The Best & Worst Character In Brawl!! *Spoilers*

[TheSMASHtyke]

Um, I have a couple things against this...

First, you shouldn't use this title. I actually thought it was going to be a detailed fact-based arguement on the best and worst character, not an opinionated discussion on you're favorite and least favorite character. You didn't put any facts behind you're opinions, and by just looking at how you wrote your first post you're already judging who's going to be the best by Melee's standards. Brawl is a whole new game. It doesn't even look like you've played Brawl.

This post put a smile on my face. =)

I agree with this man 100%. It will probably take a good 2 months, if not more, of experimentation to finally decide who will stand were in which tier.

 

[Yoshi'stheBombers7]

This post put a smile on my face. =)

I agree with this man 100%. It will probably take a good 2 months, if not more, of experimentation to finally decide who will stand were in which tier.

Thank you very much kind sir. This post put a smile on my face.
It's good to know the whole world isn't made up of mindless zombies.

 

[LinkNSnake4Main]

Best : Link\Snake

(Honorable Mention : Pit\Wolf)

Worst : Yoshi\JPuff

Automatic Suck : Gay&Watch\ROB.

 

[§leepy God]

Fun fact: no one has a true answer. Not even the people who've played it. (Unless...you own it. And not many of you do.) Everyone is just being skeptical, and that's fine.

You are correct sir. But I can't shake the fealing that this thread will get a lot of people mad. But I hope I'm wrong about that.

I'm guessing with out Jump Cancel, people are saying that Yoshi is the worst, but he's not in my option.

 

[Drik Khaail]

best;Ness
worst;Tony Little.

 

[Wireframe]

Sonic= Win

Wario= Fail

 

[Rarzy]

mine would be best: wolf, then lucario

worst: pit, then peach

 

[Nuvia]

Sonic= Win

Wario= Fail

Blargh, I will eat you.

 

[Luke Groundwalker]

Best character? Well, singling down to it, definitely ROB.

Worst has to be Sonic to be honest.

 

[Gymclass_Hero]

I dunno why, but I'm guessing on nothing other than a few videos, rob and yoshi are the worst, best might be kirby or dedede

 

[Toadster5]

Best: DK

Worst: Marth

Finally someone who knows what they're talking about.

 

[Sinistar]

Best: Marth (Tis, true.)
Worst: Donkey Kong OR Jigglypuff.

 

[IGN Forums]

Um, I have a couple things against this...

First, you shouldn't use this title. I actually thought it was going to be a detailed fact-based arguement on the best and worst character, not an opinionated discussion on you're favorite and least favorite character. You didn't put any facts behind you're opinions, and by just looking at how you wrote your first post you're already judging who's going to be the best by Melee's standards. Brawl is a whole new game. It doesn't even look like you've played Brawl.



I've actually played Brawl, and Yoshi is better this time around. His F Smash, Bair, Uair, D-Tilt, F-Tilt, and U Smash have more range. He can recover with his Egg Toss for a little bit of momentum after double jumping. Although he has lost his DJC, it actually causes new strategies. He can short hop Uair, double jump Uair, and continue rising in the direction of the opponent to perform a Nair.

These are facts. I don't believe Yoshi is not the worst anymore. However, I don't think we've played the game long enough to decide who's bad, good, etc.

it's My OPINION which means everybody has different taste!! Plus Yoshi is cool, but just not the character I want!

 

[Kips]

Alright, I'm going to bring my logic and forethought to play instead of going into a testosterone induced fanboy rage like everybody else.

The Best Character- Zero Suit Samus
Why? Because Zero Suit Samus was made ridiculously good in Brawl. She has two spikes, massive combo ability, a projectile, the ability to stun, huge range, good finishers, great launchers and a powerful recovery. This, coupled with the ease with which she is played, puts her at a fusion of Sheik and Marth due to the power of combo combined with range she presents. Logically she is the best character.

The Worst Character- Sonic
Don't scream and shout and cry- Sonic logically is the worst character in Brawl. He is nigh impossible to play at the speeds he would optimally be at, his B moves are at best used for mindgaming and to be generous, all consist of spinning at his opponent and hoping not to get Tilted away. His recovery move can be abused by others to use the springboard, while his combo and damage don't seem to be up to par with other contenders.

That's my take on it, flame if you will, but it seems to be the most logical choices.

 

[PsychoIncarnate]

Best: King Dedede/ R.O.B. tie

Second Best: Diddy/ Lucario/ Samus/ Wolf (tie)

Worst: Toon Link (I don't care)/ Jiggs/ Yoshi

 

[=Samus-Aran=]

Best: Samus-Luigi-Metaknight-Ike-Marth-Olimar-Snake-Link

Worst: Diddy Kong-R.O.B-Toon Link-Lucas-Yoshi-Wolf (Too many Star Fox Reps, that's the only reason I chose Wolf. I would have much rather have had Ridley, Bomberman, Geno, King K.Rool, etc.)

=S-A=

 

[SirPainsalot]

Best: I dunno.
Worst: I can safely say Yoshi, as cool as Yoshi is... WHY SAKURAI!!! WHY?!?!

My Best: Bowser. Meta Knight probably when I get Brawl. Or both. Maybe add Jiggz in there.

My worst: Sonic. OH DEAR GOD... THE SPEED IS TOO MUCH FOR ME TO HANDLE... I know he's Sonic but still...

 

[Norm]

everyone has a character they are best with a worse with i'm best with link in melee i'm worst with ness.

 

[No-Really-I-Suck]

anyone who says DK is the worst is setting themselves up for some nasty karma

 

[zeldamaster2006]

Haven't played yet, but in my opinion:

Best: Toon Link (though I'm maining Pit)
Worst: Yoshi

 

[Norgay]

Best: Luigi
Worst: Yoshi/Link

Luigi has improved a lot!

 

[jay~B]

The best to me, undoubtably fox

.....and the worst is peach

I got nothing against luigi but seriously stop killing yourself!

 

[Yoshi'stheBombers7]

it's My OPINION which means everybody has different taste!! Plus Yoshi is cool, but just not the character I want!

EXACTLY! Because it's your opinion, it's not official, as it says in the title. Change the title, and you're O.K.

 

[Kirin]

Best: Marth, Fox, and Diddy.

Worst: Too early to tell, but probably Falcon and Ganondorf.

 

[Speedsk8er]

Best- The final boss
Worst- Goomba #4

 

[OrnageOctopuse]

From playing this game, I can say for the most part the characters are more or less balanced.

But my personal best are:

Ike/Bowser/Pokemon Trainer(Nerf Bullet Seed)/Wolf


Worst:

Yoshi/Jiggs

 

[Kips]

anyone who says DK is the worst is setting themselves up for some nasty karma

They're practically asking for a Bum DK Giant Punch.

 

[Luteyi]

can't believe Ign is here lolz take cover

 

[A2ZOMG]

Going by awesomeness factor:
Best: Mario
Worst: Sonic

Srsly, if you're a Nintendo fan, you should understand this. =P

Going by metagame predictions:
Best: really not sure to be honest, a lot of characters are making me happy. Particularly G&W.
Worst: Ganondorf. O_O

 

[retro gamer 6]

best: kirby because he's been buffed. :D
worst: marth because he's too broken again.

 

[Vaxxaruis]

Ill just say it so everyone finally understands -sigh- The best is Marth (or possibly PIT) And the Worst is Mario

 

[AznHalfCaucasian]

sigh........Decisions decisions

Have to wait till the game comes out in America

 

[dancingfrogman]

Well I'm going to guess and predict some will be my favourite characters or worst are:
Best: Diddy Kong, king dedede, ROB, starfox characters, sonic

I'll choose these because they have an unique moveset and with some exceptions I play mostly fast and comboing ability characters or aerial characters with great recovery
worst: Bowser and probably some others

I'm not good with slow hitters or movement, because i normally go all out with mostly smash attacks and leave my self to an opening.
But one thing is that I will not main anyone just like in melee, so you can develop different stragies and to counterpick a character for someone who has trouble facing them with their main.

 

[reu_1303]

Best- Toon Link

Worst- IC

 

[AIM0001]

THE BEST: Since Ive liked Fox since 64 Ima say him of course....

THE WORST: I'm definatly going to havta say WW Link or Toon Link or The other clone Link or whatever you prefer calling this waste of a character spot....They could of had a way better character in that spot or if he was going to be in no matter what then give him his own move set..I mean I remember when there were support threads for this character and everyone sayin Oh he can be so great and different n whatever but when we finally see him he turns out being no more of an importance to the roster than Young Link. But again I'm sure many may disagree on how I feel towards this character but thats okay if youy like him then thats your opinion. But I hate this character.

 

[MarthFanatique]

best--pit or marth

worst--not my place to judge

but, i personally hope that pit won't be "too good" because then there will be too many pit fans, and i just to play pit because he's a retro character, his recovery, and his aerial attack capabilities.

 

[Stoo99]

I'm thinking from some videos that the best characters will be Toon Link, Pit, and Lucario. Lucario is definitely higher tier+ IMO :/

As for worst, eh. Ganon then Yoshi, Ganon looks so horrible.

Personally I think Snake and Marth will be pretty good too, but only because of Psycho ****** videos and Melee Marth

 

[Sir Bedevere]

Best: Marth,Olimar,or Snake. Marth as he was and still is uber1337awesome(unforunately....>_>) Olimar for his high damage-racking and great finshers, and Snake...cus of Pyscho ******.

Worst: Yoshi. No contest.

 

[MetalLuigi1209]

Yoshi isnt the worst, he has recieved so many buffs this time around. Look at the Yoshi Discussion threads in the character discussion, he has a lot going for him!

 

[Moustachio]

MARIO FTW!!!!

Ya but honestly, Yoshi kind of stinks.