Ghirahilda
♥Smash Beauty♥
This is amazing........Okay, I'm sorry, but no.
Moving his moveset to Black Shadow is a request that straight up annoys me. First of all, it's not fair to Black Shadow.Two, many changes made to Ganondorf in Brawl onward were made with his character in mind (I'll elaborate a bit later), and not really Black Shadow. Smash characters are generally included because of popularity and crap. Black Shadow isn't popular right now, and is only wanted to dump Ganondorf's moveset too. That's not a good reason to add anybody. And finally, Captain Falcon himself is based on F-Zero as a whole (his speedy nature is based off the speed and quick reflexes gameplay of F-Zero) and also the gameplay of his vehicle, the Blue Falcon; in the F-Zero games, the Blue Falcon is a balanced vehicle stat-wise; his Smash moveset reflects that by having his slower moves be stronger for a balanced blend of speed and power. So if Black Shadow were to become a Smash Bros character, the natural design choice is to base it off his vehicle's gameplay in F-Zero; his racecar, the Black Bull, has high speed (the fastest in the game) and durability, at the cost of low boosting power. This would translate in Smash to a speedy defensive character with no emphasis on actual power. That doesn't really sound like Ganondorf, does it?
Honestly, I think Ganondorf is fine as it is. I mean, yeah, making him a clone of Falcon does seem weird (and I'll admit, I used to complain a lot about it too), but currently, his moveset reflects him on a conceptual level; a powerful, calculating sorcerer who has tremendous physical strength and darkness magic. In fact, from Brawl onward, Sakurai has included plenty of nods to Ganondorf's canon portrayal in Zelda, that have flown over tons of people's heads. I found an article that explains Ganondorf in Smash a hundred times better than I ever could, but here's a quick TLDR: Sakurai doesn't want to stray from Ganondorfs origins as a heavier Captain Falcon, but he's trying to make him as faithful as possible to the Zelda games within those limitations, and it's made me appreciate his moveset a lot more.
(I do understand why people would want to see an overhaul with swords, Dead Man's Volley, etc, but I will say one thing; that's what Sakurai should have used custom moves for. He only developed the full potential of customs for Palutena and the Miis, and everyone else got slightly altered, horribly unbalanced variations on their default specials. I'm hoping the full potential of customs is explored in Smash Switch, but seeing how the DLC for SSB4 lacks custom moves altogether, the team probably gave up on the concept. But Ganondorf still uses his sword in a custom special, so hey, that's pretty cool)
But yeah, Ganondorf needs some more tweaks here and there. (And please, Dead man's volley is soooooo coooooool)
OMG please NO!I personally think that the best hope for Ganondorf to be "faithful to his canon self" in Smash is not to demand that Sakurai change his portrayal, but to demand that Aonuma/Fujibayashi change their portrayal of Ganondorf to match Smash.
The Zelda team is much more flexible in how they constantly adapt their characters to new situations, and I think that it would be far more appropriate if they give us a Ganondorf that uses magic-infused punches and kicks rather than Sakurai giving us a Ganondorf with a sword and magic.