D&D Mafia -- Game over! Mafia wins!

[Cello_Marl]

I like the Lynch All Liars approach. Innocent people should have no reason to lie.

Scum likes to say this for some reason.

BunBun and Rockin are scum.

Kuz, me, TW, Delvro, Tanny and Nabe (turns out I liked GLG) are town, if the Doc and/or Cop want to claim their targets and join us that would be great.

Ryu's wonderment at Kuz not knowing roles seemed genuine but I can't read his intent. Opportunism or not.

DH, who did you target last Night?

 

[Cello_Marl]

Summoner is also scum because he sucks.

 

[smargaret]

v/la now until Sunday

 

[Cello_Marl]

Summoner is scum for loaded questions, Rockin is scum, and BunBun wanted to lynch all liars, so they're scum.

That should be it, good game. Who do you guys want to lynch first?

@Summoner: What reasons? I don't think smargaret and TW are scum if that's what you meant. I forgot to remember to forget.

 

[smargaret]

Cello, you're making me feel like I'm on a roller coaster, lol. Not that I'm complaining.

I notice you don't give a reason why Rockin is scum?

 

[smargaret]

also, did I miss DH claiming yesterday, or are you rolefishing?

 

[Toastin Walrus]

'Course he is. And he caught a trout.

Cello's being an urk.

 

[#HBC | Nabe]

turns out I liked GLG

Why?

Heading to bed, but I'll be here tomorrow (Canadian).

 

[Ryunnosuke]

Ok, time to roleplay.

Orwolon stared in shock as J's dead body laid before her. A single tear trailed down the corner of her eye as she gasped in shock and horror. The wild elf's broken form oozed blood into a pool on the cold, cold dungeon floor. "Whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy?!" Orwolon cried.

As the others gathered around and began to debate the news, Orwolon wept silent, for she had realized the reality of this dire turn of events.

With our fatespinner dead, our luck had run out!

 

[Ryunnosuke]

vote Cello

Getting J killed because you didn't like him is scummy, and you aren't giving good explanations as to why. All I see is diverting and more "kill this guy, he's scum". I held back because I didn't want a repeat of the unfortunate game I was in last time (hint, hint, wink, wink), so this time I'm giving ya the benefit of the doubt to explain what's what.

 

[th3kuzinator]

@DH, your quicktopic functioning alright?

Spoiler

castlevania. dont hurt me

I am off to bed, ill share my thoughts on D2 when I awake.

 

[Toastin Walrus]

Swiss half posting.

For what it's worth, I told Gord J was town. <-- Vanity, verify after the game.

Cello is definitely scum. Tan is town for picking up on it, Smarg is town, DH is town, Summoner isn't aligned with Cello. The Cello wagon already started so I'll just jump on it. I'll assume I was protected last night as Cello is terri-scared of me. I knew you were scum yesterDay and said as much but didn't get a chance to get you lynched - I've only made 10 posts (roughly) this game. Cello is baiting doc into claiming as he knows he's dead as soon as I log in.

Unvote Vote Cello

Lynch him toDay. Rockin needs to be investigated.


/Skimmed

 

[Delvro]

GET YOUR FREAKING VOTES OFF OF CELLO NOW!!!

Also Vote Dark Horse

 

[Delvro]

GET YOUR FREAKING VOTES OFF OF CELLO NOW!!!

Also Vote Dark Horse

Serious vote btw. Why'd you log off without responding to it?

Also, anyone who votes for Cello is scum including Cello himself.

 

[Rockin]

@mod - Can you please tally up the final vote count for D1?

@DH, your quicktopic functioning alright?

Kuz, when you do wake up in the morning, I'd like for you to explain this.

GET YOUR FREAKING VOTES OFF OF CELLO NOW!!!

Also Vote Dark Horse

Why do you believe Cello is town? And what is your reason for voting Dark Horse?

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

Wow, like, 7 pages in a nigh x_x

Dark Horse hardly had a reason to even go after J.

I did. If J flipped scum, it would probably lead to kuz being scum (see one of my earlier posts as to how). Not my preferred cup of acid, but could help the town nevertheless

GET YOUR FREAKING VOTES OFF OF CELLO NOW!!!

Also Vote Dark Horse

Amazing! Care to tell anyone as to how?

 

[Delvro]

Why do you believe Cello is town? And what is your reason for voting Dark Horse?

Dunno if Cello is town. But he is a terrible terrible lynch for D2. By D3 it should be obvious.

My reason for voting Dark Horse is that he's scummy. =3
I reread his posts on D1 and it amazes me that we didn't lynch him then.

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

my reason for voting dark horse is that he's scummy. =3
i reread his posts on d1 and it amazes me that we didn't lynch him then.

explain why! God! Is it realy that hard?

 

[McMaymays]

@mod - Can you please tally up the final vote count for D1?

It should already be up.

 

[Toastin Walrus]

Delvro why is Cello a bad D2 lynch? Explain.
Why is DH scummy? Explain. Even better, remove your vote and vote Cello after you realise he's a dead man typing.

DH you're meant to look townie. Do that.

 

[Ryunnosuke]

I still don't understand why you're pushing DH so much Delvro. You're making Orwolon cry.

 

[Rockin]

@mod - Oh yes, I see it. My bad! Thank you :D

Dunno if Cello is town. But he is a terrible terrible lynch for D2. By D3 it should be obvious.

My reason for voting Dark Horse is that he's scummy. =3
I reread his posts on D1 and it amazes me that we didn't lynch him then.

Those are hardly any reason to think one is either a bad lynch or scummy. How about telling us in detail.

You say you dunno Cello is town, yet he's a terrible lynch? That makes little sense.

Come on Delvro.

Dark Horse - Do you still feel that Kuz is scummy?

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

Dark Horse - Do you still feel that Kuz is scummy?

Not my first pick anymore, but still on my scumlist.

 

[Cello_Marl]

Orwolon stared in shock as J's dead body laid before her. A single tear trailed down the corner of her eye as she gasped in shock and horror. The wild elf's broken form oozed blood into a pool on the cold, cold dungeon floor. "Whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy?!" Orwolon cried.

Unfortunately, what Orwolon failed to consider is that the 86 lb wild elf Endriel was in fact not dead, but merely had a glazed NPC-like look on her face for a moment. His player had simply left the session after all.

 

[Cello_Marl]

Rockin, are you Neutral or Good?

 

[Cello_Marl]

@Tanny: Elder Male One is roleplaying. Do you think he is intentionally doing it because he's scum and knows we know, or he's town and he knows we know he knows, but that would have follow up wouldn't it? I think I don't know know what to think so I'm asking you. Also, why won't Rockin answer my question? I'm sad about that.

 

[Swiss]

*Waves at Cello*

 

[Delvro]

@mod - Oh yes, I see it. My bad! Thank you :D



Those are hardly any reason to think one is either a bad lynch or scummy. How about telling us in detail.

You say you dunno Cello is town, yet he's a terrible lynch? That makes little sense.

Come on Delvro.

Dark Horse - Do you still feel that Kuz is scummy?

I dunno whether or not you're town, but I still wouldn't vote you even if you had a wagon on you, because I think you'd be a sucky lynch. Same with Cello.

Also, I'm really stupid, so I'm gonna

UNVOTE

I'm gonna say I did that because I'm sick and delirious. Yeah.

You know who I think should die today? You don't? Well, I'm not going to tell you.

I think Bunbun and Summoner should post more. I want to know everything that's going on in your minds about this game. And I mean everything.

 

[Delvro]

Rockin, are you Neutral or Good?

Do you think we should all give our alignment?

 

[McMaymays]

The deaths listed in the first post will now also be URLs to the beginning and ending of each Day.

 

[th3kuzinator]

Kuz, when you do wake up in the morning, I'd like for you to explain this.

Not supposed to really talk about castlevania mafia since it is still going on.

If you want an explanation, talk to swiss and DH.

@MOD, can I talk about an existing mafia game if I did not participate in it?

 

[Toastin Walrus]

Do not talk about Castlevania in any place where a player still alive could see it, even if it is only commenting on what I did. You're probably not allowed to talk to dead players either.

Rockin - it's irrelevant.

 

[Toastin Walrus]

Also - ignore practically everything Cello does toDay. He'll be trying to mislead you.

Cello just vote for yourself. Even better, quote your role PM when we take you to L-1, if town this will enable us to see exactly what your role was (even if VT, it'll give us useful information).

I'm sure I can think of no situation where you would oppose this idea.

For my own personal amusement - why am I town? Logical fallacy or do we have a knew one?

 

[Delvro]

You sure seem to have convinced yourself that Cello is scum.

I know some people like to write a little blurb when they vote for somebody, but both Summoner's, and to a lesser extent Ryunnosuke's, justifications for a vote were just a rehash of opinions thrown about earlier, both made after suspicion was obviously rising on Cello (starting with Tandora, who made an accusation but not a vote, then with Rockin).

No. If I was scum I could have easily felt which way the wind was blowing and made those arguments myself, while adding in random stock phrases like "this time I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt...".

Cello has made himself a VERY easy target and I have a growing suspicion that mafia have already tried to take advantage of it.

Summoner, please explain yourself better. You too, Ryunnosuke. Also, still waiting on Bunbun.

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

Delvro, do you still hold your stance that cello is town, and anyone who votes for him is scum?

 

[Tandora]

@Tanny: Elder Male One is roleplaying. Do you think he is intentionally doing it because he's scum and knows we know, or he's town and he knows we know he knows, but that would have follow up wouldn't it? I think I don't know know what to think so I'm asking you. Also, why won't Rockin answer my question? I'm sad about that.

Honestly, I have no idea. I didn't play with him in Newbie 7 and I didn't read it either so I have no previous experience with him. Ryu is known for his IRL RP like "GAME OVER MAN, GAME OVER," so this doesn't inherently scream scum to me.

Dude needs to post more though.

For my own personal amusement - why am I town? Logical fallacy or do we have a knew one?

I'm not convinced on any of the vocal players from yesterday. I have no clue which of you were overenthusiastic townies and how many of you are evil scum.

In post 369, you pushed really hard for the quicklynch. Why so enthusiastic for the Day to end?

 

[Ryunnosuke]

You sure seem to have convinced yourself that Cello is scum.

I know some people like to write a little blurb when they vote for somebody, but both Summoner's, and to a lesser extent Ryunnosuke's, justifications for a vote were just a rehash of opinions thrown about earlier, both made after suspicion was obviously rising on Cello (starting with Tandora, who made an accusation but not a vote, then with Rockin).

No. If I was scum I could have easily felt which way the wind was blowing and made those arguments myself, while adding in random stock phrases like "this time I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt...".

Cello has made himself a VERY easy target and I have a growing suspicion that mafia have already tried to take advantage of it.

Summoner, please explain yourself better. You too, Ryunnosuke. Also, still waiting on Bunbun.

My vote was supposed to be a pressure vote at Cello to get him to explain his rationale as to why he thinks he can say that he pushed the J vote because he didn't like him. Normally, I wouldn't suspect Cello to have that sort of play, but I got the impression that Cello wanted him gone, not because he thought he was scum. Even if Cello turns out to NOT be scum, he's not answering our questions as to why he voted the way he did or why he's pushing for lynches. That's anti town to me. I'm also giving him the opportunity to SAY something in his defense too, you know.

@Cello... Orwolon picks up J's character's arm and feels for a pulse. No sign of life! She then lays her head down on the wild elf's chest. No heartbeat! Orwolon takes a closer look.... and see's a strange bruise around J's neck. Hm... curiousier and curiouser.

 

[Toastin Walrus]

I'm not convinced on any of the vocal players from yesterday. I have no clue which of you were overenthusiastic townies and how many of you are evil scum.

In post 369, you pushed really hard for the quicklynch. Why so enthusiastic for the Day to end?

He genuinely believed J was scum. He pushed for the lynch as such.

^ Gord will answer better (I hope)...(He better)

Also, is Cello scum? You picked up on what a good 'ol townie should have, who are you voting? I'm literally diving out the door now so I can't check. But it should be Cello.

 

[Tandora]

He genuinely believed J was scum. He pushed for the lynch as such.

^ Gord will answer better (I hope)...(He better)

Also, is Cello scum? You picked up on what a good 'ol townie should have, who are you voting? I'm literally diving out the door now so I can't check. But it should be Cello.

I didn't vote originally because I wanted a response from Cello before I voted. And his response was right in words but the tone feels...wrong? Normally he's in total leader mode, so why does it feel like he's phonin' it in this game? He only said the one thing that helps me know he's town after I asked for it. Even then, he sorta handwaved it.

But now you're encouragin' me to vote Cello. Normally very understandable. But this is after Cello's gotten a huge wagon on him (pressure not really necessary) and Delvro declared that anyone who votes for Cello now is scum. Are you tryin' to mark me as scum? Tryin' to get attention off your own scum self? Trying to kill Cello quickly as J?

Quite frankly, I don't have anyone to trust right now. Stupid quicklynch. Stupid J for quicklynching. Argh!

AND WHY DOES SWISS KEEP WAVING AT CELLO? >_<

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

I'll post when I get home and stuff. Thanksgiving stuff.