I'm more just curious why Geno of all Mario RPG characters got the cult following. I ain't throwin' shade, it's just...
I see no same level of love or outcry for any other character from Mario RPGs. Heck, Paper Mario fans have been vocal as heck for the last decade yet in Smash bubble almost no one cares about it. It's all SMRPG and Geno. Heck, hardly anyone cares about Mallow either, just Geno.
It's weird.
I’m not really sure either, I feel maybe part of it is the memes and his design attracting a lot of people to him (at least his design alone got me interested, thought he looked really cool, and he is cool for more than his design imo after reading what people have said about him and then having actually played SMRPG). Maybe him seeming cool with some mystery or something. Of course, some of the fans are people who have known him for a long time, with them and newer fans wanting the characters to be used again.
It is strange there isn’t much outcry for other RPG characters, though. You see some support for Mallow, and a lot of Geno fans also like him but understandably want to see Geno first, but there’s not that much Mallow support nor much for the other RPG characters; closest I can think of is maybe Fawful, and his support isn’t really very loud either from what I can tell.
Outside of Smash, though, there is a decent outcry for the RPG characters to be used in other Mario games like the spinoffs, at least, although I guess even then it’s not that loud, not sure…
I think at least Operation Starfall supports SMRPG as a whole, and not just Geno, although Geno may be the main one they’d like to see in regards to Smash, but I don’t know for certain how they feel on that.