Doctor Who Mafia: Night 1 Begins! Deadline is set for the 31th at 0400.

[~ Gheb ~]

But I don't care if you are sure or not.

 

[Dark Yoshi]

But it's my reson, so you should.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

FF is dead. His N0 death immediately puts scum in a certain category of players.

I highly doubt it. At least half of the players in that list are aware of Frozen's skill as a player. Not to mention that his death seems to come from a certain power more so than from the mafia's ability to kill.

 

[The Pink Sasquatch]

I meant character, and neither head of this hydra is a girl. This is X1 btw.

@Swiss: you should be able to tell which posts are mine and which are Js

 

[~ Gheb ~]

But it's my reson, so you should.

Your reason is irrelevant in this case.

 

[Swiss]

@ X1 - I can. But I don't intend to single handedly carry town. So other people need to be sure of your alignment too. So differentiate.

 

[The Pink Sasquatch]

FF is dead because of his role I'm pretty sure, I don't think he was targeted it was just the RNG. Thats what the Modcomment on his 'flip' looked like

 

[Swiss]

Dark Yoshi are we talking to Dark Horse or Kirb?

 

[Dark Yoshi]

It's my reason answering the question, which you inquired about.

Frozen's death probably wasn't done by a player, just game mechanincs

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Alright, the answer is acceptable either way.

@Swiss

I think I can tell J and X1 apart. It's not like they are very similar...at all.

 

[Swiss]

FF is dead because of his role I'm pretty sure, I don't think he was targeted it was just the RNG. Thats what the Modcomment on his 'flip' looked like

FF was player #15.

He signed up to the game.

 

[Dark Yoshi]

this is DH btw

 

[The Pink Sasquatch]

J might post in pink idk but I'm posting in white

 

[The Pink Sasquatch]

He's a ghost. He can still talk

 

[~ Gheb ~]

It's my reason answering the question, which you inquired about.

I certainly didn't ask for yours.

 

[Dark Yoshi]

But swiss, his role let him speak while he was dead.

And besides, adumb said that one version of the ghost was killed pre-game

 

[Dark Yoshi]

I certainly didn't ask for yours.

Also, why the hell did you answer that?

You did

10contradictions

 

[~ Gheb ~]

I think the idea behind the ghost is essentially to be a "forced" tree stump.

 

[Swiss]

But swiss, his role let him speak while he was dead.

And besides, adumb said that one version of the ghost was killed pre-game

So you think whoever 'killed' him wanted to clear a good player?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

You did

10contradictions

That's not what I meant *facepalm*

But w/e, my question is answered.

 

[Dark Yoshi]

*facepalm*

no.

Abumb killed him. that was part of the ghost's role

 

[Swiss]

*facepalm*

no.

Abumb killed him. that was part of the ghost's role

The role, yes. But how do we know scum didn't chose who.

 

[Dark Yoshi]

What are you trying to say? The scum could pick who the ghost was?

 

[~ Gheb ~]

The role, yes. But how do we know scum didn't chose who.

The fact that the Ghost - somebody who can still talk after dying - is the one who's being killed right off the bat, implies that there's no choice to begin with.

I think speculating about that really won't help us a lot. The best we seem to get out of it is discussion which seemed to be no problem at all in dGames recently.

 

[The Pink Sasquatch]

We don't know if scum chose or not, but its implied that it was the work of the RNG. Either way it can't be proved so stop trying to push this

 

[Swiss]

Fantastic guys, thanks. I hadn't considered it was actually not particularly useful. Silly me.

I think DY is town.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

Wait, does that mean that Frozen is not only confirmed to be town but also completely immune to any kind of night action shenanigans? That's actually not bad at all ... having confirmed townFrozen in lylo as voice of reason may very well tip the game in our favor.

I suggest that one or two of the newer players listen to him and "proxy" their votes on him. Not to load all the responsibility on him but it's surely helpful for a new player who's lost in that swell of information and activity.

 

[The Pink Sasquatch]

umad Swiss?

 

[Dark Yoshi]

@mod request votecount

Just want to see if frozen counts as a player

 

[Swiss]

Oh Gheb u town.

I agree with that.

X1, which players would you like to see proxy their votes?

 

[Swiss]

@mod request votecount

Just want to see if frozen counts as a player

He can't vote. So it won't.

@ Mod is FF allowed to post in thread?

 

[Dark Yoshi]

Oh, okay.

Was just curious, as the only thing that adumb mentions regarding what he can/do what he can't is be targeted for NA.

 

[Swiss]

Ghosts cannot normally vote. I may be wrong in this case, though.

Ideally I would be.

Dat FF.

 

[~ Gheb ~]

#102 explicitly mentions that Frozen is allowed to post yet his name doesn't appear in the vote counts.

 

[adumbrodeus]

@mod request votecount

Just want to see if frozen counts as a player

His name wasn't on votecount 1 and it said 17 companions were alive (out of a playlist of 18).

But...


Votecount 2

The Pink Sasquatch [1] - Dark Yoshi,
Hilt [1] - The Pink Sasquatch
DEHF [1] - Gheb_01


Smargaret [0] -
Tandora [0] -
Peach Monster [0] -
Dark Yoshi [0] -
Hidajiremi [0] -
Gheb_01 [0] -
July [0] -
Chuckie [0] -
Teryble Doom~ [0] -
Kuzmaru [0]-
Dr. Riddler [0] -
Swiss [0] -
rPSI [0] -
Pythag [0] -

Not Voting[14] - Smargaret, Tandora, Peach Monster, Hilt, , DEHF, Hidajiremi, July, Chuckie, Teryble Doom~, Kuzmaru, Dr. Riddler, Swiss, rPSI, Pythag

With 17 Companions alive it take 8 to lynch.

He can't vote. So it won't.

@ Mod is FF allowed to post in thread?

Frozenflame751 (Frobisher, Town Ghost), was kidnapped in the pregame! (The ghost is a role that may still talk in-thread when dead, there are 2 variants of this role that I created, one which dies during the pregame, another that has to wait to be lynched/NK'd. Both reveal alignment on death. The ghost is not a valid night action target).

 

[Swiss]

Hida, Pythag, July.

I don't know you three (much). Give me a brief look into your experience.

Hida how long will it take you to have a good read on Tan? If you are wrong on this read, can we lynch you as confirmed scum?

 

[Dark Yoshi]

J1-12 dead yet?

Btw, Kirby is posting in lime, DH will post either in white or that brown-ish color he confirmed with.

 

[Peach Monster]

This is Edrees posting. i'm just gonna post my name before every post, i don't like using colors.

Swiss stop trying to fool everyone, we know you are always scum. this game is probably no exception.

As for Frozen, its been pretty clear that at this point he's basically a dead player who can help town just by being someone who can post and contribute with reads. when adumb talked about the other variant he was obviously saying he didn't go with that option for this game. adumb loves to talk about mafia game setups so he was just blabbing off, ignore the possibilty of the other variant, he used the first one where ghost dies pregame.

gheb i'm not so sure about newer players proxying their votes on ff. if those new players are scum and ff plays pro town it will give them a free pass. weird suggestion coming from you.

 

[Dark Yoshi]

If FF does play pro-town, and his typical pro scumhunting self, and IF any of the proxy players are scum, it will hurt them more than help them. This should be obvious.

 

[Swiss]

Swiss stop trying to fool everyone, we know you are always scum.

this game is probably no exception.

Which? Also do you have reason to trust me less than other players initially? Will I have to do more than the average townie to clear myself? If I had a way of clearing myself as 'town' at the cost of my vote but NOT my voice in this thread - assuming I was lynched not NK'd - would you lynch me D1?

gheb i'm not so sure about newer players proxying their votes on ff. if those new players are scum and ff plays pro town it will give them a free pass. weird suggestion coming from you.

Why do you assume Frozen would be less likely to find the newbies suspicious purely because they are no longer in direct control of their votes?