• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Bingo Mafia: OVAH! Who won?

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
Reference to DnD mafia. Hence directed at Kuz. You, of all people, should have gotten that.

Now, however, Aposl's done something legitimately scummy in proposing a policy lynch without even having a target. I don't know how you play IRL mafia, but when I do it, it's a lot more joking in the sense of AIMafia and nobody would even think of policy lynching. I'm getting hints of lies about experience (would someone know enough about forum mafia in their first game to know what a policy lynch looks like? doesn't sound right with earlier questions about RVS) and frankly, PLing is anti-town in general. Since the suggestion was apparently in earnest, I'm now officially suspicious of Aposl.
Reaaaaally don't think he was lying about his experience, all of his posts have come across as honest to me. Seems to me like you're looking too far into this as a scum tell.

x1, take a good look at my name:

sMARGARET. Margaret is a fairly common female name, no?

Aposl is either very noob or very scum. Possibly both. X1 has a good point about Seik/fluffposting, even though his little "test" is flawed. And early game wagons are fun.

Vote: Seikend
Hang on, so you tell X1 off for using a flawed test, and then go on to jump on the wagon that it was designed to propel? Yes he was fluff posting, but I don't think that makes him scum, especially this early into the game.

"Fun" is a pretty horrible justification, but I'll chalk that one up as a joke. Regardless I feel like your wagon could use some more steam.

vote: Smar



J's #28 still feels hella off to me. Same with GLG's #15.
Iunno I guess I don't like when people come in and announce they're town. Btw GLG is probably scum since the person who looks most town seems to always be scum.

JTB and Sqweedle should post more information in a post/better, respectively.

Asdioh and Pink Lemonade should just post at all (though I've been just as inactive, so I don't really hold that against them. Day's just starting).

I want Smar or J lynched today. Seikend would be alright but I definitely prefer those two. I don't want an Aposl lynch.
 

smargaret

Smash Rookie
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
0
Pressure, Glyph. I liked how Seik responded to it, and I jumped off the wagon. And if GLG is probably scum, why do you want to lynch me or J?
 

#HBC | J

Prince of DGamesia
Joined
Feb 14, 2010
Messages
7,591
Location
Colorado
Glyph why do you want me lynched if I haven't said anything officially?

*posting while munching on popcorn* =3
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
Pressure, Glyph. I liked how Seik responded to it, and I jumped off the wagon. And if GLG is probably scum, why do you want to lynch me or J?
Because "you're too town" is a horrible reason to lynch someone. I'm not supporting his lynch in the slightest, I just know he can make himself look town regardless of alignment.

Glyph why do you want me lynched if I haven't said anything officially?

*posting while munching on popcorn* =3
Because your early game was just that off putting to me.
 

JTB

Live for the applause
Premium
Joined
Nov 13, 2006
Messages
6,512
JTB and Sqweedle should post more information in a post/better, respectively.


I'm also terrible at d1 scumhunting, but I'm trying to improve that

soupamario is obv scum because he hasn't tried some ridiculous gambit yet

not really, but i do have my eye on him
 

smargaret

Smash Rookie
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
0
Glyph, I don't get it. "You're too town" is a horrible reason to lynch someone, but justification for saying they're probably scum? Isn't lynching what's supposed to happen to scum?
 

JTB

Live for the applause
Premium
Joined
Nov 13, 2006
Messages
6,512
Seikend also looking scummy, but might just be because he is new.

/shrug
 

#HBC | J

Prince of DGamesia
Joined
Feb 14, 2010
Messages
7,591
Location
Colorado
Reaaaaally don't think he was lying about his experience, all of his posts have come across as honest to me. Seems to me like you're looking too far into this as a scum tell.

Hang on, so you tell X1 off for using a flawed test, and then go on to jump on the wagon that it was designed to propel? Yes he was fluff posting, but I don't think that makes him scum, especially this early into the game.

"Fun" is a pretty horrible justification, but I'll chalk that one up as a joke. Regardless I feel like your wagon could use some more steam.

vote: Smar

J's #28 still feels hella off to me. Same with GLG's #15.
Iunno I guess I don't like when people come in and announce they're town. Btw GLG is probably scum since the person who looks most town seems to always be scum.

JTB and Sqweedle should post more information in a post/better, respectively.

Asdioh and Pink Lemonade should just post at all (though I've been just as inactive, so I don't really hold that against them. Day's just starting).

I want Smar or J lynched today. Seikend would be alright but I definitely prefer those two. I don't want an Aposl lynch.
Bolded parts are a bit hypocritical =o

Your reason for voting smarg is a weak tag-along though it seems that's what everyone is doing thus far.

You call J/GLG for weak posts and you call GLG scum because he looks the most town even though the game just started.

You cal JTB/Sqweedle out for posting more info when they have been posting frequently, question, why did you not call out KevinM?

Asdioh/Pink Lemonade haven't posted yes, but neither have you till just now. Why call them out now? You even say that you shouldn't be holding it against them but still point it out. Seems odd.

Then you take an adamant stance by saying you want Smarg/J lynched ToDay and then hop onto Seikend who has been the current wagon along with Smarg at the current time. You also make a point to say you don't want an Aposl lynch but leave out the whys and defend him just to defend him it seems.

Imma do this till I read more but not liking Glyph atm.

Vote: Glyph

That's just from seeing what I have seen thus far. ^^
 

BSL

B-B-B-BLAMM!!!
Joined
Feb 28, 2010
Messages
6,453
Location
Baton Rouge
NNID
bsl883
3DS FC
3308-4560-2744
Iunno I guess I don't like when people come in and announce they're town.
What about KevM?

Smar, why didn you just give all of the reasons? The reason you gave is now completely irrelevant, based on what you have said after.
 

smargaret

Smash Rookie
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
0
Because I didn't see it necessary to spoonfeed you what "general sense of playstyle" meant.
 

BSL

B-B-B-BLAMM!!!
Joined
Feb 28, 2010
Messages
6,453
Location
Baton Rouge
NNID
bsl883
3DS FC
3308-4560-2744
You said you knew how each head would act as scum.
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
You're taking everything I said and reading it as though I'm scum.



Bolded parts are a bit hypocritical =o


What. She hasn't been fluff posting. And the other bold part I already said was a joke.

Your reason for voting smarg is a weak tag-along though it seems that's what everyone is doing thus far.
What. I was the first to bring up the points I did. And if that's a "weak tag-along" what do you call the majority of the Seik wagon.

You call J/GLG for weak posts and you call GLG scum because he looks the most town even though the game just started.
What. I didn't call either of you out for weak posts, I just don't like being told "I'm town!!!". GLG does look the most town, and I won't lynch him.

You cal JTB/Sqweedle out for posting more info when they have been posting frequently, question, why did you not call out KevinM?
What. I wasn't calling them out, I just wanted them to post more. I overlooked KevinM.

Asdioh/Pink Lemonade haven't posted yes, but neither have you till just now. Why call them out now? You even say that you shouldn't be holding it against them but still point it out. Seems odd.
What. Because this is my first post thus far maybe? I don't have a post earlier in which I could bring this up.

Then you take an adamant stance by saying you want Smarg/J lynched ToDay and then hop onto Seikend who has been the current wagon along with Smarg at the current time. You also make a point to say you don't want an Aposl lynch but leave out the whys and defend him just to defend him it seems.
Because those are the people I have scum reads on, save Aposl, who has been a target and I have a town read on.

Imma do this till I read more but not liking Glyph atm.

Vote: Glyph

That's just from seeing what I have seen thus far. ^^
Neat. Lets lynch J now.

unvote vote: J
 

Pink Lemonade

Smash Rookie
Joined
Feb 28, 2011
Messages
5
Location
Ran|July
@Anyone who knows what being opportunistic is. Is the second line of Smar's #167 opportunistic?


@Pink Lemonade: Is this a good idea?

If Ranmaru thinks of something, he posts it in a QT made for the Hydra, from then July can look at it and if its easily answered, not worth asking or completely stupid, then July does not post it. July posts in the thread and Ran posts in the QT, this will effectively filter the crap that sometimes comes from Ranmaru, but means that his scumhunting will still get through, in a more refined, understandable and concise form.
I like the idea in theory, yet I feel July might hold back on ballzy thing's I'd say, and just agree with the rest of the town. For example, wagon hopping. She might wagon hop. I'll let her, so she can vote someone she suspects, but then I might derail onto another person after she has thrown enough suspicion. I try not to wagon hop without enough reason. Or if everyone wants to NL, she'll agree with the whole town. I'm like no.

I like the idea alot, so I might set up a QT for us to talk in. ;o But if I really feel if I should post it, I will. I'll post it regardless in the Qt or something first.

But of course, I have to learn myself how to better sort the questions and such, and I shouldn't just let July filter it, I have to learn how to filter it myself.


... if you think I'm scum, why on earth do you want me leading town? And if I should be leading town, why aren't you voting Aposl?

I'm not Cello.
I think they are trying to get reactions from you or something. It shows how much they really care for scumhunting though.

Btw I don't think people will catch on to you being a female through your name. Smargeret just makes me think Smarg, not Marg. Maybe you should change the S to something that doesn't make a sound with the M, like Xmargeret. That way I'd have a clue.

"Fun" is a pretty horrible justification, but I'll chalk that one up as a joke. Regardless I feel like your wagon could use some more steam.

vote: Smar



J's #28 still feels hella off to me. Same with GLG's #15.
Iunno I guess I don't like when people come in and announce they're town. Btw GLG is probably scum since the person who looks most town seems to always be scum.

JTB and Sqweedle should post more information in a post/better, respectively.

Asdioh and Pink Lemonade should just post at all (though I've been just as inactive, so I don't really hold that against them. Day's just starting).

I want Smar or J lynched today. Seikend would be alright but I definitely prefer those two. I don't want an Aposl lynch.
Yeah we just found out the game started. Already on a Smar or J lynch? What have they done that was scummy?

Glyph, I don't get it. "You're too town" is a horrible reason to lynch someone, but justification for saying they're probably scum? Isn't lynching what's supposed to happen to scum?
I agree with this. "You're too town" is a suspicion. Although Smarg, I have thought of this before and it has not worked. For example, take Delvro in Cinemafia. I had a bit of heat on me from Kuz and Kirbyoshi and J(Mafia), while Delvro stated he didn't understand what was scummy about me. I thought he was "too town" and yet, flipped town. I was doc.

So I hope you'll re-evaluate that read, it's usually better to lynch someone for being scummy, then too town. I also think "Too town" is wifom too.

You just gotta look if the "Too town" person is being genuine "Too Town" Of FAKE "Too Town".
 

#HBC | J

Prince of DGamesia
Joined
Feb 14, 2010
Messages
7,591
Location
Colorado
Smarg, you seem to be taking a lot of heat, can you explain what you think of your primary attackers and the wagon that has emerged on you?

Also, who do you personally view as scum on your wagon?

^^Seikend, you can do this as well if you want~
 

#HBC | J

Prince of DGamesia
Joined
Feb 14, 2010
Messages
7,591
Location
Colorado
You're taking everything I said and reading it as though I'm scum.


Because I found you suspicious? I didn't say you were scum but I did say I didn't like what I saw and therefore you earned my vote.

Glyph said:
What. She hasn't been fluff posting. And the other bold part I already said was a joke.
I missed the joking part, my bad. Dx

Glyph said:
What. I was the first to bring up the points I did. And if that's a "weak tag-along" what do you call the majority of the Seik wagon.
Glyph said:
What. I didn't call either of you out for weak posts, I just don't like being told "I'm town!!!". GLG does look the most town, and I won't lynch him.
You did say though that you didn't like them and that you thought I was scum based off of that one weak post. You even say you would like my lynch because of it. Did you know it was a joke post?

Glyph said:
What. I wasn't calling them out, I just wanted them to post more. I overlooked KevinM.
But you did. :urg: Also if you truly wanted to post more wouldn't you have found all who was not posting?

Glyph said:
What. Because this is my first post thus far maybe? I don't have a post earlier in which I could bring this up.
I mean why call them out in your first post because it seems contradicting for a one-time poster to call out the inactives. =x Why did you call me out as well?

Glyph said:
Because those are the people I have scum reads on, save Aposl, who has been a target and I have a town read on.
Can you explain your town read on Aposl? Explain the scum-read on J/Seikend as well since you barely commented on them but said you are okay with their lynches. Could you please also go into detail with Smarg as well?

Glyph said:
Neat. Lets lynch J now.

unvote vote: J
OMGUS :awesome:

Nah but seriously, why? I mean you change the vote to me because I voted you and called you out on that post?
 

#HBC | J

Prince of DGamesia
Joined
Feb 14, 2010
Messages
7,591
Location
Colorado
Woopsie forgot a quote to respond to ;_;

To that one though, why did you deflect the question instead of answer it and say "Well what about them?!" Me no like.
 

smargaret

Smash Rookie
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
0
No, that post was referring to BSL.

J, I think GLG started the wagon to get us firmly out of RVS and go reaction fishing - see what he did with Seik? Yeah, I think it was something like that, and I'm reasonably sure GLG is town. I have no idea why Gboy thinks I'm scum :(. BSL is interesting because as far as I can tell he isn't voting me, but the misrep and persistence are something to keep an eye on. I think Glyph is likely scum for the keeping his options open, the hypocrisy you pointed out, and the OMGUS vote he threw on you.

I would dearly love to see answers from Aposl still.
 

smargaret

Smash Rookie
Joined
Aug 12, 2010
Messages
0
I'm not wagoning for fun. "Early game wagons are fun" is an acknowledgment that I'm wagoning for the sake of wagoning, and honestly PL, they're useful to get out of RVS.

(completely offtopic: anyone else notice that the logical abbreviation of Pink Lemonade is the same as Policy Lynch? lol)
 

Pink Lemonade

Smash Rookie
Joined
Feb 28, 2011
Messages
5
Location
Ran|July
Oh, how does it do that?

Hi aposl, please respond to questions? I already did that in my 159.

Buddying between Aposl and GLG. Add in wagon on Seik = distracting from Aposl, possibly scum here.

GLG, which head is posting?

Unvote: Seik
Vote: Aposl
Hmmm, I do not think buddying is scummy at all. Only problem is it could be either s v s, t v s, or t v t. It's null because it can go either way. Just keep an eye on the both of them, ok?

(Lol I didn't think of that, but I did think of the name ;o )
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523


Because I found you suspicious? I didn't say you were scum but I did say I didn't like what I saw and therefore you earned my vote.


Okay.

I missed the joking part, my bad. Dx
Its fine, though I would have expected you to read all my posts if you were voting for me.

You did say though that you didn't like them and that you thought I was scum based off of that one weak post. You even say you would like my lynch because of it. Did you know it was a joke post?
If its a joke post, you've just admitted to being scum. Hurray!

But you did. :urg: Also if you truly wanted to post more wouldn't you have found all who was not posting?
No, I really didn't. Calling someone out would have been something along the lines of:

"I'm really not liking how they're just avoiding posting, they're probably scum." All I said is that they should post. Not saying they're town, not saying they're scum.

I mean why call them out in your first post because it seems contradicting for a one-time poster to call out the inactives. =x Why did you call me out as well?
One post is still more than zero. And like I said, I was hardly calling them out.

Can you explain your town read on Aposl? Explain the scum-read on J/Seikend as well since you barely commented on them but said you are okay with their lynches. Could you please also go into detail with Smarg as well?
Aposl's posts absolutely reek of a newer town player to me. His policy on lynching the worst player is exactly the kind of thing I would expect from someone new to forum mafia, if he were scum he wouldn't have even mentioned it.

J is scum because J is obviously scum. (ie, I don't feel the need to restate myself).

Seikend has been explained by other people numerous times.

Smarg's interactions with Aposl made me lean scum for her.



OMGUS :awesome:

Nah but seriously, why? I mean you change the vote to me because I voted you and called you out on that post?


No, I voted for you because you passed Smarg on the Scum-o-Meter. (oh, and you might notice you kiiiiinda voted for me after the post i called you out on too breh.)
 

Pink Lemonade

Smash Rookie
Joined
Feb 28, 2011
Messages
5
Location
Ran|July
Look at his pregame play.

Oh oh or

J is always scum.
Again, give me YOUR reasoning for believing it please.

Last line shouldn't apply seriously. Look at his actions IN THIS GAME, not his meta. J was town in RG, and won it for town. So you are wrong in that case.
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
Okay.

My reasoning is his pregame play.
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
I have already given an exact quote number. Go read that one.
 

DtJ Glyphmoney

Summoned from a trading card
BRoomer
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
8,559
NNID
Tip_Tappers
3DS FC
1032-1228-5523
Can't or won't. You not reading my posts is not a concern of mine.
 
Top Bottom