MoosyDoosy
Smash Ace
WOW RUDE
TOTAL mafia lAds, look at this excuse.
Vote: Spak
We have our easy Day 1 Mafia bois, follow the choo choo train.
-
Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Gheb's messy mafia madness | Day 3
- Thread starter ~ Gheb ~
- Start date
Vote: Spak
We have our easy Day 1 Mafia bois, follow the choo choo train.
Maven89
Smash Master
Vote: No lynch
Seriously, **** that guy
Seriously, **** that guy
Orboknown
Smash Hero
Theres no editing either.... lol
What zensoup hydra shenanigrams now? Lol
MoosyDoosy
Smash Ace
Hi Maven, are you my friend? If so, let's work together to kill Mafia Spak.
Orboknown
Smash Hero
Ohhhhhhh. I forgot about the vote system this game
Maven89
Smash Master
I'm thinking everyone did
Same. My phone died about an hour ago, and I just got back to my dad's car to charge my phone. Re-reading the rules.
Maven89
Smash Master
Unvote I guess
Maven89
Smash Master
So, mafia will not want to vote each other, because it would randomize the lynch, and prove the voter was mafia. The best use of this I see is to force people to vote each other if it looks like they have connections, but that would have the side effect of randomizing the lynch. Since any single person who disagrees can remove the lynchee from the lynchpool, I'm not thinking we're going to have too much democracy in this. The lynch is going to be more like musical chairs.
Orboknown
Smash Hero
Hmmm. We're gonna have to rig a system to punish people who vote in a way town doesnt agree on/for people town wants dead. Iunno quite how yet
But now that you say that, won't Mafia try to disassociate with each-other? What happens if one of the Mafia is inactive? If there are three Mafia, how could we get the last one via association?
But what if the Mafia is fine with bussing? That system won't do us any good if they play smart.
MoosyDoosy
Smash Ace
Everyone vote for the person they think they can trust for the moment and a reason if they have one or not. DO NOT vote for someone that's already been voted. If you can't trust anyone yet then say so.
Unvote
Vote: Maven89
Maven 'cuz he's already analyzing the vote thing and since he's here D1.
Unvote
Vote: Maven89
Maven 'cuz he's already analyzing the vote thing and since he's here D1.
Vult Redux
Smash Lord
MoosyDoosy
Smash Ace
The key is that mafia aren't removed from the lynch pool if they vote for each other.
So the goal is to have town vote for each other and for mafia to vote for each other. That way when the random day lynches occur, we'll easily find mafia if one of them die and we see their flip. Because the person voting the dead mafia would be their partner due to above rule.
So the goal is to have town vote for each other and for mafia to vote for each other. That way when the random day lynches occur, we'll easily find mafia if one of them die and we see their flip. Because the person voting the dead mafia would be their partner due to above rule.
MoosyDoosy
Smash Ace
If there's any flaws in my plan, say so, so that we can work kinks out. :]
I can't trust anyone yet, and I'm surprised you're willing to trust put your trust in Maven so easily. From my experience, positive reinforcement isn't the way to sniff out scum lol.
Vult Redux
Smash Lord
but did you like anything specific about what he said?
Vult Redux
Smash Lord
so you don't think he had a good reason to vote Maven?
Not really. He hasn't justified his vote other than "I trust him because he's been here for a few hours and suggested some ideas." He's not saying that he is trusting Maven slightly more than anyone else and thus voting him, Moosey's statement shows some confidence of town!Maven rather than trusting him slightly more than anyone else (he gave the option of replying with not trusting anyone.) I don't know how he could be so sure about anyone being right now unless he's Mafia or Guardian.
Vult Redux
Smash Lord
ah.
so if you had to compare, would you would say Moosy's for Maven is more fishy/suspicious/whatever than my vote for Moosy?
Vult Redux
Smash Lord
you should vote anyway!
I honestly thought your vote was an RVS joking vote. If you trust in Moosy significantly more than the rest of the game because he is trying to befriend people (which would make life easier for all alignments, so that would be a null tell,) that'd be pretty sketch.
Vult Redux
Smash Lord
I think DarkPit's vote is fine because he actually stated that he didn't trust anyone, but it may have been influenced by my post on Moosy's vote. I still don't see the benefit of voting for people right now because it's actually taking pressure off of people instead of applying pressure (which seems counter-productive for the purposes of starting a game, seeing as RVS is based off of trying to pressure each-other as much as possible until someone snaps or slips.)
Orboknown
Smash Hero
Unvote
Gonna call it a night and check in tomorrow
Gonna call it a night and check in tomorrow
Maven89
Smash Master
Why should be vote anyways?
Vult Redux
Smash Lord
to help me/everyone get reads
How would getting people to vote for each-other on the first page of the game help you get reads? There's little to nothing to go off of yet, and I haven't seen anyone do anything that merits solid reads, nor my trust.
Maven89
Smash Master
It's a very minor point, but he did just say he didn't trust anyone, meaning his vote isn't useful for reads.
This is musical chairs, I don't want think we should be filling the seats until we're closer to the end
This is musical chairs, I don't want think we should be filling the seats until we're closer to the end
MoosyDoosy
Smash Ace
Interesting. :D I have a few town reads and one read that's dropped redder.
Vult Redux
Smash Lord
well... the same reason players submit random votes in a game with standard voting? you yourself submitted a vote at the start of this game. do you think the alternative voting system makes things different?
That's not true! I learned a bit about darkpit59 from his vote. just because there's nothing huge/dramatic/whatever to go off of doesn't mean there's nothing
Yes, because voting for someone with the alternate system takes off pressure rather than adding it. You can't make someone snap under pressure by making them more relaxed.
Really? What did you learn?