As to the 2nd page discussion:
G&W doesn't **** anyone.
I think his best matchup in the game is 55-45, maybe 60-40 at worst. And that is ROB. People just don't know how to fight him. He's bad.
I'm housing with LuigiKing over this weekend for a tournament, so Imma gonna make him **** G&W.
To DMG:
Not if you're fighting a Wario. :3
Praxis, while your logic for why MK should be banned is pretty good, your logic here is infinitely worse.
I'd say that most competitive players actually know how to fight G&W. And rather, that most G&W
players suck.
And any G&W that knows low tiers should destroy them about 70/30. Virtually none of them have a realistic way to grab him or punish him with a kill move, and he edgeguards almost all of them very easily. Except almost no G&W user actually knows how most low tiers work since the matchups they focus on are all against the S tier.
My experience with Luigi is that he isn't much unlike other low tiers against G&W. No real way to grab G&W or punish him with a kill move if he doesn't suck and knows Luigi's tricks.
If you're going to argue that Luigi can do something silly like Jab out of shield...keep in mind I could just DI to eliminate any of his followups. And nothing else Luigi has is a viable attack against G&W when he's just waiting.
I like Luigi a lot and I'm really trying to establish myself as a serious user of him, but my experience against other G&Ws in my area is that this is really a terrible matchup.