Every damn time, I swear. Every time a new round of newcomer speculation kicks off, most of the community picks a small handful of characters to focus on and hardly diverges from them at all. Only seems to change if either a new game is announced to shake things up or a rumor (even an easily disproven one) grows popular enough to get people talking about a character mentioned in it. I've spent years trying to figure out how to break through that, but all I've ever been able to reach are niche crowds.
It gets especially bad with franchises like Pokémon that have several viable options with each major new entry, because the Smash community will often focus on characters for the wrong reasons. Right now, we're seeing Cinderace (because it's the "obvious shillmon"), Rillaboom (to have a complete starter trio), Urshifu (to "promote" the Isle of Armor DLC), and Toxtricity (because it got popular outside the Pokémon fandom). Hardly anyone else beyond that even has the chance to be associated with the idea of getting into Smash, and it's
inordinately difficult to change that. We're seeing newcomer speculation surrounding a game be dictated by people
outside its own fanbase, and it's...frustrating.
Reminds me of how things went down during Smash 4 speculation. Talk surrounding Gen 6 revolved around people assuming they'd just bring Mewtwo back and work the Mega forms in somehow--none of the actual Gen 6 mons were taken seriously. Talk surrounding Fire Emblem Awakening was railroaded by people outside the FE fandom assuming Chrom was the only possible option, while actual Fire Emblem fans were pretty evenly split between Chrom and Robin (with at-the-time niche picks like Lucina, Anna, etc. showing up sometimes as well).
If we're going to be able to change
anything here, I think the key will be reaching those who are fans of Pokémon first who also happen to follow Smash news. I've seen far more variance in the characters actual Pokémon fans have wanted. Zacian and Zamazenta themselves have even been brought up a few times elsewhere already, including by
the founder of Serebii himself. Is there some way to tap into what isolated patches of interest there are and unite them?
While it wouldn't have any actual effect on who the Smash team chooses, it would be nice to not feel like outcasts nor be treated like non-entities so damn often.
Alas. Nothing like having a character wind up in literally the same position in the anime that Greninja had in Gen 6, while offering not only a unique build for a fighter but also elemental powers that are to this day
completely untapped by the current roster...and get almost completely dismissed by speculators because they'd decided you had to be a starter to have a real shot. Even though we had multiple non-starters in Smash already. Even though they made an exception to
their own rule with Mimikyu because it also got popular outside its home fandom.
It's just...damn it, people, we can do better than be so...
exclusionary.
Don't mind me. I'm okay. Just...still some lingering frustration there.