• Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!

    You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!

Super Smash Bros. for 3DS/WiiU - Stage Contest - Round 14 - Kid Icarus

TheUltraDeino

TheUltraDeino

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
434
Location
Kalos Victory Road
NNID
TheUltraDeino
3DS FC
3866-8826-1729
I've played quite a bit of sonic games but I can't really think of a that great sonic stage right now. Probably because I lost interest since Lost World or something.

iunno, later I might think of something from Sonic Adventure or something
 
TheMarioaddict

TheMarioaddict

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Dec 14, 2013
Messages
345
Location
Right Behind You
NNID
TheMarioaddict
3DS FC
0130-1812-3778
Switch FC
SW-4314-7715-8313
Ok, since there's clearly no one else entering, I'm gonna call the mini round closed. Will post results when they are graded, if you still care
 
Last edited:
TechPowah

TechPowah

Smash Ace
Joined
May 23, 2014
Messages
935
Location
The room down the hall
Switch FC
1951-3245-1423
Sorry in advance for the picture size, I could only find this one pic of the exact area I wanted, and I couldn't find a smaller version.



Aquarium Park (Sonic Colors)

Here is the Japan-flavored indoor aquarium level from Sonic Colors. Hope you packed swim trunks and floaties!

Two square floor blocks connected by small bridges to the left of a pagoda standing tall on a structure, the block further left lower than the one in the middle of the screen. (In this particular pic, the pagoda appears as if it would be a walkoff, but my version of it would have the size of it decreased to have a little breathing room on the right edge of the screen.) To the left of and under the bridges and blocks is the large pool of water you would see in the original game, just barely level with the lower block. in fact, just like Sonic Colors, you can walk on the water if you run across it, though if you stop running for any reason other than to turn around while still running, you immediately start falling down to the blast zone. No infinite double jumps in water for you, though.

Speaking of the water, after a half-minute or so, the tide will rise up to completely fill the screen with water, similar to my example pic. Don't worry about drowning, though, it's as safe to fight underwater as it is to fight in space! When the tide rises, there will be a stake-like platform that also rises up to level with the lower platform, acting as both a wall and platform for lower in the stage. When you go underwater, rising tide or no, your fall speed and horizontal movement decrease, and your jump height increases. However, your horizontal launch distance decreases and upward launch distance increases, so enjoy the extra midair freedom, because it'll be that much easier to KO you from the top of the screen and harder to KO from the sides. When another half-minute passes, the water will lower back down, letting players fight like normal again, and the water goes back down to where you can run on it.

Sample Music:
Aquarium Park: Act 1 (Since the music to each act in the original game is various renditions of the same general music, I used the Act 1 edition as the most "vanilla" version, with the intention that Smash makes it's own take on the theme.)
Starlight Carnival: Act 3
Reach for the Stars <Original>
Aquarium Park (Sonic Simulator Edition) <Original>

Unlock condition:
Summon Starfy from the Assist Trophy as Sonic 10 times
 
Last edited:
D-idara

D-idara

Banned via Administration
Joined
Jul 8, 2012
Messages
3,240
Location
Venezuela
NNID
D-idara
3DS FC
4511-0670-4622
TechPowah said:
Sorry in advance for the picture size, I could only find this one pic of the exact area I wanted, and I couldn't find a smaller version.



Aquarium Park (Sonic Colors)

Here is the Japan-flavored indoor aquarium level from Sonic Colors. Hope you packed swim trunks and floaties!

Two square floor blocks connected by small bridges to the left of a pagoda standing tall on a structure, the block further left lower than the one in the middle of the screen. (In this particular pic, the pagoda appears as if it would be a walkoff, but my version of it would have the size of it decreased to have a little breathing room on the right edge of the screen.) To the left of and under the bridges and blocks is the large pool of water you would see in the original game, just barely level with the lower block. in fact, just like Sonic Colors, you can walk on the water if you run across it, though if you stop running for any reason other than to turn around while still running, you immediately start falling down to the blast zone. No infinite double jumps in water for you, though.

Speaking of the water, after a half-minute or so, the tide will rise up to completely fill the screen with water, similar to my example pic. Don't worry about drowning, though, it's as safe to fight underwater as it is to fight in space! When the tide rises, there will be a stake-like platform that also rises up to level with the lower platform, acting as both a wall and platform for lower in the stage. When you go underwater, rising tide or no, your fall speed and horizontal movement decrease, and your jump height increases. However, your horizontal launch distance decreases and upward launch distance increases, so enjoy the extra midair freedom, because it'll be that much easier to KO you from the top of the screen and harder to KO from the sides. When another half-minute passes, the water will lower back down, letting players fight like normal again, and the water goes back down to where you can run on it.

Sample Music:
Aquarium Park: Act 1 (Since the music to each act in the original game is various renditions of the same general music, I used the Act 1 edition as the most "vanilla" version, with the intention that Smash makes it's own take on the theme.)
Starlight Carnival: Act 3
Reach for the Stars <Original>
Aquarium Park (Sonic Simulator Edition) <Original>

Unlock condition:
Summon Starfy from the Assist Trophy as Sonic 10 times
Click to expand...
Just saying, you should try at least using Paint or Photoshop to draw a few lines where everything would be on the picture.
 
BridgesWithTurtles

BridgesWithTurtles

Smash Champion
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
2,174
Location
The long road to nowhere
3DS FC
3523-2059-7939
I'd definitely recommend going into Paint or Photoshop to make some markings or something as well. It really helps visualize the stage structure more than even the best description can do.
 
Kevandre

Kevandre

Ivy WAS Saurly missed
Joined
Jun 19, 2013
Messages
2,520
Location
Pacific Northwest
NNID
Kevandre
3DS FC
1736-1095-5393
Switch FC
SW-2226-3590-9812
Geoffrey Druyts said:
Here is mine.
Sorry that its a link tho.


http://logingcoolmario.deviantart.com/art/Fanmade-Super-Smash-Bros-Stage-Casino-Night-Zone-477196636
Click to expand...
I've semi-recreated yours using mostly sprites from Sonic 2.



I didn't recreate the blue background thing perfectly because that was going to be a huge pain so I just haphazardly did that one... But I figured you'd enjoy. You should describe what happens on the stage here though instead of on the link.

Edit- I'd just be careful that this stage isn't the same cat as Super Smash Flash 2's version of Casino Night Zone. It's KINDA similar so I'd just recommend caution, lol
 
Last edited:
Geoffrey Druyts

Geoffrey Druyts

Smash Ace
Joined
Mar 19, 2014
Messages
936
Location
Sandwich Land
3DS FC
1993-7715-4423
Switch FC
SW-6723-8387-1403
Kevandre said:
I've semi-recreated yours using mostly sprites from Sonic 2.



I didn't recreate the blue background thing perfectly because that was going to be a huge pain so I just haphazardly did that one... But I figured you'd enjoy. You should describe what happens on the stage here though instead of on the link.

Edit- I'd just be careful that this stage isn't the same cat as Super Smash Flash 2's version of Casino Night Zone. It's KINDA similar so I'd just recommend caution, lol
Click to expand...
Thank you for making it look better. :)

Time to explain:
The bumper will deal 1-3% and moves from left to right.

Just like in the real Sonic games, you can enter the slot-machine.
You can get damage, health (stanima), stocks/lifes, KO.s (time) and coins/rings (coin mode).
You cant get hit while using it and you have to wait 1-3 minutes so you cant spam it over and over again.

You can not fall off the stage, but you also have 2 platforms.
So the only way to KO is left, right or up.
 
Last edited:
Mega Bidoof

Mega Bidoof

Smash Hero
Joined
Aug 14, 2013
Messages
8,463
Location
The Drought
NNID
Link46
3DS FC
1160-9840-1542
TheMarioaddict

TheMarioaddict

Smash Journeyman
Joined
Dec 14, 2013
Messages
345
Location
Right Behind You
NNID
TheMarioaddict
3DS FC
0130-1812-3778
Switch FC
SW-4314-7715-8313
Okay, BadStages Grades are in! Just a note: Stages were just graded out of 10. 10 = a really terrible stage, 1 = a stage that isn't that bad. In order to make the entries fair, the two submitted by judges (aka mine and kevandre's) were graded out of 15 instead of out of 10, but were only graded by the judges who did not make the stage. (that way it still totals out to 30 total points)

Now then, on to the grades!

Sakurai's Cat Destination (D-idara)

Score: 7/10

This stage… oh my god, it’s hilarious. I would play this stage just to see it in action. Had to take a few points off because of that. This stage would be so infuriating to actually play a match on, so that boosted your score a bit.



Blank Space (theultradeino)

Score: 9/10

Probably the worst stage on the board. There’s the inherent humor of just spawning and dying repeatedly, but that would get old really fast. Beyond that, there’s so little to talk about. No platforms, no background, nothing but blandness. A terrifically terrible stage.



Pokefloats 2 (kevandre)

Score: 10/15

So, first off, props on making a stage that’s just a bad stage instead of a joke stage. Not that there’s anything wrong with joke stages, but they have an inherent likability in their humor, making them less bad as a result. However, your stage… honestly, I think it looks kind of fun. I liked Pokefloats in Melee, so the thought of getting another one with pokemon from ALL generations seems cool to me. Sadly, this hurts your score. No form of competitive play could ever take place upon this stage, though, so that helps a bit. In the end, a 10/15 is nothing to sneeze at. It’s pleasantly bad.

Blank Space = 6. Pretty open, hazard free stage. Competitive community would totes love it.

Koridai = 2. Pretty playable stage, not "worst" in any way. Just based on something awful.

Sakurai's cat Destination = 8. I ALMOST HAD A SEIZURE.

I don't know how to judge!

Blank Space by TheUltraDeino
Score: 11/10
Notes: Blank Space would actually be quite the interesting stage if it were, say, an endless freefall in which all attacks were aerial. But how can one plummet to their death "until the end of the match" if one doesn't die until the match ends? Sure, this could work in timed matches, but in a timeless stock match, it's an endless paradox. The match won't end until the players die, but they "plummet to [their] death" until the match ends. Thus, there's no way to end a stock match here. Not only does nobody get to fight, but nobody can even win (or lose), so this stage is absolutely horrendous as it takes away the key gameplay aspects that make Smash Bros. what it is. There's no fighting, no victor, and no fun. The stage's paradox is so powerful that it could possibly cause the game system to explode upon trying to load a match. The icing on the crabcake that is this stage is its ability to be so terrible with so few details. It doesn't even include a poorly-constructed picture or header.

Poké Floats 2 by Kevandre
Score: 5/15
Notes: Kind of ironic how not-bad this stage is. Believe it or not, Poké Floats isn't a very hated stage. It used to be tournament legal, and a lot of people want it to return. What you give us here is just a more well thought-out, balanced, entertaining version of the stage. While it lacks some of the charm of the original (the multiple Unown, the 3 Porygon moving in a straight line, etc), it crams a massive amount of fanservice into a single stage, representing all generations of Pokémon equally. The stage has so much going on that you can't even complete a whole cycle in a default time match. There aren't even any experience-ruining hazards. You just move from one float to the next. Some of them, like Avalugg and Seismitoad, are actually really creative. The only real problem is that the stage is too big for its own good, and isn't very creative, since you're essentially just copying a stage which was already born out of an obvious lack of creativity (or perhaps, too much drugs creativity).

Koridai by TheMarioaddict
Score: 3/15
Notes: I believe I shared my thoughts for this one back when it was posted. There's actually nothing wrong with it. Its worst offense is being a little bland. If you thought the source game alone was enough to taint it, sorry to tell you that I actually want the CD-i games to be represented. This is a terrible stage at being terrible. Now go scrub all the floors in Hyrule.

Sakurai's Cat Destination by D-idara
Score: 10/10
Notes: I see you went with both the "irrefutably OP hazard" and "game-crashing" routes. Definitely a stage I'd give a 0 playability score to during a normal set. The parallel walls are obnoxious, but because of their nature, don't allow for infinites, which are even more obnoxious than OP hazards. Granted, while the stage is absolutely terrible in every way imaginable, I think it lacks the subtle yet sheer wit of TheUltraDeino's Blank Space, which is so cleverly bad that it is neither funny nor appreciable. I will say that this stage is more likely to induce cancer than Blank Space, however.

Props to Bridges for going super in depth with the comments

Totals:

TheUltraDeino: 26/30
Kevandre: 15/30
TheMarioAddict: 5/30 (:C)
D-idara: 25/30

And the winner, by a single point, is...

THEULTRADEINO, WITH BLANK SPACE! CONGRATULATIONS, YOUR STAGE SUCKS!

TheUltraDeino said:
Here's my idea:
BLANK SPACE:
There is nothing in this stage, not even any platforms, as soon as you spawn, you plummet to your death until the match ends.
Click to expand...
 
D-idara

D-idara

Banned via Administration
Joined
Jul 8, 2012
Messages
3,240
Location
Venezuela
NNID
D-idara
3DS FC
4511-0670-4622
THE ROUND IS CLOSED! GET A LOAD OF THIS! D-idara will bring down his wrath upon the poor souls who saw Sakurai's Cat Destination and lived to tell the tale >:C
 
Last edited:
allison

allison

She who makes bad posts
Joined
Jan 25, 2014
Messages
5,138
Location
Maple Valley, WA
NNID
crazyal02
3DS FC
0216-1055-4584
TheMarioaddict said:
Okay, BadStages Grades are in! Just a note: Stages were just graded out of 10. 10 = a really terrible stage, 1 = a stage that isn't that bad. In order to make the entries fair, the two submitted by judges (aka mine and kevandre's) were graded out of 15 instead of out of 10, but were only graded by the judges who did not make the stage. (that way it still totals out to 30 total points)

Now then, on to the grades!

Sakurai's Cat Destination (D-idara)

Score: 7/10

This stage… oh my god, it’s hilarious. I would play this stage just to see it in action. Had to take a few points off because of that. This stage would be so infuriating to actually play a match on, so that boosted your score a bit.



Blank Space (theultradeino)

Score: 9/10

Probably the worst stage on the board. There’s the inherent humor of just spawning and dying repeatedly, but that would get old really fast. Beyond that, there’s so little to talk about. No platforms, no background, nothing but blandness. A terrifically terrible stage.



Pokefloats 2 (kevandre)

Score: 10/15

So, first off, props on making a stage that’s just a bad stage instead of a joke stage. Not that there’s anything wrong with joke stages, but they have an inherent likability in their humor, making them less bad as a result. However, your stage… honestly, I think it looks kind of fun. I liked Pokefloats in Melee, so the thought of getting another one with pokemon from ALL generations seems cool to me. Sadly, this hurts your score. No form of competitive play could ever take place upon this stage, though, so that helps a bit. In the end, a 10/15 is nothing to sneeze at. It’s pleasantly bad.

Blank Space = 6. Pretty open, hazard free stage. Competitive community would totes love it.

Koridai = 2. Pretty playable stage, not "worst" in any way. Just based on something awful.

Sakurai's cat Destination = 8. I ALMOST HAD A SEIZURE.

I don't know how to judge!

Blank Space by TheUltraDeino
Score: 11/10
Notes: Blank Space would actually be quite the interesting stage if it were, say, an endless freefall in which all attacks were aerial. But how can one plummet to their death "until the end of the match" if one doesn't die until the match ends? Sure, this could work in timed matches, but in a timeless stock match, it's an endless paradox. The match won't end until the players die, but they "plummet to [their] death" until the match ends. Thus, there's no way to end a stock match here. Not only does nobody get to fight, but nobody can even win (or lose), so this stage is absolutely horrendous as it takes away the key gameplay aspects that make Smash Bros. what it is. There's no fighting, no victor, and no fun. The stage's paradox is so powerful that it could possibly cause the game system to explode upon trying to load a match. The icing on the crabcake that is this stage is its ability to be so terrible with so few details. It doesn't even include a poorly-constructed picture or header.
Poké Floats 2 by Kevandre
Score: 5/15
Notes: Kind of ironic how not-bad this stage is. Believe it or not, Poké Floats isn't a very hated stage. It used to be tournament legal, and a lot of people want it to return. What you give us here is just a more well thought-out, balanced, entertaining version of the stage. While it lacks some of the charm of the original (the multiple Unown, the 3 Porygon moving in a straight line, etc), it crams a massive amount of fanservice into a single stage, representing all generations of Pokémon equally. The stage has so much going on that you can't even complete a whole cycle in a default time match. There aren't even any experience-ruining hazards. You just move from one float to the next. Some of them, like Avalugg and Seismitoad, are actually really creative. The only real problem is that the stage is too big for its own good, and isn't very creative, since you're essentially just copying a stage which was already born out of an obvious lack of creativity (or perhaps, too much drugs creativity).

Koridai by TheMarioaddict
Score: 3/15
Notes: I believe I shared my thoughts for this one back when it was posted. There's actually nothing wrong with it. Its worst offense is being a little bland. If you thought the source game alone was enough to taint it, sorry to tell you that I actually want the CD-i games to be represented. This is a terrible stage at being terrible. Now go scrub all the floors in Hyrule.

Sakurai's Cat Destination by D-idara
Score: 10/10
Notes: I see you went with both the "irrefutably OP hazard" and "game-crashing" routes. Definitely a stage I'd give a 0 playability score to during a normal set. The parallel walls are obnoxious, but because of their nature, don't allow for infinites, which are even more obnoxious than OP hazards. Granted, while the stage is absolutely terrible in every way imaginable, I think it lacks the subtle yet sheer wit of TheUltraDeino's Blank Space, which is so cleverly bad that it is neither funny nor appreciable. I will say that this stage is more likely to induce cancer than Blank Space, however.

Props to Bridges for going super in depth with the comments

Totals:

TheUltraDeino: 26/30
Kevandre: 15/30
TheMarioAddict: 5/30 (:C)
D-idara: 25/30

And the winner, by a single point, is...

THEULTRADEINO, WITH BLANK SPACE! CONGRATULATIONS, YOUR STAGE SUCKS!
Click to expand...
New Star Fox stage confirmed.
Or maybe Generator C from Metroid Prime 3: Corruption.
 
Kevandre

Kevandre

Ivy WAS Saurly missed
Joined
Jun 19, 2013
Messages
2,520
Location
Pacific Northwest
NNID
Kevandre
3DS FC
1736-1095-5393
Switch FC
SW-2226-3590-9812
D-idara said:
THE ROUND IS CLOSED! GET A LOAD OF THIS! D-idara will bring down his wrath upon the poor souls who saw Sakurai's Cat Destination and lived to tell the tale >:C
Click to expand...
If it makes you feel better, I only barely lived. My seizure was swift and destructive. I accept it as revenge for subjecting you to eye cancer back with my Teleroboxer stage.
 
Zzuxon

Zzuxon

Smash Champion
Joined
Mar 19, 2011
Messages
2,559
Location
U.S.A
NNID
zzuxon
3DS FC
3695-0453-0481
ryuu seika said:
I claim the bonus award for my stage being not only unplayable but, apparently, also unreadable.
Click to expand...
Ah, so your entry to the bad stage contest doesn't exist?
I think we have a winner.
 
Zzuxon

Zzuxon

Smash Champion
Joined
Mar 19, 2011
Messages
2,559
Location
U.S.A
NNID
zzuxon
3DS FC
3695-0453-0481
Hey, stage contests goers. I was suddenly inspired to fix 75m. Here is the product of my inspiration:
Donkey Kong Stage.png

Don't think a ton more needs to be said. I'll answer any questions.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom