Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
Bad play does not imply scum. You pointed out a lot of bad play, but you didn't really point out much scum play. CR's continuation of your case was more what I would consider a good case. I don't think you're scummy for the original case though, as I don't see a reason for town or scum to do that.
Nah, I'm not faulting you for wanting a read on Soup. Though you can't deny that it is a good way to get through the Day seeming active, while not really making connections at all. It's a thought, not an accusation yet.
You placed your vote on Ryker, wanting to lynch him as scum. Then you wonder why people aren't weighing the option of TvT when talking to you. Do you have knowledge the rest of us do not possess?
Which I'll admit is grimy as **** because its painfully obvious that SN was just targeting Soup because he was a topic of discussion, not because he was the weaker player. Most everything else that Ryker has said, though curt, has matched up with Seik and my thoughts very well. The exception to this being his SN scum read, which both Seik and myself get a pretty strong town vibe from.
GLG's third post (out of 9) and the first one he actually contributes anything worth mentioning.
Next few posts he just talks about his dislike for RVS and again tries to talk about the legitimacy in strategy behind using such a phase. Makes a comment that PFP was using dumb logic in passing, but refrains from clarifying whether that makes PFP scum and also does not place his vote anywhere despite acknowledging the game was out of RVS.
GLG finally beings branching out on something besides mechanics and, surprise, its bull. PFP's response to Soup's was a bit over-defensive at most and nowhere near as strong as GLG makes it out to be.
PFP picks up on what I was talking about wrt GLG not taking a hard stance on him (or anyone for that matter) and responds with this. GLG says he thinks PFP is scum but still doesn't place his vote on the grounds that he isn't sure on his read yet.
uhguhguhgughughgugghughgughughgugh @ the bolded. Says he doesn't like AW on the grounds that he came in guns blazing on Soup (notice how he brings everything back to Soup?) and then at the end of the freaking paragraph discounts everything he just said and says its probably nothing to worry about. This is exactly what I was talking about above with him subtly defending Soup without trying to make it look like he's actually on his side.
Literally out of nowhere. And thats all
Should read: Thoughts on the Soup slot, now that he is replacing out.
Why would our read change because Soupa is replacing out?
Your entire reasoning of SoupaScum in your first paragraph is a simple meta reasoning. We don't like it.
No they are not to be taken as null tells at best. So do you think PFP's case is twisting?
Its not, actually. Try reading things before you respond. Soup has done literally done nothing the whole game and has stalled on providing content all leading up into replacing out. That's scummy in itself. It also directly contrasts what I would expect from townSoup which is why I find it incriminating. See the quotes I put in the GLG post as for further reasoning that I agree with.
Bolded = Meta. You say the reason you find it incriminating is because it contrasts with what you normally see from townSoupa.
I clearly say I think much of it is full of air. I am going to refrain from commenting on it because I want to see how Ryker responds to it first.
When did I say some of it didn't contain meta? Some of it does contain meta and a large gut read to boot. So what?
It's weak, unsubstantiated, and just conjecture.
Whatever you say dear.
I explained it in the exact same post you quoted the above form. Try reading.
Actually it's not just what we say, it's the truth. Meta/Gut is purely a weak reason to call someone scum because it holds no air.
Right, which is why I said its not only meta and gut, his play has been downright scummy and it contradicts how townSoup would play it. What part of that don't you understand?
This is your reasoning for SoupaScum. It's pretty much a generalization of everyone's thoughts on him. Your reasoning for Soupascum is also a connection case(which are weak) to GLGscum.
Actually its not a generalization of everyone else's points and who are you to tell me that this has no merit? I further detail why he's scum in my GLG post. Read it.
This is pertaining to PFP's case, not your Ryker read.
