BatCrab
Smash Rookie
- Joined
- Feb 13, 2015
- Messages
- 7
It is not '100% bull****'.This is 100% bull****
staindgrey
Watch the TV series not the movies
You literally miss out on some important moments with Amuro and the white base crew
Just watch it how its meant
Gundam 0079 > Zeta Gundam > ZZ Gundam > CCA
After that you can watch any Gundam series you like. Most Gundam show including the AU one's share concepts and parallels to OG UC stuff hence why you should watch all off the early UC stuff first.
I suggest watching Turn A as its probably my fav next to 0079. However be reminded Turn A is like BOTW in which it takes place around 5000-10000 years after the UC and its technically the ending of Gundam.
Also dont listen to people who say Victory and ZZ Gundam is bad. They are 100% wrong.
There are many reasons to recommend the movie trilogy over the original TV series, especially in the context of showing the series to a new viewer. You're right to say that one misses out on some good moments should one choose the films over the series; the loss of episode 22 (the one I imagine you're referring to when you talk about 'some important moments with Amuro and the white base crew') is sorely missed as it's an excellent episode, as well as the loss of other parts such as Operation Odessa (which whilst not a great episode, does convey the importance of the battle better than the film...though not seeing Odessa in full arguably works in a viewers favour considering how heavily Odessa has been retconned over the years).
However I strongly feel that these losses are not comparable to the multitude of gains that are made in the compilation. The films are augmented with far superior animation (A Baoa Qu is orders of magnitude better in the films than in the series), improving the overall pacing (though I will concede there is some rather choppy editing in the middle of movie II), cutting much of the sillier elements from the series that really didn't fit the tone (removing stuff like the Gundam hammer & javelin and giving Hayato a Guncannon for the trip back up to space rather than having him still use the Guntank) and finally toning down the 'monster of the week' formula the series had in the earlier episodes in favour of something more serialised.
There is no 'right way' to watch the original Gundam when choosing between the TV series and the films, they're both masterpieces and there certainly are good reasons to prefer the TV series over the films, however it is my strong opinion that the film trilogy is better for new viewers (at least those whom are not so well versed in the idiosyncrasies of late 70's anime) and due to it removing a lot of the elements that Tomino only begrudgingly added simply to get the show made, feels closer to the original vision for the series.
Everything else you say is 100% agree with though. Release order is certainly the best way to experience the original Gundam saga; everything that came afterwords is build on it either narratively or thematically so getting that done first is the best thing to do as everything else can approached as one likes. ZZ is a good series, it's just hard to recommend because it gets off to such a poor start but if one can make it past the first 20 episodes they'll find a really good show. Victory Gundam is a masterpiece and part of the franchise I've only come to appreciate more and more as time goes by; it's probably my second favourite Gundam series now as it successfully communicates the madness of war in a way I've yet to see any other anime do.