Reporting ****, and Wishing She Hadn't
Source: New York Times
> In the early-morning hours on the campus of Hobart and William Smith Colleges in central New York... he found her - bent over a pool table as a football player appeared to be sexually assaulting her from behind in a darkened dance hall with six or seven people watching and laughing. Some had their cell phones out, apparently taking pictures...
> Later, records show, a sexual-assault nurse offered this preliminary assessment: blunt force trauma within the last 24 hours indicating "intercourse with either multiple partners, multiple times or that the intercourse was very forceful."
> It took the college just 12 days to investigate the **** report, hold a hearing and clear the football players. The football team went on to finish undefeated in its conference, while the woman was left, she said, to face the consequences - threats and harassment for accusing members of the most popular sports team on campus.
> The woman at Hobart and William Smith is no exception. With no advocate to speak up for her at the disciplinary hearing, panelists interrupted her answers, at times misrepresented evidence and asked about a campus-police report she had not seen. The hearing proceeded before her ****-kit results were known, and the medical records indicating trauma were not shown to two of the three panel members.
> Yet privacy laws did not stop Hobart and William Smith from disclosing the name of the woman - a possible **** victim - in letters to dozens of students... The school said it was legally obligated to identify Anna... the district attorney who was assessing the case disagreed, calling the identification "unnecessarily specific and, in my mind, a poor exercise of judgment."
> The day after the episode, the senior football player told two campus officers that he could not recall Anna's name even though he had spent much of the evening with her. The player denied having sexual contact with her during or after the fraternity party. Only after the officers confronted him with reports to the contrary did he acknowledge having "sexual contact" - but not sex - at the Barn, and engaging in oral sex with Anna at the fraternity house.
> While the panel did not ask the players about their changed accounts, it did let the senior give an opening statement. "I come from a wonderful family with strong Christian values," he said. "I have been blessed with a beautiful mother, grandmothers, nieces, and amazing aunts." And he added: "I treat women with the respect and honor they deserve."
> Several hours after the last witness, the panel announced its decision clearing all three athletes on all counts.
> Anna's lawyer appealed the decision to clear the senior player, Mr. Flowers, the student-affairs administrator, granted the family additional time to file its appeal and reviewed the ****-kit results and hospital records. He upheld the panel's ruling, though he did find a violation of the no-contact order.
> On May 2, the day after the federal government announced that Hobart and William Smith was among the schools under investigation, the school sponsored an event used on other campuses called "Walk a Mile in Her Shoes," in which men walk around campus in high-heeled shoes to raise awareness of sexual assault.
> The Geneva police hardly distinguished themselves in Anna's case... Detective Choffin mischaracterized witness statements, put the words of one student in the mouth of another, and stated that he "never saw any discrepancies or alterations" in what the two football players told the authorities, even though they had initially lied about having sexual contact with their accusers. And while Anna's blood alcohol tests had been done many hours after she last had a drink, he also stated unequivocally that her level "would not make a person impaired to the point of blacking out."
> Against her parents' wishes, Anna plans to return to Hobart and William Smith in the fall.