You mentioned the light source part, but I'd also mention the shading doesn't feel defined enough. By defined I mean, it looks a little too flat and doesn't add much to the details. The best way to know how shading works usually is by studying how shading is done on official sprites, especially bigger ones. It gives you an idea of how and why they're done.
(Although I know you don't do this, but as a heads up, avoid overshading or adding too many colors of shades. Usually 2 or 3 colors of shade per color is good enough)
I hope that helps a lot! It's what I usually do, it helps me understand shading and whatnot! But since you've said that sprite is really old, I'm sure you've def improved a lot since then. :D
They
didn't have much shading before. I added it because it looked too flat to me as it was before. If I was trying to have this be the same way as it was officially, I'd have left them alone and as they were before I started adding them. Hence why the ones in my sig are so different. XD
I honestly think it looks just fine and came out exactly how I wanted. I made anything that I wanted to pop out, stand out, and anything that I didn't, not. Some of the shading is to also make certain parts look like they shift into different ways and directions, too.
Like I said, I've been doing this for a LONG time. I know what I'm doing, so anything you see is entirely intentional and I have no plans on doing it differently. Tends to be why I don't like critique or advice unless I specifically ask for it myself. I'm a
selfish artist, I'll admit it. All I care about is how I think it looks in the end. It sometimes kills my mood a bit if others don't like something I worked hard on as much as I do, but if I really think it came out how I wanted, I tend to not let it bother me and keep doing what I'm doing.
Pretty much like this girl, except not
quite as maniacal and self-centered. I'm used to the way that I like to do things being considered unfavorable by others and then being shunned since I refuse to change them if I don't see a reason to. That's probably just my Aspergers kicking in, though. ¦D
But I do ask for it when I legit need help or want it, make no mistake.
Anywho, thanks for the input. Ah, but the clear it up, THIS sprite (Since I think we're both talking about Kaye here) isn't the old version.
THIS one is...God, it hurts to look at. I'm glad I've been updating it constantly over the years. But like I said, this is also an older design before it upgraded to this one. XD;
Then again, it's still one of his later ones considering I've had this character since 1998. ¦D;