Bingo Mafia: OVAH! Who won?

[smargaret]

Aposl, do you still think lynching the weakest player is the best option? If so, who is that?

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

Aposl answer my question please.

 

[Aposl]

Smar substantiate the point about Aposl in your #150

this! I was going to say the same.

 

[Seikend]

Seik - bad reasoning. Very bad. Scum X1 could just as easily see that my username has some female indications and expect you to pick up on them, and then use that to put associative tells between us.

Aah, I see. Didn't think it through.

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

Don't you get it?


Aposl answer my question please post #148. Its before what you just responded to so you must have read it

 

[Aposl]

I am leaning toward Seik because his answer was weak, he seems bad at the game, and I have stated thats what my reasoning will probably for this round, however he could be town or scum, so I would ask him to please make a decent attempt to defend himself.

 

[smargaret]

Hi aposl, please respond to questions? I already did that in my 159.

Buddying between Aposl and GLG. Add in wagon on Seik = distracting from Aposl, possibly scum here.

GLG, which head is posting?

Unvote: Seik
Vote: Aposl

 

[Seikend]

I am leaning toward Seik because his answer was weak, he seems bad at the game, and I have stated thats what my reasoning will probably for this round, however he could be town or scum, so I would ask him to please make a decent attempt to defend himself.

:/.

The case against me:

http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12447941&postcount=124

My response:

http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12447997&postcount=132


I have nothing left to respond to. Please point out why my defence is weak.

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

@Smar: Why does it matter which head is posting? If you give a valid reason then I will answer, and no, before you mention it I can't lie because half of this game can tell just by reading it.

to clarify I'm saying I can't change my answer based on your reasoning, because basically the whole game can tell which head is which and will call me out if I lie

 

[smargaret]

There are tactics that I see GLGscum preferring over those preferred by X1scum. If you're Head A and doing something I'd be more likely to see Head B doing, it's less of a tell than if you were Head B.

 

[Kataefi]

VOTE COUNT!

[4] Seikend - Sqweedle / GandhiLaserGun / BSL / JTB
[1] Aposl - Smargaret

[0] Pink Lemonade
[0] GandhiLaserGun
[0] BSL
[0] Asdioh
[0] KevinM
[0] Toasting Dat Walrus
[0] Smargaret
[0] JTB
[0] Sqweedle
[0] Glyphmoney
[0] J

[8] Not Voting: Pink Lemonade / Asdioh / KevinM / Toasting Dat Walrus / Seikend / J / Aposl / Glyphmoney

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

Smar explain what meta you have on each head of this hydra

 

[Aposl]

@ Seik, its the repetition of your defense that makes you look weak IMO. You finally stuck to your guns after defending yourself from approx. 4 attacks. These players aren't stupid, if someone points you out with weak logic, or incomplete evidence, just point it out and go about your day. Instead you re-answer over and over again, sometimes within the same post. Maybe you should re-read your posts, make sure they sound good then post them.

Also I dont count the fact that I asked you to defend yourself again, I wanted a hearty end all defense. What you did proved to me that you can defend yourself, but you still haven't made me feel that your a good player... yet. Theres still time though, I wont be quick to vote anyone without proof they are mafia. The skill level approach is a lesser of two evils thing. Of course I will vote Mafia if we can prove it.

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

@Anyone who knows what being opportunistic is. Is the second line of Smar's #167 opportunistic?


@Pink Lemonade: Is this a good idea?

If Ranmaru thinks of something, he posts it in a QT made for the Hydra, from then July can look at it and if its easily answered, not worth asking or completely stupid, then July does not post it. July posts in the thread and Ran posts in the QT, this will effectively filter the crap that sometimes comes from Ranmaru, but means that his scumhunting will still get through, in a more refined, understandable and concise form.

 

[KevinM]

Vote Seikend

KevinM on a town streak, people going to want to lynch me all game again? Doubt it bros.

He's at L-2 or 3 whatever.

Hey if we're going by Aposl logic people down to just lynch Aposl.

Vig I want you to shoot the scummiest person that isn't lynched on D1 if you're here.

Directing night actions deal with it.

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

Kevin, I actually bother to spoonfeed idiots so if you're town you'll be good.


this probably constitutes buddying

 

[Seikend]

@ Seik, its the repetition of your defense that makes you look weak IMO. You finally stuck to your guns after defending yourself from approx. 4 attacks. These players aren't stupid, if someone points you out with weak logic, or incomplete evidence, just point it out and go about your day. Instead you re-answer over and over again, sometimes within the same post. Maybe you should re-read your posts, make sure they sound good then post them.

Alright.

Also I dont count the fact that I asked you to defend yourself again, I wanted a hearty end all defense. What you did proved to me that you can defend yourself, but you still haven't made me feel that your a good player... yet. Theres still time though, I wont be quick to vote anyone without proof they are mafia. The skill level approach is a lesser of two evils thing. Of course I will vote Mafia if we can prove it.

TL;DR

The case against me implies that I'm fluffing content. I've shown in:

http://www.smashboards.com/showpost.php?p=12447997&postcount=132

That this was not fluff, but an individual look at both posts made by Smarg, and a summary. Neither am I trying to to hide a lack of stance, as I explicitly state "There's not been anything significant enough to say that smar is scum yet.". I know there's a lack of stance.

But to expect a stance from those two posts is ridiculous.

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

Smar where you at with the answer to #172. I don't need an essay

 

[smargaret]

I've played at least one game with each head and I'd like to think I have a sense of your personalities/playstyles. I know they can very town/scum, but there are things like experience levels that don't change.

I was at the door, getting a package delivered, GLG.

Speaking of answering questions, though, Aposl is still dodging them.

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

If you genuinely had a sense of our personalities/playstyles you really wouldn't need to ask me which head is posting.

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

Unvote
Vote: Smargaret

massive deflecting etc etc

 

[Toastin Dat Walrus]

Skimmed this thread up, i HATE when games start in the confirmation thread... it means I gotta care about confirmation stuffs .

Oh my gawd Ghandi not letting Ran post would make my life.

Not liking Seikend, or Smargz, and kinda not Apsol, but I gotta talk to Kuz about Apsolscummy... I hate reading new players... so don't quote me on that yet.

@Smar if you're gonna read Ghandi... read em for Ghandi, not X1/GLG. And don't go off with a inability-to-read-hydra story cuz it's straight bulls***.

@KevMo trust me, if we're lynching off of dumb, we're going with the slot that has Joey and... oh god... RANMARU... Or Sqweedlemario.

 

[Sqweedle]

i forgot to tie my shoes and i slipped on a rock and broke my face i so dum

 

[smargaret]

GLG, whether you agree or not, there is information to be gathered from that question.

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

I refuse to tell Smar which head of the hydra is posting. For those who know I request you don't let on. Metaing me or the other half is a bad idea.

GBoy if you're wrong about Smar's alignment I'm calling you scum, problemo?

 

[smargaret]

I'm pretty sure this is X1 posting. There were more layers to that question than knowing which head is which.

 

[Toastin Dat Walrus]

Yes lol look at Rusty Guillotine. I was so wrong it hurt. But good thing I'm not wrong right?

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

V/La until Saturday/Sunday. This game only. My other head will carry us. Usual story, don't lynch anyone till I'm back etc etc.

I'm pretty sure this is X1 posting. There were more layers to that question than knowing which head is which.

Oh-emm-gee... Let me guess, you were thinking you played against scum Head A, so Head A might be afraid because you know his scum meta. Your play is so deep its unbelievable.

*applause*

Either that or you are trying desparately to salvage a very weak question about heads of a hydra which you should already know the answer to...

 

[GandhiLaserGun]

I want smar to lead town for a day or two.

 

[smargaret]

... if you think I'm scum, why on earth do you want me leading town? And if I should be leading town, why aren't you voting Aposl?

I'm not Cello.

 

[smargaret]

And actually, I don't know that I've played against either of you as scum.

 

[Sqweedle]

i was about to say something obvious but i forgot that there are hypocrites among us.

 

[#HBC | J]

Jeebus I get home from anime club all happy to see the game is up and running finally and find about 3 new pages.

I'll post when I am not busy tonight =o

 

[KevinM]

I want smar to lead town for a day or two.

No thanks feel like winning

 

[Sqweedle]

D1 seems so slow.

 

[BSL]

And actually, I don't know that I've played against either of you as scum.

Everyone look at this point. Then look at #170. Then look at this one again.

 

[smargaret]

You can meta someone without having played against them. Just sayin'.

 

[Sqweedle]

that. ^
10 that.

 

[BSL]

But X1 said to explain your meta and you said it was from games you played with them.

 

[smargaret]

I never said that was true to the exclusion of all other sources of meta.

It's interesting that X1 has completely dropped the Seik thing and Aposl still hasn't answered any of the questions directed at him.