• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Work In Progress SWF Community Voted Tier List - 3.0 COMPLETE

Browny

Smash Hater
Joined
Mar 22, 2008
Messages
10,416
Location
Video Games
but... its... true...

I mean, hes not BAD or anything, but he was overhyped for a long time (like a really long gime, zero even made the conection of him being best wtfff)
Every time people say that, they need to take a look at the Brawl tier lists.

Frame data isnt everything, safety and the ability to punish hard were the most important traits. Keep the enemy out for as long as possible and every time you get a chance, do a lot of damage/kill them early.

Shulk actually does both of those quite well. His bigger flaw imo is his highly punishable landing options.
 

Paxadin

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Apr 15, 2015
Messages
96
NNID
Paxadin
3DS FC
2767-1146-9743
Every time people say that, they need to take a look at the Brawl tier lists.

Frame data isnt everything, safety and the ability to punish hard were the most important traits. Keep the enemy out for as long as possible and every time you get a chance, do a lot of damage/kill them early.

Shulk actually does both of those quite well. His bigger flaw imo is his highly punishable landing options.
The same could be said about Zelda, who's judged poorly for her very punishable frame data. Even though, if you play smart, you won't really have much problem. In fact, she does surprisingly well in tournaments in the hands of players who actually use her.
I say her only major flaw, except for a few stupid things like Din's free fall, is the same as Mewtwo, way too light for the power they have.
 
Last edited:

Lag Chan

Fastfall Nair Everyday
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
120
Location
North East England
NNID
BlankaHondaShrek
Jeez, people are overrating the hell out of Meta Knight and Donkey Kong. DK has glaring flaws that people love to gloss over and while Meta Knight is good winning one tourney doesn't automatically make you top 15. I know it was against one of the best players around but I still think it's a big case of jumping the gun.
 

Kirby Dragons

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 30, 2014
Messages
5,189
Location
Another Dimension
What's frame data?

Whatever it is, it shouldn't determine a character's tier position. I main both Zelda and Dedede, who apparently have "bad frame data", yet I have no problem easily defeating characters in higher tiers without bad data.
 
Last edited:

Paxadin

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Apr 15, 2015
Messages
96
NNID
Paxadin
3DS FC
2767-1146-9743
What's frame data?

Whatever it is, it shouldn't determine a character's tier position. I main both Zelda and Dedede, who apparently have "bad frame data", yet I have no problem easily defeating characters in higher tiers without bad data.
The big thing about frame data is the game going easy on you.
I'll use Sheik and Zelda as an example since they weigh the same.
If you screw up with Sheik, you'll more than likely be fine against most players, while if you do the tiniest screw up with Zelda, you eat a smash attack or a huge set up.


One eats everything to the face while the other never gets punished unless the player screws up twice in a row, missing the escape.
 

monzer

Smash Journeyman
Joined
May 27, 2015
Messages
296
-1:4luigi:Because a character that has no presence at nationals, has bad matchups with :4sheik:,:4zss:,:rosalina:, and random mid/high tier characters deserves to be a top tier.
I know he shouldn't be top tier, but he alreqsy has enough votes to move down two tiers. He doesn't need any more votes. A vote for Luigi at this piont is pretty much a wasted vote.
 

Macchiato

Smash Hero
Joined
Jan 4, 2015
Messages
6,629
Location
Springfield, Virginia
NNID
Macchiatooo
The same could be said about Zelda, who's judged poorly for her very punishable frame data. Even though, if you play smart, you won't really have much problem. In fact, she does surprisingly well in tournaments in the hands of players who actually use her.
I say her only major flaw, except for a few stupid things like Din's free fall, is the same as Mewtwo, way too light for the power they have.
I think all her "bad frame data" comes from her bad landing lag. Her start-up on all moves are great and her endlag is p decent but her landing lag, notably on kicks, are what her "bad" frame data is. The people who say she bad frame data probably haven't even seen her frame data. The people who keep down voting honestly probably don't know much about her and just assume or are a ESAM cultists. ANOTHER THING IS THAT TOP PLAYERS NEED TO STOP ACTING LIKE THEY KNOW EVERYTHING. ESAM's video description for Zelda was all false. Nothing he said about her was true. I actually made responses to the false statements.

image.jpg
 

Browny

Smash Hater
Joined
Mar 22, 2008
Messages
10,416
Location
Video Games
ESAM hardly mentioned her upb elevator combo oos which is godlike.

I saw it killing a yoshi at 30% middle of an omega stage simply for dash attacking her shield.

@ Kirby Dragons Kirby Dragons good frame data is a few things;
How fast your attacks come out on average
How quickly they end
How long they are active for

If your attacks are faster, end sooner and exist for a long time (think of G&Ws dash attack) compared to your opponents you will probably have an advantage. If you have long-range attacks then its ok for attacks to have 'bad' frame data, but having only a few fast moves means the enemy can avoid most of your attacks or block them more easily.
 
Last edited:

Macchiato

Smash Hero
Joined
Jan 4, 2015
Messages
6,629
Location
Springfield, Virginia
NNID
Macchiatooo
ESAM hardly mentioned her upb elevator combo oos which is godlike.

I saw it killing a yoshi at 30% middle of an omega stage simply for dash attacking her shield.

@ Kirby Dragons Kirby Dragons good frame data is a few things;
How fast your attacks come out on average
How quickly they end
How long they are active for

If your attacks are faster, end sooner and exist for a long time (think of G&Ws dash attack) compared to your opponents you will probably have an advantage. If you have long-range attacks then its ok for attacks to have 'bad' frame data, but having only a few fast moves means the enemy can avoid most of your attacks or block them more easily.
Another thing is that the elevator can be comboed into. Falling Nair to Elevator is guarenteed.
 

Xandercosm

Smash Lord
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
1,425
Location
the nearest neutron star!
NNID
vineto
+1 :4mario:Probably the best overall combo game of any character. Great frame data. Fast and agile. Oh, and Ally...

+1 :4diddy: The monkey's still got it!

+1 :4dk: "A wild buff appeared. It raised DK's rekage stat by 70%."
 
Last edited:

Nikoback

Smash Rookie
Joined
Sep 13, 2015
Messages
8
Location
Somewhere
NNID
MeltingComet
:4drmario:+1 (My main, his additional weight can be both a pro/con depending on your playstyle, and his attacks have higher knockback compared to Mario.)
:4megaman:-1 (Megaman plays a bit too weird for me. I can't get a grasp at his varied moveset, in addition to the fact that I believe his moveset can be heavily devastating. To himself. A lot of his attacks can be deflected back, which makes opponents like Mario or Pit heavily devastating should the player incorrectly time a smash attack.)
:4ness:+1 (Back Throw is basically a finishing move on it's own right.)
 
Last edited:

guymane

Smash Rookie
Joined
Sep 13, 2015
Messages
2
+:4gaw:
I feel like G&W has a lot of gimping and air possibilities which puts some MUs in its favor (those RNG 9s though).
+:4link:
Plenty of projectiles and has abilities to cover most of the other options that other MUs will have.
-:4ganondorf:
Slow, heavy, and bad recovery. The extra strength of his attacks dont help if he cant follow up as well.
 
Last edited:

Eight_SixtyFour

Smash Ace
Joined
May 15, 2015
Messages
622
:4drmario:+1 (My main, his additional weight can be both a pro/con depending on your playstyle, and his attacks have higher knockback compared to Mario.)
:4megaman:-1 (Megaman plays a bit too weird for me. I can't get a grasp at his varied moveset, in addition to the fact that I believe his moveset can be heavily devastating. A lot of his attacks can be deflected back, which makes opponents like Mario or Pit heavily devastating should the player incorrectly time a smash attack.)
:4ness:+1 (Back Throw is basically a finishing move on it's own right.)
He weighs the same as Mario. I do agree that he is underrated, but not for those reasons.
 

atreyujames

The Laziest Man in the North
Joined
Jun 30, 2015
Messages
409
NNID
Atreyujames
:4drmario:+1 (My main, his additional weight can be both a pro/con depending on your playstyle, and his attacks have higher knockback compared to Mario.)
I appreciate that someone finally gave the reason "because he's my main" for upvoting their main =)
 

Nikoback

Smash Rookie
Joined
Sep 13, 2015
Messages
8
Location
Somewhere
NNID
MeltingComet
He weighs the same as Mario. I do agree that he is underrated, but not for those reasons.
Really? I'm guessing the difference is jump height, not weight.

I should probably look up some things on Dr. Mario VS Mario though, they are both my main picks in various situations.
 
D

Deleted member

Guest
Really? I'm guessing the difference is jump height, not weight.

I should probably look up some things on Dr. Mario VS Mario though, they are both my main picks in various situations.
SmashWiki or checking out the Dr. Mario character board will probably help you in that situation. They have no difference in weight, Doc just has lower jump height and movement speed.
 

L1N3R1D3R

Smash Lord
Joined
Aug 4, 2015
Messages
1,035
Location
On my Switch
Switch FC
SW-3822-0133-6917
+1 :4drmario: Holy down-votes, Batman! He really isn't as bad as you guys think.
+1 :4peach: No way she's below DK with her combos and turnip setups.
-1 :4sonic: Weird approach options, and his nerfs make him definitely lower than the people on tier 2.
 
Last edited:

Bowserboy3

Asking mum how to talk to a lady
Joined
Aug 10, 2015
Messages
1,842
Location
United Kingdom
NNID
Bowserboy3
VOTES:

:4samus: +1 : I've voiced my opinions on Samus multiple times now, so to sum it up in short, I still don't think she is in the bottom tier.
:4ryu: +1 : The epitome of a scary character. Combos, power, kill power, great speed, survivability (solid weight stat, a good reaching recovery in Up B and a recovery extender in side B), and mind games. Watch this for example - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ltU09aKM8Dk - Watch specifically at points such as 10:56 and 15:41. Ryu is just forcing Mario to make an unsafe approach, so he can combo him into his strongest attack... yeah thats right, he can combo into Input Shoryuken, and look how ridiculously early it kills. I think this is a character to watch. If people start to push the character more, it wouldn't surprise me to see him in tier 2 for example in the future.
:4tlink: +1 : Maybe I just suck against Toon Link, but I think he has good tools, and deserves to be up there in tier 4. The reactions he can force with his boomerang and bombs are insane. He has a good set of throws that include a decent follow up throw and a good kill throw and miscellaneous stuff include surprisingly good weight for his speed and a Zair. I don't think he is as great as tier 3 (at present, unless people start to push the character more, which I do find unlikely), so I think tier 4 is his home.



OTHER MENTIONS/OPINIONS:

:4marth: : It's nice to see people finally realising that Marth isn't trash. Definitely a viable character when played the correct way. Could be near the top of his tier, if not higher. I'd like to see Marth in tier 4, but I think that is unrealistic at the moment. It's possible, but maybe in time... It's heartbreaking losing a stock at 35% at the edge (if you are the Marth player, it feels great) just because he placed a tipper correctly. I want to see more Marth players, showing what he can do.
:4lucina: : Even though I think its obvious Marth is better, I don't think there is THAT much different in the two characters. I'd expect them to be in the same tier for example, but with Marth plenty of places above her.
:4bowser: : I still don't think he is this low. I don't think he is fantastic, probably tier 5, but not this low.
:4charizard: : A similar story to Bowser, but I'm unsure whether he's better or worse than him. At this point in time, I'd actually say he's better. I want to see more people use this character.
:rosalina: : I don't know why I'm seeing all the down votes. As a top tier, she probably has the most unfavourable matchups out of them all, but if everyone keeps down voting her because of this, she'll end up in tier 3, which is clearly wrong. Certainly in the top tier/tier 1, but possibly the least reliable out of them all.
:4luigi: : I don't think Luigi is in tier 1. IMO, he would be the best character in tier 2.
:4mario: : Regarding the other bro, I think Mario is in just the right place. It's a joy to see the "jack of all trades" finally be a powerful force.
:4lucario: : I also think Lucario is in just the right place too. Yes, he has aura, but most of his killing moves are pants to land. I can only think of Aura Sphere into cancelled Up Smash that is reliable, but even then you need to land the initial Aura Sphere. Maybe he could be a little higher up, but not much.
:4zelda: : I have taken to playing Zelda a bit more, not as a main, but as a pocket, for fun sort of character. Though I don't think she is going to be moving upwards in the tier list any time soon, she still has a few things going for her. Up Tilt thanks to the buffs can actually combo into itself now, and then into an Up Air. Her smashes are strong, and link now. I like her Ftilt too, has deceptive range, and knockback. Also, DO NOT ATTACK A SHIELDING ZELDA. The elevator is real. Who knows where Zelda will end up.
:4dk: : I don't think DK is tier 3 material. Probably high tier 4, or top of tier 4 in the long run. Yes, Cargo Up Throw to Up Air allows him to have a scary grab, but his neutral is still lacking and predictable. Other than Wario, I think he is the best heavyweight (even though Wario is a heavyweight, he never feels like one to me because of his size).

Edit: Sorry for the double post, don't know what happened, noob alert most likely.
 
Last edited:

SuperDavio

Smash Apprentice
Joined
Jul 20, 2014
Messages
129
Location
Morgantown, WV
NNID
SuperDavio
3DS FC
1633-4266-1971
:4fox: -1
:4littlemac: +1
:4wiifit: -1

Fox: The character is solid, but I feel he's more in line with Tier 3; he's got a lot of tools, but he really has trouble confirming his kills. I see him being as viable as Falcon and Villager, who rightfully sit in tier 3.

Little Mac: I know his offstage game is horrendous, but it is expanding as time goes on. His ground frame data is super amazing, and he gets 2-3 chances to take your stock with each one of his. Little Mac matches are ramped up in that both players are more likely to lose quickly. As Mac's gain an edgeguard game beyond dsmash, I feel the character could reach as high as Tier 4. But for now, I think Tier 5 is a perfect placement for him in the meta.

WFT: I admit this is bias. What makes this character on the same tier as Kirby or Robin in a Vanilla environment? Could someone fill me in? I'd be glad to retract my vote.
 
Last edited:

TMNTSSB4

Smash Obsessed
Joined
Jun 15, 2014
Messages
30,474
Location
John Cena
NNID
No More
3DS FC
3368-4469-9312
Switch FC
SW-6414-0526-7609
Fox -1
Little Mac +1
Wii Fit Trainer -1

Fox: The character is solid, but I feel he's more in line with Tier 3; he's got a lot of tools, but he really has trouble confirming his kills. I see him being as viable as Falcon and Villager, who rightfully sit in tier 3.

Little Mac: I know his offstage game is horrendous, but it is expanding as time goes on. His ground frame data is super amazing, and he gets 2-3 chances to take your stock with each one of his. Little Mac matches are ramped up in that both players are more likely to lose quickly. As Mac's gain an edgeguard game beyond dsmash, I feel the character could reach as high as Tier 4. But for now, I think Tier 5 is a perfect placement for him in the meta.

WFT: I admit this is bias. What makes this character on the same tier as Kirby or Robin in a Vanilla environment? Could someone fill me in? I'd be glad to retract my vote.
Acestarthe3rd is the reason Wii Fit Trainer is so high, he hacked the website.
 

Wintermelon43

Smash Champion
Joined
Feb 13, 2015
Messages
2,767
:4fox: -1
:4littlemac: +1
:4wiifit: -1

Fox: The character is solid, but I feel he's more in line with Tier 3; he's got a lot of tools, but he really has trouble confirming his kills. I see him being as viable as Falcon and Villager, who rightfully sit in tier 3.

Little Mac: I know his offstage game is horrendous, but it is expanding as time goes on. His ground frame data is super amazing, and he gets 2-3 chances to take your stock with each one of his. Little Mac matches are ramped up in that both players are more likely to lose quickly. As Mac's gain an edgeguard game beyond dsmash, I feel the character could reach as high as Tier 4. But for now, I think Tier 5 is a perfect placement for him in the meta.

WFT: I admit this is bias. What makes this character on the same tier as Kirby or Robin in a Vanilla environment? Could someone fill me in? I'd be glad to retract my vote.
She's up there because of main bias. People such as Macchieto and Ipoit can't stand saying their main somewhre other than top tier, and will just up vote them no matter what, even if she was in her own tier at the top.
 
Top Bottom