If you ask me, there’s no reason to find the Erdrick absence surprising.
They set us up to get an upcoming Smash Direct to reveal more there. The focus here was obviously games that were “not Smash”, and the scheduling of the Direct really wouldn’t have made any sense to say, “Hey, Smash 3.0 is coming, here’s Erdrick” after briefly showing Joker. It also wouldn’t have made sense to show Erdrick after a segment on Dragon Quest XI, mainly because that’s a 3rd party title you’d be overshadowing as well with Smash.
Sure, it was hyped up. But this is a Smash website. We always put things out of context and place it into the immediate context of Smash. In the last week, there was an assumption that Shantae or Edelgard we’re locks because of a VA, there was consistent belief for a decent amount of time that Doomguy and Steve were locks, among other things.
Definitely, one way or the other, the Smash community has to chill out just a tad. Chances are we’re going to get a Smash Direct, and that’s where we’ll get more. There isn’t as much of a focus on the game anymore, so we can’t always go in expecting big news. This Direct was proof of that.