If banjo makes it in and I’ve been wondering this If we manage to get Erdrick as well, do you guys think banjo will be top tier in the tourney with his moveset speculation or would he probably wound up mid tier?
Well, there are several questions still to be asked about the moveset. How well depends on several factors, and it's too early to tell like
NonSpecificGuy
said.
But if I had to make a guess:
(*Note, I know, gameplay stuff. It may not be that important on a casual level, but that still affects the image of a character such as how
is seen. I'm also basing this on the current tiers. Based on
this compilation of
tier lists.)
The most important question kind of revolves around the animations: how much start up / end lag do the attacks have? If Kazooie comes out / gets back into the backpack fast, that's a major plus in Ultimate's aerial heavy competitive scene. The opposite is true if Kazooie takes her time to get back, then that could spell trouble if the B-K player whiffs an attack. The reason I'm asking this is that the moveset implies that B-K's attacks will be heavily commital. The Rat-at-Tat Rap (the one where Kazooie pecks forward three times in the air) takes a bit of time to do before the attack ends for example. Once you do it, you have to wait until the attack is finished / you get hurt before doing something else.
That said, if I'm going with the moveset as is, I could see them doing at least decent or pretty well versus
and
if the B-K player can consistently outrange the two. The B-K main will have to watch for Pichu's deadly knockback and Joker's Guard / Arsene, as well as the mixup games. However,
and
could easily spell trouble even for casual B-K mains. Palutena and Wolf have pretty good range, annoying projectiles (Auto Aim and Explosive Flame could nullify / beat the eggs, Wolf's Laser can effectively double damage up close) and strong combo games / finishers. Sure, you're not likely going to go up against combo machines Online, but both Palutena and Wolf have strong and fast aerials.
And then, when you get to tourneys... you've seen what people like Nairo and Zackray have been able to do with Palu and Wolf respectively already? And then, other top tiers like
and
also have fast and strong aerials. If B-K hopes to get into the top tiers, I feel that they
need little start up / end lag on their attacks. Something I'm not sure of given that Kazooie needs to come out in the first place for many attacks.
Of course, I'm saying this knowing that tiers are far from everything in the game. Yes, many people in the competitive scene have already done a lot with characters outside the top tier. That said, the tiers do impact the absolute top: 10 out of 16 who were in Winners Round 1 at Pound played top tiers, with the rest playing high tiers.
My other questions are not only weight (a heavy weight is more likely to be combo-food, that's why you don't see a lot of
in tourneys at the moment) but also how easily B-K can reposition (are they able to turn around mid-flap - thus improving on spacing?).
I reserve final judgement, of course, but my point still stands.