D&D Mafia -- Game over! Mafia wins!

[Cello_Marl]

By the way, I consider that a real scum-tell.

I'm like seriously ok with lynching me, then Rockin, Summoner, and BunFlame/whoever.

 

[Delvro]

By the way, I consider that a real scum-tell.

I don't get it

 

[Delvro]

You know people aren't going to follow your words after you die. If you want to see us lynch the group you think is scum, you need to stay alive.

I mean look at J. He told us to lynch Smarg and TW after he died and we haven't done much about that, huh? Although I'm sure he's happy to see a Cello wagon.

It's kind of disheartening to see you give up like this, really. Asking your sister to defend you against Ryunno when all you'd really have to do is post an old game or two of yours to defend yourself. =\

I don't understand the defeated attitude.

 

[Toastin Walrus]

This.

It explains a lot of Cello's behavior. I'm honestly surprised because the last game I was in Cello was super vocal and driving in the discussions. I'm confused atm as to why he was acting quiet, but unless he pulls a rabbit out of the hat I think this is leading to a lynch.

TW, are you willing to put yourself up for lynch if Cello does flip town?

Yes.

I wouldn't actually let you lynch me, but I'd make an elaborate show of willingness and then get Rockin lynched.

Also, how certain would you be of my scumminess if Cello flipped town? Would I be like soooooooo scummy

No, he isn't, because I won't let him.

Elaborate. I'd ask for reasoning, but you'd just ignore me. You'll ignore me anyway, but I'll post to you anyway.

In this post you effectively admit you have played a scummy game, and one in which I'd read you as scum, do you absolve me of any scumminess if you flip town? If you flip scum, was I bussing you?


Cop investigate Rockin, seriously. <--Not a cop crumb

 

[Tandora]

Elder female one, tell elder male one that I'm town.

How am I supposed to do that when you haven't convinced me? I thought you were goin' to show me you were town. =/

VOTE CELLO

 

[Ryunnosuke]

@MOD vote count plz

I agree Cello's coming off as defeatist. If he did flip town, then son, I would be disappoint.

 

[Cello_Marl]

Ryu - did you play in Newbie 7? You quickvoted in LyLo. Don't do that >_<

If they were scum, this is something that would never have crossed their minds. Not that they wouldn't want to say it, just that they wouldn't have thought to.

GLG is town.

If smargaret were scum with basically anyone else in the game, she would have realized that Kuz wasn't my elder brother. That also isn't the sort of tactic that she would likely try as scum, imo. So she is town.

If me and J were truly partners then wouldn't it be obvious from the start to not make it look too conspicuous by helping/favoring each other too quickly.

I'd think that if Kuz were scum, he would have played this up a bit more on the association aspect. Basically trying to push the idea that J and he were the same faction, so when J flipped town, people would think he was too. Not that it would have been effective, just what he would be likely to try. And there is the obvious part that if he actually did have scummates, no one here would have wanted him to keep so much attention on himself. No one, especially a newbie, likes to go out of their way to appear ignorant.

BunBun was picking on Kuz as the popular target. Die you lynch all liarer.

 

[Cello_Marl]

Given how much I've seemingly needlessly and without reason opposed BunBun, it is surprising that his vote isn't on me. Why would this be so?

 

[Cello_Marl]

Unless he requested replacement before D2 began, but Mod would have announced that a while ago, I'd think.

 

[#HBC | Gorf]

Sorry @everyone I'm V/LA for pretty much the rest of the day and possibly half of tomorrow. I'm being dragged to my sister's soccer tournament -____-.

 

[Delvro]

@MOD vote count plz

I agree Cello's coming off as defeatist. If he did flip town, then son, I would be disappoint.

Prepare to be disappoint. In regard to things you've said toward

Cello,

interesting statements

void tell -_-

 

[McMaymays]

Frozenflame751 has replaced into the game. Thank you, Frozen.

 

[McMaymays]

1. Cello_Marl -(6)- Rockin, SummonerAU, Ryunnosuke, Toastin Walrus, Nabe, Tandora

4. frozenflame751 -(1)- Delvro

11. Rockin -(1)- Cello

2. Nabe -(0)-

3. Dark Horse -(0)-

5. Delvro -(0)-

6. smargaret -(0)-

7. Tandora -(0)-

9. th3kuzinator -(0)-

10. Ryunnosuke -(0)-

12. SummonerAU -(0)-

13. Toastin Walrus -(0)-

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch!

A deadline has been set for December 4th, at 10:30pm (Central time!)

***PLEASE MAKE SURE TO UNVOTE BEFORE VOTING AGAIN***

 

[Rockin]

@Rockin: That's a really awkward way to say Neutral Good. Why didn't you just say it the same way as it would have appeared on your character sheet?

Well you said if I was either Neutral or good. It said 'Neutral Good', which didn't sound like it'd make sense, so that's why I said 'neutral and good.'

Smarg - How goes that re-read? Havn't heard from ya since your last post about it.

I'm looking forward to see Frozen catch up and rereading everything. I know that guy won't dissipoint.

Summoner, you've barely said anything all of D2. How about adding in something to the game, yo?

 

[Rockin]

I'm not feeling a Cello lynch anymore, but my vote is staying on him. Shh don't tell him though.

Forgot to quote this a second ago.

Any reason to this? Do you feel Cello is town? If so, then why are you voting him? If you don't think he's scummy, who do you feel we should lynch toDay?

Plz explain your reasons.

 

[th3kuzinator]

Wow, I posted this long thing last night and my internet must of cut off because nothing appeared

Ill just post the jist of what I was saying, because I do not want to re-write the whole thing.

By the way, I consider that a real scum-tell.

I'm like seriously ok with lynching me, then Rockin, Summoner, and BunFlame/whoever.

I do still think there is something going on with TW/Smarg (at least one of them).

However, Cello, with the way you have been playing D2, I am not so sure of your alignment either.

@Cello, What would be your reasons for going after rockin and summoner after your flip (assuming you flip town)?

 

[Tandora]

Well you said if I was either Neutral or good. It said 'Neutral Good', which didn't sound like it'd make sense, so that's why I said 'neutral and good.'

Rockin' have you played DnD? The way you responded makes me think you haven't.

 

[Rockin]

Rockin' have you played DnD? The way you responded makes me think you haven't.

Nope, but I've always been wanting to play it since I was like...18 (I'm 23 now). I never found the chance or the people to play it with, so I know very little about it. All I do know is that there's a lot of reading involve as well as a bit of imagination (and dice rolling).

 

[Delvro]

So with Cello at L-1, what do you guys plan to do? Hopefully we're not ready for a lynch. I'm not. And I'll be real MAD LIKE if someone hammers quickly.

 

[Cello_Marl]

Posting something now. If you hammer you're Xonar.

 

[Cello_Marl]

I'm a universal back-up. I didn't have a character coming into the game (although I did have a character sheet). As such, when J left the game, I took his character. That's why I knew how much he weighed (his character was male)

Let's see. I was...

Character Name: Undecided
Player Name: Cello_Marl
Class and Level: LV10 Undecided
Race: Human
Alignment: ...
Deity: ...?
Size: Medium
Age: Oldish...
Gender: M...or F
Height: Average?
Weight: ...uh
Eyes: two
Hair: whatever
Skin: yes

My picture was a cropped portion of the male and female humans from the PhB. Apparently, I was late to the game, and the game was underway. When I asked to see what classes people already had, I was told they were covered. I only have my vote, but was assured that I would get to be what I needed.

And now I am...

Character Name: Erendriel
Player Name: J Cello (written sloppily)
Class and Level:LV10 Fatespinner
Race:Wild Elf
Alignment:Lawful Good (the G in Good is under the L in lawful, and they are at an angle, about 15 degrees)
Deity: -
Size: Medium
Age: 117
Gender:M
Height: 4'6"
Weight:86 lbs
Eyes:Gray
Hair:gray
Skinale

I don't recognize where my pic is from. I was raised by dire ferrets that found me in the woods when I was a baby, and learned Survival. Then, tragically, a group of merchants found me and thought that my dire ferret kin were trying to harm me, so they killed them and took me back to civilization. I would never forget those ferrets, though. I vowed to something about not letting the world harm trees or something that I don't want to say too closely to the original and can't synonym my way out of it.

I ended up getting J's role. That means I have a provable power if I can guess correctly who scum will NK. A scum universal back-up is so unlikely as to be impossible. So there you have it.

 

[Delvro]

Who did you target last night with J's new ability?

 

[Cello_Marl]

@Tanny, Ryu and Delvro: Does this look like something I would make up?

@Frozen: Your best bet is to lynch me right now. If you don't, I'mma coming for that ***.

About Rockin: Seriously. People just say words in order. He didn't. He's probably either Lawful Evil or Chaotic Evil. The only time people said Good Neutral and Neutral Chaotic was 1st edition. We're up to 3rd now (e4th doesn't exist). Heck, he might be ANY alignment (it's not like the PC killers are just going to write Evil on their character sheets). But why not just say it as it was?

 

[Cello_Marl]

@Delvro: You.

 

[Delvro]

@Delvro: You.

Actually, after re-reading J's ability, I worded that badly. You don't actually target people, right? You just make a guess every night. Right?

 

[Cello_Marl]

I don't know if it counts as targeted or not. Mod, can you clarify this? PM of course.

 

[Delvro]

About Rockin: Seriously. People just say words in order. He didn't. He's probably either Lawful Evil or Chaotic Evil. The only time people said Good Neutral and Neutral Chaotic was 1st edition. We're up to 3rd now (e4th doesn't exist). Heck, he might be ANY alignment (it's not like the PC killers are just going to write Evil on their character sheets). But why not just say it as it was?

Makes sense, but he clearly knows next to nothing about DnD. I think he's either Neutral Good as he said or Neutral Evil, figuring that replacing Evil with good is a great idea.

That or his scummates coached him when you asked the question.

 

[Swiss]

Cello is this why I knew you weren't town D1?

Why did you not change D2?

Would you have become scum had we lynched scum?

 

[Cello_Marl]

@Swiss who should be Toasted Walrus: About your third question, even then I had town's win condition, so no. You continue to be sadly mistaken about your first two points, but that suits my purposes in the overall metagame and do not affect my faction's chances of success negatively here, so I am informing you that I will ignore that line of inquiry.

@Delvro: It would have been clear in context that I was referring to moral Neutrality instead of ethical Neutrality. None of Tandora, Ryu, or yourself would have coached him in that way. Yet another reason I want to check his real alignment.

 

[Cello_Marl]

By lynching. Or catching him in an AoE spell.

 

[Delvro]

Rockin said his alignment in the order that you did (from his point of view).

Rockin, you never answered my question. Are you Good or Neutral?

Didn't really want to answer cause it seems unimportant, really

But if you must know, I'm both. Good and neutral.

I'm not convinced about Rockin. Think he'd make a better investigaate target than lynch target.

 

[Cello_Marl]

I do not target.

 

[Cello_Marl]

Unvote Vote Frozenflame

@Delvro: That's fine by me.

 

[Delvro]

Cool. Let's kill Frozenflame guys.

 

[Rockin]

I'm a universal back-up. I didn't have a character coming into the game (although I did have a character sheet). As such, when J left the game, I took his character. That's why I knew how much he weighed (his character was male)

Let's see. I was...

Character Name: Undecided
Player Name: Cello_Marl
Class and Level: LV10 Undecided
Race: Human
Alignment: ...
Deity: ...?
Size: Medium
Age: Oldish...
Gender: M...or F
Height: Average?
Weight: ...uh
Eyes: two
Hair: whatever
Skin: yes

My picture was a cropped portion of the male and female humans from the PhB. Apparently, I was late to the game, and the game was underway. When I asked to see what classes people already had, I was told they were covered. I only have my vote, but was assured that I would get to be what I needed.

And now I am...

Character Name: Erendriel
Player Name: J Cello (written sloppily)
Class and Level:LV10 Fatespinner
Race:Wild Elf
Alignment:Lawful Good (the G in Good is under the L in lawful, and they are at an angle, about 15 degrees)
Deity: -
Size: Medium
Age: 117
Gender:M
Height: 4'6"
Weight:86 lbs
Eyes:Gray
Hair:gray
Skinale

I don't recognize where my pic is from. I was raised by dire ferrets that found me in the woods when I was a baby, and learned Survival. Then, tragically, a group of merchants found me and thought that my dire ferret kin were trying to harm me, so they killed them and took me back to civilization. I would never forget those ferrets, though. I vowed to something about not letting the world harm trees or something that I don't want to say too closely to the original and can't synonym my way out of it.

I ended up getting J's role. That means I have a provable power if I can guess correctly who scum will NK. A scum universal back-up is so unlikely as to be impossible. So there you have it.

I'm really REALLY unconvinced about this. You mean to tell me you basically copied off J's powers/inherited J's powers? And that when you first started, you had a semi blank sheet? No way. I don't believe it at all. Not like how the way you pushed J's lynch like that.

Kuz, Dark Horse, BunBun - I want you three to give me a nice short answer to what I'm about to ask you all. How Town are you guys?

 

[Cello_Marl]

You mean to tell me you basically copied off J's powers/inherited J's powers? And that when you first started, you had a semi blank sheet? No way. I don't believe it at all. Not like how the way you pushed J's lynch like that.

Can you explain to us why the first two parts have anything to do with how I pushed J's lynch?

 

[Cello_Marl]

BunBun didn't make that much of an impression in this game at all. Why does Rockin think he's still in it? Scummates, perhaps?!

 

[th3kuzinator]

I am currently traveling up island with the family and am just about to arrive aty destination. I am on my iPhone btw. I will be v/la for the next 6-8 hrs. I will respond to everything when I get back tonight.

 

[#HBC | Dark Horse]

Why are you putting the breadcrumbing (if Cello is even doing that) out in the open?

FoS: Dark Horse

(all of this is taken as if i was responding to this a coiple of seconds later) Cello is considered scum by just about everyone. Knowing what the bread breadcrumb is could potentially save him/her/it. If the breadcrumb proves cello is town, we don't have to worry. We have only one killing role/group, the mafia (and maybe a smart vig), an a doctor/other protection role. Doc on cello, simple. (Serial killers usually have to kill every night, thus there probably isn't an SK). Why shouldn't we?

Also, people usually say "good and neutral", not "neutral and good". It's just how people speak. It shouldn't cause any suspicion that rockin said it in the same order as cello.

Kuz, Dark Horse, BunBun - I want you three to give me a nice short answer to what I'm about to ask you all. How Town are you guys?

That all depends on who's judging. According to people such as TW, I'm town, while you seem to think of me as slightly suspicious. If im the judge, then I'm 100% town, according to my role pm.

 

[McMaymays]

SummonerAU has been prodded.