Welcome to Smashboards, the world's largest Super Smash Brothers community! Over 250,000 Smash Bros. fans from around the world have come to discuss these great games in over 19 million posts!
You are currently viewing our boards as a visitor. Click here to sign up right now and start on your path in the Smash community!
While it explains you posting less it doesn't explain what I see as a role that doesn't make sense in the game and doesn't explain the lack of reasoning behind your stances, since certainly your shadow would have time to write out full messages for you with reasoning included from the get go.
Could you give examples of where he justified his stances by exclusively the shadow's opinion? From what I was reading, he was getting advice from the shadow but not just taking it at face value. If he's just parroting the shadow exactly, I'd consider that concerning (since I don't think he would have any way of knowing the shadow's alignment).
if it is wisp (doubtful) I find that kinda uncharacteristic, granted I've only played one game with them and I think they filled a slot but IIRC they gave reasoning a lot.
Ah I meant the reasoning behind the shadows stances, but from what I can tell Ninja and the shadow have very similar stances, I'll go find some examples.
whoops, he is against a Jack lynch. Ha!
The biggest factor on making me reconsider was probably my mistake on whether this was majority vs. plurality lynch. I'm not sure if I would have moved to Bananas at all if I hadn't been concerned about actually consolidating to a giant 9 person wagon.
I assumed that you didn't like Bananas because I had moved onto his wagon. This is fairly standard play for you when you think I'm mafia. Although it hadn't occurred to me just until now, retrospectively having both me and Handorin who you are also scumreading on the same wagon was probably a big red flag for you.
Until someone mentions it
Okay, I had a look and I buy this as plausible enough for D1. Logic is completely different in that game.
You implied that the shadow gets to vote as well. And I assume it's confirmed in your role PM that the shadow is here to help you, they can't have a separate alignment. If those are both true then you should probably wait until the latest day you can to bring them in. However, don't confirm or deny any of this stuff I just said. No reason to fully give details of your role to scum. Also I doubt you will be NKed, you are too suspicious.
Triss and Laser are still my bottom two (although I haven't had time to go back and dissect Laser's response to Z25; I'll go do that during the night phase). I feel like Triss would give us more info out of the two of them (and I don't like her logic, plus it felt like she was making stuff up on the spot early in the phase). So I'll go withSpak Who is your bottom four players you'd be open to lynch?
Makes posts on Triss consecutively but fails to give any reasoning in both, like just saying lay off and not giving reasons why isn't going to help.
no reasoning again, was asked multiple times but only answered recently, can be accepted by busy I guess.
Best post so far, actually had a lot of reasoning on it and their covering of the Ran v Xivii has been good.
again two posts with no reasoning given at the time of posting.
Deadbananas
Ninja3DS is very new to forum mafia. He has a lot of difficulty reading people and was basically suspicious of everyone last game.
I agree that the vote on you without reasoning was weird (unless 3DS has a reason he stated earlier that I missed), but it looks like he's been pretty clear when he vs his shadow have been talking. Seems fine to me; I don't think he can control how much his shadow says (and we can get the shadow to confirm this later on, if 3DS is what he says he is and survives the night).
It's not that scummy people were jumping on the wagon, I do mostly evaluate people individually D1. But just SO many people were very willing to immediatly jump on the DeadBanana's wagon, it felt very opportunistic. Basically exactly what you were saying.
If they were an experienced player, they've been lying about their forum experience and have been playing the noob card since page 2 to justify their actions (which, if they were experienced, rendered them useless to scumhunting). It was a bad move any way you cut it, but if they're experienced, that makes their actions (which they know are bad) to be inherently anti-town and are trying to coast by on everyone's good graces.
That makes a bit more sense but also makes me a bit more confused since posts with his suses and evidence have had more reasoning in them than posts with his shadow.
