• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Official DLC Speculation Discussion Volume II

Status
Not open for further replies.

Louie G.

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 21, 2013
Messages
9,768
Location
Rhythm Heaven
I'm baffled when I see people ascribe what is clearly a general hierarchical system solely to Sakurai seemingly finding the choices we've been given as the most interesting. Just a coincidence it aligns with the fact that it could mistaken for an intact and active hierarchy, then, is it?

It's not a super common viewpoint, but it's one so obtuse that it's memorable.
I feel like this gets construed in odd ways both directions. When there is a very clear, cemented hierarchy of characters it is typically followed and once that has been covered then we get into the weeds and explore supplementary characters. Really though, I'd argue Mario is the only series where we've actually gotten to this point - Pokemon / Fire Emblem are their own beasts and Zelda should have gotten there by now... but I digress.

As silly as it is to suggest that this is broken for certain franchises, I think there's a breaking point where I find it equally silly for people to cling onto it. Like Impa as I mentioned before, she's technically the next most important Zelda character, but she's so far behind the other three where it really wouldn't be a crime to throw in a Skull Kid or Midna instead. Or for Mario, where after Rosalina, Bowser Jr and a potted Plant all made it in first people are still insistent that Waluigi or Geno ought to wait their turn for Toad.

Regardless of my own personal opinions on those characters (it is pretty odd that Toad isn't here yet) I think once we've hit that sweet spot - like, the three or four most important characters, that's when Sakurai can just go for who he finds interesting. But there's no way we would have gotten the likes of Skull Kid before Ganondorf "just because", either. I dunno, I think you probably get what I mean.
 
Last edited:

Ivander

Smash Legend
Joined
Dec 1, 2014
Messages
10,948
Second on that totem pole would be Demitri, but unfortunately I don't believe Midnight Bliss would fly in Smash.
I think Nintendo has already learned their lesson from this.

Super Crown | MarioWiki | Fandom
And it comes back around to this image:


But yeah, I'm pretty sure the reason why Midnight Bliss would not have the transformations is that they would have to make unique concept art and a model for each and every character. Like it's one easy thing to have some of their characters be transformed into an actual reference from their games, like Link as a girl and in his Desert Voe outfit or Cloud as "Miss Cloud" or Mr. Game & Watch as the woman from Oil Panic. But you also have to do concepts and models for characters like Dedede, Ridley, the Pokemon characters, and 60-70 other characters.
Then there's also the fact that they'll need permission from many of the owners of the characters. Like just because some of them may be okay with it doesn't mean all of them will be okay with it. And yeah, it's quite possible Nintendo doesn't want to open the can of worms again in regards to genderswapping concepts like what happened with Bowsette.
And any potential Midnight Bliss design can just as much erupt like it did with Bowsette. Like it's not like Midnight Bliss is not that much different from Rule 63 which doesn't trend much, but for every 10 or 20 Midnight Bliss designs, you're bound to get at least one Goeniko. Who is Goeniko? Look up Goenitz and SvC Chaos, then look up Goeniko and how she became an actual character due to her popularity.

All that aside, Midnight Bliss doesn't just refer to Demitri's move. It also refers to his true form that he uses for Midnight Bliss.

And it should be noted that Midnight Bliss has been used in other games without the genderswapping needed, like Project X Zone.
 
Last edited:

2006ToyotaTacoma

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Jan 23, 2021
Messages
273
Location
Aboard the Ark of Yamato
D

Deleted member

Guest
Who're you picking?


My picks are Sora and Dixie Kong.
I'm not looking for anyone in particular, so this what I'm going to do. I'm going to pick 6 first party characters I'd be happy with then roll a 6 sided die and that's who I'll put down. Then I'll do the same for a third party character.
For reference:
1 = Impa
2 = Toxicitry
3 = Dixie Kong
4 = Tetra (or Toon Zelda depending on how they label her)
5 = Dry Bowser
6 = Rillaboom

1 = Dr. Robotnik
2 = KOS-MOS
3 = Morrigan
4 = Master Chief
5 = Chrono
6 = Laharl

And, according to random.org, my choices are (insert drumroll here):
1st party: Rillaboom
3rd party: Chrono
 
Last edited by a moderator:

N3ON

Gone Exploring
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 6, 2008
Messages
21,444
Location
Vancouver
I feel like this gets construed in odd ways both directions. When there is a very clear, cemented hierarchy of characters it is typically followed and once that has been covered then we get into the weeds and explore supplementary characters. Really though, I'd argue Mario is the only series where we've actually gotten to this point - Pokemon / Fire Emblem are their own beasts and Zelda should have gotten there by now... but I digress.

As silly as it is to suggest that this is broken for certain franchises, I think there's a breaking point where I find it equally silly for people to cling onto it. Like Impa as I mentioned before, she's technically the next most important Zelda character, but she's so far behind the other three where it really wouldn't be a crime to throw in a Skull Kid or Midna instead. Or for Mario, where after Rosalina, Bowser Jr and a potted Plant all made it in first people are still insistent that Waluigi or Geno ought to wait their turn for Toad.

Regardless of my own personal opinions on those characters (it is pretty odd that Toad isn't here yet) I think once we've hit that sweet spot - like, the three or four most important characters, that's when Sakurai can just go for who he finds interesting. But there's no way we would have gotten the likes of Skull Kid before Ganondorf "just because", either. I dunno, I think you probably get what I mean.
Right, but, even when you get past the indisputable series peaks, there is still a hierarchy isn't there? It's just each bracket gets more broad as you descend, like a pyramid. If it's not Impa, maybe it'd be Skull Kid or Midna. Maybe it's Tingle. But it's not Veran. It's not Zant. It's not Medli. Who comes after Sonic? Maybe it's Tails, maybe it's Eggman, maybe it's Shadow or Knuckles. But it's not Vector.

I mean it's not an exact science; what works for one series may not work for another. There may be a surprise here and there along the way. And it doesn't 100% boil down to pure series importance either because popularity is a factor. But clearly there is a framework here around which the trend exists.
 

ahemtoday

Smash Ace
Joined
Oct 30, 2020
Messages
874
While we're on the subject of hierarchies, I'd like to talk about a character whose hierarchical position I find interesting: Ridley. If you look at any individual Metroid game, Ridley is almost never at the top. I mean, the top is Samus, because she's the main character, but the top of the pile of every other character. My point is, Ridley is basically always playing second fiddle to the main villain of each game, be that Mother Brain, Metroid Prime, Dark Samus, the SA-X, or... whoever the big bad of Other M was supposed to be. His only position as actual final boss is him getting retconned into Metroid 2.

But the key word there is "always". If you look at the series, Ridley is at least tied for the most prominent villain, and it's because he's always second fiddle to the revolving door of main villains. Everyone else is getting 1st place in one Mario Kart race and last in the rest, and Ridley's racking up points by getting 2nd in all of them.

You forgot to mention an exception to the hierarchy rule, where Min Min got in before Spring Man, the mascot and shoto of ARMS. Though maybe ARMS could end up creating its own hierarchy, where in other crossover games with ARMS characters, Min Min has to get in first?
It's a little too early to call, but I could see Min Min becoming the Morrigan of ARMS. definitely.
 
Last edited:

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,407
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
Who're you picking?


My picks are Sora and Dixie Kong.
Crash Bandicoot and Bandana Waddle Dee
 

LiveStudioAudience

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 1, 2019
Messages
4,435
When do you guys think CP11 will release?
I'm guessing September. Even if it gets revealed at E3, its easy to imagine it airing close to the Fall Direct, with the latter likely announcing the formal date of the Sakurai presents. Every formal Nintendo Direct since March 2018 has had Smash news, and it feels fitting for it to finally conclude then.
 
Last edited:

Technomage

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 18, 2019
Messages
2,289
When do you guys think CP11 will release?
We're not even at CP10 yet, let's hold our horses.
While we're not even at CP 10 yet, I do theorize that CP 11 will release either by the end of Summer or early Fall; we certainly won't have to wait until Christmas (which was actually an idea I once proposed).
 
Last edited:

Verde Coeden Scalesworth

Flap and Swish~
Premium
Joined
Aug 13, 2001
Messages
34,381
Location
Cull Hazard
NNID
Irene4
3DS FC
1203-9265-8784
Switch FC
SW-7567-8572-3791
CP11 screams Fall to me. I'm thinking September-November for the possible time period. Reveal and release overall. I don't think a bonus character is coming, nor do I think E3 will get two characters this time. Usually when it happened there was a lot of time and a lot of reveals to do anyway. This is not the case for Pass 2.
 

Merengue

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Feb 23, 2021
Messages
357
Who're you picking?


My picks are Sora and Dixie Kong.

E3 Reveal: Reimu Hakurei

Final Reveal: Porky Minch from Earth Bound including a WoL sequel featuring him as the main villain.
 

The Rhythm Theif

Smash Ace
Joined
Jun 6, 2019
Messages
885
Location
An Apartment With Stolen Forgery Art In Paris
Switch FC
SW-2028-5151-9144
Who're you picking?


My picks are Sora and Dixie Kong.
My picks for third party? I could drone ON AND ON about who I want. But my main picks are Sakura Kasugano, Mega Man Zero, or Lilith. If we get anyone else though, I'm cool with that.

First party? Maybe Dark Meta Knight since Star Allies gave Meta Knight's Mirror World counterpart an ENTIRELY NEW MOVESET so that he's not just a Meta Knight clone.
 

FJA147

Smash Cadet
Joined
Jul 13, 2020
Messages
50
My thoughts a promotional first party that is going to piss people off and a underwhelming third party that will not fill people expectations. In Smash 4- Corrin and Bayonetta
FP1- Terry and Byleth, but I think that Terry was well received but he was more of an unknown third party to a good amount of people
 

SharkLord

Smash Hero
Joined
Jun 20, 2020
Messages
7,675
Location
Pangaea, 250 MYA
My thoughts a promotional first party that is going to piss people off and a underwhelming third party that will not fill people expectations. In Smash 4- Corrin and Bayonetta
FP1- Terry and Byleth, but I think that Terry was well received but he was more of an unknown third party to a good amount of people
I dunno, wasn't Bayo pretty well-received until everyone saw how busted she was? From what I can gather Nintendo might've twisted somethings in her favor, but if she was the highest-ranking in Europe (And maybe top five in the US, but I don't really remember), she must've done at least decently well.
 

DarthEnderX

Smash Hero
Joined
Nov 10, 2014
Messages
8,403
Last edited:

LiveStudioAudience

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 1, 2019
Messages
4,435
I dunno, wasn't Bayo pretty well-received until everyone saw how busted she was? From what I can gather Nintendo might've twisted somethings in her favor, but if she was the highest-ranking in Europe (And maybe top five in the US, but I don't really remember), she must've done at least decently well.
I recall the reaction being fairly positive. I think Corrin ended up being unintentional boost to Bayo in that sense actually; after the groans and eye rolls by many to another FE character, getting a fairly cool and unexpected fighter like the latter made her seem much more special.
 
Last edited:

Perkilator

Smash Legend
Writing Team
Joined
Apr 8, 2018
Messages
11,407
Location
The perpetual trash fire known as Planet Earth(tm)
I recall the reaction being fairly positive. I think Corrin ended up being unintentional boost to Bayo in that sense actually; after the groans and eye rolls by many to another FE character, getting a fairly cool and unexpected fighter like the latter made her seem much more special.
You think in the former's case, reception would be even slightly more positive if it was Azura instead of Corrin? I know that's what I wish it was if only because she'd be way more unique
 

N3ON

Gone Exploring
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 6, 2008
Messages
21,444
Location
Vancouver
When do you guys think CP11 will release?
Probably September. But there's enough buffer room that August and October aren't unfathomable either.

August, I’m still sticking by Calendar Theory
Becomes pretty questionable when you consider that Steve was lined up to release in September. They wouldn't reorganize their schedule for the sake of some trivial quota of every month having something.

I dunno, wasn't Bayo pretty well-received until everyone saw how busted she was? From what I can gather Nintendo might've twisted somethings in her favor, but if she was the highest-ranking in Europe (And maybe top five in the US, but I don't really remember), she must've done at least decently well.
Not really. Bayo was always a divisive character, then being touted as the ballot winner rubbed people the wrong way, and being tied together with Corrin compounded the negativity and brought her down as well. It wasn't unilaterally negative but it was probably more negative than any of the earlier five.
 

LiveStudioAudience

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 1, 2019
Messages
4,435
You think in the former's case, reception would be even slightly more positive if it was Azura instead of Corrin? I know that's what I wish it was if only because she'd be way more unique
Perhaps among Fire Emblem fans, but realistically those that tend to be apathetic/antipathetic towards FE (ie the ones not inclined to be thrilled at their Smash inclusions) are likely not really going to make a lot of distinctions between the actual nuanced differences with characters. Even Lyn showing up as a fighter would get some backalsh, and she's among the more liked FE characters among casuals/non-fans just based on her aesthetic design if nothing else.
 
Last edited:

SKX31

Smash Master
Joined
Feb 22, 2019
Messages
3,462
Location
Sweden
I dunno, wasn't Bayo pretty well-received until everyone saw how busted she was? From what I can gather Nintendo might've twisted somethings in her favor, but if she was the highest-ranking in Europe (And maybe top five in the US, but I don't really remember), she must've done at least decently well.
IIRC she was kinda well-recieved initially as you said - the only mark against her was that she wasn't a Ballot winner a lot of people expected, whereas someone like :ultridley: or :ultbanjokazooie: might've been. This video (volume warning) encapsulate personalities' and players' reactions pretty well:


And yeah, opinions only really started to turn post-release: people at the time didn't know that Sakurai had moved on to Ultimate, but the effects of that move were keenly felt since several aspects were crazily overtuned.* The same was for :4cloud: and yes, :4corrin: , whose Counter Surge could at release OHKO charged Smash attacks and whose Pin was a lot safer.

*(Sidenote: certain aspects of :4bayonetta: don't need repeating, but one aspect that often goes un-mentioned was that Witch Twist (Up B) not only reached higher than :ultbayonetta: 's does - meaning that 4 Bayo could reach the top blastzone a lot easier - it also had larger hitboxes and was faster, meaning it was even more difficult to react to.)

You think in the former's case, reception would be even slightly more positive if it was Azura instead of Corrin? I know that's what I wish it was if only because she'd be way more unique
I'm willing to say yes, but barely. She'd still get a lot of negative emotions thrown her way due to the timing of Fates' release and how many Fire Emblem characters had appeared in relatively rapid succession, but would perhaps get less flack thanks to her being a more defined character and probably not having a Counter (which might be a minor factor all things considered).
 
Last edited:

AreJay25

May or May Not Be Pac-Man
Joined
Mar 4, 2015
Messages
7,210
Location
Location
I will never not laugh at the fact that after Bayo's release, there was a patch specifically made to nerf her and only her, and she was still busted as **** lmao

We had to wait 2 whole years for her to actually feel normalized and it was in an entirely different game
 

SharkLord

Smash Hero
Joined
Jun 20, 2020
Messages
7,675
Location
Pangaea, 250 MYA
And we have liftoff. Current course of action is solidifying the rules and seeing how we should go about the first couple submissions.
 

N3ON

Gone Exploring
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 6, 2008
Messages
21,444
Location
Vancouver
I'm wondering who was actually there when it happened, among the discord, and who is just speaking from what they can piece together.

People were lead to believe there was a ballot winner coming, do you think they wanted it to end on two unexpected fighters? Some people got the wrong idea that with Ryu and Cloud they were just ramping up.

The mob wanted K. Rool or Isaac. Shovel Knight or Inkling or Snake. Even Wolf. Maybe Banjo. Bayonetta... not quite so much. If you're going to go off reaction videos and the strange qualifications Nintendo propped Bayo up with, you're not getting the full picture.

People also say Cloud was welcomed with open arms. Not so much. He was also very divisive. People got over that one quickly, but history doesn't seem to remember that he was by far the most polarizing character of the DLC until the next two.

Bayo, at the best of times, was another divisive pick. Beforehand, a lot of people thought she didn't fit. She also had the misfortune of being last, and facing all that entails. She also had the misfortune of being paired with Corrin. She also had the misfortune of being the conclusion to most of a year of expecting a fanbase favourite. It wasn't all negative, and I don't want to paint that picture, but it certainly wasn't overly positive either. Like I said, the five that preceded the final presentation were all better received, Cloud included. It was very mixed, and there was a lot of negativity. And unlike Cloud, that negativity only grew when people got their hands on her.
 

Technomage

Smash Champion
Joined
Jan 18, 2019
Messages
2,289
I will never not laugh at the fact that after Bayo's release, there was a patch specifically made to nerf her and only her, and she was still busted as **** lmao

We had to wait 2 whole years for her to actually feel normalized and it was in an entirely different game
And that brings me to this funny video:


Though who's the guy whose face was photoshopped onto Hans Moleman's body?
 
Last edited:

LiveStudioAudience

Smash Master
Joined
Dec 1, 2019
Messages
4,435
Maybe I just wasn't as deeply in the Smash scene, but I just don't simply recall that much overt dislike or excess controversy at Bayo's reveal. It could be that I'm grading on a curve and that after the likes of the response to Byleth or the November 2018 Smash Direct, any grumbling during that time just seems mild by comparison.

I think part of it is that the expectations just didn't seem as raised in the Smash 4 era and thus the fallout (either positive or negative) weren't as notable to boot.
 

N3ON

Gone Exploring
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 6, 2008
Messages
21,444
Location
Vancouver
Maybe I just wasn't as deeply in the Smash scene, but I just don't simply recall that much overt dislike or excess controversy at Bayo's reveal. It could be that I'm grading on a curve and that after the likes of the response to Byleth or the November 2018 Smash Direct, any grumbling during that time just seems mild by comparison.

I think part of it is that the expectations just didn't seem as raised in the Smash 4 era and thus the fallout (either positive or negative) weren't as notable to boot.
It's hard to grade the volume of similar events years apart when you're relying on memory and other non-empirical measures. I remember there being a lot of negativity around ROB as well, but now that seems quaint and hard to quantify. I wouldn't be able to stack it up next to Corrin or Byleth, the events were too far apart. I just know that these characters all precipitated a notable amount of negativity.

The list is not exhaustive, but in it I would also include Bayo. Not to the same extent as the aforementioned, but I believe she has a place among it as well. Keep in mind that the level of negativity that surrounded Corrin would've been mitigated had it been offset from a great deal of positivity from Bayo. Look at WFT being offset by Villager and Mega Man. Look at no one caring about Chrom because he was sandwiched in between Castlevania and K. Rool. I mean, even Banjo cushioned Hero. But the story isn't that people shrugged at Corrin and were at least happy about Bayo.

I have no "were you mad about Bayo" poll to link to, but I do remember what transpired, and it was very mixed. There is a reason people thought the ballot was rigged for the next several years. I still can't believe they were right, but that's neither here nor there.
 

Cosmic77

Smash Hero
Joined
Dec 17, 2017
Messages
9,547
Location
On a planet far far away...
Switch FC
2166-0541-5238
Maybe I just wasn't as deeply in the Smash scene, but I just don't simply recall that much overt dislike or excess controversy at Bayo's reveal. It could be that I'm grading on a curve and that after the likes of the response to Byleth or the November 2018 Smash Direct, any grumbling during that time just seems mild by comparison.

I think part of it is that the expectations just didn't seem as raised in the Smash 4 era and thus the fallout (either positive or negative) weren't as notable to boot.
There was definitely some mixed opinions that day. People had all of the top contenders listed in their heads, and Bayo was nowhere near K. Rool, Banjo, and a few others.

Corrin took more of the hate though. Wasn't a lot of people jumping for joy considering how the game hadn't even come out yet overseas. A lot of people took it as unwanted promotional material for Fates.
 

SKX31

Smash Master
Joined
Feb 22, 2019
Messages
3,462
Location
Sweden
And that brings me to this funny video:


Though who's the guy whose face was photoshopped onto Hans Moleman's body?
As someone who saw that live (aside from "Whoa there commentators' curse!"): Yeeeaah that moment shown in the vid highlighted some things that 4's balance patch didn't touch, such as Witch Twist getting up there. I'm pretty convinced that Sakurai took the nerfhammer to her after that match because the beatdown was vicious.

And the guy photoshopped onto Moleman's head? Puretty sure that's MKLeo, who was proficient at :4bayonetta: and used her as a secondary. While Plup, who's a Melee :sheikmelee: player, certainly did not have a lot of time to practice :ultridley: at all. So it's no surprise that Leo was able to perform that touch-of-death combo in front of Sakurai's eyes.

Sidenote: Although now Plup's a Mega Man / Ridley player in Ultimate, so guess he took a liking to the character after all.

Maybe I just wasn't as deeply in the Smash scene, but I just don't simply recall that much overt dislike or excess controversy at Bayo's reveal. It could be that I'm grading on a curve and that after the likes of the response to Byleth or the November 2018 Smash Direct, any grumbling during that time just seems mild by comparison.

I think part of it is that the expectations just didn't seem as raised in the Smash 4 era and thus the fallout (either positive or negative) weren't as notable to boot.
It's hard to grade the volume of similar events years apart when you're relying on memory and other non-empirical measures. I remember there being a lot of negativity around ROB as well, but now that seems quaint and hard to quantify. I wouldn't be able to stack it up next to Corrin or Byleth, the events were too far apart. I just know that these characters all precipitated a notable amount of negativity.

The list is not exhaustive, but in it I would also include Bayo. Not to the same extent as the aforementioned, but I believe she has a place among it as well. Keep in mind that the level of negativity that surrounded Corrin would've been mitigated had it been offset from a great deal of positivity from Bayo. Look at WFT being offset by Villager and Mega Man. Look at no one caring about Chrom because he was sandwiched in between Castlevania and K. Rool. I mean, even Banjo cushioned Hero. But the story isn't that people shrugged at Corrin and were at least happy about Bayo.

I have no "were you mad about Bayo" poll to link to, but I do remember what transpired, and it was very mixed. There is a reason people thought the ballot was rigged for the next several years. I still can't believe they were right, but that's neither here nor there.
I can't recall that much dislike either, although that might be down to me focusing a lot more on the competitive side of things - and I was practically unaware of speculation at the time. TBF I could see a lot of those invested in speculation at the time look at it from a more negative perspective. That said, I can definetely say that there were quite a lot of positive reactions that day as well.

Then again, I'm pretty wary of extrapolating either the competitive or speculation side to other segments of the Smash fanbase who are not invested in either. Partly because a lot of casual Smash fans aren't going to be as invested in who's the next Smash character or how they'll play (albeit they might also have their own wishes), but also since the Smash fanbase is relatively disconnected from each other as is.
 
Last edited:

True Blue Warrior

Smash Hero
Joined
Oct 4, 2013
Messages
9,727
Location
United Kingdom
NNID
TrueBlueSM
3DS FC
2036-7619-4276
It's hard to grade the volume of similar events years apart when you're relying on memory and other non-empirical measures. I remember there being a lot of negativity around ROB as well, but now that seems quaint and hard to quantify. I wouldn't be able to stack it up next to Corrin or Byleth, the events were too far apart. I just know that these characters all precipitated a notable amount of negativity.

The list is not exhaustive, but in it I would also include Bayo. Not to the same extent as the aforementioned, but I believe she has a place among it as well. Keep in mind that the level of negativity that surrounded Corrin would've been mitigated had it been offset from a great deal of positivity from Bayo. Look at WFT being offset by Villager and Mega Man. Look at no one caring about Chrom because he was sandwiched in between Castlevania and K. Rool. I mean, even Banjo cushioned Hero. But the story isn't that people shrugged at Corrin and were at least happy about Bayo.

I have no "were you mad about Bayo" poll to link to, but I do remember what transpired, and it was very mixed. There is a reason people thought the ballot was rigged for the next several years. I still can't believe they were right, but that's neither here nor there.
It doesn’t help that people can recall the past in a way it never happened which is how you get people saying that Krystal was far more requested for Brawl than Wolf ever was when that simply wasn’t true.
 

N3ON

Gone Exploring
BRoomer
Joined
Jan 6, 2008
Messages
21,444
Location
Vancouver
It doesn’t help that people can recall the past in a way it never happened which is how you get people saying that Krystal was far more requested for Brawl than Wolf ever was when that simply wasn’t true.
Maybe I'm an unreliable narrator... but most of the people who appear to disagree don't seem to have actually been part of the speculation scene at the time.

Also, those polls aren't going to be worth much when the most number of votes a character got is 69. That's a pretty small sample. That said, that top 11 seems about right insofar as the members if not the ranking.

I can't recall that much dislike either, although that might be down to me focusing a lot more on the competitive side of things - and I was practically unaware of speculation at the time. TBF I could see a lot of those invested in speculation at the time look at it from a more negative perspective. That said, I can definetely say that there were quite a lot of positive reactions that day as well.

Then again, I'm pretty wary of extrapolating either the competitive or speculation side to other segments of the Smash fanbase who are not invested in either. Partly because a lot of casual Smash fans aren't going to be as invested in who's the next Smash character or how they'll play (albeit they might also have their own wishes), but also since the Smash fanbase is relatively disconnected from each other as is.
Perhaps I should expound that I wasn't trying to speak on the competitive or casual scene. Both seem less invested in who shows up, and that will generally lend to lower highs and higher lows when it comes to reactions, bar someone getting their favourite character or something.

I was just speaking on this side of the community. I mean, I'm sure there were many casual fans who thought getting another FE character was lame but got over it just about as soon as they learned about it in the first place. Those poor fools, unbothered by meaningless things.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom