Turned out just how I wanted it, only with a little blood sweat and tears lol. not really that much work just a few warnings to give before people start. This is stuff I learned on my first run.
1. USE TAPE FOR THE BUTTON SLOTS! I didn't and i ended up spending a while sanding down the walls of the place where the buttons go.
2. DON'T PAINT STICKS! Okay I didn't do this but it seems like a terrible idea lol.
3. WHEN THEY SAY LIGHT COATS THEY MEAN LIGHT COATS! I did heavy coats and it made it blotchy and drippy on my first try at painting the controller
4. CHECK ON THE CONTROLLER BEFORE YOU PUT THE NEXT COAT ON! On my current controller you can't see in the photo but I actually mummified a tiny hair under the controller's clear coats lol.
5. DON'T PAINT BUTTONS! I did, waaay more work than it's worth and I doubt it will even last.
6. WHEN PUTTING THE CONTROLLER BACK TOGETHER REMEMBER THE INITIAL ASSEMBLY OF THE TRIGGERS! Things that were part of the left trigger at the beginning are not interchangeable with the right trigger pieces. I didn't notice this since the black piece under the spring looks exactly the same on either trigger, put them in separate plastic bags or something.
7. DON'T PAINT THE DPAD! I know I did lol, the dpad is stiff to begin with and painting it just made it worse while one would think it couldn't get worse.
8. AFTER A COAT MAKE SURE YOU PAINTED EVERY INCH BEFORE STARTING THE NEXT COAT. Sometimes certain areas of the controller are harder to reach than others so unless you are trying to hit that part specifically you won't hit it very often/enough.
9. Oh yeah, expect an update on whether or not ****ty 3rd party controller shells will fit with regular 1st party controllers. Someone in this thread said they won't work but I read somewhere else they do and they look like they would fit so I ordered 2 online for like 8 dollars and I'll check it out and report back.
10. THE ONLY WAY TO REMOVE PAINT IS SCRAPING!!! YEAH I KNOW THAT SUCKS ASS!!! My first botched paint job was sooo difficult to remove, I tried all these chemical means even turpentine and none worked at all. The one thing I did notice was that with nail polish remover it was
slightly easier to scrape off. I recommend sand paper, steel wool or an actual scraper.
11. CLEAN IT WHILE YOU ARE IN THERE, THIS **** AIN'T A QUICKY TO OPEN!!!
Also thanks so much to everyone who responded to my questions when I was in the process of doing this, especially GameCubeScrubb.
Just one problem, my joysticks stick as shown in the picture in those directions they are pointed in only. I haven't opened it up after I noticed this so I just thought I could get some opinions on what the problem might be before I do open it because, as I said, it isn't exactly a quick operation to open it frequently.
UPDATE: Already opened it up and fixed the sticking joysticks, the problem was a little too much paint on the opposite side under the area where the joysticks are inserted, in a way that the base of the opposite side the sticks point towards gets jammed. New tip: NO, REALLY USE TAPE!!!