GwJumpman: Your confrontational attitude was at some points anti-town and several of your attacks on Swiss were poorly founded, yes he was controlling town, but was there any ulterior motives? Did any of his actions actually look scummy? working together is not always a bad thing.
SkylerOcon: Throughout the entire game you managed to post so few stances and so little content I'm suprised you survived as long as you did. If you just posted a few opinions and stuck to them you could have won the game. Several times you were asked your thoughts and all you could say were 'nitpicky' things. In other games you die real fast for doing this. Not too sure about the night kill choices, once adagio had claimed cop you should have been very aware of the doc possibility and who would be protected, its very bad for mafia if a doc protect happens.
BSL: possible MVP indeed, you played solid the whole way through, you got caught up with Blaziking but it is hard to differentiate between noobtown/noobscum so I don't blame you. You have potential to be a good town player. I still can't believe that despite the fact it
explicitly says in your PM, you thought you lose if you die..
Adagio: Claiming so soon wasn't the best of options but your night action choices were superb, Either Skyler or Gova were good choices each night and the fact you picked those two was impressive. In future games you should hold off claiming until you have a guilty, or you are around L-1/L-2 and about to be lynched.
Swiss: Your paranoia almost got the best of you at the end there, going on about Sword being scum fake claiming doc couldn't be possible if you believed Adagio's claim of roleblocked cop. There had to be a doc at that point, and do you really think a newbie would just leave Sword unCC'ed? I'm also surprised you didn't try to meta Skyler, who said at the start he'd played mafia twice before. You're not IC'ing again after
this post. I almost gave you a warning and threatened modkill on repeat offence but I thought that would only encourage you. I only considered it because its a newbie game after all.
Sworddancer: Good choice of night actions, getting a doc protect is very good and I think you played well overall. Paranoia about the other IC is fairly understandable just try to keep on top of it.
Blaziking17: Even though you did die D1 you only really fell down on lack of experience, you didn't play intentionally anti-town but sometimes lynches like that happen D1, your lynch still gave town information and to be fair I don't think you played that badly.
J: Odd that you were NK'ed, I'd have liked to see you play more but meh, I think you are slowly evolving as a player but in all honesty sometimes I think people find it hard to believe you based on the pure amount you AtE. You also could be a real good town player one day.
Gova: I wouldn't expect any newbies to ever fakeclaim a PR, but if you did it would have been very ballsy and very effective, had you done it D2, and done it convincingly enough to atleast out the other doc, you'd have won MVP hands down and probably won the game for scum. I don't blame you for not wanting to do it in your first game, props for even thinking of it and Navi was a good char to go with that claim. You've got great scum potential, I'd love to see a game with a Swiss/Gova scumteam. With the cop claimed it was a good idea to draw the lynch away from Skyler as keeping the roleblocker was important. In the future you can try 'bussing' your scummate which is essentially when one scummate pushes for the other's lynch in order to gain town credibility, in this game it perhaps wan't the best choice but keep it in mind for future games, which I hope you play.
Activity, and lack thereof: At the start of the game I decided to allow 72 hours between posts since it was a newbie game, but it was a bad decision. Several periods of little-to-no activity was a shame :/
If you enjoyed it: I really do suggest you go to the
sign-ups thread and join a game, small games to start with, there's sign-ups for GorditoBoy's game at the moment and I'll be playing in it, so I can help you out. If you don't like that game you can always wait for others to come along as they always do.
