What does everyone define as quickshooting? This is the other side of the Chuckie brain btw and I've just finished up reading
Eye I think it's important that behind every shot there needs to be a buildup of opinion and contribution from all players. Making votes/wagons or declarations as to why/why not player XYZ should be considered kill-fodder is the way to go imo. A vote system is absolutely necessary to replicate this =D In the instance Kev or anyone does decide to shoot someone against a majority consensus, I hope it doesn't come from the middle of nowhere and that his target is discussed and judged by everyone.
We have the ability to daykill for a reason, and that reason is that in this game players are supposed to be able to take matters into their own hands when they feel everyone else is being deceived. We should NOT be playing like the game wasn't designed this way and just pretend it's a normal mafia game with a strange lynching mechanic.
Where has this setup been run outside of swf (just out of curiosity)? I disagree slightly with this quote only because every example I've seen where a player took matters into their own hands was one that was detrimental to the Town. This is simply my observation from the last BIM game.
@BIM2 and mechanics in general: I think Town was lacking a sense of buildup to a lynch because everyone had the capacity to become lone rangers and kill quick, which players did
Standard mafia has a sense of "teamwork" because hammers are made through building a team of voters and players must group together in their votes to reach the hammer. It's this structure that BIM is missing and sends Town into a spiral of hysteria (a la BIM part deux) - trails went cold, commitments dissolved into the space time continuum, motives became clouded in mystery, and it's for this reason that using the design of the game to take matters into your own hands I feel can prove to do more bad than good for the Town in the long term, which is why we should aim to make this game as "standard mafia"/comfortable as possible and avoid the potential
natural disasters that the design of the game can entice us with...
That's my 2 cents. The last game was a great example of disorganisation from the Town, but that's the only experience I'm going off.
Who wants to cast the first vote? Wii will.
Vote: Chibo...
...because currently I don't understand your intentions for wanting Swiss to shoot/die if you don't find him scummy... that is, unless you wanted to out him as something else? U scum?
Can you elaborate on #84 a bit more plz then?
_
VOTE COUNT:
[1] Chibo: Chuckie
[0] Omni
[0] Swiss
[0] Friddle/FrozenRiddle/RiddleFlame/Frodo
[0] Ronike
[0] KevinM
[0] Mentos
[0] Rockin
[0] Chuckie
[0] Nicholas
[0] Zei
[0] Sold "Cha-ching" £££$$$
[13] Not Voting: Omni / Swiss / Friddle / Ronike / KevinM / Mentos / Rockin / Nicholas / Chibo / Zei / Sold
(^We'll use this template!)
_
@Zei: Eye don't know what to make of Swiss atm because he acted much less obvious in Discworld than he did in other games (and scum Swiss, sorry to say, was effortless to spot in those other games loool) - I think he's trying to be captain commander, saviour of all, and I think his anti-quickshot proposal is more tuned in from a Town POV - I say this because I feel he'd wait around and gauage the situation before nose-diving into a dictatorship/proposal like that as scum. Very early to have anything concrete atm, but time will tell. You must have been interested in Swiss yourself to have asked this... what are you thinking about him atm?, and Tandora/Nich?
I've just noticed Omni asking Chuckie something about agreeing with something. I'm gonna let Vanz answer that. FWIW, we play independently because of our timezones and we've only talked a little about the game so far about how we'd approach this game.
@Mod: can we post our hydra communication logs and our QT posts? (say yes say yes say yes say yes!) Wii'd be able to give better insight in how we function with this power-up.
@Swiss: Plz could you give us opinions on Nich and Kevguru plz? Also, I agree with Kev slightly that you're "bullying the mechanics", as in you're trying to take charge and lead the Town - but I want to know what you've learned so far from the reactions of everyone in response to your proposal.
Why did you even consider shooting me?
@Ronike: Swiss vs Super Troll - in what way did Swiss come out strongest?, and what does that mean to you in light of both players? and does that imply you agree with what Swiss is saying if he came out on top?
