Spirited Away - Game Thread - Game Over!

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

##Sabrar

This format requires a new approach.

I'm already tunneling this post and I think Sabrar is sitting quite content knowing he's accomplished his goal

 

[FateShirou]

i just think it should be stated at some point while you're still in limbo so there's no time wasted trying to decipher what the cookie might mean, yk?

if i give someone a cookie, i want them to be noticed aka i am feeling sus about them

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

Oh I'm Kamji the Forge Spirit btw and I swap targets, informed busdriver variant as the targeters are informed that their selection was modified

 

[Darkpit54]

loving how we're rehashing the "lol are we all red herring PRs" discussion from completely vanilla mafia but with the added bonus of the mod already giving us the answer

to be fair, they do seem like they might be more powerful than initially anticipated. seems like they could be helpful at least once, although the need to be sanctioned for a lot of them is pretty limiting

 

[Darkpit54]

if i give someone a cookie, i want them to be noticed aka i am feeling sus about them

This would be a good play except for this:

the player who i give the cookie to can accept or deny it

They would just deny the cookie, no one is going to be like "hey guys, that sanctioned spirit thinks I'm sus" lol. Would definitely be way more helpful if they couldn't deny it but it iz what it iz

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

to be fair, they do seem like they might be more powerful than initially anticipated. seems like they could be helpful at least once, although the need to be sanctioned for a lot of them is pretty limiting

yeah I think this is what xivii was getting at with the "low impact" verbiage as opposed to "no impact" or similar tokenizing language

 

[LaserGuy]

I'm already tunneling this post and I think Sabrar is sitting quite content knowing he's accomplished his goal

Can you explain what you find suspect about this post?

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

if i give someone a cookie, i want them to be noticed aka i am feeling sus about them

protip, you probably don't want to show your hand quite to much this early on

I'm reading this impulse to proactively explain himself as more townleaning

 

[Swiss]

I'm curious. If you didn't read the part of all powers being rubbish then why did you want to suggest a mass-claim?

Because there’s no nk

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

Can you explain what you find suspect about this post?

I didn't say it was suspect, I said I was tunneling it

its uncharacteristic of what I've seen historically from sabrar, and I think that's the joke he's making in the post making reference to how a new game format is an excuse for him to act out of meta

why he felt the need to draw overt attention to it is what I'm spinning my mental wheels over

 

[Darkpit54]

could someone walk me through what playing with swiss is usually like?

i was feeling a little off, especially after all of this:

Maven is town - he hasn’t even read the rules

Maven why didn’t you read the rules

Ah.

Turns out that I also, didn't read the rules.

but I wasn't really sure if it's any different from standard for him

 

[Darkpit54]

ironically reminds me of xiv's "haha I'm so town" that I tunneled so hard on from totally vanilla, in which he was, so... maybe I'm totally off again. but someone please tell me they got the same vibes

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

swiss going aggro at another slot for something and then ironically getting caught with his pants down doing the same thing is pretty par for the course I'd say lmao

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

him using "someone else is being wagoned for something so I'm not gonna do that" timidry is not par for the course for him however hence my vote

 

[LaserGuy]

I didn't say it was suspect, I said I was tunneling it

its uncharacteristic of what I've seen historically from sabrar, and I think that's the joke he's making in the post making reference to how a new game format is an excuse for him to act out of meta

why he felt the need to draw overt attention to it is what I'm spinning my mental wheels over

Ah okay, sorry, I usually think of tunneling to more refer to an alignment read, whereas you just mean you're thinking a lot about it.

Liking your content so far. You can be Town this game.

ironically reminds me of xiv's "haha I'm so town" that I tunneled so hard on from totally vanilla, in which he was, so... maybe I'm totally off again. but someone please tell me they got the same vibes

Your assessment here is basically correct. I think it's NAI for Swiss, but I haven't played with him as scum so I'm just going by personality.

 

[Swiss]

You guys really don’t like my quips eh

Darkpit talk to me a little more about what you don’t like. Why is hypocrisy bad?

 

[Swiss]

[QUOTE="LaserGuy, post: 24397512, member:
Liking your content so far. You can be Town this game
[/QUOTE]

This feels very awkward

 

[Swiss]

Almost as awkward as trying to play mafia from my phone

 

[FateShirou]

wow swiss, cant believe you messed up ur 1000th post

 

[Swiss]

swiss going aggro at another slot for something and then ironically getting caught with his pants down doing the same thing is pretty par for the course I'd say lmao

Why phrased as aggro? I’m being nice

And I hard cleared him

And myself

Explain

 

[Swiss]

wow swiss, cant believe you messed up ur 1000th post

Feels bad

Btw what do you think about Laser and him being awkward

 

[Swiss]

When we sanction someone can they type in this thread?

No right?

 

[Xivii]

Vote Count [B1-2]

LaserGuy | 2/5 | Swiss, Sabrar
Sabrar | 1/5 | LaserGuy
Swiss | 1/5 | FrozenFlame

Not Voting: bessie, Maven, Darkpit, FateShirou, somitomi

Spoiler: History

sab, sab
las, sab
sab, unv
sab, las
mav, las - invalid
swiss, las
som, shi

som, unv
fro, swi

With 9 players in Limbo, it takes 5 to banish.
The deadline for Banish 1 is Friday, the 21st at 11:59 pm MT.

 

[Maven89]

Maven is town - he hasn’t even read the rules

Why would you assume I haven’t read the rules instead of faking a vote?

 

[Darkpit54]

swiss going aggro at another slot for something and then ironically getting caught with his pants down doing the same thing is pretty par for the course I'd say lmao

Your assessment here is basically correct. I think it's NAI for Swiss, but I haven't played with him as scum so I'm just going by personality.

okay thanks, I'll try to withhold judgement for now then

You guys really don’t like my quips eh

Darkpit talk to me a little more about what you don’t like. Why is hypocrisy bad?

I was really entertained, there's just something that feels manufactured about it. I tend to read a lot by gut feelings, especially early on, and it's difficult for me to distinguish between scum trying to come off as town, and a townie doing... whatever that is. it seemed really convenient to offhandedly mention that someone must be town for not having read the rules, and almost immediately after go "oops i didn't either! that's so silly and townie of me!", like an easy way to seem townie without actually doing anything. I feel like I've spent too long focusing on this and still haven't really explained it, but i may reevaluate and try again.

I think I try to focus on people's motivations, and I struggle to find why town would need to paint themselves as being more townie, while scum would have an obvious reason. but I've been very wrong before, so I'm trying to withhold judgement for now

speaking of motivations, could you explain your reasoning for the vig fakeclaim? you seemed to know at that point there was no nk to draw

 

[Swiss]

Remove the laser sus

Maven were you faking a vote? Why

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

Why phrased as aggro? I’m being nice

And I hard cleared him

And myself

Explain

calling someone out for not reading the rules is an aggro move, well intentioned or not

is it the 7th inning right now because the rest is a big ****ing stretch

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

yes I realize that baseball joke is probably lost on you across the pond folks which includes the guy I'm roasting

 

[Darkpit54]

Almost as awkward as trying to play mafia from my phone

also nvm that last post, you're now incredibly relatable and trustworthy. this is how i play every game

When we sanction someone can they type in this thread?

No right?

No, unless there's some ability that allows it ig. per the rules they only have their own chat

 

[#HBC | FrozeηFlame]

Why would you assume I haven’t read the rules instead of faking a vote?

????????????????????????????????????????

 

[Swiss]

okay thanks, I'll try to withhold judgement for now then


I was really entertained, there's just something that feels manufactured about it. I tend to read a lot by gut feelings, especially early on, and it's difficult for me to distinguish between scum trying to come off as town, and a townie doing... whatever that is. it seemed really convenient to offhandedly mention that someone must be town for not having read the rules, and almost immediately after go "oops i didn't either! that's so silly and townie of me!", like an easy way to seem townie without actually doing anything. I feel like I've spent too long focusing on this and still haven't really explained it, but i may reevaluate and try again.

I think I try to focus on people's motivations, and I struggle to find why town would need to paint themselves as being more townie, while scum would have an obvious reason. but I've been very wrong before, so I'm trying to withhold judgement for now

speaking of motivations, could you explain your reasoning for the vig fakeclaim? you seemed to know at that point there was no nk to draw

No that’s fine.

I claim vig every game - this game has just made it moot

 

[Sabrar]

I think I try to focus on people's motivations, and I struggle to find why town would need to paint themselves as being more townie, while scum would have an obvious reason.

Cementing myself as town is like 30% of the job of being town. I get that you think talking about it is scummy, but seeing as the only other option is to die, and it's not interfering with my scumhunting, you can deal with it.

 

[Darkpit54]

noted, thank you

 

[Maven89]

Remove the laser sus

Maven were you faking a vote? Why

No I didn’t read the voting rules, i was just hurt you thought that

 

[Maven89]

No night kill doesn’t mean there’s no roles that can hurt us

 

[Swiss]

See I read the voting rules yet completely missed most of the other rules.

Maven darkpit town leans

 

[Darkpit54]

No night kill doesn’t mean there’s no roles that can hurt us

can you elaborate on this? considering roles were picked separate from alignment, they all seem relatively harmless, right?

 

[Swiss]

calling someone out for not reading the rules is an aggro move, well intentioned or not

is it the 7th inning right now because the rest is a big ****ing stretch

I mean is it

Is this a baseball analogy? Rephrase in football or f1 please

 

[Swiss]

I’m pretty sure every role in this game is useless

 

[Swiss]

As Sabrar kindly pointed out