The Good Dinosaur is such a beautiful movie that is unfortunately incredibly scatterbrained in its execution. It’s hard to quite explain why everything feels so incredibly disjointed but I think the ideas they put in were just not really connectable. The only plot points that payed off was his promise to his Mama after what his Papa said to him. The whole point with the other humans kind of came out of nowhere and the T-Rex’s came and went before you could really establish any connection with them, which sucks since they got Sam Elliot and the voice of gold to voice Butch, and then the Pterodactyl’s were so situational that they didn’t feel like a real threat.
I think the dynamic between Spot and Arlo, despite it being the focus of nearly the whole movie, was also severely undercooked. Besides the very beginning where he let Spot go and the successive scenes involving food, there wasn’t much development between the two, Arlo grew quite a bit but it was done so in such a typical fashion that it just seemed a bit forced.
I still enjoyed it. I think it’s a solid 6/10 or something, it’s not terrible but it IS one of Pixar’s weakest films despite it being one of their most stunningly beautiful.