Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
I think it's the issue that as we have fewer characters, the ones who are the most important and the ones who are popular will split off.The poll is, and has always been based on what you want, not what you expect / what is confirmed.
So, yeah. I'm sure they are. I find it funny that we have the likes of Ashley, and Skull Kid deconfirmed. Two characters with moderate popularity passed over. We then look at WFT, Rosalina, and Villager. Three characters with smaller fanbases than the prior two before they were confirmed. Next we have the likes of Mewtwo, King K Rool, and Ridley no where to be seen, despite being the most wanted newcomers. ****s kreay. Megaman was on spot, though.
What? Her appeared in Mario and Luigi Dream team, Sticker Star, and Super Mario Bros U/Super Luigi U as a boss character. The only notable games he hasn't appeared in are 3D Land and 3D World.Bowser Jr. - Outside of children who grew up with the Gamecube, a lot of people don't care for him. This is why he's appeared less and less in the main Mario games.
Doesn't mean people like him.What? Her appeared in Mario and Luigi Dream team, Sticker Star, and Super Mario Bros U/Super Luigi U as a boss character. The only notable games he hasn't appeared in are 3D Land and 3D World.
Since when has there been any massive show of dislike for Bowser Junior except for those few who complain about the Koopa Kids getting played under him. I would think that the large number of people voting for him shows that way more people like him.Doesn't mean people like him.
Dude, people obviously like him, maybe not you. But people do. As of right now, it seems more people like him than Toad even.Doesn't mean people like him.
If you honestly think that people don't like Bowser Jr., than you are ignoring hard data.Doesn't mean people like him.
...except Rosalina and Yoshi are the most popular Mario charactersI think it's the issue that as we have fewer characters, the ones who are the most important and the ones who are popular will split off.
Brawl was the kind of pick up game. 64 set the stage, Melee expanded it to include the more important Nintendo characters outside of the stars of the series. From there, you have the second bananas. For contrast, Peach is very much a star of Nintendo as is Zelda and Mewtwo. They are prominate characters from Nintendo biggest series. Brawl picked up the other characters who were important to their own series but less so to the whole of Nintendo characters. This is why we got characters from series like DK, Kirby, and Starfox and had no new Mario or Zelda characters. The problem is that Brawl got the rest except for maybe Ridley. After that, there really isn't many importaint characters. But Smash needs to take the most important characters. To explain this, we have to look at Playstation All Stars Battle Royale. It did add big Sony names like Sly, Parappa, Kratos, and Sweet Tooth. But there are other characters who make less sense, like Big Daddy, Evil Cole, and even Emmett aren't that important. This is in contrast to characters who are Sony icons, like Crash, Dart, and Captain Bizarro (I think that's his name). Case in point, the company didn't take care to make sure the most importaint characters were in.
To explain this, let's look at Mario. There are a lot of characters who did well in the poll, but Rosalina was added. So let's look at the Mario characters.
So none of the characters really stand out and it would be hard to call them iconic. But we have this new character called Rosalina. She was a prominate character in the successful Mario Galaxy and she appears again in 3D World. She has enough of a face in the main games. So what would make sense to add is Rosalina despite not being very popular with fans. The same is true of Villager and WFT. They weren't very popular, but Animal Crossing and Wii Fit are successful series, so them having a character would make sense (as an aside, Villager may have been more popular if we didn't assume he wasn't going to get in). Now let's look at the reverse. Skull Kid is a popular choice for a Zelda character. However, is he really iconic. I'd say no. Unless you specifically played Majora's Mask, you wouldn't know of him and Majora's Mask was a niche game for the series. So he didn't make sense to be added. So as you see, the issue is the most importaint characters are not the most popular and vis versa.
- Toad - Toad is very iconic character, but he usually has a filler role in games and he doesn't stand out like the rest of the cast
- Waluigi - Waluigi has his own fanbase, but he hasn't had a strong role in the series (despite demand for more). Again, some people feel like he's filler
- Bowser Jr. - Outside of children who grew up with the Gamecube, a lot of people don't care for him. This is why he's appeared less and less in the main Mario games.
More characters who are high on the poll will get in as there is still convergence in some areas. The most obvious would be Little Mac, Ridley and Palutena. There will be some areas where it wont happen (Krystal, the Mario characters, Pac-Man).
Why do you say that? They have the biggest r34 following?...except Rosalina and Yoshi are the most popular Mario characters
(Not relating to Smash Bros)
Source please....except Rosalina and Yoshi are the most popular Mario characters
(Not relating to Smash Bros)
I was excluding the main 4 and was talking about the present.Source please.
I know Yoshi is popular everywhere, but this is the first I've heard of Rosalina being super popular, I'm collecting data on Mario characters for an Infographic at current, so if you have anything concrete I'd like to see it.
For the record here's what I have so far found;
As of 2008, Japan's list of favourite video game characters was something like this
and 2010 I managed to find this and this for their favourites.
For Mario Kart in the UK I managed to locate this.
In nearly all of these polls Mario and Yoshi are the most popular Mario characters, with Luigi and Toad occasionally rearing their heads. I admittedly don't have any American data at all yet, so if you have something send it my way.
So you excluded the four characters that were more popular to make your point stand?I was excluding the main 4 .
You got data for that statement?was talking about the present.
Err. Why? Excluding the main four but including Yoshi seems like a weird way to state who is overall the most popular, but alright...I was excluding the main 4 and was talking about the present.
Again, I'd love to see the data for the present Mario character popularity as Swampasaur asked, as it will help with my infographic immensely.You got data for that statement?
But I'll take this finding and add it to what I have anyway. Could be handy....except Rosalina and Yoshi are the most popular Mario characters
(Not relating to Smash Bros)
That was just to avoid getting a reply saying "Yoshi isn't a Mario character, he's a Yoshi character"For the record I would of settled for a 2013 poll if there was one, but at least Edit2 is something concrete. Although it's in the context of who people want for Smash, rather than regular Mario and since we've already GOT Rosalina I have to wonder if it's actually influenced by that.
I was asking more for in general than in Smash due to you posting this:
But I'll take this finding and add it to what I have anyway. Could be handy.
Source please.
I know Yoshi is popular everywhere, but this is the first I've heard of Rosalina being super popular, I'm collecting data on Mario characters for an Infographic at current, so if you have anything concrete I'd like to see it.
For the record here's what I have so far found;
As of 2008, Japan's list of favourite video game characters was something like this
and 2010 I managed to find this and this for their favourites.
For Mario Kart in the UK I managed to locate this.
In nearly all of these polls Mario and Yoshi are the most popular Mario characters, with Luigi and Toad occasionally rearing their heads. I admittedly don't have any American data at all yet, so if you have something send it my way.
700's are like, as high as you can expect to be if you aren't Ridley/KRool/Mewtwo/MegamanBandana Waddle Dee in the 300s and Palutena in the 700s?
Well, that's very debatable.700's are like, as high as you can expect to be if you aren't Ridley/KRool/Mewtwo/Megaman
And Bandana isn't that big of a deal anywhere but here. He's liked, but not exeedingly so. I mean, look at Tingle. You'd expect more from the most likely Zelda choice.
It's really not. Outside of Toon Zelda, it's really not.Well, that's very debatable.
Pit 1st? Mario 2nd? ....
Done.
There was also one from 2012 (Japan, by the way), featuring Mario, Luigi, Yoshi, and Waluigi (I can't recall if Toad was in it or not, because for Christ's sake, I can't find the image). But yeah, Rosalina... Not that popular.
Anyways, sweet thread, will keep my eyes on it.
EDIT: Ah, here it is:
It was claimed to be retweeted by Sakurai a while back (most likely due to the abundance of Kid Icarus characters, with Pit taking 1st place). But there you have it.
*ahem* Vaati.It's really not. Outside of Toon Zelda, it's really not.
I can help you Tell me what you want to do and I can translate it for them. Here is the link for the SSB4 forum : http://www.jeuxvideo.com/forums/0-29170-0-1-0-1-0-super-smash-bros-for-wii-u.htmDo think they'll mind it's in english?
Edit: The entire site is in french, I'm signed up and ready, but I don't know.
Mario's been rocking 1st place for far too long, bud. It was about time someone snatched his throne.Pit 1st? Mario 2nd? ....
What was the poll for?Mario's been rocking 1st place for far too long, bud. It was about time someone snatched his throne.
The poll itself is also in english, you know.I can help you Tell me what you want to do and I can translate it for them. Here is the link for the SSB4 forum : http://www.jeuxvideo.com/forums/0-29170-0-1-0-1-0-super-smash-bros-for-wii-u.htm
I would say a poll for the most popular Nintendo characters, but the presence of Hatsune Miku and others leans towards a general 'most popular video game characters' poll.What was the poll for?
Those results are very.... shocking.I would say a poll for the most popular Nintendo characters, but the presence of Hatsune Miku and others leans towards a general 'most popular video game characters' poll.