All true. Having grown up with DK64 like the Rare DKC's, can confirm it was universally loved until you started having revisionism that spawned from the bad game design video and such. I get some not liking the game because too many collectibles, but to say it was to blame for like the death of platformers/3D platforms at the time is reaching higher than even Lanky's arms can extend.
Back to DKC2 though, yeah, going through it 2 player on NSO made me much more appreciative of the Kong balance when compared to the first one. It's like night and day.
You mean Snoman Gaming's vid? That came out 4 years ago. People had that opinion as early as 2005 IIRC. What Snoman said certainly wasn't new by 2016 stabdards. People turning against DK happened shortly after Rare going to Xbox.
Yea '64 has charm, but it's more Banjo-Kazooie than DK flavor. Everything has googly eyes and some of the settings felt lifted from BK. The DK Rap is intentionally corny and that's A-Ok, but King Kut Out was Rare leaning on the 4th Wall like in BK. They're telegraphing to us that they ran out of time/budget for a legit boss so here's the jpeg of K. Rool's official art to fight.
It's definitely not the death of platformers though and I can't believe people thought that it was. It's like the PS2 Platformers of Jak, Sly, Ratchet, Prince of Persia and Sunshine, Galaxy and Rayman 3 never existed in their minds which indicates to me they don't know what they're talking about. Ratchet, Jak and Sly total 9 high profile platformers of the PS2; add Prince of Persia's 3 games plus Banjo-Tooie, Sunshine, Galaxy and modest success of Rayman 3 and Tak's duology, plus cult classics like Psychonauts or Conker and you have at least 20 well-received platformers following DK64. Not to mention at least 4 Sonic platformers (2 Adventures, Heroes and...2006), 2 mediocre Crash and 4 Spyro games (loved Twinsanity though), Ratchet's 5 PS3 platformers and you have dozens of 3D Platformers trickling out from 2000 to 2013.
Like don't get me wrong, I don't wanna play through DK64 again but it's not the Sonic '06 of the 1990s. I'm surprised this is a thing lol.