For my point, I think good mafia play comes from individual thread control, aka controlling how you appear in the game instead of controlling the game itself. I know almost all of my town misylnches came from me doing a horrible job controlling my appearance in the game, normally by going inactive and letting others define it, but other time through social mistakes that make me appear like a prick. Good scum hunting is being able to critically think through options related to why this person would say such and such, or why the mafia would do such and such, and coming up with the plausible solutions. I feel like this is the core of the game, putting on a good appearance and being able to detect bull**** from other players solely through text. There's differences based on your role/alignement, but being good at those two things is critical for every player. Many times a towny can get lynched for their BS even if it's pro-town BS if they can't control how the town views it.