Cartoon Cartoons: OVAH

[Clownbot]

I'm so confused

OS can I pick anyone or do I have to go with Dancer here? -_-

 

[Overswarm]

hmm. . . Funny how clownbot decides to give in once a single third party comes in to play and shows support for OS. *shrugs*

Clown I think at this point you get to pick someone for OS to do a PBP on.

Psh, no he doesn't. I've gotta talk about the_Guide and quick lynching. Pay attention, sworddancer!

 

[Overswarm]

OS can I pick anyone or do I have to go with Dancer here? -_-

Dancer!

You picked me like a bum, and while you can do a post like that on me, that's not the deal! Do it on your own time!

I'd like to learn more about sworddancer, and this way I can learn more about both of you simultaneously.

 

[Overswarm]

I'm out for the Night and am working MLG this weekend btw, so you won't hear much from me. Just FYI.

 

[Overswarm]

er... out for the night*. Force of habit capitalizing in mafia games, haha XD

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Hmph, sorry OS, I just kinda assumed that you would do that since you did in Code Geass.

Also is that last post a possible slip OS?

@Clown: I'm willing to bet that you would, at the very least, continued your back and forth with OS had someone else not come along and showed support for him.

 

[Greenstreet]

Sometimes the best town is the town that stays out of the way. Especially Day 1. But I accept your criticism.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Oh? Why would that be Greenstreet?

 

[Greenstreet]

Be more specific. Why would the best town be the town that stays out of the way? Or why do I accept your criticism?

 

[Clownbot]

An Analysis on PSILythdancer

...Splitting each third of the player slot into separate parts.

RocketPSIence​

Votes... or rather, Vote:

SSBF (RVS vote)

Thought this was kind of weird, but of course, he did leave pretty early on.

Other Notable Interactions:

Guide: One thing that struck me as most interesting looking over his posts is that he associates with Guide a lot but never expounds on what he thinks of him or places a vote on him. E.g.

The_Guide, this game IS hunches.

You'll never get anywhere if that's how you play.

Don't cockblock me Guide.

His attitude about Guide is generally negative, but I can't quite place whether or not he actually found Guide scummy, and if he did it's rather... Odd that he wouldn't place a Vote or at least FoS.

DZLE: He once referred to DZLE as being passive and jokingly told him to grow a pair. I guess the meta is sort of interesting but there's nothing too noteworthy here.

OS: He once told you not to **** with most of the players in the game too hard because they were less experienced and came from the DR. I'm not really sure what to make of this, probably just more messing around.

SSBF: This is one post he made about SSBF which may have been the reason he never unvoted

So you made an entirely blind assumption that wanting to start a different conversation outside of RVS is bad?

...But he replaced so quickly and never really got to elaborate on his thoughts with this.

Other Notable Posts:

The only other post that might be considered halfway notable is his claim to have never been Mafia before. Struck me as sort of odd because I've played several games with him and I bet he's had more in the DR.

Lythium​

Votes... Or rather, Vote ( again? ;_; ):

Exn

Her ideas about Exn's play were pretty much parroting. In the post after her explanation on why she found him scummy she noted that she was ninja'd and now it looked like she was just parroting Vrael, but even if you remove his post from the equation people had pretty much said everything she noted.

Other Notable Interactions:

Exn: At first all she placed was an FoS despite allegedly not liking his play. She places a vote later but not too much had been unveiled (she said "your play sucks" which looks like what she thought before). Considering Exn is gone now and flipped Town I don't really see why scum would do this unless to create connections that don't really exist... You know, throw Town off the trail and all that?

Vanderzant: In her first post of substance she says she doesn't care for his actions regarding Ermac (he had called for more votes on Ermac earlier). Basically I disagree with her thoughts on the subject. She acted almost as if Town couldn't handle their votes well when applying pressure. I'm also not sure if she found this scummy or... What. (seems that way a lot with this player slot... sigh.)

Later on in her 278 she makes another point on him which leads me to believe she found him scummy (although never pursued his lynch). She points out some kind of contradiction which tbh I really don't see.

Nday: Asks Nday once who he finds scummy and why.

Ermac: Comments on his PBPs by saying they're "lovely" but they're not helping Town (don't quite get that one). Then she asks who he finds scummiest atm

OS: She thought you were kind of suspicious for the same reasons as me. She didn't like how you were acting sort of secretive and not explaining your actions.

Other Notable Posts:

Her next to last post in the game is pretty much a rant on why she's been inactive. She sort of says a lot without saying much, if you know what I mean.

Sworddancer​

Votes:

DZLE
Guide

Without really catching up or anything he jumps right in with his first post of substance and votes DZLE. I guess his suspicion is legitimate enough but it was kind of weird that he didn't say anything about previous events that had transpired.

His vote on Guide was because of a "crummy response" on Guide's part but considering there wasn't really a case to argue against I question the merit of his vote.

Other Notable Interactions:

Greenstreet: He says he's one of his top suspects. His reasoning is fair enough, I guess.

OS: He supports the guy. Why? I don't know. He just does. With what? Couldn't tell you.

SSBF: he has something to tell him =o

Myself: I don't know, I guess he finds me suspicious... Although his suspicion is based on an assumption... But whatever...

Other Notable Posts:

Dancer was asked who his top 3 suspects were and while he did reply to that request he only gave two.

In Conclusion...​

I have what you'd call a null read on Dancer at this point. A lot of the player slot's suspicions have been sort of vague and I pointed out what I found odd. Overall I guess I'd place these guys somewhat high on my suspect list but there are bigger fish to fry at the moment.

 

[Deleted member]

@Sworddancer: What is it? Is there any reason for hiding it until later?

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

The former GreenStreet.

SSBF, I just want your attention, and your attention only. I don't want to post something and have others interfere. So, are you here? As in, are you listening right now?

 

[Deleted member]

@Sworddancer: Yes, please do tell.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

Okay. . .

I think you're extremely scummy, and should be toDay's lynch. Your actions in this game speak for themselves. There all with scum intent.

Unvote Vote SSBF

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Sold2 replaces Dark Ermac effective immediately.

 

[Greenstreet]

The nail that stands out get hammered.
If you run around making accusation left/right and centre:

• People will waste a lot of time trying to reason your actions
• People will lynch you because they think you are trying to get the attention off yourself
• People will suspect you to be scum - which leads to wasted tracking and a wasted vig kill

Succinctness, as I've previously stated with regard to ermacs PBP is pro-town. You can achieve a lot in a few words.

But I do accept your point, and it is Day 2 now.

 

[DtJ S2n]

Be back sometime guys I'm going on an adventure for approximately 35 pages.

 

[DtJ Jungle]

Riddle replaces DZLE-Falz

Thanks Riddle!

 

[Greenstreet]

My suspicions lie on Nday and the_guide

There are a few points to note:

• After dark_ermacs PBP on Nday, the_guides vote switches straight to ermac - while dark_ermacs post doesn't state Nday is scum, it indicated he would be an acceptable lynching target for the day. I found it odd that despite dark_ermac contributing by pointing out a good target, he got the vote on him as a result.

• This seems particularly strange considering later on the_guide states that dark_ermacs posts are more useful than inactivity

• Nday requesting everyone to tell him how many games they've played - while this isn't large, I generally get suspicious that scum are trying to find their first nightkill.

• Despite both seeing dark_ermac as the logical lynch, or at least confident that he should be lynched over Exn, here and here, neither of them make any effort to stop a bandwagon on a player who puts more coherent thoughts into his posts. I put this down to the previous vote and suspicion Exn had on Nday. Or to avoid being a vote hopper.

I'm hesitant in posting this, as the_guide has placed his vote on me twice now, so the intent behind my suspicions will seem questionable. To combat this, I'm only going FoS Nday. (But it's pretty clear I don't like either of them)

FoS: Nday

Feel free to respond/critique/vote me in response to this post. This post is not exhaustive.

 

[Riddle]

I shall read it tonight/tomorrow and post thoughts tomorrow probably.

 

[Deleted member]

Okay. . .

I think you're extremely scummy, and should be toDay's lynch. Your actions in this game speak for themselves. There all with scum intent.

Unvote Vote SSBF

I honestly cannot see how I am a more worthy lynch candidate Day 2 then DZLE-Falz/Riddle and Dark Ermac/Sold2. Both player slots have played scummily in some way or form. Of course I'm willing to give Sold2 and Riddle to chance to redeem the slot, but that doesn't mean I excuse there predeccessor's actions.

Also, how has my game play been entirely been with scum intentions?

 

[Riddle]

I find it interesting that you are willing to give us a chance to redeem ourselves. We have the same role as our predecessors and us playing less scummily just indicates better play not a different allignment. Of course this also is reversible. My predecessors play was simply bad, not indicative of his allignment.

Anyway my top 2 targets.

Ermac/sold2 - his pbp analyses were scummy. inexperienced Scum in my experience tend to make huge posts that make them look like contributors but really just restate what has already been said. This is exactly what I saw in ermacs posts. I agree with greensteets post stating that succint posts are pro-town.

OS - not so much scummy as anti-town. His deal with it attitude and the way people are blatantly buddying him make it hard to get reads on anyone associated with him as well as him. OS I want to see more reasoning from you and everyone who is buddying him needs to stop right now. I'm honestly surprised you guys have let OS get away with this ****.

There are 2 people specifically that I'm getting town reads from but I won't disclose their identities without a good reason.

 

[Riddle]

In addition to what i already said about ermac I'd like to note that he essentially catalyzed the lynch of a townie.

 

[Deleted member]

I find it interesting that you are willing to give us a chance to redeem ourselves. We have the same role as our predecessors and us playing less scummily just indicates better play not a different allignment. Of course this also is reversible. My predecessors play was simply bad, not indicative of his allignment.

That is true that your alignment does not change regardless of how well you do. Of course your predeccessors choices will influence you throughout the entire game, hence why my vote is still on you. However, while I don't change my vote immediately just because a person got replaced, that doesn't mean it's sticked in stone with the replacement as well. If you actually do well in this game, I will unvote you.

 

[Dark_Ermac]

I'm back, and rereading.

 

[Greenstreet]

Sold2 replaces Dark Ermac effective immediately.

lolw ut?

 

[Riddle]

Fair enough.

And I totally forgot unvote, vote: sold2[/bold]

 

[Clownbot]

You've kind of been replaced, dude.

 

[Dark_Ermac]

... ****.

It's only been 24 hours, too. I hate when I forget about it due to Night Phase.

Eh, next game...

 

[Riddle]

Bbcode fail. unvote, vote: sold2

And I just replaced in. L2read

 

[Riddle]

Bbcode fail. unvote, vote: sold2

 

[Dark_Ermac]

/in as a replacement for sold2 in case he forgets about the game

 

[Clownbot]

Riddle, if that was directed at me I was talking to Ermac.

 

[Riddle]

Ugh double post. And I totally didn't see the ermaf stuff. That thing to you was quickedited out of one post but not thw other once I realized.

 

[ndayday]

My suspicions lie on Nday and the_guide

There are a few points to note:

• After dark_ermacs PBP on Nday, the_guides vote switches straight to ermac - while dark_ermacs post doesn't state Nday is scum, it indicated he would be an acceptable lynching target for the day. I found it odd that despite dark_ermac contributing by pointing out a good target, he got the vote on him as a result.

• This seems particularly strange considering later on the_guide states that dark_ermacs posts are more useful than inactivity

• Nday requesting everyone to tell him how many games they've played - while this isn't large, I generally get suspicious that scum are trying to find their first nightkill.

• Despite both seeing dark_ermac as the logical lynch, or at least confident that he should be lynched over Exn, here and here, neither of them make any effort to stop a bandwagon on a player who puts more coherent thoughts into his posts. I put this down to the previous vote and suspicion Exn had on Nday. Or to avoid being a vote hopper.

I'm hesitant in posting this, as the_guide has placed his vote on me twice now, so the intent behind my suspicions will seem questionable. To combat this, I'm only going FoS Nday. (But it's pretty clear I don't like either of them)

FoS: Nday

Feel free to respond/critique/vote me in response to this post. This post is not exhaustive.

1; At the games you've played question. I don't see how that even works as far as finding night kills go. I intended it to show who the less experienced were, because in past games I held the reasoning that newbies make mistakes much easier, and ___ is IMO townie that's getting too much attention and tripping up. Basically, I find players starting out to be extremely easy to figure out, and as town I want to take any shortcut I can to finding scum or town, so I know who to protect/put pressure for a lynch on. I don't know if this makes sense.

2; I was away from my house for the weekend that you guys hammered on Exn, I was not able to defend him.

--

Stuff I'm working on:

votes on Vrael; SSBF, OS
votes on Exn; Greenstreet, Clownbot (fos)DZLE, DZLE, Vrael, SSBF, Ermac, vanderzant, OS
*votes on these two players through the course of D1

I think it would have been extremely easy for scum to jump on the Exn vote yesterday. I think Vrael's death was either random shot in the dark on mafia's part, or the randomly investigated Vrael and he seemed good to kill that night.

I don't want to reveal my suspicions just yet, I'm waiting for reactions on posts the rest of you guys made.

 

[Greenstreet]

You were there by the time the wagon had formed and Overswarm was given the hammer though.

 

[Overswarm]

I don't want to reveal my suspicions just yet, I'm waiting for reactions on posts the rest of you guys made.

Post them.


(I'll get to your stuff tomorrow clown, just was reading to catch up and figured I should point out NDay trying to pull an Overswarm)

 

[ndayday]

Post them.


(I'll get to your stuff tomorrow clown, just was reading to catch up and figured I should point out NDay trying to pull an Overswarm)

I haven't looked at those who did vote for Exn, but I am auto-suspicious of The Guide for not voting him. I haven't looked back on him though, so I have no idea what the circumstances were etc. Just hold on there buddy.

You were there by the time the wagon had formed and Overswarm was given the hammer though.

I was leaving that morning, no time to post anything beyond "Hey guys I'm going to be gone." I can see where this seems weird.

 

[Greenstreet]

People were jumping on the wagon by this point. You were active during and a couple hours after this time in other threads.

 

[#HBC | Dancer]

I honestly cannot see how I am a more worthy lynch candidate Day 2 then DZLE-Falz/Riddle and Dark Ermac/Sold2. Both player slots have played scummily in some way or form. Of course I'm willing to give Sold2 and Riddle to chance to redeem the slot, but that doesn't mean I excuse there predeccessor's actions.

Also, how has my game play been entirely been with scum intentions?

Do I really even have to tell you? You know as well as I do that you're scum. There is no point of hiding it, really. You should just give up and admit that you're scum at this point.