Dexter Mafia ~ ...?

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Also I'm at L-1.

 

[#HBC | J]

Actually you are at L-3.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Actual L-2 we're both wrong.

 

[Choice]

He has had no crums and he has said nothing else about his role, like wtf. How is his more believable?

the context in which he made his post vs yours. no crumbs, but he pretty much doesnt have any posts either and i don't really like how quick the turn over from crumb -> claim was from you.

Tell ya guys what, I'll agree to be lynched to prove he's a liar.

How does that sound?

i like how towny this sounds, but i dont like the notion of losing cop. though i guess what washed said was true, 1 town to 1 scum is a great trade for town.

 

[Choice]

ebwop: i forgot to add that the character you claimed sounds less likely to be cop than his, but again i don't know the flavor at all pretty much so i'm not giving that much weight.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

1 town for 1 scum, fair trade to me.

Let's do it!

 

[#HBC | Laundry]

why the **** isn't red ruy dead now

this **** doesn't need to be prolonged, anything posted now on the situation is added confusion considering votes will give us results.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Glyph, lets go to hell together.

@WL: Vote me please.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

You to J or Rajam, let's catch some scum.

 

[T-block]

Yeah kay. Pretty sure he'll flip scum.

vote: Red Ryu

L-1

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

Very well.

Unvote Vote: Dark Horse



What wonderful content I see here. not.

Any other reads, scum picks? Anything?

Have you been reading? I've said tat j/tan/you is the scum team, I'm not going to report it in the post that breaks the camel's back

Soup, you've apparently liked my catchup post, yet you now put me as "leaning scum". Explain.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Quotes please Dark Horse where you said we were a scum team, never saw that once during my reread.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

first off, what ever happened to the rajam wagon? Major talk for the first 5 or so pages, then poof. it's gone.

Dislike tandora's 199. Let's see what we get from it:

I am always so scummy. I'm either a pr or i get manipulated.

J mad you stole his color.

WL be skimming.

that dedede thing was funny

sex jokes

Why not me

soup is an idiot who should be copped

hold hands with me j.

Which of these facts technically contribute?


soup is an idiot who should be copped (notice how tan simply states this. She doesn't state any thoughts on soup's alignment.

Why these three, not me (mep)

Attack on skimming (One of the biggest leads I have on tan's meta is, when she's scum, she will attack people for dumb reasons, (like skimming) [go check out tan's original analysis on ryu in D&D if you have no idea what i'm talking about. Or a post in inception, where she attacks KY for rockin having wrong definition of suicidal townie, even though the arsonist role in the same flash presentation was different than the usual arsonist role in All-Stars, a game tan participated in)

And what's this? An introduction?

FoS: Tan

then there's soup 132 question: "wl I'm asking a bunch of people questions, does that make me town?". RR's reaction was horrible. Soup is obviously implying that wl shouldn't judge people off of that. But RR jumps on it as if soup called himself scum.

SvT here, with RR scum.

Dislike J's recent attack on soup and T-Block.



J essentially went "you are wrong, therefore you are scum". And J, before you attack me for some reason involving implications, realize that implications are also what you've also thrown at soup.

J, what do you think about the early rajam wagon?

did I cut off my reread early? Screw it.

Quotes please Dark Horse where you said we were a scum team, never saw that once during my reread.

Here.

So, what's your reasoning for the vote now?

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

That isn't calling them a scum team, just that you disliked them and found them scummy, try again.

 

[Choice]

dark horse, i'm confused at what you're trying to achieve here.

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

RR, do I have to spell it out in black and white?

It should've been obvious that I did think they were scum, not just "suspicious". common sense says that if you suspect three people, they're probably scum.

You're reaching.

Kill this guy

choice, I'm debunking RR's weak attack on me.

 

[#HBC | J]

Dark Horse, I just found out you thought I was scum by just saying it now. The only one I thought you thought was scum was Tanny do to the FoS and then RR for the most recent vote on him. ._.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

RR, do I have to spell it out in black and white?

It should've been obvious that I did think they were scum, not just "suspicious". common sense says that if you suspect three people, they're probably scum.

You're reaching.

Kill this guy

choice, I'm debunking RR's weak attack on me.

But you never stated this, ever.

Look at that post again, no where in there does it list us as a team, nowhere in there does it list in black and white J is scum, Nowhere di you say as scum me and Tandora were aligned with each other.

But it's ok when I flip town, after Glyph your next.

 

[Choice]

i think you wanna be responding to #675 then dark horse. =)

that's RR's post with all the explanations in terms of his case on you.

 

[#HBC | J]

RR, give me your town list. Be as in depth as you can with each individual person.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12679717&postcount=675

Respond to this Darky mcskimming Horse, funny how you completely dodged this when I asked about it.

~

@J: Sure, give me a bit for that one.

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

Dark Horse, I just found out you thought I was scum by just saying it now. The only one I thought you thought was scum was Tanny do to the FoS and then RR for the most recent vote on him. ._.

J, are you saying that a suspicion and FoS make a significant difference?

If so, I wish I could go back and edit that, and FoS you, as that's all you take.

But you never stated this, ever.

Look at that post again, no where in there does it list us as a team, nowhere in there does it list in black and white J is scum, Nowhere di you say as scum me and Tandora were aligned with each other.

But it's ok when I flip town, after Glyph your next.

IF YOU THINK THREE PEOPLE ARE SCUM, COMMON SENSE SAYS THAT THEY'RE ALL ON A SCUM TEAM.

YOU'RE GRASPING AT STRAWS. THE ONLY WAY YOU'LL BE FLIPPING TOWN IS IF YOU'RE A DEATH ANTI-MILLER

 

[#HBC | J]

DH, that actually isn't common sense, and no, your tone in your post did not imply I was scum but more that you disliked what I was posting. You didn't really say in length that I was suspicious.

RR, no real rush.

 

[Choice]

dark horse, i don't think i ever got a response now that i think about it when i commented no your attack on skimming stuff. why do you NOT think skimming is bad?

 

[#HBC | J]

WL, you said something w.r.t. DH's alignment is indicitive to you based on RR's flip. What are you thinking now. Consider both flips when answering this question for me. Thank you.

Choice, scum-picks? I can't remember any from you.

 

[#HBC | J]

Tanny! Oh dear god save me! ;____;

 

[#HBC | Laundry]

WL, you said something w.r.t. DH's alignment is indicitive to you based on RR's flip. What are you thinking now. Consider both flips when answering this question for me. Thank you.

Was this when Ryker said he considered a TBro/Gheb scum team if RR flipped town, right?

 

[#HBC | Laundry]

@WL: Vote me please.

My vote hasn't moved from you.

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

NOW LET'S GO AND SKEWER YOUR PATHETIC CASE, PIECE-BY-PIECE

He shows dislike for Tandora and showcases his case of meta on Tandora. Tandora apparently goes after people for BS reasons like skimming then showcases some games that may have had moments where she did pull the BS reasons to lynch people. I don't see this at least from Tandora's recent posts or at the very least what BS reasons she is calling out people.

SKIMMING. WERE YOU EVEN READING THAT POST? I HAD STATED IT IN BLACK AND ****ING WHITE.

Dislikes J's attack on T-Block and Soup...doesn't say why which seems odd he wouldn't.

More comments at J about why is he did a "Disagree with me you as scum" he says J has been doing, not sure about this. Doesn't seem like J has actually done this much if at all.

THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT I MEANT. YOU'RE TRYING TO SPLIT MY POINTS APART. WHAT'S MORE, THEY DON'T HAVE TO DO IT "SEVERAL TIMES" TO MAKE IT A SCUMMY ACTION. IT'S AS IF YOU'RE TRYING TO SAY SCUM META IS THE ONLY SCUMTELL.

Fair comment, but where is anything that suggests he is going after the ones on the Rajam wagon? Common Dark Horse, you call out Ryker but anyone else on the wagon?

Soupamario, Ryker, Asdioh, WashedLaundry, T-block,

All the people on the wagon, Ryker was the only person he has attmpted any form of a persuit on, anything on T-Block, Asdioh, Soup, WL? Nope.

MAYBE BECAUSE THAT'S BECAUSE AL LTHEM PLUS J/YOU/TAN= 7 SCUM, AND PROBABLY TO MUCH FOR A 16 PERSON GAME?

He states Ryker is fine, and comments that a comment was ignored to hide it, so if he is fine with Ryker explaining himself? Why has he not gone after others. He said already the wagon was scummier than Rajam, yet why has he not put pressure on anyone else on the wagon?

BECAUSE PRESSURE IS USUALLY A DEAD GIVEAWAY, AS SCUM WILL EASILY KNOW HOW TO REACT TO PRESSURE IN A PRO-TOWN WAY?

I already mentioned my dislike of DH's play before this point, I address the post in question and still thought DH was bouncing around far too much to be considered scum hunting.

YET YOU HAD MADE KNOW MENTION OF THIS IN YOUR CATCHUP POST.

WHICH IS IT? BOUNCING AROUND OR LACK OF STUFF?

DH, that actually isn't common sense, and no, your tone in your post did not imply I was scum but more that you disliked what I was posting. You didn't really say in length that I was suspicious.

FINE THEN

FOS: J

HAPPY?

dark horse, i don't think i ever got a response now that i think about it when i commented no your attack on skimming stuff. why do you NOT think skimming is bad?

skimming just shows absent minded play. Pretty much any human can commit it out of carelessness. It's pretty much a human error that some people think is a scumtell.

 

[#HBC | J]

Yea, iirc.

Is your opinion still the same?

 

[#HBC | J]

._.

Turn caps off please and I have never seen such an AtE/rage in a post before. Dark Horse, just calm down, take a breather, and come back.

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

Also, remember his 750? He thinks two cops is a safe bet. He's trying to convince people that he might not be scum if glyph dies and flips cop

 

[#HBC | Laundry]

I'm not sure how to read this DH vs. RR interaction at the moment but I can see TvT and SvS clearest. It could be anything, though. I'm still slightly suspicious because I don't think he ever answered why he needs Gheb's opinion on his towniness but it's such a minute, stupid thing that I can't read too much into it. My read on DH as scum if RR is town was dependent on Gheb moreso than RR.

 

[#HBC | Laundry]

EBWOP: be back in ten minutes, i'll analyze this **** to pieces.

if red ruy's not dead when i'm back, y'all disappoint me.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

You skipped some of my pointts, there were around 14 quotes in my original post and you have around 5 in big bold letter while also not addressing most if any of them, very cool.

Point#1: No you didn't state it black and white try again.

Point#2: No it isn't that point was brief at best and you brought in nothing else.

Point#3: No but you excluded them all and only looked very minimally at Ryker at best.

Point#4: Ok so pressure is a dead giveaway, where is it at anyone else at the wagon, why ignore them?

Point#5: Both actually you lack content and the little you have is all around the place and not clear.

Calm down.

And thx J.

 

[CT Chia]

Vote Count 1-10

The deadline has been set for 9:00pm EST on May 12th

With 16 players alive it takes 9 to lynch!

Tandora (0) -
Glyph (0) -
JTB (0) -
Rajam (0) -
vVv Choice (0) -
WashedLaundry (1) - Rajam,
Ryker (0) -
Gordito (0) -
Zen (0) -
Red Ryu (7) - WashedLaundry, Ryker, Dark Horse, Glyph, vVv Choice, Red Ryu, T-block,
Gheb_01 (0) -
Soupamario (0) -
T-block (1) - Soupamario,
Dark Horse (1) - Tandora,
Asdioh (0) -
J (1) - Gheb_01,

No Lynch (0) -

Not Voting (5) - Gordito, Zen, JTB, Asdioh, J,

 

[Tandora]

Scum safe claiming town cop, and Joey Quinn...seriously?

I've never watched Dexter so I have no clue who he is other than he had a former partner who died, has a tough guy persona, and is put off by Dexter Morgan.

Also btw, from what I can gather my sanity isn't guaranteed from what my role PM is saying, so idk if I am a legit cop or insane, etc.

I want to say right now I am going to skim any posts that give away spoilers about the show. I hope I don't lose anything important for the game, but I really don't want the show ruined for me.

I do know that Quinn is from Season 3 and he could be considered a corrupt cop.

"Real" cop should counterclaim imo. Getting a scumbag on D1 is effectively the same as lynching a scumbag via a guilty result. I really don't care about the flavor involved though. If there's no CC I'm going to assume that he's the cop.

J, I can't give you a direct answer to an unclear question. If you and I share the same idea of what "posting style" is, my answer would be "no" however.

Here's the thing. I have suspected from the beginning that there may be several cops in this game, all with differing sanity.

Angel, Doakes, Guerta, Debra, Mizuka, Quinn are all cops that Dexter works with in the show. I could very easily see Doakes as a paranoid cop or he could get a guilty on Dexter regardless of Dexter's alignment since he is VERY suspicious of Dexter.

We cannot determine there is one "real" cop in this game.

Tanny! Oh dear god save me! ;____;

I'm inclined to believe Ryu's claim. The final line confirming his sanity is an awful specific detail and I have been in that situation where I didn't completely read my pm (aka Dissidia) because I figured I knew my role and didn't need to read thoroughly.

Glyph, is your sanity confirmed? Is it confirmed in the same method RR claimed?

In short, don't depend on either character claims or role claims too much guys. Look at motivation. As I said before in this game, WHY and HOW someone says something is more important than WHAT they say.

RR has been a huge lynch target and it's 72 hours in a large game until deadline. I don't think his claim was premature and scum would have waited a lot longer.

Everyone take a moment to do a reread. Hell, take a random player and just ISO them. Step back from the situation and really read their posts.

And RR, don't be stupid and self-vote. If you're really town, then you're hurting your faction. Live! Fight! Win!

F***.

 

[Tandora]

EBWOP: Also, not happy with the FIVE character claims on D1.

 

[#HBC | Red Ryu]

Unvote

I wanna die to out Glyph though...I think he's scum since he vanished against after making two posts with nothing and leaving.