the smash nerd's roster is the next one.
Mario series: I don't think Shadow Mario should be there. It is not that important to Bowser Jr.'s character. But Bowser Jr. is great.
Donkey Kong series: It is cool how you prefer Dixie over K. Rool. It looked like I'm the only one who prefers her. But K. Rool would make this perfect.
The Legend of Zelda series: Impa is good, but Tetra and Tingle are better. I doubt we will get a Zelda newcomer.
Metroid: Should have Ridley.
Yoshi series: Perfect.
Kirby series: As much as I like Bandane Dee, he is too unlikely. Maybe in Smash 5 or 6?
Star Fox series: Wolf should be there instead of Krystal.
Pokémon series: Meowth and Genesect are cool but they should not be in over Lucario and Pokémon Trainer.
F Zero series: Perfect.
Mother series: Lucas should not be cut.
Fire Emblem series: Marth is confirmed already, he should be in.
Wario series: As much as I love her, Ashley is impossible.
Kid Icarus series: Remove Magnus from it.
Pikmin series: Remove Charlie. If a Pikmin newcomer would happen it should be Louie but it is more likely we will have just Olimar.
Retro series: Wait. There is no retros in there!
Obscure/historical series: Just Mr. Game and Watch?
Other series: Perfect.
Third-Party series: Snake should be there, but he is an okay cut.
Series balance would be good if it had any retros.
Good
- Creative choices (Impa, Saki)
- Almost perfect series balance (the reason it is not perfect is explained below)
Bad
- No retros
- You went over the creativity limit and added unlikely characters (Charlie, Magnus, Ashley)