryker, what do you make of WL's basic cookie-cutter views of yours and insistent buddying of your slot? I feel like he is just trying to get on your good side with his over-the-top way of pushing your scum-reads as well and is trying to reach for reasons to make himself seem original on the wagons that have been presented to himself.
Laundry reads well to me and, while he agrees with me, he looks at the game in a very similar way as I do, so when I point things out, I expect him to agree.

Accusing him of buddying me is like accusing me of buddying Swiss. It's going to happen, regardless of alignment, until the need to lynch him pops up. Most of the time, it continues even as it happens.

He always tries to make himself original. There's very little reason not to because if you go that extra mile, then people don't get on your back for sheeping nearly as often.

He's not over-the-top any more than usual. Being loud is what commits him to the game similarly to the way I explode sometimes. He works himself up or at least acts like he's worked up because the adrenaline gets you focused.

WL cannot be scum unless Kevin is and Marshy isn't.

What makes you of a July-WL connection to do the way WL is trying to subtly diffuse the July wagon? He is the only one to speak up thus far of the July case not having merit and actually the first to call it reaching because none of Swords/Ran/and even July herself called the case reaching.
You know what? I trust his opinion on it and asked him to keep going. J, NOTHING about that case jumped out at me as remarkable enough to bother remembering going into Day 2. That is a VERY bad sign for your case. The people you have backing it are yourself (scum), Ran (with his blinders), and Swords (hit or miss). Those are the opinions I value least on the playerlist, which is interesting given the player composition.

This is actually where I can see the point to where WL is scummier than July because she at least responds to posts and actually tries to see the others PoV in the argument while still giving her defense. WL just tries to find a way to discredit the argument and inflate it into a show of "OMG U SO SCUUUUUUUUUUMMY" without actually providing much reasoning behind his suspicions. His posts come across as extremely fake, especially when talking about his J/Marshy/July posts. I do not get his JulyTown read where he is okay with her not being in the lynch pool. I also find his suspicion of Swords unprecendented and I don't get why he finds him as scum. He says because of Swords weird hop onto WL when he was actually like the main proponent to WL's wagon and his suspicion of Swords seems invested in a bit of OMGUS.
I do not see WL-July as scum without both KevMo and Marshy being town. However, I haven't been as sure on something in a long time. If one of them is scum, then there's you and MAYBE ONE OF THEM! That doesn't mean that the other of them or Raz can't be scum.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
Hey Ran/Ryker, put your vote on J. He needs to die today.
No. We have him, he can sit. If I don't push Marshy/KevMo, then the July wagon has the potential to kick off again and it will be nigh impossible lynch both of them.

J is a dead man walking that a light breeze could knock off balance.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
KEVMO

Play the game or die. Your only avenue out is Marshy or convincing my I'm wrong, but I'm pretty convicted.

The combined force or you, Marshy, and J is not pushing a WL or July lynch past me when the logical choice is one of the three of you. I will not lose this game on this day phase.
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
Alright guys. I thought I'd explain the changed mechanic of this game in this post so it's totally clear. There will be two deadlines this game: one for the typical vote, which will last 10 days, and one that lasts 5 days. The one lasting 5 days is going to be in place in order to hold everybody's once-per-Day agent role. Everybody will have the ability to send any other player an anonymous letter through the moderator, so prior to the deadline, you must send your letter in the following format, as well as the recipient.
Gorf, do these two deadlines overlap or is one held after the other?
 

#HBC | Laundry

Grand Sage of Swag
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Messages
3,954
Location
Under a bridge
3DS FC
3926-6895-8719
No. We have him, he can sit. If I don't push Marshy/KevMo, then the July wagon has the potential to kick off again and it will be nigh impossible lynch both of them.

J is a dead man walking that a light breeze could knock off balance.
Ah, true, lost my wits for a moment. Not only that, should you die, I lose my chance on getting marshy or KevMo whereas J can be lynched amongst July, Ran, and I.

vote: KevMo
 

#HBC | Ryker

Netplay Monstrosity
BRoomer
Joined
Sep 16, 2008
Messages
6,520
Location
Mobile, AL
I have faith that you'll get one if we lynch J today. I don't have faith that you'll get both should it be necessary.
 
Top Bottom