Work In Progress SWF Community Voted Tier List - 3.0 COMPLETE

[Cedy]

Dedede should go up a tier.

 

[aquaticpineapples]

Shouldnt we allow people to upvote swordfighter as well, if any other character can get up/downvoted?

 

[16bit]

 

[Browny]

To everyone who asked if they are doing it right, yes

@ aquaticpineapples no, there was such a heavy agreement that mii swordfighter is in their own tier, I wont even allow them to move. The previous round had something around 14 people say it should be in its own tier vs 2 who said it should join the tier above them

 

[Jucchan]

Vote for Bowser Jr. to go up a tier.

 

[Diddy Kong]

 

[DjinnandTonic]

*sigh* I wanna vote Palutena higher, but in good faith, I can not. Unless customs are considered for her?

 

[Metalex]

Vote for Bowser Jr. to go up a tier.

I couldn't agree more, Many people think Bowser Jr is a midtier character so i have no idea why he's so low here.

 

[Luigi#1]

Characters aren't suppose to move more then 2 spaces unless you vote them up a tier.
Unless you strongly disagree again which then anarchy reigns.

 

[Macchiato]

I couldn't agree more, Many people think Bowser Jr is a midtier character so i have no idea why he's so low here.

His moves are pretty janky, it's pretty hard to get the kill and even when yew land a smash, sometimes they fall out of it. The cannon is a horrible projectile and he's super gimpable. Let's also bring up the fact that he has this mechanic that makes him take more damage than other characters. He's viable but imo he's not very good like everyone who mained him a few months ago have dropped him.

 

[CostLow]

Original:

Vote:

 

[misterOWAIN33]

G&W low tier???
Ah, well, I'm not exactly a metagame expert. I vote for to move up a tier anyway.

Shouldnt we allow people to upvote swordfighter as well, if any other character can get up/downvoted?

Eh, you're right. I downvote one tier.

 

[pershona]

 

[Hat N' Clogs]

Doc to move up +1 tier

 

[rm88]

Doctor doesn't belong here, I think.

 

[ShortcutButton]

Move Doctor Mario up a tier.

+1 Dr. Mario
+2 Bowser Jr.
-2 King Dedede
+1 Palutena
-2 Wii Fit Trainer
+2 Mii Gunner
-1 Mr. Game and Watch
-1 Charizard

 

[Wintermelon43]

Bowser Jr up one tier

 

[L9999]

 

[PurpleSoda]

+1
+1
+1
+1
-1plz

 

[Beef Tank]

1 vote for Bowser Jr. to go up to the F tier.

 

[Beanie!]

+Dr. Mario +1.

 

[Smashoperatingbuddy123]

Ill play the game

S
A
B
C
D

I will change my tier list eventually this is what im looking at so far

Mr game and watch is way way way higher on my list because im a main, and i really really do think all of you are underating him, hes way better than he was in brawl in my opinon

For sonic Im not kidding i think he deserves a S in mine i got the most kos with him out of every character i used

For falco well yea he is slower but i do notice better knockback with him but specials need a lot of work

Shulk is low on mine due to delays in his attacks and they are slow even ikes attacks are faster than shulks and monondo arts its hard to use

Yep diddy is definatly the highest and sword mii is the lowest

Mii swords mans specials suck big time and not much range attacks are with him and barely any of the sword attacks have high knock back besides the smash attacks though

EDIT: forgot luigi i just put him in.

 

[Jucchan]

His moves are pretty janky, it's pretty hard to get the kill and even when yew land a smash, sometimes they fall out of it. The cannon is a horrible projectile and he's super gimpable. Let's also bring up the fact that he has this mechanic that makes him take more damage than other characters. He's viable but imo he's not very good like everyone who mained him a few months ago have dropped him.

Yes, some aspects of him are definitely not ideal, but it's not like results for him are non-existent like other characters in G.
A recent one that comes to mind is Sumabato 2, where he took 7th out of 137 entrants:
http://smashboards.com/rankings/sumabato-2-smash-wii-u-singles.4636/event
He got 7th in an 100-person Netherlands tournament too I think.
In my view, Bowser Jr. and Dedede are the two characters in G that have enough results and potential to go to F.

 

[New_Dumal]

Original G Tier :


Changed G Tier :
(Palutena +1, Wii Fit trainer -2, Bowser Jr + 2, Doc.Mario -1, Mii Gunner +1 , Charizard -1)
--> 1 vote for Wii Fit Trainer to go down a tier.
----------------
I mean... Doc should be obviously better than D3 with a bit better recovery.Maybe he still is, but I keep my vote.
Palutena is a lot better than people realize it. But I needed to try send Wii Fit Trainer for where she belongs.
(WFT don't have a single effective way of approach, make pression, or build a positive MU against anyone in my point of view.)
As the last thing... Why we don't have Zelda or Samus here in G tier ? I mean...Bowser.Jr and D3 are there .

 

[MasterOfKnees]

Dedede 0, Bowser Jr. +2, Dr. Mario 0, Charizard +2, G&W +2, WFT -2, Palutena -1.

Vote for Dedede to go up a tier.

 

[The_SuperiorTaste]

I vote Palutena to go up a tier.

 

[HeavyLobster]

Jr., Zard, Palutena, and Gunner really don't belong here at all, and I have no idea why they're below the likes of Mac, Falco, and Zelda, so the real challenge is deciding who the biggest outrage is. Gotta go with Jr, as he's a couple tiers too low even without customs.

I vote Bowser Jr. to go up a tier.

 

[Luigi#1]

Ill play the game

S
A
B
C
D

I will change my tier list eventually this is what im looking at so far

Mr game and watch is way way way higher on my list because im a main, and i really really do think all of you are underating him, hes way better than he was in brawl in my opinon

For sonic Im not kidding i think he deserves a S in mine i got the most kos with him out of every character i used

For falco well yea he is slower but i do notice better knockback with him but specials need a lot of work

Shulk is low on mine due to delays in his attacks and they are slow even ikes attacks are faster than shulks and monondo arts its hard to use

Yep diddy is definatly the highest and sword mii is the lowest

Mii swords mans specials suck big time and not much range attacks are with him and barely any of the sword attacks have high knock back besides the smash attacks though

Luigi wins by being absolutely nowhere.
Anyways, just read the op.

 

[Macchiato]

Yes, some aspects of him are definitely not ideal, but it's not like results for him are non-existent like other characters in G.
A recent one that comes to mind is Sumabato 2, where he took 7th out of 137 entrants:
http://smashboards.com/rankings/sumabato-2-smash-wii-u-singles.4636/event
He got 7th in an 100-person Netherlands tournament too I think.
In my view, Bowser Jr. and Dedede are the two characters in G that have enough results and potential to go to F.

Actually doc has rice who always gets like top 3 in his tournaments and there's Kool aid. For wii fit there's TKBreezy and Johnnumbers.

 

[PigglyJuff]

I'm dissapointed at villagers position.
Anyway, vote Wft up a tier

 

[Duzzzyy]

Original:


Changed:

Send Palutena up a tier, I don't think she deserves this tier at all.

 

[PurpleSoda]

Ill play the game

S
A
B
C
D

I will change my tier list eventually this is what im looking at so far

Mr game and watch is way way way higher on my list because im a main, and i really really do think all of you are underating him, hes way better than he was in brawl in my opinon

For sonic Im not kidding i think he deserves a S in mine i got the most kos with him out of every character i used

For falco well yea he is slower but i do notice better knockback with him but specials need a lot of work

Shulk is low on mine due to delays in his attacks and they are slow even ikes attacks are faster than shulks and monondo arts its hard to use

Yep diddy is definatly the highest and sword mii is the lowest

Mii swords mans specials suck big time and not much range attacks are with him and barely any of the sword attacks have high knock back besides the smash attacks though

That is the hoghest i have seen falco and game amd watch,thank u sor,thank u

 

[Xyrohip]

Moved up Dr Mario
bring Dr. Mario up a tier

 

[Scamper52596]

My vote goes to Bowser Jr. to move up a tier.

 

[Luigi#1]

Moved up Dr Mario and Bowser JN

You can only move up one.

 

[Wintermelon43]

You can only move up one.

I think he means he moved them up one spot, not one tier

 

[Xyrohip]

You can only move up one.

I fixed it
I meant to move them up 1 spot I voted Dr Mario up one tier though

 

[Xyrohip]

Dedede should go up a tier.

Sup Cedy

 

[PurpleSoda]

This is my tier list,this took me over an hour to make,U stands for unknown,this is a crappy tier list,dont trust it
S:
A:
B:
C:
D:
U:

 

[Smashoperatingbuddy123]

Luigi wins by being absolutely nowhere.
Anyways, just read the op.

Fixed luigi is put on i figured i forgot atleast 1

Which op on another forum or first post of this.