Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
It appears that you are using ad block :'(
Hey, we get it. However this website is run by and for the community... and it needs ads in order to keep running.
Please disable your adblock on Smashboards, or go premium to hide all advertisements and this notice. Alternatively, this ad may have just failed to load. Woops!
As a reminder: honorable mentions are basically players that would've likely made a specific section of the rankings if they had more attendance, but they did not have enough attendance to qualify for the rankings. Dabuz is a special case for the entire rankings, as he initially planned on attending just enough events to not meet the attendance requirements (guess he didn't feel like getting ranked this season ¯\(ツ)/¯ ); however, the changes to the requirements mid-season meant that he had inadvertently attended enough to qualify. LumiRank team treated it as a special circumstance and allowed him to opt out. Lea is another special case for the entire rankings, as he missed out on being a Top 50 HM, but was grouped with them anyway due to only being 0.04 points behind #50.
It’s that time of the year again. Welcome to LumiRank 2024.2, the definitive Super Smash Bros. Ultimate ranking for the second half of 2024. Join us in celebrating the 50 players who set themselves apart from the field as some of the strongest in the game right now.
luminosity.gg
Here are the rankings for 51-100 and 101-150, with their respective honorable mentions.
HM: Leaf()
HM: Many
HM: Bobo
HM: Char
HM: Xerzal
HM: Space
HM: ΩRugal()
HM: LittN!()
HM: Ogatou
HM: Skinny the Pooh
As of right now, the only characters in the game not represented in the rankings as a main or secondary are:
If HMs are excluded, then the list will include:
If secondaries are excluded, then the list will include:
Now obviously will later be rep'd by Marss, will later be rep'd by Light and Kaninabe, and will later be crossed off the secondary list with Asimo. may likely be rep'd by WebbJP later, but I am not 100% sure.
I am 50/50 on whether or not Lumirank will count Miya's secondary (I wouldn't lmao).
As a reminder: honorable mentions are basically players that would've likely made a specific section of the rankings if they had more attendance, but they did not have enough attendance to qualify for the rankings. Dabuz is a special case for the entire rankings, as he initially planned on attending just enough events to not meet the attendance requirements (guess he didn't feel like getting ranked this season ¯\(ツ)/¯ ); however, the changes to the requirements mid-season meant that he had inadvertently attended enough to qualify. LumiRank team treated it as a special circumstance and allowed him to opt out. Lea is another special case for the entire rankings, as he missed out on being a Top 50 HM, but was grouped with them anyway due to only being 0.04 points behind #50.
It’s that time of the year again. Welcome to LumiRank 2024.2, the definitive Super Smash Bros. Ultimate ranking for the second half of 2024. Join us in celebrating the 50 players who set themselves apart from the field as some of the strongest in the game right now.
luminosity.gg
Here are the rankings for 51-100 and 101-150, with their respective honorable mentions.
HM: Leaf()
HM: Many
HM: Bobo
HM: Char
HM: Xerzal
HM: Space
HM: ΩRugal()
HM: LittN!()
HM: Ogatou
HM: Skinny the Pooh
As of right now, the only characters in the game not represented in the rankings as a main or secondary are:
If HMs are excluded, then the list will include:
If secondaries are excluded, then the list will include:
Now obviously will later be rep'd by Marss, will later be rep'd by Light and Kaninabe, and will later be crossed off the secondary list with Asimo. may likely be rep'd by WebbJP later, but I am not 100% sure.
I am 50/50 on whether or not Lumirank will count Miya's secondary (I wouldn't lmao).
[Edit: 1/1/25] The 2nd video is up. From here on, I will simply update this post for each of the remaining parts, which will happen in the next few days.
[Edit: 1/2/25] 3rd video is up
[Edit: 1/3/25] 4th video is up
[Edit: 1/4/25] Final video is up
HM: Leaf()
HM: Many
HM: Bobo
HM: Char
HM: Xerzal
HM: Space
HM: ΩRugal()
HM: LittN!()
HM: Ogatou
HM: Skinny the Pooh
The only characters in the game not represented in the rankings as a main or secondary are:
If HMs are excluded, then the list will include:
If secondaries are excluded, then the list will include:
Apparently there was a big tournament I was completely unaware of called Dr. Insano's Bonfire that happened 4 months ago. It had some notable players like Hurt, Ken and Skyjay. I posted the link if anyone wants to check it out.
This weekend featured two supermajors, one in Japan and one in the Tristate.
Maesuma'TOP 1 (579 Entrants)
1st: acola
2nd: Doramigi
3rd: Raki
4th: Miya
5th: Raru
5th: Carmelo
7th: alice
7th: MASA
9th: Rarikkusu
9th: KEN
9th: Lvl. 1
9th: Yoshidora
13th: Taikei
13th: Navy
13th: Asimo
13th: sssr
17th: Chag
17th: Shirayuki
17th: YamaD
17th: Kaninabe
17th: Karaage
17th: Ryuoh
17th: Kome
17th: Nyonoknb
25th: Elon
25th: Shupi
25th: Umeki
25th: Shion
25th: Iba
25th: Gorioka
25th: Hero
25th: Miko
33rd: 33Peranbox
33rd: Gachipi
33rd: Kuroponzu
33rd: MildnaH.O
33rd: Yone_pi
33rd: Kurofune
33rd: Omuatsu
33rd: Futari no Kiwami Ah~!
33rd: Rimu
33rd: Marcos
33rd: MaT
33rd: Mark
33rd: Nininga
33rd: Ezs
33rd: Ike
33rd: Manto
This tournament had a common (but funny) theme of all of acola's bracket demons losing to a different Steve that isn't him. It also featured Doramigi beating acola 3-0 in GF set 1, then acola beating him back 3-0 in set 2, thus exchanging 3-0s.
This is the first time in recent memory that there have been 3 Steve players in top 8 of a major, granted that all 3 won with a different character at some point in the bracket.
Also, it seems that Falco has been getting increasingly elite level results as of late, not to the same level as Luigi's recent explosive results, but getting close. He is a fairly common top placing character in Japanese majors in the past few months. Definitely a character to look out for.
This is the first LMM event since LMBM 2023 where Steve is legal, following the usual Twitter poll.
After seeing that he is the new #1 in the world, Sparg0 entered New Game + mode, proceeding to absolutely demolish the competition in this event. No player in this tournament brought him to game 5. Heck, he even got 2nd in the Rivals 2 bracket (outplacing his seed) and was the only person who brought CakeAssault to game 5.
Low tier mains rejoice, cause JeJaJeJa brought Kirby all the way to 9th in this tournament beating players like Jakal and Kola. Zelda mains also eat nicely today, with Free KayFlock getting 25th.
Ness also got a lot of exposure this tournament, with ATATA getting 17th, PkChris getting 9th while beating MkLeo, and Syrup used Ness to beat Omega and he used him in both sets vs Hurt (granted that he lost both of those sets, but it is the thought that counts ).
Very early to say, but it seems like Hurt might be coming back into being a top 5 player if he keeps this up. 1st at Smash Awesome beating acola twice, Shuton twice and Akakikusu with only one loss to Shuton, and 2nd at LMBM beating Syrup twice and Peabnut, only losing to the recently crowned #1.
One thing I can say is that the year of doesn't seem to have ended with how many upset's Luigikid64 made. Wins over players like MuteAce and Tilde are quite nice. The breakout run of the tourney honestly. Just gonna say that Luigi is a really good character despite his exploitable disadvantage state and recovery, and Raru has figured out how to deal with some of Luigi's bad matchups. I don't really think touch of death characters can really be bad in Ultimate because there's just times where if a player makes a single error like misspacing an attack, suddenly they get hit and take a lot of damage or lose their stock. Punish games are getting really important in Ultimate overall so those characters just get better and better.
I'm bored so I'm going to throw out some hot takes. I think is the worst character in the game, followed by and then is third worst.
Sword Fighter is really bad. The devs tried to make him a jack of all trades but he ends up being worse at any specific thing than the characters who specialize in it. His zoning is really underwhelming, his swordplay is slow and not particularly powerful or oppressive. He's just an all around underwhelming character.
Everyone knows why Mac is bad. I've been watching a lot of games by Peanut and Major, the best Mac and Ganon players, respectively. With Ganon's terrible recovery it's hard to put him above anyone but Mac's recovery is almost as bad and he's a lot lighter. Mac gets gimped or even outright KOed so easily I think he has overall worse survivability than Ganon. Mac's KO punch gets hit out of him so easily that he rarely lands it. A lot of MUs seem hopeless for Mac.
Ganon's still really bad but he can be more oppressive than the other two characters. His attacks are huge and hit super hard so he's actually really scary in advantage. The meta is leaning more toward strong advantages than strong neutrals: look at DK's rise.
Play some please. He really isn't even bottom 10. Mostly lacks kill power, but if you know how to use him, he's good. Still 100% the WORST Mii character though, by far. I'd say he's bottom 20ish, maybe bottom 15.
Earlier I made a post explaining why I think Luigi is really good, and today Larry Lurr dropped a video where he discusses why he thinks Luigi is better then Mario.
Ganon: I do think Ganon's slightly underrated but he still needs some serious buffs. First I'd make flame choke not freefall to bring his recovery more in line with other super heavies. Jab frame 7>5. And I'd give him his Brawl Usmash instead of his volcano kick utilt; there's no reason why he needs warlock punch and volcano kick. Brawl's usmash was like G&W's current usmash: slow to start but virtually unpunishable for those who don't know.
Little Mac: Mac's too glass and not enough canon. I'd make it so ko punch takes 20% damage before it's knocked out of him. Currently any move that makes Mac tumble will make him lose it and that's most attacks at the %s he gets ko punch. Currently Mac can't use sideb again until he lands or grabs the ledge even if he's hit. That's why his recovery is so bad. I'd make him regain it after being hit.
Krool: IMO Krool's an underrated mid-tier. However there are a few things the devs put in place to keep him from being too powerful that are unnecessary that I'd remove. I'd make crown always reappear on his head and make belly armor never break. He's such a punching bag that these changes wouldn't be overpowered.
Dedede: I'd make gordos take 10% damage before they are sent back at him. I think this one change would actually make Dedede a threatening zoner. Currently gordos get sent back by almost any attack and they're pretty bad outside ledge trapping.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but this is the first time solo Aegis made top 8 at a supermajor in a long time, typically Aegis players have some co-main or pilot the character as a secondary. I think the last time solo Aegis made top 8 at a supermajor was at S Factor 11 (which was by Cosmos).
Also Miya has now surpassed MkLeo when looking at players' total major wins, if you are going by the SmashWiki page. Quidd (Yes, the LMBM 2022 winner) decided to randomly attend this event and got wins over Toriguri, Yadon and Tas.
Been a quiet week in Ultimate, since this weekend's tournaments have been B tiers.
Instead, I found an interesting article by Luminosity earlier this month (posted back at January 9th).
It is a tier list based purely on results and it ranges from October 2021 (when Sora released) to December 2024 (last month).
Welcome to Luminosity’s Official Results-Based Tier List for December 2024, presented by LG Schu.
luminosity.gg
S+
S
S-
A+
A-
B+
B-
C+
C-
D
F
I personally don't hold much weight into this list, since it covers such a wide date range and the meta has evolved so much in the past year that it is almost unrecognizable from the early portion of this date range, but I think it is interesting enough to warrant a bit of discussion.
Been a quiet week in Ultimate, since this weekend's tournaments have been B tiers.
Instead, I found an interesting article by Luminosity earlier this month (posted back at January 9th).
It is a tier list based purely on results and it ranges from October 2021 (when Sora released) to December 2024 (last month).
Welcome to Luminosity’s Official Results-Based Tier List for December 2024, presented by LG Schu.
luminosity.gg
S+
S
S-
A+
A-
B+
B-
C+
C-
D
F
I personally don't hold much weight into this list, since it covers such a wide date range and the meta has evolved so much in the past year that it is almost unrecognizable from the early portion of this date range, but I think it is interesting enough to warrant a bit of discussion.
This list should certainly be taken with a grain of salt but it does shed some light on discussions we've had in this thread. Luigi vs Kazuya for example. Luigi has been pulling ahead lately but Kazuya still has better results. That could change in the future but it's hard to predict trends. Kazuya might not have as good a player as Raru but he has more lower rank results. He's definitely someone who's doing good all over.
Another discussion is Toon Link vs Young Link. Neither have exactly been doing great but YL has been getting more results. As a YL player I definitely think he's the best Link. As I discussed in a earlier post, YL has a lot of advantages in his moveset over TL like a f4 Nair to break combos and much better midrange zoning and combos.
Palutena continues to be a top tier without a top player.
And finally, I've said frequently that Ike's mid tier and this supports it. Ike's a character that didn't do much so everybody assumed his entire kit was bad. He still has some good things going for him and people tend to underestimate swordies. If Ike hits you once he'll probably hit you at least once more. I've played an Ike who got 3rd at a regional tournament and his Nair still combos fine. He has a better recovery than a lot of swordies because sideB. He also has a really good Bair and Dtilt starts combos. Controlling space with a huge sword is a big benefit in Ultimate. I can't see him in low tier with characters who have crippling weaknesses like Mac and Ganon.
1st: Miya
2nd: ShinyMark
3rd: Hurt
4th: acola
5th: Lima
5th: Sonix
7th: Sisqui
7th: Jogibu
9th: Umeki
9th: KEN
9th: Glutonny
9th: Lui$
13th: Widara
13th: Shoe
13th: Apple Reviewer
13th: YamaD
17th: Steamy
17th: Kaninabe
17th: Kyon
17th: Mr. E
17th: AMGonza
17th: Tubasuwa
17th: Raflow
17th: Marvelous_Marco
In the 2nd pre-local, which had the talent pool of a major, ShinyMark got wins on KEN, Sonix, Lima, acola, Hurt and Miya but lost to Miya twice. Acola also beat Sonix for the first time using Steve. Seems like most of the players that were demons to Steve have now fallen to a Steve player recently. Though Hurt hasn't lost to a Steve other then acola in a very long time and the same goes for Sparg0.
It's interesting Glutonny has been going the last couple tournaments. Although Link does seem like a strait downgrade from Wario. IMO Link's a solid mid tier but he struggles from poor mobility and frame data. He has some good things going for him like excellent offstage intercepting with arrows and bombs and the best ledge trapping of the Links. Unfortunately he struggles with similar issues as other big sword characters like needing space to activate his slow cuts. He's generally best as a zoner who uses his big sword and projectiles to force approaches then walls the opponent before they can get close enough to do damage. Unfortunately there are a good many characters who can destroy this gameplan like Falco who has a reflector and laser that can nullify Link's projectile game. Shiek and Fox can be hard because they can slip in and vortex Link and Link doesn't have good options to escape. Then their are characters who simply have a better midrange game like the little Links and Minmin who force Link to approach, which he is not good at. Furthermore, Link lacks the sauce to makeup for his shortcomings; his damage is okay but not great and his kill power isn't outrageous like top tiers. He's a fun character to play but if Glutonny is looking to win he should look elsewhere.
It's interesting Glutonny has been going the last couple tournaments. Although Link does seem like a strait downgrade from Wario. IMO Link's a solid mid tier but he struggles from poor mobility and frame data. He has some good things going for him like excellent offstage intercepting with arrows and bombs and the best ledge trapping of the Links. Unfortunately he struggles with similar issues as other big sword characters like needing space to activate his slow cuts. He's generally best as a zoner who uses his big sword and projectiles to force approaches then walls the opponent before they can get close enough to do damage. Unfortunately there are a good many characters who can destroy this gameplan like Falco who has a reflector and laser that can nullify Link's projectile game. Shiek and Fox can be hard because they can slip in and vortex Link and Link doesn't have good options to escape. Then their are characters who simply have a better midrange game like the little Links and Minmin who force Link to approach, which he is not good at. Furthermore, Link lacks the sauce to makeup for his shortcomings; his damage is okay but not great and his kill power isn't outrageous like top tiers. He's a fun character to play but if Glutonny is looking to win he should look elsewhere.
According to some of his streams, Gluto's Link is the character he has the most fun with outside of Wario and he feels content enough with his placings that he wants to try and push another character to the highest level. From what I'm getting, he knows Link isn't THAT good compared to Wario but doesn't really care? Although he did say he's going full Wario for Genesis so he probably won't bring out the Link at a supermajor for a long time if ever.
Very wild tournament, with big names like Sparg0, Sonix, and Raru eliminated already.
Also, the curse continues. Raru underperformed in a major tournament, thus a different Luigi player gets top 8 instead. This almost always happens. XD
5 Japanese players, 2 US, 1 European. Almost seems like it's a Japanese tournament that US players invaded rather than the other way around. We could very feasibly see a Japanese top 4. Unless Luugi makes some huge upsets we're going to see a Japanese player in winners side Grand Finals.
Wow, Hurt dominated the top 8 of Genesis X2, with no games dropped in top 8. Kola was by far his hardest opponent, as he had to clutch up a reverse 3-0 in order to win that set.
Hurt's 2025 season looks absolutely incredible right now. 1st at Smash Awesome! (that counts for the 2025 season), 2nd at LMBM 2025, 1st at Kowloon 14, and now 1st at Genesis X2.
Hurt's had wins over Acola before, but never this dominant. The first set in particular had shades of Acola's sets with Sparg0 before he finally won one with Aegis last year. Dude looked completely lost about how to deal with Snake's walling, which goes to show just how masterful Hurt's play was this tournament. He only dropped 3 games, actually, so yeah, he was on one. While the LumiRank this year is supposed to be a full-year ranking, meaning there's a LOT of time left for other players to catch up, Hurt is almost certainly in the running for #1 right now.
I had a sneaking suspicion it was going to be released right after Genesis X2 lol (for reference, the previous list was dropped the day before Genesis X).
For reference about my upcoming data points, this was the previous list:
Here are the character movements from the previous list: +21
+17
+16
+15
---
+10
+9
+8
+7
+6
+5
+4
+3
+2
+1 0 -1
-2
-3
-4
-5
-6
-7
-8
-9
-10
---
-12
-14
-16
And now comparison among ranks. Rises: S -> S+ A+ -> S A+ -> S- A -> S- A -> A+ A- -> A+ B+ -> A+ A- -> A B+ -> A B- -> A B+ -> A- B- -> A- B- -> B+ C+ -> B- D+ -> B- C- -> C+ D+ -> C- D- -> C- E+ -> D
No Movement: S+ S S- A+ A A- B+ B- C+ C- D E
Drops: A -> A- B+ -> B- C+ -> C-
Notes:
This list is fairly top heavy (S and A tiers) similar to the first official tier list.
The D and E tiers no longer has a "+" and "-" in-between each letter category.
Donkey Kong has both the 4th largest rise in terms of spots (+15 spots) and the single largest rise in terms of tiers (D+ -> B-). He arguably got he single largest increase in terms of tiers in Ultimate's history between two tier lists.
The top 5 in terms of rising spots are: Luigi, Olimar, Hero, Donkey Kong, and Kirby
The top 5 in terms of dropping spots are: Marth, Sheik, and Pac-Man=Trainer=Sephiroth
The top 6 has exactly the same characters as the previous list, although the ordering is altered slightly.
Kazuya returned to his placement from the first official list (he directly swapped with Peach). He and Min Min are the only newcomers to the top 10, while Joker and Peach is moved to just outside of it (they do retain their S- tier ranking though).
Pit and Captain Falcon hilariously simply swapped spots with eachother, and are otherwise placed extremely similarly to the previous list.
With Luigi's meteoric rise, he has now overtaken Mario for the first time since the early SSB4 days.
With Falco's meteoric rise, Wolf is now the lowest ranked Star Fox character for the first time ever.
With Hero's meteoric rise, he has now overtaken Terry for the 2nd highest ranked FP1 character for the first time ever.
With Ryu's rise, he is now the 2nd highest ranked FGC character, overtaking Terry.
With Jigglypuff's enormous drop, it is now the lowest ranked Pokemon character for the first time ever (Lucario held the title in the 1st list; Mewtwo held the title in the 2nd list).
The biggest surprise for me in this list is Kazuya ascending back to the top 10 despite having a downturn of top level results in 2024 in comparison to the previous years. However, the article pointed this out, and now it makes sense.
Apparently there are some Japanese players who think that he is straight up the best character in the game for some reason.
There are a lot of things I find weird about this list but I'll just go over the biggest. 1st why is Minmin so high? What has she ever done? It's weird to see her above characters like Cloud, which brings me to 2, Cloud's underrate as sword characters tend to be. I realize Cloud only really has spargo but he should definitely be top tier. He's below characters like Yoshie ffs. 3 I disagree with Toon Link above Young Link. Neither have done much but I think YL has a lot of tools TL lacks but I already went over that in a previous post. 4 I think Krool and Ike are both criminally underate; I'd put them both 2 tiers higher but I'm sounding like a broken record at this point. Weight in general is an underrated character trait and therefor heavyweights are often slightly underrated. Is Bowser really 2 tiers worse than DK? I could nitpick a lot but that's the gist of it.
There are a lot of things I find weird about this list but I'll just go over the biggest. 1st why is Minmin so high? What has she ever done?
Doramigi and ProtoBanham have won several majors throughout Ultimate's history at this point with Min Min, and Doramigi became top 15 throughout the entire last year, top 8'ing events pretty consistently. Min Min also has a really good advantage state and edgeguarding that can take stocks off very easily.
Honestly if you don't think Min Min is top 15, I think you're out of the loop at this point.
The biggest surprise for me in this list is Kazuya ascending back to the top 10 despite having a downturn of top level results in 2024 in comparison to the previous years. However, the article pointed this out, and now it makes sense. View attachment 399219
Apparently there are some Japanese players who think that he is straight up the best character in the game for some reason.
Oh, that's interesting, especially since acola has a Kazuya himself but hasn't used him in nearly two years.
Something I realized after making my post is that while top level Kazuya stocks have went down, high level went up cause there are more Kazuya players popping up like Skeleton and Wildz. Tea has been using more Kazuya lately, and Raki has emerged as a top player, also using more Kazuya lately than his Steve. So yeah, while Kazuya is a less frequent top 8-at-a-major character, his rise is a little more understandable with that context, although prob still too high overall.
"Doramigi and ProtoBanham have won several majors throughout Ultimate's history at this point with Min Min, and Doramigi became top 15 throughout the entire last year, top 8'ing events pretty consistently. Min Min also has a really good advantage state and edgeguarding that can take stocks off very easily. "
To be fair, so have a lot of characters. Winning a major isn't that big a deal. Is Minmin good? Yes. Is she better than Fox, Cloud and Roy? No. Is minmin a whole tier better than Luigi and Bayo? No. The thing about top ten or top 15 is there are about 20-25 characters you could make a case for. It's easy to cherry pick one character's results but you could do the same with several characters.
Minmin is a very polarized character. She has THE best advantage state in the game but also a pretty bad disadvantage state. Her recovery is terrible and she lacks any burst options to escape from juggles or get back down to the stage.
Raru won 2 majors and a supermajor in 2024 with the character, and he and other Luigi players have been placing top 8 consistently in major events throughout the 2nd half of the year.
Character got the metagame glow up of a lifetime.
Doramigi was ranked 11th on the most recent LumiRank, and he won two majors with solo Min Min (Sumabato SP 54 and Sumabato SP 49). ProtoBanham has also gotten good results with Min Min in the past (though he also used Lucina). Omuatsu is also fairly notable, 118th LumiRank 2024 season 2 and 83rd 2024 season 1. There's also Justice who got 149th on the 2024 season 1 LumiRank. Dabuz also got some results with her as a secondary.
Isn't Min Min doing better in Japan than Roy is? And what is Cloud even doing in Japan? Other than Sparg0 the character doesn't seem to be doing too much, and Sparg0 doesn't even seem to believe the character is top 10.
Looking at the character placement percentages by EazyFreezie, Min Min ended up being #9, while Cloud was #17, Roy #13. This, of course, isn't everything (Sonic is #12 yet I imagine most people here would agree that he's at least 10 and probably #2 or #3). Oh, and Kazuya is #4 on this list.
I struggle to see Luigi as a top 15 character. Bayonetta might be a bit low though. To me the Diddy Kong placement seems more out of place than the Min Min one (top 15 would seem like a better fit than top 10 for Diddy, but I could be wrong). At the end of the day, I don't know how much exact placement really matters in this game, if you're a top 20 character you're going to be really strong regardless. If I see a character in A+ or higher winning a major I'd probably go "No surprises there".
Oh, and I think we should probably consider Japanese tournament more important in regards to viability than US tournaments. The gap in skill between the US and Japan seems to have widened. Don't get me wrong, there are still many strong US players (like Zomba, Light, Tweek, SHADIC etc) but I think Japan is quite a bit stronger at the moment.
It's entirely possible that Japan was always stronger and that there was quite a bit of NA bias. Might be quite likely, even. If a character is doing really well in a stronger region that might be saying more than if it's doing well in a relatively weaker region. Note that I'm not saying the US is a weak region by any means, it's likely the 2nd strongest region in the world still, but I believe the gap between the US and Japan is fairly significant these days. As such, it seems reasonable to me that we should weight strong results in Japan as more important than strong results in the US, Mexico, Europe, or Canada.
Doramigi was ranked 11th on the most recent LumiRank, and he won two majors with solo Min Min (Sumabato SP 54 and Sumabato SP 49). ProtoBanham has also gotten good results with Min Min in the past (though he also used Lucina). Omuatsu is also fairly notable, 118th LumiRank 2024 season 2 and 83rd 2024 season 1. There's also Justice who got 149th on the 2024 season 1 LumiRank. Dabuz also got some results with her as a secondary.
Isn't Min Min doing better in Japan than Roy is? And what is Cloud even doing in Japan? Other than Sparg0 the character doesn't seem to be doing too much, and Sparg0 doesn't even seem to believe the character is top 10.
Looking at the character placement percentages by EazyFreezie, Min Min ended up being #9, while Cloud was #17, Roy #13. This, of course, isn't everything (Sonic is #12 yet I imagine most people here would agree that he's at least 10 and probably #2 or #3). Oh, and Kazuya is #4 on this list.
I struggle to see Luigi as a top 15 character. Bayonetta might be a bit low though. To me the Diddy Kong placement seems more out of place than the Min Min one (top 15 would seem like a better fit than top 10 for Diddy, but I could be wrong). At the end of the day, I don't know how much exact placement really matters in this game, if you're a top 20 character you're going to be really strong regardless. If I see a character in A+ or higher winning a major I'd probably go "No surprises there".
Oh, and I think we should probably consider Japanese tournament more important in regards to viability than US tournaments. The gap in skill between the US and Japan seems to have widened. Don't get me wrong, there are still many strong US players (like Zomba, Light, Tweek, SHADIC etc) but I think Japan is quite a bit stronger at the moment.
It's entirely possible that Japan was always stronger and that there was quite a bit of NA bias. Might be quite likely, even. If a character is doing really well in a stronger region that might be saying more than if it's doing well in a relatively weaker region. Note that I'm not saying the US is a weak region by any means, it's likely the 2nd strongest region in the world still, but I believe the gap between the US and Japan is fairly significant these days. As such, it seems reasonable to me that we should weight strong results in Japan as more important than strong results in the US, Mexico, Europe, or Canada.
This kind of logic could also be said about Luigi, for example, who isn't top tier. He's just A+ tier and he's gotten a tidal wave of results lately. Like I said, there are about 20-25 characters deserving of top 15. Minmin's the one the tier list chose. It could easily have been Luigi up there in S- tier instead of Minmin and he'd have been just as deserving. The tiers are largely based on player perception.
This logic has to stop. I agree Japan is the single strongest country but not by much and it's not stronger than NA as a region. Japan is kind of like it's own region. The problem is everyone holds them on a pedestal but if you look at Lumirank, there's Spargo, a NA player, in #1. There's 10 NA players in top 20 and 9 Japanese players (and Glutonny). Japan just happened to dominate the most recent supermajor. Seriously, people need to stop acting like Japanese players are inherently better than NA players and take it on a case to case basis.
There was even a Shortcat Mario Kart 8 video where he claims Japanese MK players are better but a 20,000vr player from any region is as good as a 20,000 vr player from any other region.
Yes, I get the impression that many people voting are going by what feels correct to them rather than trying to systematically look at various results etc for each characters (which would be time intensive and wouldn't necessarily result in a better tier list anyways).
I think it's fairly clear that there's a noticeable gap between Japan and the US, and a noticeable gap between the US and Europe. The US was long considered the #1 region in Smash games (seems to still be the #1 region in Melee), but it is no longer the case in Ultimate. Europe, with France in particular, is catching up a bit to the US but I would still say there's a noticeable gap between the US and Europe. The gap between the US and Europe has long been acknowledge, and we should also acknowledge that there's a noticeable gap between Japan and the US. Currently, 54 of the top 100 are Japanese (55 if you count Neo, although he's currently living in Indonesia). US? 24. Mexico? 6. Canada? 3 (Riddles, Ouch, and Anarchy). Europe 9 (France 3, Germany 2, Spain 2, the Netherlands 1, the UK 1). And then one from the Dominican Republic (Sonix) and two from Guatemala (ShinyMark and Haunter). Even if you want to lump NA together as one region (which I find questionable*) it seems that it's plausible that Japan is stronger than NA (going by LumiRank, 55 Japanese players vs 36 NA). I don't think we should disregard what is happening in the US, Mexico, Canada, France etc, but Japan is currently the #1 region by quite some margin and it makes sense that our main attention should be on what's happening in Japan (although it's understandable that many people prefer watching tournaments with commentary in English and not all Japanese tournaments have English commentary, so I understand why so many prefer watching US majors over Japanese majors).
*I suppose one could argue that lumping Europe together as a region would also be questionable, and perhaps it is. Even then I'd wager that there's more overlap between the German scene and the French scene than the Mexican scene and the Canadian scene, largely for geographical reasons (Paris to Berlin is closer than Austin to Mexico City, and I imagine the train infrastructure is probably better too.) If Europe isn't lumped together as a region then I suppose France is the most notable region in Europe.[/QUOTE]
As a tier list this is pretty reflective of where Ultimate's meta is right now; i.e mostly Japan dominant. And very few mains at a top level are as consistent as Doramigi has been with Min Min. I don't think people appreciate enough that Doramigi at worst has basically been Japan's Sonix; someone who consistently places high up in top 8s across every recent major he's been in, and unlike ProtoBanham he's doing it as a solo main. He's also not the only Min Min who's doing well in Japan, with players like Omuatsu drawing up a crop of also impressive consistent results. Ironically her meta is in a better place now after ProtoBanham's retirement, and that doesn't apply equally to a lot of other characters who's results were carried by one person that can no longer carry them such as Incineroar and Sora (though as far as the latter is concerned his results have at least become far less centralized across multiple high level players). From a certain point of view she might have the most accurate placement on here since it reflects on her Placement Percentage for 2024, which increased by one spot over its second half. The numbers don't lie; the perception of Min Min has only gone up.
Tier lists are all about optics, and the optics for characters like Fox, Cloud, and Roy feel particularly western; an inarguably weaker region at this point in the meta. With Fox, frankly his placement over or under is a distinction without a difference because even if we ignore Paseriman having completely fallen off and Kaninabe posting results that are great but not at that same level of peak we saw in 2023, it's only a one position difference which suggests any one person who voted for this tier list could've split the difference. There's nothing to scrutinize over his placement given how close their weighted average is. Cloud on the other hand? Only really being played by Sparg0 in a quasi-main capacity. Roy? Outside of Kola who's a bit too woefully inconsistent, what is he doing out here that's meaningfully different from characters above him? Both these characters have just as many flaws under the scope such as fragile off-stage endurance.
Luigi probably should be higher but I don't think everyone is bold enough to assert yet that he's kind of just better Kazuya due to how sudden his rise has been. Same goes for Falco who's just an off-stage hawk now and maybe the character people should be the most wary about.
Doramigi's current season is 2nd at a major, 1st at a major, and 2nd at two supermajors. The season has recently started but he seems like a strong contender for top 5 right now, and easily top 10 at least (for the time being).
Also, Hurt is probably #1 in the world right now, yeah? Smash Awesome! and GENESIS X2 wins and 2nd at Luminosity Makes BIG Moves 2025 should put him in a really strong position.
Japan being better gamers than the west is an urban legend that has been circulating through many gaming communities and it needs to stop. The reason I consider NA a region is that's how tournament travel and wifi works. Japan is very isolated from the rest of the competitive world because it's considerably harder to go there or vice versa. There really isn't a smash scene in other eastern countries like China. Japan definitely won Genesis but if you look at tournaments in a long term scope it goes back and forth. The best Western Players Spargo, Sonix and Light could beat the best Japanese players on a good day and vice versa. The whole "Japan is better" thing has become a self fulfilling prophecy. People think Japanese players are better so they rank them higher. I will say it does help that Japan is less spread out in terms of population so it's easier for them to throw together tournaments with greater attendance.
The problem is that most of either community doesn't get a lot of interaction, the West and the East.
It varies from game to game. You wouldn't disagree that NA is a stronger region than Europe when it comes to Smash, would you? But I don't think NA is the #1 region in Ultimate, at least not anymore (and it possible that Japan was always #1). In Melee, it is clear that the US is #1.
While it is true that the best NA players can beat the best Japanese players, it's also true that the best European players (such as Glutonny and Luugi) can beat the best NA and Japanese players on a good day. That doesn't mean that Europe is equally strong as NA or Japan when it comes to Smash, does it? I think most would agree that Europe is not as strong as the US and Japan when it comes to Smash, and I think we should also admit that Japan is noticeably stronger than the US at the moment. Japan would likely be stronger than NA as a whole too.
If you took the 50 best players from NA and the 50 best players from Japan and had them compete in a tournament I bet the Japanese players would do noticeably better. The same would likely happen if you took the 200 best from each region. If you took the 5 best from NA and Japan it'd likely be close, though. And if you took the 50 best from Europe most of them would not do too well.
Lumirank top 100 having 55 Japanese players vs 36 for NA is saying something. One could certainly argue that Lumirank's methodology is a bit unfair (and to some extent we're not getting around the fact that it's easier to host majors in Japan than in Europe or NA) but overall based on seeing how these players play and comparing them to equally ranked NA players it doesn't strike me as particularly unfair.
Why is Japan doing so well? I think one of the main reasons is the geographical advantage. Japan is smaller than California while having a (presumably) significantly larger player base. Infrastructure is good and attending locals and bigger tournaments tends to be significantly easier and cheaper (I imagine California would be a really strong region if they had as many majors and top players attending local tournaments as Japan does). From what I've heard, top level and high level players are more likely to go to locals and play with a variety of differently skilled players, while in the US top players are, from what I've heard, often less likely to play with non-top/high level players unless it's a money match. This helps make the Japanese scenes stronger. Furthermore, the online environment is apparently significantly better in Japan, which means getting quality practice is noticeably easier in Japan compared to almost every other region.
I think it's also important to not consider a handful of players evidence for how strong a country overall is. Sweden in Melee might be one of the best examples of this. Sweden had Armada and Leffen, two of the greatest Melee players of all time, yet Sweden overall was considered not a particularly strong country for Melee.
Something that hasn't been mentioned much but I get the feeling that Japanese players are pushing the meta forward more than NA and European players these days. Falco has been pushed quite a bit recently, Luigi as well (though Europe and NA have some strong Luigi players as well), Min Min is largely pushed by Japan, and even Snake is getting his meta pushed to the limit by Hurt (although Snake was always a fairly significant meta threat). Oh, and Japan is pushing Steve more than any other region (though Steve is also relevant in NA and Europe, of course). Japan has acola as #3, Raki #34, 33peranBOX #49, Yamanaction #63, Carmelo #65, 5 Steve mains in top 100 (also Miya and Rarikkusu have notable Steve secondaries). NA has Syrup #14, Onin #22, HaunterGV #62, Just Blue #83, 4 (also respectable).
If we were to grade them, I'd probably do something like: Japan S tier, the US A tier, Mexico/Canada/Europe B tier (individually France might be B tier though weaker than Mexico still, maybe B-).