The Best of the Best Brawl Stage COUNTER/BANNED (Port Town Aero Drive vs. Onett)

[OmegaXXII]

well due to AbsoluteZero's inactivity in the past few weeks of his thread I decided to create this all new daily updated thread

NOTE: Your choice depends on stage preference under the catagory, not the actual category itself.

First of I will pair of all Neutral stages as needed

First Round:

Final Destination vs. Battlefield: Outcome: Battlefield

Yoshi's Island vs. Smashville: Outcome: Smashville

Delfino Plaza vs. Castle Siege: Outcome: Delfino Plaza

Lylat Cruise vs. Halberd: Outcome: Lylat Cruise

Neutral /Counter Semifinals

Battlefield vs. Pokemon Stadium 1: Outcome: Battlefield

Delfino Plaza vs. Lylat Cruise: Outcome: Lylat Cruise



Second Round: COUNTER stages.

Brinstar vs. Corneria: Outcome: Corneria

Green Hill Zone vs. Luigi's Mansion: Outcome: Luigi's Mansion

Pirate Ship vs. Distant Planet:: Outcome: Pirate Ship

Norfair vs. Pokemon Stadium 2: Outcome: Norfair


Pictochat vs. Frigate Orpheon: Outcome: Frigate Orpheon

Yoshi's Island (Melee) vs. Jungle Japes: Outcome: Jungle Japes

next up:

Norfair vs. Skyworld: Outcome: Norfair

Port Town Aero Drive vs. Onett: Outcome:

 

[Sosuke]

Battlefield.
FD begs for gimps.

 

[Tim_The_Enchanter]

Final D.
Although it gimps, it is still more neutral than battlefield due to platforms.

 

[peeup]

For most nuetral? BF
FD has gimping, and campers can do whatevery they want.

 

[cjrocker]

Battlefield

 

[Cha0s Finale]

Most neutral? I guess that would be Battlefield. Like others have said, Final Destination favors campers and gimpers.

(But I still like FD more... )

 

[IShotLazer]

Battlefield is far more an even playing field.

 

[Sunstar]

Battlefield

battlefield is fair for all characters i think...

FD... whenever i play bowser for fun (i am not really skilled with him) and my enemy is somebody with a b-spam compareable to wolfs one... i have about 50% damage before even reaching him... that cannot happen on battlefield

 

[MKonguard]

Battlefield

 

[GPEternity]

Battlefield. FD has too much camp and spam potential and has a lip.

 

[Samuelson]

I think BF is more neutral than FD. FD is a campers dream while BF seems to be more fair all around. BF is a perfect level for characters with good aerials because of the platforms.

Overall BF>FD as far as neutrality goes IMO.

 

[Alus]

Battlefield

battlefield is fair for all characters i think...

not for pika, kirby, mk,... and marth has a strong advantage on this map... i have a long list...

as for all the people that say camping isnt fair...wow... if you cant get over it than that is a problem with your own skill (im not trying to flame anyone but battle field is one of most unfair maps...) and king isnt asking which map is more "Neutral"from what i have read...

 

[Crazy_mofo213]

Battlefield
FD has gimped me way to many times.

 

[JesiahTEG]

I say Final Destination. It's flat and getting through platforms can be a pain.

 

[istudying]

Final Destination

 

[Ori_bro]

battlefield bttr than FD

 

[AaronR]

FD. Fox needs space to move. It's annoying to be looking for a place to land but you see 3 Ike's charging Fsmash a pokemon and an Assist Trophy. FD will still have somewhere to land. If you're on Battlefield, it's over.

 

[Alus]

battlefield bttr than FD

hey that needs more reason into it...

 

[Safu]

Kindav hard for me to choose seeing how i like both of them but due to bf having platforms i lose often since i can never fall through them -_-
So i guess i choose FD

 

[Link_in_park]

Battlefield for sure. Final Destination gives characters with long-range projectiles an advantage. It's so different from every other neutral stage in the game that I don't even think it should be considered neutral. That's just my opinion, though.

 

[lax guy5]

Final Destination. I love Battlefield too but for me to use Pikachu effectively, I need nothing overhead.

 

[X-Quizit614]

Battlefield. You can stratigize more, in my opinion.

 

[Ilex]

FD.

Battlefield's platforms get annoying and in the way when trying to use aerials.

 

[blowuptheking]

FD
Yes Final D favors campers and people with projectiles, but Battlefield favors people with a long reaching usmash. (Marth, MK, pika thunder) Smaller characters' (TL comes to mind) usmash can't reach a person standing on a platform above them.

 

[BrawlerHarrison]

With campes, BF.
But FD is cooler XD

 

[Cease Tick]

Battlefield, seeing as I play lots of Zamus.

 

[socandrewcer]

Final Destination

 

[OmegaXXII]

looks like Battlefeild is the obvious choice for Neutral so Battlefield wins!

next up: Yoshi's Island vs. Smashville

 

[-DXH-]

Yoshi's Island

 

[TheSundanceKid]

Yoshi's Island

 

[-Giga-]

Yoshi's Island
Smashville has that annoying music!
I also get distracted by the characters in the background.

Yoshi's Island is simple.

 

[MKonguard]

Smashville i like the music as well

 

[Blackimar]

Im with Smashville because i liked Animal crossing and i love the music especialy The roost(its a song on Smashville)

 

[whiteolimar]

Smashville it has nice music and is pretty cool on a Saturday evening. Also its not to big.

 

[Golem the Stern Father]

Give me Smashville, or give me death.

Spoiler

not really

 

[Sgt. Baker]

Smashville. K.K. Rider and Tom Nook FTW

 

[OmegaXXII]

okay folks, looks like Smashville takes this round, next up:

Delfino Plaza vs. Castle Siege

 

[CT Chia]

as much as it makes sense to say castle, i dont like the lil lips on the ledge that can get some characters on the first stage, theres walk offs almost half the time, the transforms are awkward, etc

delfino does have water, but not that often. it also has a walk off, but its quite rare. the regular parts of the stage are nice, and the transforms are really simple.

 

[fkacyan]

Hm, that's tough. I like both stages, but...

Delfino.

 

[Conclusively]

I like the music on Castle Siege, but overall as a stage, Delfino Plaza is better. Delfino is really fun, and it has a wide variety of sections, even the parts in between sections changes, which keeps things entertaining. Castle Siege (First Part) has an evil ledge that screws your recovery, Second Part has walkoffs and the statues that interrupt projectiles, Third Part is like a Lylat Cruise in hell. Bleh. Delfino ftw.