RapeFalcon said:
Sheik ban not sure probably FoD
Advantages: none
Some Advantages IMO: Yoshi's Story, BattleField, DK64
Neutral: Brinstar, FD, Dreamland 64, Pokemon Stadium
Some Disadvantages: Rainbow Cruise
Disadvantage: Every other stage
_______________________________________
Marth ban FoD
Advantages: Dreamland 64, DK64, PokeFloats
Some Advantages: FD, BattleField, Rainbow Cruise
Neutral: Pokemon Stadium
Some Disadvantages: Yoshi's Story, Corneria
Disadvantage: Every other stage
_______________________________________
Peach ban FoD or Dreamland 64
Advantages:DK64, PokeFloats, Rainbow Cruise
Some Advantages: Yoshi's Story, Battlefield, FD
Neutral: Pokemon Stadium, Brinstar, Princess Peach's Castle
Some Disadvantages: Dreamland 64, FoD, Corneria, Mute City
Disadvantage: Every other stage
sheik
i wouldn't say 'not sure', you definitely should ban FoD lol. also what you might wanna do with this thread is have 2 stages to ban; 1 random-select and 1 counterpick (consider dk64 random select). some tourneys don't let you ban random-select stages so you have to have a counterpick to ban, as well.
also i would change the wording you use such as advantages/disadvantages etc.; you make it sound as if falcon actually has an advantage over the opposing character when you counterpick the said stage. for example, dreamland 64 is a great stage against fox (one of his best), however he still doesn't have the "advantage" over fox.. he probably doesn't have the advantage over fox on ANY stage. so yeah i'd change the wording to something like 'reccomended/not reccomended/neutral.' another suggestion would be to categorize stages into tiers; such as Top/Upper/Middle/Lower/Bottom tiers. in this case, Kirby64 would be a top tier falcon stage in the fox matchup, while green greens would be bottom.
anyway about sheik, i would definitely raise yoshi's story up one rank; it's probably your best anti-sheik stage. dk64 is great too; i've beaten a lot of sheiks on dk64 that i couldn't beat on other stages; those are probably the best stages against sheik. i'd also move FD up to 'some advantages' or 'upper tier' if you feel like calling it that; it's pretty good against her.
pokemon stadium should definitely be in some advantages/upper tier; it's gr8. rainbow cruise shouldn't be in some disadvantages/lower tier; just like pokefloats no character moves around like falcon (although i'll admit sheik is good on those 2 stages as well).. i'd say it's a middle tier stage.
marf (yes, marf)
i'd definitely raise FD to top tier, and pokemon stadium should be upper tier (some advantages). yoshi's story is probably a neutral/middle tier stage although it's arguable.. falcon can do a lot on yoshi story as well so i'd probably say neutral; not sure.
peach
dk64 should probably be dropped down to some advantages; it's great but peach is able to abuse the barrel like fonz said so you're gonna have to knee her into the blast line to get your kills. yoshi's story is the best stage against peach and should definitely be in the advantages section with pokefloats and r.cruise; battlefield is arguable - it's either top tier or upper tier... i'd leave it at upper. pokemon stadium is either top tier or upper tier as well, i'd put it in the upper tier. pp's castle is one of the worst stages against peach and should be put in disadvantages.
fd is a terrible stage against peach and should be put in lower tier (it's not exactly bottom tier but still terrible).. a single grab from peach = death. no joke.
also your peach counter-pick list doesn't make sense; you say to ban dreamland/FoD when they aren't in the disadvantage (bottom tier) section. wouldn't you be making the best choice by banning a stage in the disadvantage section? IMO, FoD is a much worst stage against peach than Kirby64; I'd move FoD to the disadvantage/bottom tier section and suggest it be banned. ;x
nice list though, i thought everything was accurate and this is really helpful; a friend of mine is reading your list right now. =P the only thing that needs major work is the peach section, but yeah this should def. be stickied once the entire list is compiled.
EDIT: i suggest the rank names be changed to:
advantages -> top tier
some advanages -> upper tier
neutral -> middle tier
some disadvantages -> lower tier
disadvantages -> bottom tier