I just picked up FE:A yesterday and it's awesome. I'm for sure a Chrom supporter now.
But this will severely hamper my Roy-fanboyism. How to have both in game? Lol
I can't help but feel Chrom is the better of the two.
I hate that Roy is only liked for his appearance in Smash Bros. I can say this most assuredly because he is one of the least liked lords among people who have actually played the games.
Oh, yeah. Sure. Smash is a legit reason to like a character. We have folks like Sheik and Captain Falcon who are certainly more important as fighters than characters.
The difference being at least they are internationally-recognized and now recurring fighters. Roy is a step above a nobody. Chrom, for how redundant he is among the ranks for Marth and Ike, is at least adored internationally, some detractors aside. If Chrom appears in this game, people will be pining for him to return just because he was in a game for when Smash 6 rolls around. It's such a finicky value. I am 100% sure Chrom would be more appreciate by people for a single cumulative Smash appearance than Roy was, if they would only give him a chance.
Granted, both of them have a variety of reasons for not appearing regardless.